Health: A Social Phenomenon Essay

1756 words - 7 pages

With movements made by the governments and medical professionals of developed countries in the interests of giving patients more choice, the definition of “healthy,” especially in contemporary society, has become subjective (Freemantle and Hill 2002, Armstrong 1995, Bury 2008, Van Krieken et al. 2006: 379-380). Variations in interpretation appear between groups divided along socio-political, demographical lines, or even between individuals themselves (Freemantle and Hill 2002: 864, Heath 2005: 954, Blaxter 2000:44, Van Krieken et al. 2006). This ambiguity has underscored debates and conflicts in recent years between patients, academics, politicians, and medical practitioners on issues of medical authority, the extent of involvement in the decision making process over personal health as well as the health of others related to them through social structures and institutions (Van Krieken et al. 2006, Blaxter 2000, Bury 2008, White 2002).
This essay will attempt to illustrate how “health” is a social phenomenon through the examination of power and inequality. It will focus on the social causes and effects of medicalisation and how the attitudes and positions people occupy in society influence their medical needs. This essay will also highlight some of the challenges faced by the societies around the world in addressing medical inequality.

Medical dominance and medicalisation
According to Foucault and Illich (in Van Krieken et al. 2006: 351-352), doctors and the medical profession have traditionally been empowered by their knowledge as the authority that society defers to with regards to the definition of disease and health. With improvements in medical technology as well as the advent of the hospital, an evolution from “Bedside Medicine” to “Hospital Medicine” took place, disempowering patients and subjecting them to a position of social subordination to the authority and the “medical gaze” of doctors (Armstrong 1995: 393-394, Van Krieken et al. 2006: 352).
Marxist and feminist views similarly show a hierarchy being established under a medical authority, though framed in the context of the needs of capitalism and patriarchal society respectively as a form of social control and dominance over disadvantaged groups (Van Krieken et al. 2006: 352-354, Broom and Woodward 1996: 360-361, Blaxter 2000). Micro-perspectives are complementary to these arguments; that through a socially-empowered medical process, individual or group identity can be formed through the differentiation of various traits of individuals as “normal” or otherwise (Van Krieken et al. 2006: 355-356, White 2002: 152-156).

These social relationships are all possible explanations for medical dominance in modernity, and consequently, the growth of medicalisation where certain “abnormal” aspects of human life are identified, labelled and “treated” by medical intervention (Foucault 2003: 39-41, Armstrong 1995: 394-395, Van Krieken et al. 2006: 352-357, Broom and...

Find Another Essay On Health: A Social Phenomenon

Stress as a Social Determinant of Health

2379 words - 10 pages health becomes evident (Thoits, 2011). Chronic stress can worsen an already existing problem in the body. In a recent study, the participants improved drastically from chronic stress after learning how to control the triggers of stress (Nguyen, 2012). The triggers included negative thoughts and pain. For this reason, stress is a more of a negative social determinant of health. This section analyzes stress as a social negative determinant of health

Health Consequences of Smoking; A Social Factor

1063 words - 4 pages Health is a complex issue, there are many levels of causation that contribute to an individual's overall health. Individuals have their own reactions to outside factors that shape how their body works, how they treat their body and how their mind works. Nevertheless, health does not revolve primary around access to health care or having an adequate doctor but also around the social factors, the daily life factors that influence individual's

A Troubled Future for America: Health Care and Social Security Reform

1087 words - 4 pages past problems no longer fulfill the needs of the future. The people of America have also adapted to the ever changing times. The programs initiated during the New Deal era provided Americans some sense of stability however they did not have longevity in mind or take into account the changing demographics of our country. Halstead and Lind address two of these programs, employer-based health coverage, and social security reform in the book The

Article Review of What are Child-care Social Workers Doing in Relation to Infant Mental Health? An Exploration of Professional Ideologies and Practice Preferences Within an Inter-agency Context.

984 words - 4 pages health visitors, midwifes, sure start workers and social workers did demonstrate "the existence of the phenomenon in a more implicit way" (Pg1013). By the professionals demonstrating this it came across that the mental health problem wasn't down to the child, it was down to the parenting.These findings provide the evidence that social workers are not knowledgeable enough to deal with mental health problems. There were some ideas that all the

Social Influences in Health Decision Making

1295 words - 5 pages Health behaviour theorists have long attested to the importance of social influences in health decision making. For example, the prominent Social Cognitive Theory builds in a construct of outcome expectancies, of which social outcome expectancies, or the value of the anticipated reaction of those in one’s environment, play a role. In essence, an individual is going to consider anticipated approving or disapproving responses, by his/her peers

Sociology of Gender

856 words - 3 pages lose it way before marriage. It has been instilled within young people that to achieve manhood a boy must lose his virginity, where as on the other hand virginity is taught to be a girls womanhood and that she should value and save it (Carpenter, 346).Aside from the United States, other cultures have the same idea as well that women need to remain pure and virgins. For example according the Better Health Channel, Female genital mutilation

Biceps and Body Image: The Relationship Between Muscularity and Self-Esteem, Depression, and Eating Disorder Symptoms

576 words - 2 pages the Mental Health of Immigrants 3The authors describe the current situation in the United States involving immigration, the type of immigrants, and their characteristics. A particular attention is given to the legal and to the undocumented immigrants. The two very distinct types of immigrants often tend to face dissimilar challenges due to their particular social status. The up to date statistics also give the reader a precise idea about the socio

Health Care in the Global South

4595 words - 18 pages Health care and usage in the global south has always been a phenomenon of interest to both researchers and policy makers alike. This keen interest is embedded in the special demographic characteristics of this part of the world coupled with poverty and underdevelopment. This region has more than 50% (5.8 billion) of the world’s 7 billion population and a natural population growth rate of over 2% (Population Reference Bureau 2013); coupled with

Poverty and Mental Illness

2487 words - 10 pages the loss of income but also the loss of a social network. This loss causes material strain and may increase strain on relationships. Those in a community affected by poverty who continues to be employed may also suffer strain due to decreased wages, decreased job security and increased workload. The loss of community resources may also occur. The stresses brought about by these precursors can result in negative effects on mental health. The impact

The opinions and perceptions of Sri Lankan physicians

1279 words - 5 pages address the ‘brain drain’ phenomenon in Sri Lanka, providing physician level care where necessary to support practicing physicians 8. From 1940s to the late 1900s, Sri Lankan health outcomes have shown marked improvement. Average life expectancy increased by 30 years between 1946 and 1996, while the introduction of healthcare to rural populations and an outreach of antenatal care to mothers has contributed to a decreased both infant and


990 words - 4 pages social can only be arrived at by systematic research that attempts to uncover how social interaction is defined. This more specifically focuses on the interplay of individuals and their response to social factors (p. 128). Economy is a social phenomenon according to Weber. Economies result from communities, which are arranged in such a way that goods, tangible and intangible, symbolic and material, are distributed. This distribution is always unequal

Similar Essays

Love: A Chemical Reaction Or A Social Phenomenon?

1280 words - 5 pages simply articulates that the act of love is nothing short of a social phenomenon. Eric Fromm states that “Love is supposed to be the outcome of a spontaneous, emotional reaction, of suddenly being gripped by an irresistible feeling” (51). Which when discussing love with others is more apt to be the description in comparison to the physiological explanation. While the idea of love requires both the psychological and the physiological for the sake of

Social Dating Is A Modern Phenomenon In Our Society

1229 words - 5 pages Most people, especially teenagers, are influenced by their peers, parents and social media. Whether it is what is in style or what the kids are doing these days, it seems like everyone is following each other either through a social network such as Facebook or through face to face interactions. One of the areas in which they are influenced most is dating. Dating is a modern phenomenon which has only recently been brought up in the last century

Health: A Major Social Issue Essay

1848 words - 7 pages Health is something that many would not associate as being a social issue, yet many sociologists have argued that it is a major social issue. They argue that the way we experience and understand health is dependent upon society. In 1946, the World Health Organisation (WHO) defined health as, “a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being” (WHO, 2003). This definition is very holistic in the sense that it encompasses all aspects of a

Health From A Social Perspective Essay

2533 words - 10 pages WHO, 1986 defines health as a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being. Therefore, it is viewed as much a social as a biological issue. "Healthy" is broadly used in the framework of “healthy environments” as to its impact on the benefit of humans. In addition to health care interventions and a person's surroundings, a number of other factors are known to influence the health status of individuals, including their background