The Physician As A Double Agent

906 words - 4 pages

The physician is an integral part of the health care system. The staff the facility keeps defines the health outcomes for the patients of that facility. So, it is very important to hire staff that helps create overall health care quality and good outcomes. Sometimes, however, physicians are placed in a difficult position because of the different roles they manage. The definition of a double agent, the marketplace, and the ethical aspect should be considered when defining a physician’s role as a double agent.
Rich (2005) states that the physician has the upper hand in the relationship because of their medical knowledge. This leaves the patient at a disadvantage and causes them to be dependent on the physician when making decisions about their care:
The physician–patient relationship is the quintessential fiduciary relationship because of the vast disparity in knowledge about disease and treatment between the clinician and the typical lay patient. The consequence of this disparity is that the physician has a moral (and ultimately a legal) responsibility to utilize that manifestly superior knowledge exclusively for the benefit of the patient. (Rich, 2005, p. 393)
Therefore, the patient trusts the physician to not only act on their behalf but also make choices that would benefit them. Hicks (2014) states that having this approach may cause problems because “In health care, the physician is both a healthcare provider and an agent of the consumer. The physician’s incentives in the provider role may not be aligned with the incentives of the consumer” (p.479). Therefore, defining the physician as a double agent. Furthermore:
Doctors are agents for two distinct groups. The physician is an agent for the patient, but also an agent for insurance companies-especially in the managed care settings. In balancing both relationships, the doctor must juggle the conflicting principal-agent problems of information asymmetry and third party payment. (Shafrin, 2006, para.1)
As a double agent the physician must satisfy many demands and the most prominent demand may not factor the patient as the highest priority. There are many things a physician is required to do as a double agent. Angell defined that essentially, “Doctors are supposed to tailor their care of patients to save money for third parties” (Angell, 1993, p.282). Those third party payers can manifest themselves in various forms including: DRGs, HMOs, PPOs, the hospital, and even the physicians themselves. Angell provides an example of how physicians save money, “Under the DRG system of hospital reimbursement for Medicare patients, doctors are supposed to be agents for the hospital, discharging patients as rapidly as possible and keeping services to a minimum so that the hospital can game the system” (Angell, 1993, p.282).
As a...

Find Another Essay On The physician as a double agent

Theater as an Agent of Social Change, "A Raisin in the Sun"

842 words - 3 pages It is important to read Lorraine Hansberry's "A Raisin in the Sun" in the contexts of "Lorraine Hansberry's Les Blancs and the American Civil Rights Movement" by Joy L. Abell in the African American Review. Abell provides background on Lorraine Hansberry that gives the reader a better understanding of her position on civil rights and how she believed as a writer she could help to bring about social change. "A Raisin in the Sun" was written and

Knowledge as a Double Edged Sword in the novels Oryx and Crake as well as A Canticle for Leibowitz

4041 words - 16 pages . Whorehouses. Prisons. And from the ranks of the desperate, as usual.’”(296). which shows Crake as heartless, and willing to resort to deceit and treachery in his blind ambition search for knowledge. After all of Crake toils, his vision is realized with the double-edged sword of humanity, and knowledge becomes the sole factor in the elimination of an entire race. Thon Taddeo Pfardentrott in the novel A Canticle for Leibowitz is a scientist who is

A Career as a Registered Nurse or Physician Assistant

1456 words - 6 pages , college level math and English 90. A unique course that Cleveland has for studying as physician assistance is history and physical exam techniques. Unique courses for University Washington Seattle are; pre-calculus, physics, molecular genetics, and social science or humanities. Finally, a unique course at City College of San Francisco is psychology. But the cost of each school can also vary on which school too choose and depending on the school

The Cuban Embargo: A Double Edged Sword

2004 words - 8 pages just harming The U.S and the Cuban community economically. It’s a double edged sword and either way both Countries are getting affected. The Cuban embargo should be lifted because the embargo is harming Cuba’s economy. By hurting one country’s economy it affects others as well like a domino effect. It’s been years that the embargo has been implemented. I don’t think thinks it’s mature for the U.S to hold grudge against Cuba. Cuba is no longer a

Women in Film as Portrayed in the Movie, Double Indemnity

1110 words - 4 pages liberates the female character from the restrictive and oppressed melodramatic situation that render her helpless” (Kolker 124). There are arguably two extreme portrayals of the character of Phyllis Dietrichson in Double Indemnity; neither one is an accurate or fare portrayal. Despite the fact that the character of Phyllis as the “tough as nails” perpetual, intentional aggressor is a valid attempt to obliterate the image of women as the oppressed

A Comparison of Heart of Darkness and The Secret Agent

3072 words - 12 pages ).   There is a striking congruence to his own experiences in almost all of Conrad's works. It seems that Conrad took most of his characters from reality, of course moulding them a little, and most of what happens in his writing has happened to Conrad himself, as Marlow's journey in Congo , or the numerous allusions to suicide in his works, as in The Secret Agent, of which there is much controversy over whether Conrad himself tried to commit suicide or

TNF-α: Contradictory Roles in Cancer Progression and As a Chemotherapeutic Agent

2480 words - 10 pages of TNF-α- mediated inflammation as a causative agent in tumorigenesis. A closer inspection of the progression of hepatocellular carcinomas invokes TNF-α signaling directly. In heptocellular carcinomas, there is a marked progression from non-malignant nodules to malignant nodules, which occurs after extensive inflammation. This marked shift to malignancy is caused by the release of TNF-α from the liver stroma into the epithelial layer of

A Case for the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide

1379 words - 6 pages A Case for the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide On February 20, 2009, my grandfather was diagnosed with stage 3 pancreatic cancer. When initially diagnosed, his oncologist told him that he had less than one year to live. During the last year of his life, my grandfather received palliative care that was meant to ease the pain caused by the progression of his disease. However, as the weeks progressed, my grandfather's cancer ravaged his

A Comparison of "The Other" and "Double Conciousness" by PJ

1424 words - 6 pages would result in the ultimate goal of black Americans, to be able to cast aside the veil of "double consciousness" and truly see oneself as an American through one's own eyes. Only then, after no longer viewing themselves through the contemptuous and pitying eyes of white America, could blacks start on the road to achieving their goals no matter what arena of society it was a part of.The paths toward an equal footing in society that women and

The Notion of a Double in Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights

1167 words - 5 pages The Notion of a Double in Wuthering Heights   Brontë's Wuthering Heights is the captivating tale of two families and the relationships that develop between them.  The narrator, Mr. Lockwood, relates the story as told to him by Ellen, the housekeeper.  The novel contains an excellent illustration of the doppel-ganger, the notion of a double.  Generally, this concept is applied to specific characters, as in

The Cover-up, is a short story about a computer hacker that gets assasinated by an agent from the government.

750 words - 3 pages irritated hacker slapped the side of the monitor. Nothing happened. Disgusted and exhausted, Simon stood up from his chair and made his way to his bed. It was pitch black in his tiny apartment. Unaware that there was a massive filing cabinet in front of him, he walked right into it. A loud slam echoed throughout the room as papers rustled and fell. The blow to his head instantly knocked him out.BEEP!Simon's head was throbbing. A sharp pain sliced through

Similar Essays

School As A Socialization Agent Essay

1132 words - 5 pages School is the first place, as children that we begin to interact with others in a public environment. At school we meet new friends, learn our society?s norms, as well as learn good moral values. It is also a very influential socialization agent in our life. A norm is what is generally accepted among society but not necessarily a law. For example not picking your nose at a restaurant is not a law but it is the norm and if you were to do so you

A Career As A Real Estate Agent

1926 words - 8 pages , distance from the nearest shopping, size of the rooms, and various features of the house. Such things as, the fireplace, pools, the size of the garage and even the gardens are discussed when overviewing the house. The agent has to be very convincing in his “pitch” in order to convince couple that the house is a perfect place to call home. Finally, once an agreement has been made between the two parties, it is necessary to then prepare legal

Family As A Primary Agent To Socialization

1229 words - 5 pages how they perceive the society they live in (Bourne, 2006). The family also shapes the children to be able to relate well with other people that are not part of their family and with a good relationship it impacts to the peace achieved in a country. This paper addresses the reasons as to why the family is considered the most important agent of socialization. It’s evident that families have changed over time and they have adopted different ways of

Teacher Leadership As A Change Agent

1835 words - 7 pages change happen in education? Considering current framework in light of the ever-changing context of schooling, appear to view classroom-based teachers as having little to no authority, as being incapable of initiating school wide change according to their will. Mostly, teacher has been considered in two roles. The first role of the teacher as a receiver and implementer of the strategies & practices formulated by others, i.e. national policy efforts