This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Healthcare And Immigration Essay

3129 words - 13 pages

Running head: A MORAL DILEMMA: SHOULD HEALTH CARE AND PUBLIC 1 EDUCATION BE GRANTED TO ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS? A MORAL DILEMMA: SHOULD HEALTH CARE AND PUBLIC EDUCATION BE GRANTED TO ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS? PAGE 11
Final PaperLehi DickeyPUAD 6815March 21, 2013Professor Frank ScottIllegal immigration has been a complicated issue for the United States for the last century and a half. How to best correct America's immigration debacle is definitely a moral dilemma for many people. With the days of Ellis Island steamboats and open-door policies behind us, we are struggling to define the rights of those people who are coming to our country illegally. A multitude of issues arise from this situation: should illegal immigrants be able to work? Should they receive health care? Should they be educated in the public school system? Should they receive welfare benefits such as food stamps and unemployment checks? These, and many more questions are perplexing our government and its constituents. What is the moral and or ethical thing to do? Ethics is a way of being rather than adherence to rules or precepts, or making a string of decisions, but rather refusing to accept whole cloth… (Stivers, 2008, p.147). Morality is both subjective and objective, it just depends on what state' it is in from its genesis to its internalization.Morality is subjectively created, then externalized and made communicable, tangible, and therefore objective, and then internalized from the objective state making it subjective as it's held in the mind of the individual. I have chosen to focus my ethical issue analysis on the following public issues: health care and education. The key to being a successful public administrator is to have a balance and control of one's objective and subjective responsibilities. A key question that public administrators must ask themselves when making such a decision such as granting illegal immigrants the right to health care or public education is whether or not to follow their objective responsibility. The objective responsibilities of public administrators are defined by both, "accountability and imposed obligation…[meaning they have] responsibility to someone else for something" (Cooper 2012, p. 81). Essentially these responsibilities involve an external, tangible source of obligation, and it is these things outside of the administrator that create responsibility. The sources of objective responsibility then stem from things such as superiors and subordinates, elected officials, public policies, and citizens.I have always been passionate about issues related to public education and the healthcare system. I have been in the education field for twenty years and have had students in my class who had to be withdrawn from school due to the fact that their parents were in the United States illegally. Furthermore, I have had students who were not born in the United States who was absent frequently due to the fact that they were sick, but could not go...

Find Another Essay On Healthcare and Immigration

We Must Provide Subsidized Healthcare for Illegal Immigrants

2685 words - 11 pages and access to subsidized healthcare; yield a few attainable solutions in addition to some recommendations for the future on how this issue may be solved. Immigration has been around in the United States of America since the colonial times. Along with those immigrants come many other issues, including healthcare. Many of the millions of immigrants presently in the United States are without insurance. This paper will discuss how important it

Deportation in America - English 1010 - Informative Paper

957 words - 4 pages Introduction Immigration reform has been a highly debatable topic in this 2016 campaign for election. Immigration reform is meaning to make changes to current immigration policy to our country such as, open borders, amnesty, gaining citizenship, United States economy and the effects this could all have on our country. Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump are among the top candidates running in this year’s 2016 election. Both candidates have taken a

Econ Research Paper

1071 words - 5 pages could create jobs for American workers if they were to become legal. These business owners could play a huge role in reducing unemployment in the United States, which would also play a role in the economy. Critics of illegal immigration argue that an large inflow of illegal immigrants also bring high economic costs through the lowering of domestic wages and the raising of public spending on things like education and healthcare. As mentioned

Immigration & Inequalities among Asian Americans

1802 words - 8 pages need of medical attention, they cannot go to hospital facilities as they risk getting exposed. The outcome of this inequality in access to healthcare is more often than not the prevalence of chronic diseases such as diabetes, HIV and cancer, which ultimately result in low quality of life. Why Asian Americans are Important to the US The current debate over immigration reforms has perhaps gotten everybody speculating on the fate of the over 11

Illegal Immigration in the United States

930 words - 4 pages create a situation where we're dealing with illegal immigration, so that we don't have illegal immigrants," he said. "And we've got legal residents or citizens who are eligible for the plan. And I want a comprehensive immigration plan that creates a pathway to achieve that." One exception he does have is that healthcare should be offered to illegal immigrant children because they are in our kids’ playground and schools and if they aren’t treated

Illegal Immigration

1544 words - 6 pages ), Hondorous (380,000) and China (280,000)” (Infoplease 1). The rising number of illegal immigrants over the past ten years has led to an increasing concern about the effects of illegal immigrants on wages, national security, and public finances. Evidently, illegal immigration has been a source of economic stress, increased insecurity, low healthcare services, and reduced education standards. To delve deep in understanding the negative impact of illegal

Immigration

1841 words - 8 pages negatively to the United States, forcing legislators to grapple with finding best mechanisms to address the problem. Illegal immigration also poses serious questions on the country’s economy, and how to address the growing demand for low-cost labor while at the same time providing adequate jobs and economic opportunities for the American citizens. The nature and extent of illegal immigration in the United States make it a highly sophisticated issue

Welcome to the U.S.A

1261 words - 6 pages chance of becoming a citizen of the “land of the free and the home of the brave.” Strict enforcement of a more streamline verification process by the government in supervising legal immigration is needed to continue America’s evolution culturally and economically with the addition of individuals from foreign nations trying to properly enter the United States of America. Currently, the immigration process of America is quite flawed, requiring

Immigration's Effects on the Economy

1763 words - 7 pages cannot . This type of unfairness brings about tension that I will discuss later.Since 1969, illegal immigration has cost our country $24.4 billion dollars. This is why it amazes me when you have our government fighting over wether we should supply healthcare to everyone. This is frustrating to Americans because if us as Americans were not wasting our tax money taking care of other peoples? problems and using the money to take care of our natural

Immigration

3600 words - 14 pages -born Americans do. One-third of annual population growth of the United States now is from immigration. Twenty to twenty-five percent are illegal aliens or about 200,000 (Andryszewski 87). Illegal aliens cause a strain on welfare and health care facilities, not to mention more unwanted population. For example, in California, taxpayers were paying three billion dollars a year to benefit illegal aliens with education, healthcare, and other benefits

asdasdasds

1601 words - 7 pages School of Government found that about 50 percent of American adults believe that immigrants burden the country because they, “take jobs, housing, and healthcare”, while the other 50 percent believe that, “immigrants strengthen the country due to their hard work and talents” (Delener & Ventilato, 2008). Over the past decade, “over half of the increase in the U.S. labor force,… was the result of immigration-legal and illegal” (Orrenius & Nicholson

Similar Essays

Immigration: My Solution Essay

897 words - 4 pages immigration is that the conditions in which many of these immigrants lived in in their native countries were so dire. If the United States wants a long-term solution to illegal immigration, we must give economic aid to these countries, namely Mexico.Illegal immigration is not as important of an issue as the Iraq war, public healthcare, gay marriage, abortion, or the corruptness of insurance companies and big corporations. Racial discrimination against

Debating Immigration Essay

1364 words - 5 pages accept their views without thinking over their argument. Are the rising costs of healthcare, education, government deficits and the problem of unemployment the fault of legal immigration? This is what the House Majority Leaded, Dick Armey of Texas had to say on the issue, "legal immigrants contribute more to the American economy then they detract from it. Immigration keeps U.S. industries competitive, increase employment through

Come To The Usa Essay

1299 words - 6 pages laws has brought on a very polarized controversy with some wanting amnesty for immigrants, while others seek for strict enforcement of legal measures and deportation of illegal aliens. Many people have taken stands and have spoke up on the matter. Mocking America’s laxity on illegal immigration in his song “Come to the USA,” comedian Ray Stevens, on of the many who voiced their opinion, uses irony to argue against the US immigration policy. Unlike

Federal Immigration Control Essay

2407 words - 10 pages additional things they should do to improve the current status of illegal immigration. Tens of millions of legal immigrants over four centuries have made the United States what it is today. They came to make new lives and livelihoods in the new world and hard work benefited themselves and their new home country. However, there are several things the government should do in order to enforce our laws regarding illegal immigration. Therefore, the three