This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Heathcliff And Hareton Earnshaw In Wuthering Heights

4534 words - 18 pages

Discuss the portrayal of Heathcliff and Hareton Earnshaw in WutheringHeights.
Are they products of nature or nurture?

I am going to look at the nature and nurture of both Hareton Earnshaw
and Heathcliff, of Emily Brontë's 'Wuthering Heights', and try to
decide whether these two characters are products of their nature or
their nurture. A person's nature is the way they are born, their 'raw
state of mind', the parts of their character unaffected by outside
influence. A person's nurture is the way they are brought up, and they
way they are influenced and shaped by society.

The Lintons and Earnshaws are part of the Gentry class of Victorian
England; they are both landowning families, fairly high up in the
class hierarchy. But the genetic natures of the families are entirely
different: the Lintons are well behaved, subdued, spoilt, steady,
sensible and arrogant; in comparison, the Earnshaws are strong willed,
moody, generous, free spirited, easily influenced, laid back and
non-formal. The nurture of the characters is connected very strongly
to social status: Heathcliff is denied social status initially by his
birth and subsequently by Hindley, which creates great hatred in
Heathcliff: this denial of status is perceived much more seriously
than what we consider serious today. Catherine chooses Edgar over
Heathcliff for reasons of social status, even though she and
Heathcliff are so similar. Hareton is also denied social status, which
turns his attitudes against the Gentry class and creates rifts between
him and other characters: for example, it makes Cathy and Linton, who
would be his equals, look down on him. Social status is so important
to the characters it is used as a weapon against enemies, and a tool
for becoming more self-aware.

The first time Lockwood meets Heathcliff he is very aware of his
suspicious and defensive nature: 'the solitary neighbour that I shall
be troubled with', 'his deep black eyes withdraw so suspiciously'.
This is not necessarily entirely due to Heathcliff's nature; it could
also be attributed to nurture. This suspicion could be due to his
cruel treatment as he was growing up; by Hindley especially, teaching
him to trust no-one. This effect of nurture could also explain why
Heathcliff doesn't welcome Lockwood into his house, or apprehend the
dogs when they attack him. Heathcliff is looked upon favourably by
Lockwood at first, he says he is a 'capital fellow', but this opinion
changes as Lockwood is subject to Heathcliff's cruel and cold hearted
attitude. He describes Wuthering Heights as being 'completely removed
from the stir of society' and 'a perfect misanthropist's heaven': he
soon realises that Heathcliff could be described in similar ways,
especially after he is refused a guide home in a storm and is attacked
twice by Heathcliff's dogs. Lockwood changes his mind about Heathcliff
being a capital fellow; he goes on to describe him as a 'rough fellow'
to Nelly Dean, who...

Find Another Essay On Heathcliff and Hareton Earnshaw in Wuthering Heights

The Character of Heathcliff in the novel, Wuthering Heights

531 words - 2 pages , Wuthering Heights. As a result, Heathcliff takes revenge by becoming the new owner and forcing Hindley's son, Hareton, to work long, hard hours in the fields. Another character that Heathcliff demonstrates his revenge on is Edgar Linton. Edgar married Catherine Hareton, who Heathcliff was madly in love with, and as a result, Heathcliff decides to take venegeance on Edgar by marrying his sister, Isabella.A second theme that is related to the

Compare Contrast of Mr. Darcy and Heathcliff in Pride and Prejudice and Wuthering Heights

626 words - 3 pages Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte and Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austin both have many similarities and differences with one another. There are few characters that can be compared and contrasted, but two that stood out the most were Mr. Darcy and Heathcliff. In Wuthering Heights, Heathcliff shared common life problems with Mr. Darcy from Pride and Prejudice. For example, both Mr. Darcy and Heathcliff have complicated love lives that struggled

Heathcliff - A Character Defined By His Past, in Wuthering Heights

1293 words - 5 pages Wuthering Heights is a novel whose main character is said to have a double significance. He is said to be both the dispossessed and the dispossessor, victim of class hatred and arch – exploiter, he simultaneously occupies the roles of working class outsider and brutal capitalist. Heathcliff has all these characteristics because of his experiences. He is a character moulded by his past. Heathcliff is a character defined by his sympathetic

Heathcliff, the Non-Conformist Portrayed in Bronte's Wuthering Heights

636 words - 3 pages In Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights Heathcliff is represented as a non-conformist due to his unorthodox behavior in relation to other characters. The novel gives an idealistic insight into the accepted social discourses of the era, to which Heathcliff does not comply. These unconventional heroic traits can be closely associated with that of the Byronic Hero. Heathcliff also struggles to adjust his persona to the stereotypical romance hero in his

The Character of Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte

993 words - 4 pages The Character of Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte What do we learn about Heathcliff’s character from Pg 12 - the entrance of Heathcliff (paragraph 2) to Pg 13 “my amiable lady”. How typical is this of elsewhere in the novel? This extract is taken from the beginning of the novel, chapter 2. In this chapter we begin to pick up on the uncomfortable atmosphere in Wuthering Heights and a further insight

Wuthering Heights Essay - Is Heathcliff truly evil?

598 words - 2 pages Wuthering Heights Essay - Is Heathcliff truly evil? I think with the modern understanding of the way childhood affects one's whole perception of life and the world, we would be arrogant to call Heathcliff evil. Without a doubt Heathcliff is an anomaly. Lockwood initially describes him as "a dark skinned gypsy in aspect, in dress and manners a gentleman". The first view we have of heathcliff is as dark, handsome, gentlemanly and morose

The Jealous Heathcliff of Wuthering Heights

1656 words - 7 pages The Jealous Heathcliff of Wuthering Heights     Throughout Wuthering Heights, Heathcliff's personality could be defined as dark, menacing, and brooding. He is a dangerous character, with rapidly changing moods, capable of deep-seeded hatred, and incapable, it seems, of any kind of forgiveness or compromise. In the first 33 chapters, the text clearly establishes Heathcliff as an untamed, volatile, wild man and establishes his great

Heathcliff Is A Villain In The Story "Wuthering Heights" And As Such Cannot Win The Sympathy Of The Reader. Discuss

297 words - 2 pages Heathcliff is a villain in the novel, "Wuthering Heights", however he can still win the sympathy of the reader in different stages of the novel.When Heathcliff first came into the story, he was an innocent, young boy who had done nothing wrong. He was tormented and disturbed nightly for 18 years, ever having only one wish to be reunited with Catherine. At this stage of the novel, the reader tends to sympathise for Heathcliff for all that he has

Role Play Essay on "Wuthering Heights" by Emily Bronte. Write the conversation between Heathcliff and Catherine

1267 words - 5 pages After the death of Catherine, Heathcliff got on thinking of Catherine, although he had won in his revenge plan, but he's not happy at all. Because he has lost his beloved Catherine. One day, he dig out Catherine's coffin, he would like to bury with his woman. Not long after, he was dead peacefully. He met Catherine's soul and they traveled the place they once lived, and their memories are full of each other.Heathcliff: Catherine, my Catherine

Wuthering Heights-Love is what drives Heathcliff to insanity

865 words - 3 pages Heathcliff so welldesigns. Encouraging Hindley to gamble and drink, Heathcliff's wishes begin to take holdas Hindley must give up Wuthering Heights due to gambling and Heatchcliff takes it away.Hindley passes, "true to his character: drunk as a lord" (160). In the methodical way onlyknown by a man incensed with an unfulfilled love, Heathcliff moves on to take revenge onthe man most responsible for his unhappiness,Edgar Linton. After becoming rich and

Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë - Heathcliff, a protagonist or antagonist?

815 words - 3 pages Wuthering HeightsWuthering Heights may be perceived to be just another novel, waiting to be read by the average reader, sitting on some remote bookshelf. This narrow-mindedness will be out of the mind of the reader when he turns past the first page; this novel is anything but conventional. Some characters have more depth to us than many real-life people, and one such character is Heathcliff. Ravaged by the past and bent on avenging everyone who

Similar Essays

Characters Of Catherine And Heathcliff In Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights

1626 words - 7 pages years in Liverpool, this distortion had already begun when Mr. Earnshaw brought him into Wuthering Heights, a "dirty, ragged, black-haired child"(45; ch.7). Already he was inured to hardship and uncomplainingly accepted suffering. Heathcliff displays his strength and steadfastness when he had the measles, and when Hindley treated him cruelly if he got what he wanted. From the very beginning he showed great courage, resoluteness, and love. Few have

Examine How Young Cathy, Hareton, And Linton Compare And Contrast With Catherine, Heathcliff, And Edgar In Wuthering Heights? What Differences And Similarities Do You Find Between These Two...

595 words - 2 pages As characters of the first generation in Wuthering Heights marry and bear children, the focus shifts to the younger generation. However, the second generation is under a huge influence of the elders. Cathy (for clarity's sake, I address the daughter of Catherine as Cathy in this essay), Hareton and Linton Heathcliff are not solely influenced by Heathcliff's brutal force. Their personalities greatly exhibit unique combinations of the first

Wuthering Heights Heathcliff Essay

1834 words - 7 pages Wuthering Heights Heathcliff Heathcliff is introduced in Nelly's narration as a seven-year-old Liverpool foundling (probably an Irish famine immigrant) brought back to Wuthering Heights by Mr. Earnshaw. His presence in Wuthering Heights overthrows the prevailing habits of the Earnshaw family, members of the family soon become involved in turmoil and fighting and family relationships become spiteful and hateful. Even on his first night, he is

Elizabeth Bennet Vs. Catherine Earnshaw In Pride And P Rejudice And Wuthering Heights

1380 words - 6 pages . Being raised in a narcissistic society that looks down upon her and family's status, she grew up to have a natural defensive remark to any insults. Her natural defensiveness led to her prejudice towards a very wealthy Mr. Darcy who shared the same impression of Elizabeth. After a realization of his true noble personality, Elizabeth then found true love with Mr. Darcy which cannot be said for the beautiful Catherine Earnshaw, in Wuthering Heights