This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hegemonic Masculinity Practices Essay

1493 words - 6 pages

As mentioned before in historically specific masculinities, hegemonic masculinity is not a universal phenomenon. Hegemonic masculinity practices are not only dominate towards women - domination practices also involve ‘other’ masculinities. Hegemonic masculinity is thus “the hegemony over women and hegemony over subordinate masculinities”, according to Demetriou (2009,341).
Not all men and their practices, fall within the hegemonic masculine “category”. Connell and Messerschmidt (2005:846) observe that there are hierarchy within masculinity and describe this as a pattern of hegemony. Within this hierarchy, certain masculinities are socially more central and more associated with authority and power compared to others. They expand by stating that non-hegemonic masculinities, within the masculinities sphere – are subordinate to their hegemonic brothers. They describe this subordination as complex with factors such as cultural consent, discursive centrality and marginalization playing a part in the process of domination and the creation of non-hegemonic masculinities.
Demetriou (2001, 341-343) label non-hegemonic masculinities as internal hegemony (or masculine hegemony over other masculinities). Three forms of internal hegemony are identified: subordinate masculinity, marginalized masculinity and complicit masculinity.
Subordinate masculinities, according Demetriou and in concurrence with Wedgwood (2008:335), specify that certain groups of men have less status and privilege than the ‘dominant’ hegemonic group. He uses the example of gay versus heterosexual men - with gay men receiving the short end of the stick in relations to material practices and is discriminated against in a political-, economic-, cultural- and legal sphere.
Marginalized masculinities refer to the domination of men (by men) based on their social class and/or ethnic group (Demetriou, 2009). Connelll and Messerschmidt (2005,847) concur and elaborate by arguing that marginalized groups are often dominated on condition of their specific location (local level) and use blue-collar workers as an example. In regards with ethnic groups – oppression based on race comes into play. Connell and Messerschmidt (2005:848) observe that marginalized masculinities lack economic resources and institutional authority to change their situation and be incorporated into hegemony masculinity.
Complicit masculinities as a non-hegemonic group, does not act in the way prescribed by the hegemonic model (Demetriou, 2009). They are, however, still passively sustaining patriarchy. This relates to the cultural idea attached to masculine hegemony: civil society promotes patriarchy through examples of what “true masculinity” should be - as illustrated previously with the Brad Pitt example. These men are not in the “army of domination”, per se, but still benefit from patriarchy.
3.7. Femininity and gender hegemony
Connell state in Wedgwood (2008,335) that there is a need for a “more complex model...

Find Another Essay On Hegemonic Masculinity Practices

Mad Men & The Representation of "US"

2321 words - 10 pages general relaxing of social taboos. Draper made a life for himself and accomplished the American Dream, a job on Madison Avenue, a lovely housewife, two darling children and a house with a picket fence. That was the picture of America in the 50s and Draper lived up to it--he is the ideal American man. In this sense, Donald Draper is also the face of hegemonic masculinity. This social structure concerns the dominant socially constructed norms and

Implications of Living in a Gendered Society

2691 words - 11 pages , " 'Masculinity' to the extent the term can be briefly defined at all, is simultaneously a place in gender relations, the practices through which men and women engage that place in gender, and the effects of these practices in bodily experience, personality and culture." (1995:71) In addition to this Conner states, "Masculinity is, in effect, defined as not-femininity" (1995:70). From this one must speculate as to where this

HIV/AIDS Propelled the Study of Sexuality

2046 words - 9 pages ‘heteropolarity’ maintained within the context of hegemonic heterosexuality, which asserts conventional femininity as ‘passivity, helplessness, and victimisation’ (Vance, 1984), in opposition to a super-ordinated masculinity; predicted upon independence, activity and the possession of sexual desire and power (Goldstein, 1994; Connell, 1987). Consequently, heterosexuality has often been theorised by feminists as a repressive, patriarchal institution

Discussion of Theoretical Perspectives in Danby, S. (1996). Constituting social membership: Two readings of talk in an early childhood classroom. Language and Education, 10(2&3), 151-170

1654 words - 7 pages . Different power relations imply that at any point of time in a society, there is a dominant set of discourse that defines what is right, normal or desirable (MacNaughton, 1995, p. 43). In most societies, the dominant gender discourse of hegemonic masculinity positions females in a subordinate position to males (Connell, 1995, 1996; Davies, 1996; cited in Grieshaber, 1998, p. 17). Such asymmetrical power relations is not natural, and therefore

Gender as a binary construction

2872 words - 11 pages genderless and refuse to let us readers know the gender of their four months baby.Hegemonic masculinity is the dominant form of masculinity; it is masculinity that society places most value on, its part of the dominant norms and values. Hegemonic characteristics include white, middle class, strong, arrogant, the breadwinner of the family. It is also a social construct of an idea type in terms of Webber's definition it means an extreme example by which we


2158 words - 9 pages allows patriarchal structures and violence to occur. Therefore, it shows that religion contributes to intimate partner violence and of women's subordination. Social construction of Masculinity The social construction of hegemonic masculinity and gender roles is supported by patriarchy system which allows women abuse to take place within the family. Connell (1998), notes that masculinities is culturally defined that is usually associated with men

Gender Representations in Music Videos:

2137 words - 9 pages what has been described as the cultural valorization of certain kinds of hegemonic masculinity (particularly in terms of gender relations), in which practices and dispositions that indicate male dominance over females are implicitly encouraged and celebrated. Therefore, hip hop music videos essentially amplify these subcultural orientations in the way they portray male and female characters, thereby perpetuating stereotypical gender behaviors

Gender Analysis of Loser by Lady Saw

2529 words - 11 pages logically to the parallel reality of male artistes such as Vybz Kartel, in the dancehall space, who appropriate sexual reward for money spent on female counterparts – as expressed in the song “Tek Buddy Gal.” It could therefore be understood as a reinforcement of the hegemonic masculinity that already exists in the dancehall, according to Donna Hope. (Hope, 2010) In a contradictory shift of thought, it is seen where negative attitudes towards female

A Beautiful Ideal: Advertising as Proscriptive, Not Merely Descriptive

980 words - 4 pages Softly 3, “To a great extent advertising tells us who we are and who we should be” (Kilbourne). Advertising determines the standards that people strive to achieve in society. Reflecting the male hegemonic standard, a binary opposition is established where men are portrayed as active, strong, controlling, and independent in advertising. In contrast, women are displayed as passive, weak, controlled, and dependent. This opposition is best represented

"Walklate (1998: vi) suggests Feminism and Criminology may be contradictions in terms. To what extent do you agree with her?

1708 words - 7 pages to be established, this masculinisation does not seem to be conducive to offending" (source adapted from Naffine, 1987:96). This lack of proof of the hegemonic masculinity of crime would suggest again that there is no room for feminism within criminology at least on this basis of criminology being sex-specific towards male offenders or at least female 'masculine' ones.So far this essay has mainly discussed reasons why feminist perspectives have

Conceptions of Canada as a Peaceful Nation

1548 words - 6 pages , Canadians view white people as normal and good. Therefore, with these ideas in mind, the peacekeepers felt compelled to colonize and civilize the Somali natives. Specifically, the article suggests:there is a relationship of hegemonic masculinity to the making of Canada as a white nation-state that when military men performed themselves as colonizers, they drew on, and simultaneously sustained, a national mythology in which bodies of color are

Similar Essays

Examining Sub Cultures: The Goth Culture Essay

1825 words - 7 pages focus on Goth culture and the extent to which it challenges the hegemonic norms of masculinity. “Hegemonic Masculinity refers to a culturally dominant set of ideas and practices about what it means to be a man and how men should behave” (Mansfield, 2007: 1). It is, in simpler terms the general perception of what it is to be masculine that dominants society and the way in which most people portray their masculinity. It is hoped that through the

Masculinity And Hegemonic Masculinity Second Year Of University Essay

2780 words - 12 pages status. Although these types of practices may appeal to the conventional Western concepts of hegemonic masculinity, this does not necessarily result in a leisurely and good life span of the individuals who subscribe to these practices. As gender dynamics evolve and women's authoritative powers grow stronger, the concept of masculinities may witness the extinction of power differentiation and a more consistent and equitable dynamic between men and

Masculinity In The Workplace Essay

1404 words - 6 pages explained by Williams is hegemonic masculinity. It is a concept that was first introduced by R. W. Connell and he defines it as follows: ”The socially dominant form of masculinity in any given historical period. Qualities currently associated with hegemonic masculinity include physical strength and bravado, exclusive heterosexuality, stoicism, authority, and independence.” According to Martin Kilduff and Ajay Mehra, male hegemonic masculinity is

The Role That Sport Plays In The Social Inclusion And Exclusion Of Young People

2014 words - 9 pages people together within the educational setting and provide them with a sense of belonging, it can also socially exclude others (Swain 2000). Within the semiformal subsystem, sport can be used by boys as a symbol of their hegemonic masculinity (Swain 2003; Swain 2000). In a study carried out by Swain (2003) it was identified that boys proved their masculinity to others through their body, by being athletic and physical. This research identified