Heinrich Schliemann Essay

4663 words - 19 pages


"We could describe (Heinrich) Schliemann's excavations on the hill of Hissarlik and consider their results without speaking of Troy or even alluding to it," Georges Perrot wrote in 1891 in his Journal des Savants. "Even then, they would have added a whole new chapter to the history of civilization, the history of art" (qtd. in Duchêne 87). Heinrich Schliemann's life is the stuff fairy tales are made of. A poor, uneducated, and motherless boy rises through his hard work and parsimonious lifestyle to the heights of wealth (Burg 1,2). He travels the world and learns its languages ("Heinrich Schliemann"), takes a beautiful Greek bride, and together they unearth the treasures of Troy and the citadel of Agamemnon, thereby fulfilling the dream he has chased since childhood (Calder 18,19; Burg 8). Indeed, by presenting his life in romantic autobiographies as a series of adventures, starring Heinrich Schliemann as the epic hero (Duchêne 14), he ensured his status as a lasting folk hero and perennial bestseller (Calder 19).

The reality was that Heinrich Schliemann was an incredible con man, a generally unlikable braggart who succeeded only because of his queer mix of genius and fraudulence. He had a shylock's conscience when it came to business dealings, and his shady methods pervaded both his life and his archaeology (Burg, 15-31). Schliemann had a habit of rewriting his past in order to paint a more dramatic picture of himself. Among the events he reported that have been found to be grossly untrue are his tales of being entertained by the American president Millard Fillmore and his wife in 1851, and his narrow escape from the San Francisco fire of that same year (Traill 9-13). More disturbing is when he applies these tactics to his archaeology. In December of 1981 Professor David Traill, a Latinist, concluded that the "Treasure of Priam", Schliemann's

most impressive find at Troy, was actually a composite of several small finds uncovered from beyond the walls of the city. Schliemann had collected the pieces from 1871 to 1873 in order to produce a single find large enough to earn him the respect of fellow archaeologists, and also permission from the British to excavate at Mycenae (Calder 33). Twenty years of research led the Traill to the belief that, "the question is no longer whether but rather to what extent we should distrust Schliemann's archaeological reports" (Traill 6).

However, the modern scholars' assessment of Schliemann as a fraud and a psychopath (Calder 36-37) unfairly detracts from the importance of what he discovered and innovated as an amateur archaeologist ("Heinrich Schliemann: An Objective View of a Flawed Man of Genius"). Schliemann himself once wrote, "If my memoirs now and then contain contradictions, I hope that these may be pardoned when it is considered that I have revealed a new world of archaeology. The objects which I brought to light by...

Find Another Essay On Heinrich Schliemann

The Trojan War Essay

1149 words - 5 pages astonishing queen named Helen, whose angelic loveliness sparked the tension between Troy and Greece. Helen was the queen of the Greek city-state Sparta, married to King Menelaeus. In Heinrich Schliemann’s book “The Search for Troy” he announced that “Helen was considered to be the most gorgeous mortal in the entire world” (Schliemann 36). Her godly looks were adored all around, but one man was jealous of Greece having such a beautiful queen, and wanted

Atlantis - Will we ever know?

964 words - 4 pages . Schliemann introduced himself as thegrandson of the famous Heinrich Schliemann, the archeologist who discovered the ruins ofancient Troy in 1873. His "discovery" made front page news (The New York American,October 1912.) and boasted of an advanced civilization with aircraft, power-driven boatsand the like. Schliemann said his grandfather told him on his deathbed of the family'ssecret: the location of Atlantis. Schliemann's claims made waves, but didn't

Atlantis: We will never know. Speaks also of Plato's work in this

933 words - 4 pages thegrandson of the famous Heinrich Schliemann, the archeologist who discovered the ruins ofancient Troy in 1873. His 'discovery' made front page news (The New York American,October 1912.) and boasted of an advanced civilization with aircraft, power-driven boatsand the like. Schliemann said his grandfather told him on his deathbed of the family'ssecret: the location of Atlantis. Schliemann's claims made waves, but didn't hold water;when pressed for

The book that changed me

696 words - 3 pages truth for everyone but I have found it to be such for me when I was introduced to Heinrich Schliemann, the protagonist of Dream of Troy. Schliemann was not only a successful entrepreneur but he was a polyglot and archeologist. His life was full adventures, which were vivid and never void of tempestuous ups and downs. The one thing that amazed me the most was his firm belief that you can reach absolutely everything if you work hard, believe in

The Myth of the Matador and Theseus and The Iliad by Homer

2547 words - 10 pages years ago against Troy, and that Agamemnon was victorious. In 1870, Heinrich Schliemann started to excavate for the Trojan Empire. Schliemann’s life goal was to find the city of Troy. He decided to excavate Hissarlik. He almost lost hope in finding Troy, however he kept on trying. He excavated deep into Hissarlik, finding what he thought was the city of Troy. Schliemann first found a great gate, with a road leading inside. The road was big

ancient

1824 words - 7 pages archeological evidence provided being limited and hard to find. Due to these reasons, it is hard to find any proof of the war of Troy as anything more than speculation and myth, excepting the discovery of a site that is believed to be the place of Troy in a village in modern day Turkey by Heinrich Schliemann in 1862. The archeological evidence has since been widely accepted as the ancient city of Troy, however, there is still large amounts of

Schliemann’s Archaeological Breakthrough

832 words - 4 pages Heinrich Schliemann’s archaeological break throughs on the “Tell of Hissarlik” provided a substantial awareness of the civilizations of the Bronze ages1 and hence our understanding of its relationship to Homeric Troy. Many aspects of the Historicity of Homeric Troy include the existence of the Trojan War, the accuracy of Homers Iliad and contributions of Schliemann and other Archaeologist. Schliemann’s archaeological breakthrough was instigated

Atlantis the Lost Civilization

1972 words - 8 pages hundred and translated it into one thousand (Berlitz 63).Even though there are many serious researchers actually trying to discover Atlantis, there are some who are not so serious. The greatest and most infamous Atlantis hoaxer used an already famous name to gain recognition. His name was Dr. Paul Schliemann. Dr. Paul Schliemann claimed to be the grandson of Dr. Heinrich Schliemann, the archaeologist who discovered the ruins of ancient Troy in

Was There a Trojan War? This essay attempts to answer a question that is very controversial

1663 words - 7 pages attacked the city of Troy. Despite this, they are still uncertain as to why this war took place.German scientist Heinrich Schliemann was the first to present archaeological evidence that supported the existence of the Trojan War. In 1870 he had excavated the site for Troy, looking for signs of the ruined city. Troy was located on a small strip of land called the Dardanelles, which extended from the coast of Asia Minor. Previous scholars had noted

The Historic Accuracy of Homer’s Iliad

2986 words - 12 pages seen to be the first person to discover the mound called Hissarlik situated in the Troad area in north-western Asia Minor in 1865 .Although not having the resources to carry out further investigation, he invited wealthy German business man turned archaeologist Heinrich Schliemann to investigate. Schliemann was obsessed with the Iliad, having been read it as a child and seeing a depiction of Troy in a common history book by Ludwig Jerrer

Helen of Troy Fact vs. Fiction Research Paper

2018 words - 8 pages investigators pursue the search for the ancient city.In May of 1873, an archaeologist by the name of Heinrich Schliemann discovered the Troy, or Truva, in Turkey. Using the Iliad as a guide to find the lost city of Troy, Schliemann found a village in Hissarlik that's location matched Homer's writings.The geographical features described by Homer were generally in an accurate location. When Schliemann found Troy in the village Hissarlik, there was a

Similar Essays

Archeology: Heinrich Schliemann Essay

863 words - 4 pages Archeology, which is the study of human activity in the past, has many significant names that discovered important sites to the history of art. One of these names is Heinrich Schliemann. Heinrich Schliemann was born on 6th of January, 1822, and died on December 26th, 1890. Schliemann was a businessman who could speak 15 languages, and he was a world traveler. His father used to read for him Homer’s Iliad when he was eight years old, which made

Heinrich S Chliemann Biography Essay

1558 words - 6 pages began the year after. After finding the treasure, Schliemann illegally exported it from Turkey.Although Heinrich Schliemann contributed a lot to archaeology, many archaeologists have reproached him, believing that he had destroyed many things of great value during his tremendous excavations, although the backward time and the underdeveloped methods of archaeological research must be taken into consideration.Whether the extensive diaries and papers

Troy Essay

558 words - 2 pages was a entertainer, and the iliad was a recited song that he would tell to an audience as a form of entertainment, however they were not written down until hundreds of years after the great battle between the Greeks and Trojans.In 1870 Heinrich Schliemann began the excavation at the site of Troy. Schliemann was a amateur archeologist from Germany. Schliemann followed the geographical clues in the 'Iliad' and began excavating North West Turkey

Advent Of The Trojan War Essay

589 words - 2 pages invincible warrior of the Greeks may have not existed, the wooden horse is thought to have been made up by Homer and finally the cause of the war seems to be imaginary. Until the 19th century it actually was widely believed that Troy and the Trojan War were imaginary. It was not until 1871 that German-born American citizen Heinrich Schliemann excavated a site in Turkey. Schliemann surprised many by discovering the lost city of Troy. Although