This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hemingway’s, A Farewell To Arms: Does The Film Do Justice To The Novel?

854 words - 3 pages

A Farewell to Arms, published in 1929, is a classic short story written by Ernest Hemingway about the hardships and cruelties of love and war. In 1932, a film adaptation of the novel was developed by Director Frank Borzage and nonetheless the unquestionable originality of his photography as well as for his excellent directorial concepts; Borzage misses on many levels of Hemingway’s brilliant description and significant dialogue between the main character Lieutenant Frederic Henry and his fellow Italian officers. The film is voiced and positioned towards the eyes of Borzage rather than the story of Hemingway and the incidents are frequently noticeable throughout the film. But to be reasonable, the novel is a difficult task, considering that the story is told in the first person. If anyone has not read Hemingway’s, A Farewell to Arms, the film will appeal as a rather interesting tragic romance but in some of the scenes, however, the producers take this for granted and assume that the spectator has read the book before. My argument is that the film misses on many of the important aspects that Hemingway’s print version offers. The film does not do justice to the book. Director Frank Borzage focuses merely on the romance characteristics of the story, ignoring the brutalities of war, skipping over many scenes, trying to enhance the melancholy approach to the book.
The films explanations skip too quickly for my liking, from one chapter to another and the sufferings and understandings of Lieutenant Henry are passed over too brusquely, being advised rather than voiced. Violence within the film is drastically censored, in fact there is no recollections of the violence and brutality of war and in some scenes, Borzage does not even attempt to show the wounded, but contents himself by depicting what the wounded man sees, for example, the faces from above him, the hospital ceiling. Also in the film, a viewer is confused as to where the characters are in the film, and when Lieutenant Henry decides to escape from Italy to Switzerland the glimpse of him getting into a boat is not recollected within the novel as Henry goes to Milan to find Catherine so they can leave for Switzerland together. The confrontation between Catherine and Henry appears to gather up hastily within the film and whenever Catherine and Frederic begin to acknowledge their love for one another, the melodrama comes forth and the story becomes intolerably sentimental. To me, it seemed as if the director feared he...

Find Another Essay On Hemingway’s, A Farewell to Arms: Does The Film Do Justice To The Novel?


1114 words - 5 pages World War I began in 1914 and lasted until the end of 1918. In that time young men had to go to the front and fight for their country. It is also the time when Ernest Hemingway’s novel A Farewell to Arms takes place. It talks about Frederic Henry, a young American who is an ambulance driver for the Italian army. He is also the novel’s narrative and protagonist. He falls in love with an English nurse, Catherine Barkley. She is the main woman

"A Farewell To Arms" : This essay shows how existentialism ties into the novel and gives description of important events

658 words - 3 pages This novel shows the existentialist way of thinking in the way that each person's life in the war was unique and the existence of that individual is unexplainable. Each move and each act is that person's responsibility, which may lead to something else, sometimes the difference between life and death. There is no God to watch over man, to dictate morality, or to reassure justice. Instead, the universe is indifferent and hostile to a soldier's

A Farewell to Arms

1076 words - 4 pages A Farewell to Arms, one of the most renowned masterpieces of Ernest Hemingway, is a detailed account of life during World War I, which depicts a gruesome and deleterious reality of a soldier by incorporating themes of impermanence and change. The author of this work tries to convey his notions about the concept of war and love. Throughout the novel, relationship between man and woman in a grim reality of war is frequently discussed. Thus, A

A Farewell To Arms

2502 words - 10 pages 1) Introduction In this academic paper I will analyse the novel "A Farewell To Arms", written by Ernest Hemingway in 1929. The analysis will contain several important sub-points, as following: setting, characters, themes, structure, narrative technique and style. With the help of these points I shall be able to point out what this novel is about and of what it consists of.2) Main part contains: a. Setting b. Characters c

A Farewell to Arms

1619 words - 6 pages A Farewell to ArmsIn this study I will compare "a farewell to arms" by Ernest Hemingway and the same version of the movie dated back to 1932, which is indeed a work independent than the book, the novel itself. Therefore I will, in this study, make an enlightened and detailed outlook of two different works of art, the picture and the novel. Because there are really lots of parts in movie which are not following the same way of life, act

A Farewell to Arms

1843 words - 7 pages . Is it right to take a literary legend such as Hemingway and alter his creation to make money in the box office? In my opinion, if your goanna do it, do it right! After reading "A Farewell to Arms", it is a horrible make of such a great great novel. The book is so much better than the movie. I saw the movie first, the read the book. Going into the book, I thought it was going to be just like the movie, it wasn't! If you haven't seen or read it either, read it first. Trust me! You're sleep better at night. But that is the problem in our society, it is now visual rather than a (like reading) society. Do you think so?

A Farewell To Arms

731 words - 3 pages Literary scholars often fail to identify the true meanings of the great literature of our time. Someone once said that "In great writing, the style of writing is most important, not the content." The author of this axiom was correct in assuming that style is important in great writing however, this speaker has obviously not read Ernest Hemmingway's novel A Farewell To Arms. In Hemmingway's exceptional novel, he proves that the two literary

A Farewell To Arms

1576 words - 6 pages member to put themselves in his place. An interesting secondary theme is the theme that implies Catherine is crazy. Because of things Catherine says and does the crazy theme seems to fit her personality. Throughout the story there is plenty of evidence of all these things and these aspects made the story even better and much more fun to read. Bibliography: Gellens, Jay. Twentieth Century Interpretations of A Farewell To Arms.Englewood Cliffs, N.J. 1970. Lewis, Robert. A Farewell To Arms (A War With Words). New York, 1992. Monteiro, George. Critical Essays On: Ernest Hemmingway’s A Farewell To Arms.New York, 1994.

"A Farewell to Arms"

772 words - 3 pages theme of the novel "A Farewell to Arms" is the condemnation of war. I think, Hemingway wants to express his negative attitude to this cruel war and to show how it can destroy people's lives. The inhumanity of the war is the main problem of this novel.

A Farewell to Arms - 872 words

872 words - 4 pages In the book A Farewell to Arms, Catherine's passion for her values and motivations prove to, not only direct her, but direct Henry towards a fulfilled life. Catherine had an intense desire for love, dedication, and redemption. Through her love, she convinces Henry to live his life in a zealous way and take risks for a good cause. As a result of her dedication to a loved one, her liberating relationship is prolonged. Catherine's yearning for

The Irrelevant God in Ernest Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms

2854 words - 11 pages . Hemingway’s Resentful Cryptogram. Ernest Hemingway’s A Farewell to Arms. Ed. Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea, 1987. Fiedler, Leslie A. Love and Death in the American Novel. Rev. ed. New York: Stein and Day, 1966. Grebstein, Sheldon Norman. Hemingway’s Craft. Carbondale: Southern Illinois P, 1973. Hemingway, Ernest. A Farewell to Arms. New York: Scribner Paperback Fiction, 1957. Killinger, John. Hemingway and the Dead Gods: A Study in Existentialism. Lexington: U of Kentucky P, 1960.

Similar Essays

Hemingway’s A Farewell To Arms Essay

1189 words - 5 pages Our existence in life is special and unique, but unfortunately war destroys all living things. Ernest Hemingway explores his viewpoints on war and presents those concepts in the novel, A Farewell to Arms. Difficult situations arise during war, because it interferes with many aspects of life and usually has a negative impact overall. Hemingway articulates his beliefs about life during war, through the young character Fredrick Henry, but focuses

Self Absorption In Hemingway’s A Farewell To Arms

1028 words - 4 pages Self-Absorption in Hemingway’s A Farewell to Arms Catherine Barkley and Frederick Henry, the main characters in Hemingway’s A Farewell to Arms are two of the most self-absorbed characters I have ever come across. Frederick Henry thinks only of what he wants while Catherine worries only about what Frederick thinks and wants. They are constantly thinking only about themselves, which is why I believe that it was a good thing that the baby was

Modern Features Of "A Farewell To Arms" Viewed Trhrough The Main Characters Of The Novel

2424 words - 10 pages A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway is considered one of the great novels of World War I. It introduces the theme of love, while war occupies all of Europe. It is a complex novel with many characteristic aspects of modernism. After looking into Hemingway's biography, the reader can tell that he included details from his personal life in his novel. He based the main character Frederic Henry upon his own experience as an ambulance

How Marvel’s “To His Coy Mistress” Theme Relates To Hemingway’s “A Farewell To Arms”

1140 words - 5 pages Marvel’s poem to “His Coy Mistress” with its carpe diem theme is cleverly quoted in Hemingway’s novel “A Farewell to Arms”. The theme of seduction and living in the moment is apparent through several characters in the novel. Alcohol is also referenced throughout the story and used as a vice by the soldiers to think about the moment and not about the future. Catherine’s character is a perfect example of carpe diem. And war and violence force