Henri Pirenne Thesis, Explained And Proved.

919 words - 4 pages

In a series of articles and addresses which culminated in the book Mohammed and Charlemagne, Pirenne advanced the thesis that the Ancient World ended only after the Arab invasions of the seventh and eighth centuries had swept around the perimeter of the Mediterranean and had converted it into a Moslem lake upon which, as one Arab writer graphically said, the Christians could no longer "float a plank."The waters of the Mediterranean have held the Roman empire like cement; over its waters had passed trade and commerce, the Roman military and naval might, and the vital exchange of ideas. The German tribes that had occupied the western Empire had not, according to Pirenne, destroyed this Mediterranean unity of the Roman Empire. They had, in fact, admired the superior civilization and had labored to continue it; the German chiefs had mimicked the Roman emperors in dress and ceremony, had appropriated Roman government, had continued to use the civitas as the center of administration, had employed the gold coinage of Diocesan and Constantine, and had done what they could to preserve Roman culture. Though these German kingdoms had had no effective political ties with the eastern half of the Empire, they had still partaken of the Mediterranean unity and had enjoyed unbroken economic exchange with the East and because of this the Empire has not fallen into the dark ages.The Conventional date for the Fall of the Roman Empire is 476 AD but Pirenne looks not at the disruption of the government by Germanic tribes but at the exchange of trade and culture, which at this point is still ongoing. Pirenne gives evidence that goods like papyrus continued to be traded between east and west that eastern merchants could be found in western ports, that eastern products like spices continued to be available and that some money continued in circulation. It seemed to him, therefore, that there was at this point in the 5th Century no break in the unity of the Mediterranean, and no turning point.It is also important to remember the amount of respect the Germanic tribes had for the Romans. The Germanic tribes in the West were becoming Romanized. Germans served in the Roman Army and sometimes Germans commanded the armies of Rome. Thus the conflicts in the West were not civilization versus barbarians but instead Romanized Germans fighting against Germanized Roman armies. The battles in the East were a different matter; there it was Roman culture versus Parthian (Persian) culture. Losses in the West could be regained by diplomacy if not military operations, but losses in the East were permanent. Thus the shift of administration from Rome to Constantinople reflected this situation.As the Germanic tribes came to ahead with Charlemagne it is again important to realize the respect for the culture, crowned by the Pope, Charlemagne became,...

Find Another Essay On Henri Pirenne Thesis, explained and proved.

"The Passion" By. Jeanette Winterson Essay

2100 words - 8 pages , and there are days when a stroll will take you round your kingdom like a tin-pot prince" (p.97).The last passion that I feel was apparent was the passion that Villanelle felt for Henri. This was not a passion that was filled with sexual desire; instead it was a friendship that Villanelle was passionate about. Villanelle loved Henri like a brother, wanted him to be happy, yet she knew that he loved her passionately and wanted to marry her

Accomplished Life of Marie Curie Essay

1765 words - 7 pages research even after Pierre's death. After her tragic loss, Marie had been invited to occupy the physics chair at the Sorbonne held by her late husband. She presented an inaugural lecture, scheduled for November 5, 1906 and explained the theory of ions in gases and her thesis on radioactivity. This was a very rare occurrence in the history of the Sorbonne. (Ashburn)In December of 1911 Marie Curie had won her second Nobel Prize, which was the first

Magna carta

622 words - 3 pages paragraph of the paper and summarizes how your paper proved the thesis; no new information is given in this paragraph. Introduction General Statement about the Topic Main Points Thesis Body First Paragraph - Main Point Supporting Details Supporting Details Concluding Sentence Transition Second Paragraph - Main Point Supporting Details Supporting Details Concluding Sentence Transition Third Paragraph - Main Point Supporting Details Supporting Details Concluding Sentence Transition Conclusion General statement about the Topic Summary of the main points used to prove the thesis

Aphrodite And Her Works

1277 words - 5 pages Hesiod, consisted of her rising from the sea where Uranus’ genitals had fallen after Kronos had mutilated him in a fit of rage (Columbia University Press). This particular story explained many of her different characteristics-particularly her promiscuity and tempermentality.This myth also implied the absence of any parental figures for Aphrodite, which may also explain her inability to settle down in marriage. Upon Zeus’ orders, however, she was

J.J. Thomson

746 words - 3 pages investigation of conducting electricity through gases. However, after breakthroughs by Marie Curie and Henri Becquerel in the field of radioactivity he turned his attention to this branch. In 1898, Marie Curie (Polish physicist) and Pierre Curie (French physicist) were one of the first scientists to isolate radium and polonium from pitchblende (uraninite). Henri Becquerel received a Nobel Prize for his work, finding radioactivity in uranium. Wilhelm

The Importance of Writing Techniques: Comparing Chinese and English Academic Writing

1001 words - 5 pages academic writing and these tools have helped me throughout the semester. Furthermore, these techniques are essential and necessary in order to write a successful essay. As I look through my first essay, I find countless errors and places I can improve. In my revised essay, I carefully restated my thesis statement, reconstructed my PIE paragraphs, and worked on stronger transitions words, because these three parts are the heart of a successful

Gerald Graff's Hidden Intellectualism

1937 words - 8 pages College has always been a process that introduces students to academic challenges that are not present during high school. So when my professor assigned Gerald Graff's essay, "Hidden Intellectualism", I thought this was his thesis. “Missing the opportunity to tap into such street smarts and channel them into good academic work." (Graff 142) I thought that this was his thesis because it explains the main idea of the essay but I assumed its

Revolution of 1800

1843 words - 8 pages still wanted to be connected to the mother country, Britain, and his thesis also states that the Republicans taking power was the “fulfillment” of the American Revolution. In the election, Thomas Jefferson and Aaron Burr, both Republicans, tied, which held up the transition of power. Everyone was aware that a Republican would win, after Adam’s unsatisfactory presidency, but no one knew which candidate would pull through. The House of

John Brown's raid on the federal armory at Hapers Ferry - Cuba City advanced placement US history - DBQ

4970 words - 20 pages , America in the World, Geography and the Environment, Peopling, Identity, Politics and Power, and Economy. These will be explained in a separate activity. By the end of the first paragraph, the reader should not only know the thesis but also have a clear idea of the main arguments that will be developed in the body of the essay in support of the thesis. How much specificity to include in the roadmap should be a balancing act. On the one hand

"A Lesson Before Dying" by Ernest J. Gaines - speech

939 words - 4 pages Jefferson will die with dignity- Grant Wiggins, the narrator. A cynical disillusioned teacher called upon to instill a sense ofpride and self-worth in Jefferson before his execution- Tante Lou, Grant's aunt and Miss Emma's best friend- Vivian Baptiste, Grant Wiggin's girlfriend- Henri Pichot, the owner of the plantation that once employed Miss Emma and Tante Lou ascook and housekeeper- Sam Guidry, sheriff of Bayonne County; Henri Pichot's brother-in

Slaughter House Five

993 words - 4 pages up my thesis with evidence (quotes) from the book itself to help me state that my thesis was right. I had also found three secondary evidence (quotes) from reliable sources that will back up my primary evidence for my thesis. I had backed up my thesis throughly without others really being able to dispute my thesis since I have found reliable information from reliable sources. In final I had explained and back up my thesis that I believed that Billy Pilgrim has PTSD in the book Slaughterhouse Five and there are many ways that this becomes apparent throughout Kurt Vonnegut’s novel.

Similar Essays

What Are The Problems Surrounding The Evidence For And Against The Pirenne Thesis? Europe From Late Antiquity To The Early Middle Ages

2757 words - 11 pages What are the problems surrounding the evidence for and against the Pirenne thesis?Europe From Late Antiquity to the Early Middle AgesCormac Griffin: A1177407In 1921, the Belgian historian Henri Pirenne hypothesized a premise that aimed to explain the materialization of settlements and the model of trading in Europe throughout the medieval period. Acknowledged as Pirenne's Thesis, it confronted the established orthodoxy, extracted from the works

Henri Saint Simon Essay

1507 words - 7 pages In Henri Saint-Simon’s writing “Lettres d’un habitant de Genève à ses Contemporains”, he stated that there should be three classes of mankind (Saint-Simon, 1803). In this proposition he explained that the first class was composed of scientists, artists and all those that hold the liberal thought or idea (Saint-Simon, 1803). The second class consisted of all the proprietors who did not fit in the first class. The third class is constructed by

The Formation Of Capitalism In European History

1355 words - 5 pages virtually all of society, dictated the need for a king to maintain public peace. Thus, the monarchs remained in power, but only figuratively (Pirenne, pp. 147-150). Obviously, feudalism and capitalism are diametrically opposed to one another. Therefore, it is only after the dissolution feudalism that a capitalist society can emerge in Europe. Feudalism, by its very structure, was resistant to change, thus when a force outside this order

Pooppoop Essay

2228 words - 9 pages -Islamic conquests, which be- gan in the seventh century and which, as the celebrated Belgian historian Henri Pirenne wrote in his landmark book Mohammed and Charlemagne (1939), shattered once and for all the ancient unity of the Mediterranean, destroyed the Christian-Roman syn- thesis and gave rise to a new civilization dominated by northern powers (Germany and Caro- lingian France) whose mis- sion, he seemed to be saying, is to resume defense of