Genetic Engineering: There Is No Genetic Definition Of Humanity

1801 words - 7 pages

With advances in genetics and the decryption of the human genome, many people are taking the time to sit back and ponder the questions of what humanity is and where it comes from.1 Will techniques such as gene therapy eventually create people who aren't quite human? If humanity is a flexible and ever-changing concept, then how do people know if they are human? Does some standard measure of humanity seem likely in our future, and is it even ethically proper to impose such a standard?

Philosophy offers the most satisfying definition of humanity: a human person is a conscious individual who interacts with an outside world. The details of the various philosophical debates on the exact nature of personhood would be enough to fill a library, but the main ideas can be summarized as follows: a person is self-aware, having the ability to think about thinking. Nothing in this definition of humanity involves matters of genetics or quantitative analyses of specific traits, which makes this definition applicable to people who may not be human in the way science tries to define the term.

Defining humanity in a scientific sense, however, is a nettled endeavor. Many "strictly human" traits can be found in animals. Wolves have a complex social structure. Bonobos, a subspecies of chimpanzee, can learn an abstract symbol-language and show the ability to understand grammar and syntax.2 In other experiments dolphins-who are genetically more distant from humans than bonobos-learned a type of sign language showing that they, too, are able to grasp complex rules of language.3 One only has to yell at the family dog to see that animals can express emotion and empathy. What, then, is left to humans?

Many point to our advanced technology as proof of our uniqueness, but it is well known that chimpanzees use tools on a regular basis. The only difference in this instance is that chimpanzees don't need to have very many advanced tools-they are more suited to their environment than the researchers who must carry around thirty pounds of gear to study them.

Despite evidence to the contrary, many people still cling to the belief that humans are somehow superior to all other organisms-this innate superiority being the essence of humanity. Humans are, after all, the most successful large animals on the planet, having spread to every continent and taken control of the ecosystems there. However, it could be argued that certain kinds of bacteria are more highly evolved than people-their genomes do not contain long stretches of "junk DNA" and their genes are organized into related groups more efficiently than the genes of most eukaryotes, like humans.4

The fallacy in the idea of human superiority is that most people assume that evolution is some sort of race: organisms compete with each other to be the most successful species of all, an "ultimate organism." "Evolution has no pinnacle and there is no such thing as evolutionary process."5 The truth of the matter is that...

Find Another Essay On Genetic Engineering: There is No Genetic Definition of Humanity

Genetic Engineering Essay

1565 words - 6 pages . There are potential negative factors that would only come into play if it used for the wrong reason. Yet, if controlled by the government, genetic engineering will be to help man accomplish great things.For every controversy there are opposing sides to an issue. Genetic engineering of course is no different. There are a small minority that would like genetic engineering of humans to cease. A majority of the general public, as well as the

Genetic Engineering Essay

1160 words - 5 pages Genetic Technology and the betterment of our world What exactly is genetic engineering? A simple definition of genetic engineering is "the ability to isolate DNA pieces that contain selected genes of other species"(Muench 238). Genetic engineering has been the upcoming field of biology since the early nineteen seventies. The prosperous field has benefits for both the medical and also the agricultural field. The diminishing of diseases

Genetic Engineering

1727 words - 7 pages world hunger is not due to lack of food, but rather corrupt governments, and lack of distribution, not production. Therefore, these genetically modified foods which may pose a risk to the consumers should not be distributed if there is no lack of natural foods.Another concept of genetic engineering which faces controversy is genetic engineering can help create plentiful and nutritious foods with great benefits for the environment. However, this

Genetic Engineering - 1178 words

1178 words - 5 pages In the field of animal and human genetic engineering there is much more speculation, than fact, because very little has actually been tested in the real world. Firstly, there’s a big question mark over safety of genetic engineering. In addition, genetic engineering can cause greater problems than that what we have today. Moreover, we can create a injustice world between Designer vs Non-designer children. Furthermore, genetic engineering is a

Genetic Engineering - 1422 words

1422 words - 6 pages individual would be used in the re-creation of the organ.Not only does genetic engineering present the possibilities of saving lives; it can save entire species from extinction. Genetic engineering could be used to increase the population of endangered species of animals, thus saving them from total extinction. This would help maintain a natural balance, and provide a continuous life cycle. Even though there is belief by some that genetic

Genetic Engineering - 2142 words

2142 words - 9 pages to save their child's life.Cloning is another form of genetic engineering that is not accepted as morally right. For example, to clone a human heart scientists do not have to clone the whole person. They only need to clone the heart by itself. This process of cloning would eliminate transplants and the use of anti-rejection drugs. It is; however, wrong to clone a whole human being. There would be no purpose in cloning a person, because it offers

Genetic Engineering - 2204 words

2204 words - 9 pages humanity by altering its genetic composition by encouraging breeding of those presumed to have desirable genes) is rightly seen as a major risk to developing genetic engineering technology. Eighteen percent of people interviewed in the United Kingdom said that if they could choose, they would make their child less likely to exhibit aggressive or alcoholic behaviour. Technically, if the gene for this behaviour were isolated, it

Genetic Engineering - 812 words

812 words - 3 pages Genetic engineering is no doubt the one of the most popular gossipy topic in the area of science and technology in the recent years. The reason for this is that it has a significant impact towards the human and it can be so called revolution of new life. Genetic engineering will be essential and beneficial towards all living organisms in the future years. Genetic engineering offers many solutions to individual and social needs but the

Genetic Engineering

1031 words - 4 pages benefit for humans in our continuous strive to manipulate the environment. The basic uses for genetic engineering include gene therapy, cloning, biological warfare, vaccines and antibiotic, human reproduction, and food production. Most of these uses of genetic engineering have positive results for humans; however there are some areas that have negative results. Gene-therapy is the alteration of an individual’s genetic material

Genetic Engineering

627 words - 3 pages Genetic Engineering Two years ago, genetically engineered bacteria, which unexpectently killed beneficial soil fungi, escaped into sewers through human error and have become toxic to plants and survived when expected not to.3 These are the sorts of consequences that come with playing God. DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) - the chemical compound that makes up the genes and determines the type of proteins a cell can make - is the core of genetic

Genetic Engineering - 1176 words

1176 words - 5 pages increasing importance is being placed on the role of genetic engineering in the use of riding the incidence of genetic disorders. 'There are over 6,000 known disorders which are due to a change (mutation) in a single gene.' (Healey, 1994: p. 11) These disorders cause havoc in growth, development and general health. (Healey, 1994: p. 11)Despite the acceptance of disabilities in the 21st century, the manner in which society portrays disabled persons as

Similar Essays

Genetic Engineering Is Unethical Essay

1135 words - 5 pages always beneficial to society. Genetic engineering is “altering the genetic material of cells and/or organisms in order to make them capable of making new substances or performing new functions'; (Wald 45). It is also one of the top controversial issues of the 20th century (Epstein 1). Many believe that continuing to provide genetically constructed inventions in this world is ethical, which means that these inventions conform to one’s moral standards

Ethics Of Genetic Engineering Essay

847 words - 3 pages is possible, would the fact that we can make that choice makes it right? Once we decide to begin the process of human genetic engineering, there is really no logical place to stop. If diabetes, sickle cell anemia, and cancer are to be cured by altering the genetic make-up of an individual, why not proceed to other "disorders": myopia, color blindness, left-handedness? Indeed, what is to preclude a society form deciding that a certain skin

Genetic Engineering (Genetic Technology) Essay

564 words - 2 pages abundant quantities. Other interesting ideas included attempts to make plants require less significant amounts of water. This concept could be quite helpful where there is drought, or other forms of water dearth. The possibilities of genetic engineering are endless, however there is much opposition to limitless potential of this branch of science. Many argue that mass production of genetically altered food could be unsafe or dangerous. Others say

Genetic Engineering Essay

1768 words - 7 pages help Lilith lead her people back to Earth. But there is a price. For the Oankali were genetic engineers. DNA manipulators. Gene traders. They planned to give us their alien ness. They planned to take their humanity. Through this novel, I have an interest in ‘genetic engineer’. What is genetic engineering? Is it possible to cure cancer by changing or manipulated genes or DNA? How does it work and how it can be manipulated? Also, I would