Hick´S Hypothesis About Religions Essay

1507 words - 6 pages

Imagine that three people are all touching a part of an elephant. The first is touching the elephant's leg and says that the elephant is like the truck of a tree. The second is touching the elephant's trunk and disagrees with the first, saying that the elephant is like a large snake. The third person is touching the elephant’s side and says that the elephant is like a great wall.
Each person is convinced that they are right and the others are wrong because of what they know and have experienced. What they don’t realize is that they are all technically right because they are each describing a different aspect of the elephant. The same analogy can be applied to the major religions of the world.
In 1973, John Hick discussed the idea for a paradigm shift in thinking about different religions in his book God and the Universe of Faiths. Hick suggested that each of world's religions should be viewed as "different human responses to one divine reality…." In a later book, Hick presented a theory that attempted to explain all the religions. Hick refers to this theory as a "pluralistic hypothesis" and was that all religions are culturally conditioned responses to the same ultimate reality.
Hick’s pluralistic theory faces one major difficulty though, the contradicting claims that each different religions makes. How can all major religions be responses of the same ultimate reality when they contradict one another? For a pluralistic view to be plausible, the hypothesis has to sufficiently explain how religions can make incompatible claims while at the same time be responses of the same ultimate reality.
To overcome this difficulty, Hick attempts to explain four critical factors: (1) people are inherently religious; (2) there is substantial diversity in the content of religious beliefs; (3) the assumption that religious beliefs are not an illusion; and (4) the recognition that almost every religion positively changes its followers' lives.
The first two factors are self-evident to most people, so in arguing the third factor, Hick examines two approaches to understand religious phenomena that he finds unacceptable: naturalism and absolutism. Naturalism is the belief that only natural laws and forces operate in the world and that nothing exists beyond the natural world. Though Hick acknowledges that the universe can be interpreted from a naturalistic perspective, he does not find plausible the claim that all religious beliefs are delusional.
Absolutism, in contrast to naturalism, generally accepts a realist view of religious phenomena. Absolutism also maintains that only one system of religious beliefs is exactly true and all other religions which disagree with it are false. Hick rejects this attitude, claiming that although absolutism may seem plausible when focusing on only one religion, application to the real world leaves it highly implausible. Also if absolutism were true, empirical evidence would exist to confirm it.
It is obvious that different...

Find Another Essay On Hick´s Hypothesis About Religions

Christianity In Comparison To Other World Religions

1534 words - 6 pages and approaches. I will end with a quotation from the Bhagavad Gita, with summarizes the paper very appropriately: "Howsoever man may approach me, even so do I accept them; for, on all sides, whatever path they may choose is mine" BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. John Hick & Brian Hebblethwaite, Christianity and other Religions, William Collins Sons & Co Ltd, Glasgow 1980.2. Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia, 2001 3. Geoffrey Parrinder, Upanishads, Gita and the Bible: A Comparative Study of Hindu and Christian Scriptures, Harper & Row, Publishers, Inc., 1972.4. Elizabeth Breuilly and Martin Palmer, Christianity and Ecology, Cassell Publishers Ltd., 1992.

Camparing Christian Mysticism and Buddhism Essay

3400 words - 14 pages What can be said about the unspeakable? How does one begin to describe the indescribable? The very act of discussing ineffability questions whether anything can be truly ineffable in the first place. Religion almost always critically depends on the ineffability of some experience or entity. This is a widespread tendency, but some would argue that it is a rule for all religions. That there must be the recognition of something “beyond

Reflection Paper For Philosophy Of Religion: The Continous Conflict Between Religious Pluralism And Exclusivism

1707 words - 7 pages way that some are right and some are wrong (exclusivism). Finally, one can also (3) think about all religions as false (atheism).Let me take into consideration the third stance first. By arguing that all religious beliefs are false, it also means arguing that God or any form of the transcendent does not exist. And by arguing this, means rejecting all of the theistic theses that were formulated in the history of man. And this is the part where the

Organizational Management And Leadership

3063 words - 12 pages World Wide Web: http://www. findarticles.com/cf_0/m1038/3_44/75645904/print.jhtml Biech, E. (1994). TQM For Training. New York: McGraw-Hill. Gitlow, H. S., & Gitlow, S. J. (1994). Total Quality Management In Action. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall. Hick, M. (1998). Quality Management. Mike Hicks Eagle. Retrieved Sep 3, 2004 from the World Wide Web: http://www.eagle.ca/~mikehick/quality.html Perigord, M. (1987). Achieving Total Quality Management: A

Compare and contrast two beliefs about life after death. Assess which of these two views may provide a stronger philosophical basis for belief in life after death?

1402 words - 6 pages Hick is that he doesn't successfully get over the continuity problem. Vardy thinks that there is a break in continuity so much so that the replicated could not be the same person. Bernard Williams argues that Hick’s portrayal of an endless life of replications would be a meaningless life. It might prove a boring life.Dualism is the idea that the mind and body are two separate substances; it is possible to survive death, as the soul disembodies

What is the Verification Principle?

1741 words - 7 pages The verification principle arose from a movement in the 1920’s known as Logical Positivism and, in particular from a group of philosophers known as the Vienna circle. They applied principles of science and mathematics to religious language and argued that, like human knowledge, religious language also had to be empirically verified through experiences if it were to be considered meaningful. They believed that this was the basis of all forms of

What is the Catholic view on genetic engineering?

1279 words - 6 pages , analysed and applied these results to the hypothesis, it can be concluded that both Catholicism and Islam share partially equal views on the topic of Genetic Modification. The two religions share the same opinion on Gene Enhancement being immoral and unethical, however their views differ moderately when Gene Therapy is considered. Catholicism is typically based in origins of Natural Law and Kantian Ethics, but also shows signs of Situational Ethics


1040 words - 5 pages . Hick thinks that religious experience should be open to evidence that could falsify it and even though we cannot test every claim we can take a look at liberation/ salvation which is reappearing in religions. Hick thinks that being open to possible falsifications can strengthen faith. Evans believes a similar thing that we should have our beliefs but we should be able to hear others out and maybe come to common ground, but the process will

An Analytical Approach to Truth and Religion

6399 words - 26 pages general is true. I hope, however, that my analysis will contribute to the solution of the problem of truth of religion in general and of religions other than Christianity and will do this from a neutral point of view, not from that of the Christian religion. At the very beginning we face the problem of the multitude of expressions: truth question in religion, truth of religion, truth about religion, religious truth, truth in religion. Which of them

A view of Christianity as the dominant western religion and its effects on society's perceptions of other religions

710 words - 3 pages today, according to Paul Knitter, is because "today we in the west know more about other religions than ever before." Because there is this knowledge of other religions, one can draw many similarities between them.In drawing such similarities between religions one can see that there is an inert oneness or sameness between all religions. Knitter defines religious dialogue as "the exchange of experience and understanding between two or more partners

Explain what is meant by verification and falsification, in the context of religious language? Evaluate their criticisms of religious language

1844 words - 7 pages . Nevertheless Logical Positivists claim that statements about God have no meaning because they don’t relate to anything that is real? In the debate about religious language, there are two types of language, cognitive and non-cognitive. Cognitive language conveys facts i.e. things that we can know. Non-cognitive language, predictably, conveys information that is not factual; emotions, feelings and metaphysical claims.In the 1920's in Vienna a

Similar Essays

Alternative Hypothesis About Emergence Of The Religions, Its Adaptive Factors For Human And General Investigation Of Historical Development Of Rel

2070 words - 9 pages contents about existence (Hefner, 2012). Since the hypothetical fire religion, religions are expressions of specific human-object relationship and also consist of human imagination (with anthropologists own word: Symbolic Thought). However, external world shaped once again, according to this perspective. Religions and its destructive side of applying by followers were dark side of it. Destructive side primarily comes from primitively “Augmented Reality

My Objections To Pluralism And Exclusivism

2683 words - 11 pages to religion. Divine exposure has taken its individual forms in different cultures and has led to separate great religions. Regional differences in human ways of conceiving divine have continued and remain in faiths around the world today. Third, he recognizes that almost every religious tradition clearly changes the lives of the people who believe in the religion. Hick believes that all religions are not rivals of each other and that we cannot


1500 words - 6 pages In his article Science/Religion, John Hick goes into detail to describe his viewpoints and claims against scientific naturalism. Scientific naturalism is the belief that there is only a physical existence, that there is no such reality beyond our physical realm, there is no such thing as the meta-physical, trans-physical, supra-physical or suprasensory reality that religions lead us to believe in. Hick goes on to argue that this is in no such

The Problem Of Evil Essay

2216 words - 9 pages imperfect and were made that way in order to find goodness through their freedom. He also states, “We have the hypothesis of humankind being brought into being within the evolutionary process as a spiritually and morally immature creature, and then growing and developing through the exercise of freedom in this religiously ambiguous world” (Hick). Hick believes that humans start as self-regarding animality and are being groomed to self-giving love. I