High Noon, By Fred Zinneman And Treasure Of The Sierra Madre, By Jouhn Huoston

1065 words - 4 pages

The films High Noon, directed by Fred Zinneman, and Treasure of the Sierra Madre, directed by John Houston, bring rise to the question of self benefit or selflessness through the main characters. The lead role in High Noon is Marshall Will Kane who has restored a town, Hadleyville, from its atrocious past. Even though Kane has recently retired due to his marriage, he comes to face the eminent destruction of the Hadleyville again when his enemy Frank Miller and his gang return. Howard, the main character of the film Treasure of the Sierra Madre, is a wise cracking old man who meets two men and agrees to help them hunt for gold. Although both characters play a similar role of leadership, they both possess contrasting motives behind their goals.
Howard and Marshall Kane are put into positions that force the audience to decide whether their actions are of self-indulgence or for the benefit of those around them. Howard meets two men, Dobbs and Curtin, in the El Oso Negro dormitory and decides to join them on their quest for gold. Dobbs and Curtin both have little to no knowledge of gold mining, but Howard offers them his expertise that he has gained through past gold mining experience. Before Howards goes on this hunt for gold, he warns the men that gold can change a man and drive them down the path of insanity. Howard teaches the men how to mine for gold and tries to keep the peace when Dobbs begins to form paranoia about his gold. One can believe that “[h]oward is knowledgeable about mining and human nature, ethical in his conduct, reasonable in his dealings with men, aware of his own weaknesses, committed to helping others in the group develop a similar awareness and, by the end of the film, fully aware of life’s essential dilemmas and of humanity’s limitations” (Graebner 32). He gets through to Curtin who trusts Howard and maintains a mental clarity, but Dobbs succumbs to the gold paranoia.
When Dobbs acts in aggression towards the group, Howard tries to maintain the peace revealing he desires the best for all. His actions to maintain the peace are necessary so the group will benefit as a whole and continue to help one another mine for gold. On the other hand, Graebner states “Howard’s defects, including his concerns with his own self-interest and, especially, his rather surprising acquiescence in the ‘majority’ decision to kill Cody.” His agreement to kill Cody (a traveler that wanted to mine with them) portrays a greedier side of Howard and conveys his unwillingness to share any more of their wealth. Although he shows this alternate side, Howard ultimately intends to mediate and keep peace within the group for the benefit of everyone. He later proves his good incentives when he saves the life of a young boy, helps maintain the peace between the men, and accepts without anger that their gold had been lost.
Marshall Kane on the other hand has good motives for defeating his rival Frank Miller, but gives reason to believe that his efforts...

Find Another Essay On High Noon, by Fred Zinneman and Treasure of the Sierra Madre, by Jouhn Huoston

Critical Analysis of Darkness at Noon by Harold Krents

1248 words - 5 pages Critical Analysis of Darkness at Noon by Harold Krents In "Darkness at Noon", Harold Krents vividly describes some of the everyday prejudices disabled citizens must face. Presented in an often humorous fashion, the author opens the reader’s eyes to the cruel ironies of society’s preconceived and inaccurate judgments, and their long reaching effects on his life. Krents begins his essay by pointing out to the reader that he

Sinclair Ross's Praire Isolation by Symbolism: "The Lamp at Noon"

922 words - 4 pages and created an emotional storm that afflicts Paul and Ellen's "isolated acre" (7).In both "The Lamp at Noon" and "The Painted Door", another prairie based piece by Ross, Ross employs weather to imitate the feelings of the key personalities, but more importantly he uses prairie landscape and weather to exemplify the fissures between husband and wife. Crying winds, lonely moments, and climatic symbolism are features of both short stories, which

Learning to Read and Write, by Fred Douglas

673 words - 3 pages "Life Experiences that we have in Common"In "Learning to Read and Write" by Frederick Douglass, Douglass describes the hardships of his life. Even though my life experiences are different from Douglass in many ways, they are similar in many respects. Frederick Douglas lived through slavery, and in my lifetime I lived through the ends of the Cold War, Gulf War, terrorist attacks, and a time in which a person's right is being more and more

The Longest Memory by Fred D'Augiar (about black slavery)

1409 words - 6 pages females and males. In The Longest Memory we get to see an example of a mothering female, an opinionated female, a dominant male, a rebellious male and a group of animalistic males, each having their own different stereotype. Despite the book challenging a few of the preconceived gender stereotypes the book The Longest Memory still displays very vivid stereotypes, which are 'by the book'. I think that Fred D'Aguiar wrote the book exceptionally well

The Hidden Treasure of Love: A Haunted House by Virgina Wolf

1233 words - 5 pages in every room in the house with hope that the treasure is still there. In the end they come upon the living couple asleep in their bed, the treasure was still there in their possession and the light of the heart was the buried treasure.        The story, “A Haunted House” is written by the woman that currently lives in the house. The narrator starts by saying, “Whatever hour you woke, there was a door shutting” (p. 1). This begins the story by

The Man in the High Castle: Criticisms of Reality and Dictatorship by Philip K. Dick

1342 words - 5 pages The Man in the High Castle: Criticisms of Reality and Dictatorship by Philip K. Dick “Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.” -Philip K. Dick Botwinick writes in A History of the Holocaust, “The principle that resistance to evil was a moral duty did not exist for the vast majority of Germans. Not until the end of the war did men like Martin Niemoeller and Elie Wiesel arouse the world’s conscience to the

The American West / Uses movies High Noon, Stage Coach, and The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance to discuss the 'myth' of the American West and where the 'myth' comes from

3238 words - 13 pages . However, he discusses the practicality of frontiersmen moving west. One quote in particular, in my point of view, correlates quiet well to the following movies and reading: High Noon, Stagecoach, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, and "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance". Turner says, "This perennial rebirth, this fluidity of American life, this expansion westward with its new opportunities, its continuous touch with the simplicity of primitive

High Fantasy: The Games of Thrones by George R.R. Martin

1789 words - 7 pages of Thrones in the late 1900s, reshaping the idea of a High Fantasy novel. From the beginning of Martin’s career there was Tolkien imitation. J.R.R. Tolkien is the author of many High Fantasy novels, such as Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit; many authors tried to capture the essence of this type of fantasy by following his structure meticulously. Martin’s goal was “to show the world what was wrong with the Tolkien clone industry” (Larsen). His

Treasure Island, by R L Stevenson. Describes the relationship between Jim Hawkins and Long John Silver, and how this changes throughout the story

1186 words - 5 pages "Treasure Island"Set in the days of sails and ships, buried treasure and pirates, Treasure Island is an epic tale of a young boy by the name of Hawkins, and his search for the buried treasure of the notorious Captain Flint. Treasure Island is written by Robert Louis Stevenson (1850 - 94), his other texts include The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde and Kidnapped. I choose to read and review this book because I was familiar with some of

The Importance of High Ethical Standards, as Explained by Eric Wahlgren in The Ins and Outs of Ethics

742 words - 3 pages The Ins and Outs of Ethics is a Business Week Online magazine article from May 13, 2001, it was written by Eric Wahlgren. In the article he interviews Michael Rion, the author of The Responsible Manager. Rion is also a leading business ethics advisor who consults many Standard and Poor’s 500 companies. In the article Wahlgren asks Rion why it is important for businesses to have a high ethical standard. In his responses, Rion explains that

How does the way in which time is structured in a film affect the narrative. With references to High Noon, and Ned Kelly

1187 words - 5 pages one real minute closer to noon, and when noon arrives, so does the train carrying Frank Miller, the notorious gunslinger.The use of clocks in High Noon is emphasizes the importance of time and also provides a running commentary for the viewer on how much time Kane has left. The secondary storylines, such as the break up of Kane's marriage to Amy, Harvey's resignation as deputy and Ellen's background with Miller, are supported by the use of real

Similar Essays

Implications Of The Masculiune Gaze In The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre

898 words - 4 pages gold does not only serve as the desire for the trio, but also becomes the audience’s desire as well. If the traditional Hollywood cinema films use women as the desire for male characters, and utilize women as the visual pleasure for audience as argued by Mulvey; The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is therefore considered as a type of non-traditional, disruptive narrative. The film lacks of the masculine gaze between men and women, instead, this masculine gaze is upon male characters’ desire for gold. Gold is the substitution for male’s desire for women in the film.

"The Longest Memory" By Fred D'aguiar

833 words - 3 pages therefore held in high regard by the reader.Chapel is both a hero and a victim of prejudice. The innocence and beauty of his love for Lydia contains many similarities to the poignant love story of Romeo and Juliet. One can truly identify the prejudices and corruption of the society at that time when young Lydia is told "By teaching little Whitechapel to read and write when he can never use it you have done him the gravest injustice." The two

A Speech About The Theme Of Racism In The Novel "The Longest Memory" By Fred D'aguiar

588 words - 2 pages work and the whip." This could almost be seen as a cruel sense of irony, as Chapel does end up dying due to the whip. Cook, doesn't have a christian name either, it is even doubtable that she has a name at all, as when she is first talked about by Sanders Snr, she is simply referred to as the "slave girl", and eventually becomes Cook. Cook was raped by Sanders Snr and although the action itself isn't necessarily racist

Book Review Of Darkness At Noon By Arthur Koestler

622 words - 2 pages . While in prison, Rubashov learns there are other political prisoners being maintained in the cells next to him. In particular prisoner number 402 and Rubashov carry on conversations by using the "quadratic alphabet" (Darkness at Noon, p. 19), better known as wall tapping. During Rubashov's interaction with the other prisoners, Rubashov learns of how the prison system works and receives an understanding of the other prisoners' background.Rubashov