Higher And Lower Pleasures: Their Effects On Millian Utilitarianism

1443 words - 6 pages

In this paper, I examine Mill’s distinction between higher and lower pleasures that he presents in his Utilitarianism. Then, I raise objections to Mill’s distinction by focusing on the ambiguity of his definition of pleasures and his concept of the competent judge. I conclude that, with a recalculation of the definition of pleasures, his distinction of higher and lower pleasures can support a broader theory of utilitarianism.
1. Examining Mill’s Distinction
Utilitarianism is a moral theory that is rooted in the belief that happiness, which is understood as pleasure and the privation of pain, is the only thing that is intrinsically good. Mill’s endorsement of this “greatest happiness principle” is as follows:
1.1: “The creed which accepts as the foundation of morals "utility" or the" greatest happiness principle" holds that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure and the absence of pain; by unhappiness, pain and the privation of pleasure.”
Thus, it seems that Mill is inclined to accept a version of Bentham’s hedonistic utilitarianism. That is to say, Mill seems to be endorsing a quantitative theory of utilitarianism, which works on the bases of maximizing the duration and intensity of pleasure. However, later in Utilitarianism, Mill addresses an objection concerning the idea that utilitarianism is a theory that “favors sensual or voluptuary pursuits (e.g. push-pin) over higher or nobler pursuits (e.g. poetry).” Thus, he makes the distinction between pleasures of the intellect, higher pleasure, and sensual, lower, pleasures. This is to ensure that utilitarianism is not seen as “a doctrine worthy only of swine.”
Mill rejects Bentham’s, hedonist, idea of focusing on the quantity (duration and intensity) of pleasure, and replaces it with a focus on the quality of pleasure. Thus, splitting pleasures into two categories: sensual and intellectual. Mill does believe that hedonists are able to defend the distinction between higher and lower pleasures, but their defense is unsatisfactory because it would only allow for intellectual pleasures to be superior extrinsically. But, Mill takes it a step further and says that intellectual pleasures are superior to sensual pleasures both extrinsically and intrinsically. Here is how Mill puts is:
1.2: “If I am asked what I mean by difference of quality in pleasures…there is but one possible answer. If one of the two is, by those who are competently acquainted with both, placed so far above the other that they prefer it, even though knowing it to be attended with a greater amount of discontent, and would not resign it for any quantity of the other pleasure which their nature is capable of, we are justified in ascribing to the preferred enjoyment a superiority in quality so far outweighing quantity as to render it, in comparison, of small account.”
He rejects the idea that the only thing that is...

Find Another Essay On Higher and Lower Pleasures: Their Effects on Millian Utilitarianism

America’s Prisons and Their Effects On Society

2066 words - 8 pages frequently late for work. In prison, inmates do not have to plan out their own day. They are told what, when, and where to do everything. They are not given any responsibility. Therefore, after years of incarceration, ex-cons have a hard time adjusting to life on the outside. They have to plan out their day on their own for the first time in years, and many of them end up being late for work or not showing up at all on a regular basis. The

Various Effects of Cyberterrorism and Their Effects on Societies

896 words - 4 pages bioweapons” (Nakashima). Whichever mode or information terrorists use, all involve the extraction of large amounts of data. Satellite technology is another way terrorists can get their hands on information or reach other members, especially through Google Earth and GPS devices. These instruments can identify targets and provide directions for any given person. Utilizing this tool, adversaries can easily pinpoint a specific location and launch

Video Games and their Effects on Communities and Communications

1537 words - 6 pages . Their study consisted of collecting information of 813 college students from all over the country regarding the time spent playing video games and the quality of their relationships with friends and family. The results showed that as the video games usage rate was higher the quality of their relationships was poorer. The study was not focused to find a reason to those results but, if we think a little about the issue, it is not difficult to find

Genetic and Environmental Influences and Their Effects on Development

1170 words - 5 pages there are some aspects of our persons that one has a bigger influence on compared to the other. Hopwood et al., (2011) suggests that our personality as we grow and mature is more effected by our environment opposed to our genes. This paper examines the effects Hopwood et al.’s research in comparison to Bouchard, Lykken, McGue, Segal, and Tellegen’s research on this issue. Hopwood et al.’s (2011) research took a look at our personality and how

Drugs and Their Effects on Women from Utero into Adulthood

1842 words - 8 pages amplified chance of delivering preterm babies who may have a lower head and chest circumference, as well as reduced birth weight ("MSACD Marijuana."). Because of these effects, the fetus has an increased risk of mental retardation that could manifest itself later in life. Just as with smoking during pregnancy, usage can still affect the baby after birth if the mother is breastfeeding. What the mother is taking into her body during these breast feeding

Effects of Homelessness on Children and Their Educational Success

1124 words - 4 pages homelessness as adults are decreased. The U.S. government relies on the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act to help these homeless students, but studies indicate that the immense pressures these students face outside of school still have profound negative effects on their academic success.The US Department of Education (2004) defines homeless children as "those who lack a fixed, regular, and adequate nighttime residence" (p.2), but it also recognizes a

Different Methods of CyberCrime and Their Effects on Modern Society

1363 words - 5 pages Different Methods of Cybercrime and Their Effects on Modern Society The world we live in is more technologically advanced than ever before, with newer developments coming every year. Men, women, and children worldwide rely on the Internet for work, school, play, socialization, and any number of other reasons. Yet, despite the great advantages technology gives to us, with our increased reliance and connectivity comes an increased risk of crime

Chief Executive Officer Roles and Their Effects on Large Corporations

2052 words - 8 pages Chief Executive Officer Roles and Their Effects on Large Corporations The Chief Executive Officer is responsible for the success or failure of the company. They are responsible for the operations, marketing, strategy, financing, and the creation of company culture, human resources, hiring, firing, and compliance with safety regulations, sales, etc.This all falls on the CEO’s shoulders. The CEO’s main function is to set a strategy, vision and

Advances in Animation and Their Effects on Modern Cinema

3200 words - 13 pages Advances in Animation and Their Effects on Modern Cinema Animation has been a huge contributor to today’s media when it comes to movies and televisions programing. For decades, using a series of images to create the illusion of movement, has evolved into billion dollar industries for entertainment. Animated movies are in a completely different league of their own and, no matter how simple they may seem, require a sufficient amount of

Stimulants and Their Effects

752 words - 3 pages Stimulants and Their Effects: Should These Drugs Be Prescribed for ADHD Children?In this day and age, drugs are being prescribed without hesitation. In fact, many of these drugs are being prescribed for children with various disorders. One of these disorders is called Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). An estimated five to ten percent of children are diagnosed with this syndrome (Taylor 11). One of the methods to treat this

Major Effects of Globalization Like Adapting to Changes, Lower Tariffs and Cheaper Labor Cost Make a Difference on Philippine Economy and Firms

2687 words - 11 pages Major Effects of Globalization Like Adapting to Changes, Lower Tariffs and Cheaper Labor Cost Make a Difference on Philippine Economy and FirmsA research paperPresented toJose Cristina Pariña, Ph.D.In partial FulfillmentOf the Requirements forENGLRES2012-2013Nikka Jennine L. EscoberAlejandrea A. LalataApril 1, 2013OutlineIntroductionAdopting to ChangesA. Technological developments1. Communication2. TransportationB. Internet as an agent of

Similar Essays

Videogames And Their Effects On Behavior

2293 words - 9 pages Videogames and their Behavioral Effects Tommy scuffles through the front door, drops his book bag on the floor and plops down on the couch with a scowl across his face. As his PlayStation fires to life, he replays scenes from the day in his head of being shoved into the lockers by Billy, unable to form the words to impress Sussie, and sitting alone at lunch listening to the popular kids laugh and joke, ignoring him as if he did not exist. No one

Biofuels And Their Effects On Water Resources

2034 words - 8 pages Biofuels and Their Effects on Water Resources Due to desires to decrease greenhouse gas emissions, the increasing concerns of trade balances and geopolitics, as well as the growing rise of the price of crude oil, nations worldwide are taking bigger steps in establishing sustainable energy alternatives [1]. In order to meet more sustainable energy needs there has been an increase in the demand of biofuels. With this increase in demand comes the

Nonresident Parents And Their Effects On Families

828 words - 3 pages Nonresident Parent's Involvement and its Effect on the Family Members Divorce, single parenting, early pregnancy, are just some reasons for a parent not to be present in their families as a matter of fact its been said that almost half of the kids have had lived in a family where one of the parents for many different reasons had been missing. But is it different when parents are involved with their kids? What are the different effects that

Landfills And Their Effects On The Enviroment

1387 words - 6 pages Landfills And Their Effects On Humans And The Enviroment Every year Americans collectively create approximately 208 million tons of municipal solid waste, which breaks down to 4.3 pounds of waste generated per American per day. In addition to this normal waste, the United States produces roughly 279 million tons of hazardous waste per year.1 All of this waste has to go somewhere. Two good methods of waste disposal, infrequently used, are