This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hindu Muslim Antagonism In India Essay

1308 words - 5 pages

Qinxin RenANT 324Prof. Van HollenOctober 26, 2013 Hindu-Muslim Antagonism in IndiaOver the past thirty years, the relationship between Hindus and Muslims in India has largely been marked by tensions and turbulence. Since the early 1980s, recurring communal violence between the top two religions of India has taken place in the form of intense public riots. The reason for such violence, as many scholars believe, lies primarily in the fundamentally different cultural and religious norms of Hinduism and Islam. And therefore, conflicts are generated by the two groups' "natural antagonism" toward each other as a result of the irreconcilability of such differences. However, this view is largely inconclusive, because in India, the way communalism is manifested is often shaped by economic and political factors, rather than being merely religious or cultural (Shani, 2011: 297-298).By characterizing the relationship between Indian Hindus and Muslims as "naturally antagonistic", this aforementioned view is implying that, a mutual hostility between the two peoples is historically present regardless of the conditions and circumstances. However, this implication can be easily proven wrong. First of all, if Hindus and Muslims had always been hostile toward each other, it would follow that the process of interaction between the two religious communities is a historically violent one. But this is certainly not the case. In fact, Hindus and Muslims have shown that they are able to coexist peacefully, or even to form a "close intercommunity relationship" (Williams, 2011: 248-252). This relationship could be a product of necessary economic interactions, as is the case with the city of Varanasi, where the production of silk sari requires the cooperation of Hindus and Muslims (Williams, 2011: 250). Also, there is also a tendency for Muslims to bond more easily with Hindus who belong to a lower caste. For example, because of their socially considered inferior caste identities, there might be certain difficulties preventing a Hindu of lower caste from receiving barber services from fellow Hindus, who are members of higher castes. In such cases, caste discrimination could effectively drive people to seek social relationships with Muslims. In general, for regions where Muslims and Hindus who live geographically closer, there tends to exhibit an everyday living pattern of peaceful interaction and mutual dependence.In addition, this view of interpreting communal violence is identified as a "culturalist" one; for it emphasizes only the part cultural and religious differences play in conflicts (Shani, 2011: 297-298). However, by doing that, it mistakenly rules out other contributive factors, such as the influence of politics and economy on communal interactions. By examining the cases of communal violence between Hindu and Muslim community in India, it can be noted that such events were usually directly triggered by a change in the society's political or economic context. Such...

Find Another Essay On Hindu-Muslim Antagonism in India

The Causes of tension Between Hinduism and Islam

1226 words - 5 pages While analyzing past interactions between Hinduism and Islam, we can see some outstanding tensions that arise from territorial conflict between India, a predominantly Hindu country, and Pakistan, a predominantly Muslim country. The primary focus of this tension arises from a common area – Kashmir/Jammu. The conflict in this region can be accredited to the differences in religion. The conflict in Kashmir stems from 1947. This was the year the

Partition of India Essay

2384 words - 10 pages In 1947 British rulers of India divided India in two countries. Pakistan consisting of Muslims majority provinces and India with Hindus and other religious majority people (cite?). This partition was due to the demands by Muslims who found it impossible to live with Hindus as they were socially, morally and religiously different from them. Process of this Muslim Hindu separation was started out by Muslim educator Sir Syed Ahmed Khan who in

The Clash Between Nehruvian Secularism and Hindu Nationalism

2926 words - 12 pages majority of India’s population with over 80 per cent and the rest being shared by the other religious beliefs. 2nd largest religion in India is Muslim with a number of plus, minus 75 million followers this showing the massive population of India with Muslim community making up only about 11 per cent of the population. Hindu nationalism is the belief that politics should be organized with the ideals of the Hindu religion drawing from the elements

Hindus vs Muslims

577 words - 3 pages home to a highly significant religious site being fought over by Hindus and Muslims.Some 3,000 holy places are scattered across India, where hundreds of years ago Muslim rulers are said to have destroyed sacred Hindu temples to build mosques. But Mathura, Ayodhya, and Varanasi are three that were singled out for dispute in the early 1990s by Hindu extremists because of their religious importance.At the city's heart, not far from the sacred bathing

The Demand of Pakistan and Two Nation Theory

1638 words - 7 pages most south Asians do after it .Bahadur shah zafar II who probably was not strong as the previous MUSLIM rulers took part in the mutiny 1857 and after its failures he was imprisoned Effects on Muslim The Muslim had lost their control and could not accept it mentally after such long period of ruling in India. On the other hand the Hindu took advantage of the situation and joined hands with the British and got very close to them all this caused to

The Religious Conflict in South Asia

1547 words - 6 pages South Asia focusing on India and in particular the continuing Hindu-Muslim tensions, and look at possible reasons for the continuing conflict which appears to have escalated since the withdrawal of British Rule from India. Multiple events had shaped the Indian subcontinent with regards to Hindu and Muslim relations. In the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries the Mughal rule over the Indian subcontinent witnessed Hindus and

Indo-Pakistani Conflict

4084 words - 16 pages PAGE 2 [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] Gill PAGE 10 The province of Kashmir has remained a point of contention between India and Pakistan resulting in mounting antagonism in the region. The conflict ignited when tensions heightened between the Indian National Congress (INC), which represented the majority Hindu population, and the All-India Muslim League (AIML), which argued for a separate homeland from Hindu Indians. The conflict further

India Vs Pakistan

527 words - 2 pages state of Pakistan was founded, along with its arch rival Hindu neighbor India. Many Muslims and Hindus opposed the creation of two separate states, and Nathuram Godse, an Indian Hindu fanatic, was one of these. He believed that Gandhi was wrong in letting Jinna create the Muslim state of Pakistan, and decided to kill him. On the evening of Janurary 30, 1948, Mahatma Gandhi was assassinated by a Hindu fanatic. This brought the whole nation to mourning

Violence against the Muslims in India

1003 words - 5 pages parts being about 1000 miles apart. The act was not easy to put into action. Violence against the Muslims in India has been occurring sporadically since the nation’s independence claim in 1947, mostly in the form of mob attacks on Muslims by Hindus. These attacks are often referred to as communal riots. They are a part of a pattern of irregular religious violence between the Hindu and Muslim communities, which has been linked to an increased

The Importance of Religion in Indian Politics

1519 words - 6 pages discrimination of religion. Religious fault lines are rapidly being carved by India’s surging Hindu nationalist movement, dangerously alienating India’s one hundred million Muslims, antagonising Muslim nations throughout South and Central Asia and the Pursian Gulf. Merely last December India had perhaps a taste of foreseeable threat when Muslim officials in oil-exporting nations discussed oil-boycotting India

British Evil in India

643 words - 3 pages everyone was born into a class and was never able to move up in it. The culture of India was different from Britain. The religion that is in India is Islam, Hindu, and Sikhs. Most of the foods that were eaten in India were vegetarian foods. Cow and the Pig were the most sacred animals in both Muslim and Hinduism. Lifestyle and homes were both simple for Indians. Since the caste system was in play at this time if you were born in a high caste you

Similar Essays

Religious Considerations For Healthcare Providers In America: Christianity, Judaism, Hindu, Muslim, And Buddhism

4040 words - 16 pages care providers of the opposite gender and prefer to receive care from a same gender provider.6 Hindu Hindu is the third largest in the world. Most followers are from India but also Trinidad and Africa. Many Hindus that live in America originally came here as students, or their parents did. Most American-Hindus are fluent in English, but some older women may not be as comfortable and may require an interpreter in the healthcare setting. Hinduism

Prophets Facing Backward: Postmodern Critiques Of Science And Hindu Nationalism In India

3403 words - 14 pages Meera Nanda's book Prophets Facing Backward is an extraordinary and compelling book. Few in the West are aware of the alarming confluence of ideas arising out of the contemporary nationalistic politics of India with its endorsement of 'Vedic science' and the dominant postmodernist, social constructivist and sociological trends in science studies in the West. Nanda's book is an intellectual bombshell dropped on this potent combination. No one

Ghandi Essay

293 words - 2 pages Gandhi Essay A Famous quote Gandhi remarked was, "I am Muslim, and a Hindu, and a Christian, and a Jew." Gandhi was a profound leader who fought for peace between Muslim, Hindu, Christian, and Jews. When he states that he is a Muslim, Hindu, Christian, and a Jew; he explains that no matter what religion is in your background you are equal and have as much rights as the others. A man with enough courage to take beatings, hunger

Unrest In Kashmir Essay

978 words - 4 pages Muslim majority was that they were led by a Hindu leader which gave a strong point to the Indian leaders. Although there was a clear Muslim majority in Kashmir before the 1947 partition the political developments during and after the partition resulted in a division of the region. The territory of Kashmir was contested even before India and Pakistan won their independence from Britain in August 1947. Under the partition plan Kashmir was free to