Hinduism, Hindutva, Colonial And Post Colonial Myths

2756 words - 12 pages

Vrinda Nagar
Dr. Haris Qadeer
Master of Arts (English) Final
21 April 2014
Hinduism, Hindutva, Colonial and Post-Colonial Myths
"During this period (early history of the British in India) in India, while the Europeans fought one another and the British intrigued among themselves for personal advantage, Mughals killed Mughals, Rajputs killed Rajputs, Mughals killed Rajputs, Rajputs killed Mughals, British killed Mughals and Rajputs, Mughals and Rajputs killed British, and starvation and taxation kept killing the farmers and laborers of India as usual." 1
This is how Wendy Doniger defines the pre-independence early history of India (of the 19th century) in her book ‘The Hindus: An Alternative History’. Karl Marx too in an article that he wrote for the ‘The New York Daily Tribune’ describes an India that has either always been under the influence of foreign powers or remained in a state of discord because of continuous internal conflicts that took place within castes and tribes. This western view of India and the denial of there ever having been ‘A Golden Indian Age’ led to the orthodoxy in the conception of the idea of Indian Nationalism. Nationalism, even though a borrowed western idea itself, had to necessarily be adopted to refute the notions of India as a barbaric and savage country. And in doing so, through a propagation of myths and in other places through the terming of some real facts as myths by both colonial and the native population, a history was created that could in no way have remain unbiased and unjust to a large section of the Indian society.
This bias manifests itself not only in the problematic of gender, where a rigid ‘Hindutva’ (which was an answer to the colonial accusations of Indian perverseness) combined with Victorian moral ethics doubly suppressed women and homosexuals, negating the past history of a Hinduism that can be seen in the ‘Khajuraho’ temples, in the ‘Kamasutra’ or elsewhere in the country; but also in the questions of caste, religion and on the basis of loyalty to the colonizers in pre-independence India. This bias is not only not ahistorical but with the rising wave of a ‘Hindutva’ politics, it has also jumped out of the boundaries of the ‘apolitical’.
An example of this is the idea prevalent in certain parts of the society that the colonizers, even though violators of human rights themselves, in many circumstances had also civilized the country by abolishing brutal practices like the ‘Sati’ and by having offered a scathing critique of the oppressive Indian caste system, helped in removing it. What remains hidden behind this myth is the fact that the colonizers had not only in their early days of invasion and in their ‘oriental spirit’ as Doniger points out, remained oblivious to the brutal act of Sati and intended not to interfere with Hindu practices but also throughout their rule propagated the ideas of caste distinctions. These distinctions based themselves not only on the existing Hindu caste system but...

Find Another Essay On Hinduism, Hindutva, Colonial and Post-Colonial Myths

Hong Kong Post-colonial Cinema Essay

4669 words - 19 pages The Construction of the ‘Western Other’ in Hong Kong Post-colonial Cinema Hong Kong has always remained a very unique city, one which is said to have ‘a Western past, an Eastern future’. Since its colonisation by the British in the 1860s, it has maintained to a very large extent its Chinese identity and its connection to its Motherland, while at the same time, has frequent contact with the Western world, politically, economically, and

Feminism and Women’s Rights in Post-Colonial Africa and France

1474 words - 6 pages Feminism has not been an issue at the forefront of post-colonial France, which may be because there were many issues with women’s rights also in Africa. This may be changing because of the attention that the headscarves affair, female excision, and equality rights groups have been recently receiving. Women’s rights in African cultures are very different than in most of the Western world, like France and the United States. Women, in general, have

Post Colonial Nation building in Africa

3608 words - 14 pages these issues ultimately undermines political stability and the ability of new states to effectively govern citizens through a legitimate political institution. The fundamental challenges that new states face are extensive social change accompanied by rapid modernization; especially when insufficient concern is given for establishing firm political institutions.The post-colonial states of Asia, Africa, and Latin America are generally complex

Post Colonial Interpretations of Shakespeare’s The Tempest

1945 words - 8 pages Post Colonial Interpretations of Shakespeare’s The Tempest “…do we really expect, amidst this ruin and undoing of our life, that any is yet left a free and uncorrupted judge of great things and things which reads to eternity; and that we are not downright bribed by our desire to better ourselves?” – Longinus Since the seventeenth century many interpretations and criticisms of William Shakespeare’s The Tempest have been recorded. Yet

India In The Post-Colonial Era

1035 words - 5 pages During the post World War II period, many one-time colonies achieved political independence. However, these newborn nations were still dependent on powerful allies to survive. A nation is truly independent when it is able to survive culturally, economically, and militarily without the aid of any other nations. As long as a nation is dependent on its ally's support, it can be manipulated into undesirable decisions.India gained political

Decolonization, Nationalism, Imagining and Representing Communities: A review of Post-Colonial Literature

1215 words - 5 pages in the rebuilding of a national identity that had been affected by colonization. The development of language and allowing individuals to feel apart of a larger community was crucial in creating the national imagined community. Benedict Anderson discusses an “unselfconscious coherence” (Anderson), in which he claims is a bond shared by populations within the Post-Colonial societies. The indigenous population of Indonesia imagining the community

American History: Colonial Period, Revolutionary Time Period and The Post-Modernism Period

870 words - 4 pages much different we live now in comparison to any of these time periods with the exception of post modernism. Post modernism is the current way way of writing. These time periods range from 1607-current. We have read and learned the ways of writing from 400 years in the matter of nine months. We truly need more time to truly understand all of these ways of writing. The colonial time period was the first time period that we had to joy of learning

Othello - Shakespeare & Oliver Parker film version: traditional, post colonial and feminist intepretations

1250 words - 5 pages through the film version directed by Oliver Parker (1995). This film has given insight to the modern audience including myself to further the understanding of the post-colonial and feminist perspectives of Othello and thus helped to shape out sympathies.The traditional reading examines the play in an Aristotelian sense where Othello, a man of high rank in social status or in the 'chain of being' is undone by weaknesses or 'hamartia' in his

The Origins of the African Post-colonial economic crisis - Essay

1017 words - 5 pages Political Economy of Africa: Assignment 1 Table of Contents Introduction 3 Context: Characteristics of colonial and post-colonial Africa 3 The Political origins of the African post-colonial economic crisis 4 A history of centralised rule and political tradition 4 Government intervention in the economy 4 Neopatrimonialism 5 Conclusion 5 Bibliography 5 Introduction This essay – being the first Assignment for a module titles

Subverting Power: The Lesson of Post-Colonial Literature

2931 words - 12 pages Subverting Power: The Lesson of Post-Colonial Literature Your Name School Affiliation Outline A. Introduction Thesis: Adgar and Alizdeh, as representatives of post-colonial literature, provide evidence that otherness, essentialism and orientalism are notions that explain the issues that arise in the contemporary world as a result of imperial tendencies on the part of Western societies, and their writing suggests a peculiar form of

A Post-Colonial Liberation Reading of The Epistle to Philemon

2224 words - 9 pages book of the bible, asking questions borne from a Post-Colonial liberation hermeneutic to show the deficit of traditional readings of this text and explore the role of hermeneutic in interpretation. This will be achieved through explaining the term hermeneutic and specifically the Post-Colonial hermeneutic this essay uses before surveying how the Epistle to Philemon has been interpreted and used historically. After this, we will explore the

Similar Essays

Revolts: Colonial And Post Colonial Era Essay

1892 words - 8 pages The colonial and post colonial era was an era filled with astonishing events that rattled America’s standings with racism. This time was so powerful and moving, because it gave the slaves an amount of courage, trust, and determination so big that they were able to carry out an ample amount of rebellions in America against the whites. From Denmark Vesey in South Carolina planning to rebel furiously with other leaders after purchasing freedom, to

Colonial And Post Colonial Mentalities In The Middle Passage

1280 words - 6 pages so, how do authors weave the colonial and post-colonial mentalities into the framework of certain texts. Charles Johnson’s Middle Passage advances both colonial mentalities as well as post-colonial perspectives. The novel sheds light on traditional European colonial notions African savagery, the inferiority of African people as sub-human and commodities, and—at the same instant—presents the post-colonial perspective of the archetypical American

Post Colonial Literature Essay

937 words - 4 pages Post colonial’ as we define it does not mean ‘post-independence’, or ‘after colonialism’, for this would be falsely ascribe an end to the colonial process. Post-colonialism, rather, begins from the very first moment of colonial contact. It is the discourse of oppositinality which colonialism brings into being” (pL.117) The term post colonial is resonant with all the doubts and complexities of the various cultural experiences it involves. It

Post Colonial Libya Essay

2214 words - 9 pages widespread throughout Libya today. Libya's post-colonial narrative is a two-sided one: its relatively prosperous state was shaped by a combination of interconnected internal and external pressures, including the limitations of its natural environment, the reforms of its post-colonial rulers, as well as its interactions with other countries; meanwhile, its current social-political chaos developed from internal dissatisfaction with Gaddafi’s