Hiroshima: The Right Decision Essay

1036 words - 5 pages

Arguments and discussion surrounding the Atomic bomb in Hiroshima tend to be devoid of context. They rely on the assumption that the immorality of the bomb was reason enough to not drop it on Hiroshima, regardless of circumstance. This contention, however, rests on the notion that there was, at the time in 1945, a better solution, which involved fewer casualties, an expedient Japanese surrender, and above all (according to the opposition) morality. Given a closer look, the three legs of the aforementioned argument collapse when considering how the atomic bomb minimized casualties,expedited Japan’s surrender, and prevented enough bloodshed to become a morally justifiable endeavor. ...view middle of the document...

” In common with both Walzer and Churchill statement is the notion of aversion. Aversion from further bloodshed, from suffering, and from further casualties. Finally, lest it is preferable that America should have sacrificed its soldiers in the name of an erroneous definition of “morality,” which involves the superfluous slaughter of countless Americans, it can be rightfully asserted that dropping the bomb was preferable to invasion.
Along with minimizing deaths, the bomb also quickened the surrender of Japan. Responsible for a plethora of casualties, Japan was too dangerous for America to ignore. With the Japanese dodging surrender at every turn, an intimated America faced a conundrum. At the foot of a forked road, Americans knew that this mantra would lead to Japan’s implosion, and acknowledged that the only definitive way of ending Pacific suffering would through an unlikely Japanese surrender. The Japanese leaders, as Walzer noted, that they could fight their way to an American capitulation and eventual peace negotiation. From this, bellicose Japan could then be mislabeled as dormant and rebuild their military. Foreseeing “dormant” Japan’s potential eruption, Truman and his advisers reached the consensus, for the sake of ending the war, that the bomb was necessary.

Further, those who take the use of the bomb out of context, forget that Americans were in a state of total war with the Axis powers. Allied with Germany who was guilty of shipping civilians via boxcar to concentration camps and then having “the guards [fire] into the cars to stop the noise,” when they would cry in pain, Japan showed no remorse in supporting total war. As John Hersey recalled, “In total war, as carried on in Japan, there was no difference between civilians and soldiers, and … the bomb itself was an effective force tending to end the bloodshed.” As the Japanese showed no regret for endangering its citizens, and the world around it, the United States showed no regret in putting an end to this ultimate evil. After the bomb had been dropped, and the war was finished, most...

Find Another Essay On Hiroshima: The Right Decision

A persuasive essay leaning towards the fact abortion should be a decision women have the right to make

594 words - 2 pages Think for a second that you are against abortion. Now put yourself in the shoes of a father or relative of a woman who was raped or a young teenager who was impregnated by her boyfriend. Would you still be against it then? It is easy to be against something that has never affected your life. You can say abortion is murder and it is wrong, but it is a choice women have the right to make. Whether or not to have an abortion is a decision women have

If you only get one chance, cross your fingers and hope that your emotions make the right decision

1724 words - 7 pages make us think on our feet to act quickly. It is the long-term decision making that blinds us from making the right decisions, when we have this time for our emotions to seep in and affect our reasoning.Knowledge Question 2: To what extent does memory influence our emotions, justifying how reasoning is valued above all other ways of knowing?I believe that memories have massive effects on our emotions. Take phobias for an example. They are past

Oklahoma; is Anti-Abortion the Right Decision?

1947 words - 8 pages .” Liberty is defined as “freedom from control, interference, and restrictive conditions (“Liberty”). U.S. citizens have the right of doing, thinking, and speaking in accordance to choice, and abortion is no exception. What sense does it make to give a woman the right to vote, but take away her right to choose what she does with her body? Abortion has a tendency to stir up emotions, regardless of if you are pro-life or pro-choice. So, it comes to

The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms

1464 words - 6 pages Untitled The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The debates of whether use

Autonomy and Responsibility The Decision to Drop the Atomic Bombs on Japan

1320 words - 5 pages War because of the bombing of Pearl Harbor. By becoming involved in World War Two, the U.S. had to fight Japan, which led to the most important decision of the century. This decision was whether or not to drop the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This decision was mainly placed on the shoulders of President Harry Truman. Truman did not jump to the idea of using the atomic bombs on Japan right away. In fact, he and other military

A Closer Look at the Bombings in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

2058 words - 9 pages information above attempts to show how the atomic bombing was not justified, historians’ evidence and extensive research prove the atomic bombings were justified. American Stalinists looked at the bombs on Japan as right, necessary, and justified (Boller 14). In Rinjiro Sodei’s Hiroshima and Nagasaki as History and Politics Senator Nancy Kassebaum in 1994 stated the bomb was important in helping to bring the World War II to a merciful end (Sodei 1120

Hiroshima: Killing Thousands of People

1465 words - 6 pages small for the military bases to be vastly separated from civilians. A bomb of such a large magnitude being dropped on a military target would have catastrophic effects, especially when the target is surrounded by civilians. The explosion in Hiroshima only killed people right at the epicenter of the blast. The majority of people were killed by fires, structural failure of the buildings due to the tremendous force of the explosion, and

The Unnecessary Atomic Bombing of Japan

610 words - 3 pages their lives. Just because of one decision that could have easily been avoided. The United States should not have dropped the atomic bomb on Japan. Because they inflicted wounds on Japan that are never going to heal as told in the final chapter of Hiroshima. If the United States had not

The Bombing of Hiroshima

586 words - 2 pages The Bombing of Hiroshima The bomb was dropped for many reasons and President Truman was faced with a hard decision to drop the bomb. During World War II, the first atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima. If he dropped the bomb he would surely have killed an estimated 200,000 Japanese and the city of Hiroshima. Otherwise he would risk the invasion of Japan, which would cause even more causalities and even more Japanese lost lives. Truman thought

The Atomic Bomb that Ended the War, But Many Innocent Lives Were Lost

956 words - 4 pages already signed treaties to prevent war. Moreover, the U.S. has begun to realize its crime against humanity for using the atomic bomb. Four years ago, U.S. Ambassador, John Roos, became the first U.S. official to attend the annual atomic attack memorial ceremony at Hiroshima, Japan though he did not speak at the ceremony (Atomic Bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki). No matter how things are right now, an irreversible change has been made in the course

The Day That Shook the World

940 words - 4 pages rubble and bodies. Although the Japanese were affected tremendously, other areas were not as traumatized by the results, but they were still stunned. “My God, what have we done?” Robert Lewis, commander of the Enola Gay (the plane that dropped the bomb on Hiroshima) was astounded by the impact and devastation of the bomb he had just dropped (“Counting Deaths”). And so was the rest of America. President Truman had made the perplexing decision to bomb

Similar Essays

The Decision: Finding The Right College

2084 words - 8 pages , it is vital to gather as much information as possible while on campus. All four students are now happily enrolled in different universities. After crunching numbers, talking to people, and touring the colleges, they all realized where they should go. They are thankful they are finally done with the decision. The college search can be frustrating. However, if a student does their search right, they will end up in the right institution. It can

The Right Decision Or No Choice

1124 words - 5 pages and urban areas. It also tells the struggles and the choices that poor people have to make at the same time. However, as many different considerations are being taken into account, the decision is not always as simple as choosing whether it is a right or a wrong choice. If I am the parents who have to take care of my family, under those circumstances, perhaps I would do the same as well.

Making The Right Decision To A Fulfilling Career

757 words - 4 pages these statements actually bothers my mind in which it gives a different approach of viewing how life would be without a good successful career. Sometimes, doubting yourself of making it throughout 4-years of college may occur but the right decision is to always follow instincts and change a fixed mindset to a growth mindset. Almost a year now in college, and seeing a lot of experiences, which includes all the negative comments made by most high

If You Were President Harry Truman, Would You Have Made The Decision To Drop The Atomic Bomb On Hiroshima?

1203 words - 5 pages IF YOU WERE PRESIDENT HARRY TRUMAN, WOULD YOU HAVE MADE THE SAME DECISION AS HE DID, WITH DROPPING THE ATOMBOMB ON HIROSHIMA?The 6th of August 1945 was a day that people will always remember with terror. On this day, an atomic bomb was used by the U.S. against Japan, in the city of Hiroshima. This was the first time in world history. Before this sad event, Japan and the U.S. were having conflicts with each other because Japan tried to invade