Hispanic Vs. Native View Of The Aztec Conquest

1646 words - 7 pages

In order to have a true account of the Aztec conquest, a person must be a detective.One has to take into account personal objectives, cultural beliefs, and their motives behind their writings. In addition, "attention must be paid to the 'silences' as well as to the documents".(p 27) The strengths in Bernal Diaz's writtings, such as his eye for detail and his minimal personal objectiveness, but also the inherent weaknesses of the other writtings provide us with what many call "The True History of the Conquest of New Spain".Every source has its own set of strengths and weaknesses. An examination of these sources are required for anyone to come to a conclusion of each source's own bias, and to dertmine a conclusion of their accuracy. Hernan Cortes took the credit for the accounts of the expedition, and for many years his word was the truth for many, especially for those back in Spain. They became the "basis of the official story" because they were "realistic and direct, lacking the fantasy found in others". (p 15) However, Cortes was all but direct with the people that he encountered in New Spain. From the first encounter with these new people, he uses his political strategies, which Diaz takes note in his accounts, to gain a sense of his surroundings. His primary focus was that of learning of the politcs and the wealth of the region. One can already see the gold pesos gleaming in the eyes of Cortes when he finds of the vast wealth of the land.He also paints a very explicit picture of the indigeonous people of the region and their customs, especially their religious practices. He compares them to the Moors (Muslims) which the Christians have fighting in Europe for many years prior to the expeditions. "Horrible and abominable customs they have which should certainly be punished". (p83) Cortes' letter to the king and the way that he communicates with the people of the new world remind me of Eddie Haskel talking to Wally's mom. Buttery and sweet as mollasses, but shady and having alternate motives. As in the instance of the Noche Triste, for which neither Diaz or Cortes were present.One account was taken, not from Cortes' letters, but from Istoria de la conquista de Mexico, by Francisco Lopez de Gomara. He was hired by Cortes to write his biography of these accounts in order to please the people of Spain and give and "accurate account" of the events that transpired. De Gomara was always very favorable to Cortes in his writtings, which is something that angered Diaz. He was the first to address the reasoning behind the violent massacre called the Noche Triste, meaning sad night. His account softens the responsiblilty of the members of the spanish that did the slaying, and of course explaining that there was a possible conspiracy from the indians. Also, he makes note of Cortes' sorrow and excuses him from taking any action in response to the event by saying that "Cortes, who must have felt badly about the affair, dissembled his feelings so as not to...

Find Another Essay On Hispanic VS. Native View Of The Aztec Conquest

The Conquest Of Greece Essay

1132 words - 5 pages The Conquest of Greece Swords clashing together, Athenians and Spartans standing side by side trying to fight the murderous Persians who are on a conquest to conquer all of Greece .The Persian empire was located on the continent of Asia, and it existed between 530 B.C.E to 330 B.C.E .The Greco -Persian war started in 479 B.C.E when the Persian empire (modern day

1066: Year Of The Conquest Essay

919 words - 4 pages Book Review of 1066: The Year of the Conquest. 1066: The Year of the Conquest, written by David Howarth, tells of one of the most important dates in the history of England. In 1066, William the Conqueror and William of Orange fought the historical Battle of Hastings. The outcome of this battle lead to many changes to the English people. The Norman people became assimilated into the English way of life. Howarth proceeds to tell the tale of

The rise of the Aztec Empire

1230 words - 5 pages The Aztecs were a nomadic, native American tribe that resided in the Valley of Mexico from the 1200s to the mid-1500s. After exploring most of the Valley of Mexico, they settled down and started farming in 1345. The Aztecs built a huge empire and were ahead of their time in some aspects. However, in 1519, a Spanish Conquistador named Hernando Cortes led a force of 300 men to Yucatan. This signified the beginning of the end of the Aztec empire

The Rise of the Aztec Empire

2512 words - 10 pages The Aztec Empire of the 14th and 15th centuries was one of the most successful and powerful Mesoamerican kingdoms at that time. The community of people began in the middle of a lake and eventually became the capital of an empire. The Aztecs were comprised of multi ethnic and multi lingual individuals that lived in a large area that stretched from the Pacific Ocean to the Gulf coast and housed over fifteen million people (Schmal). Their ability

The Diversity of Hispanic Americans

1164 words - 5 pages Hispanic American DiversityAlthough there are many different ethnic groups who speak Spanish it is not uncommon to hear them all grouped together as Hispanic or Latino. These groups are from many different countries and cultures. The three most populous groups of Spanish speaking ethnic groups in the United States are, in order by density, Mexican, Puerto Rican and Cuban. Then you have Spanish speaking ethnic groups from Central and South

Native Americans vs the United States of America

2965 words - 12 pages Times were very hard for Native Americans during the mid to late 1800s. The reasons for their afflictions could only be blamed upon the United States of America. For thousands of years, Native Americans had roamed around the Americas. There had also been many tribes spread across the West that fought between each other in order to have their land.1 It wasn’t until after reconstruction in the United States, that the white Americans started

Epidemics and the Spanish Conquest of Mexico

2241 words - 9 pages The Aztec and Mesoamerican indigenous civilizations were some of the most well developed pre-industrial civilizations with populations averaging approximately twenty million prior to Spanish conquest (Marr and Kiracoffe 2000). These same civilizations were also witness to one of the worst demographic tragedies in human history seeing population losses of almost ninety percent, down to one million inhabitants a century after conquest (Marr and

Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest

927 words - 4 pages do not have room to discuss it in length, I must briefly explain Restall's thoughts regarding the question, "If the conquest of the Americas was achieved by a mere "handful of adventurers," how did they do it?" Restall attacks the myth that the conquest was accomplished by a rather small number of Spaniards in chapter three. He claims that much of the fighting and military operations were carried out by native allies of the conquistadors

The Style, Point of View, Form and Structure of Native Son, by Richard Wright

1169 words - 5 pages ;                                           Perhaps the major effect of narrating Native Son from Bigger's point      of view is to allow you to sympathize with a character who might   &nbsp

This essay shows the resistance and accomadation of Native Americans on Europeans. Shows the devastating affects of each style of conquest. Reference to James Wilson- "The earth shall Weep"

2060 words - 8 pages Cultural AttackThe Native Americans were living a peaceful and fulfilling life living off the land until the Europeans arrived. Most of the conquest was through war but they were also able to conquer culturally. Many tribes resisted and responded to the Europeans in different ways. Accommodation was always first, but when accommodation fails, resistance is always the last resource. Each impact had its devastating affects. The Europeans migrated

The Fall of the Aztec and Inca Empires

1859 words - 7 pages The Fall of the Aztec and Inca Empires In this essay I will tell how the Aztec and Inca empires ended, and also I will compare the fall of both empires, using for a point of departure the arrival of the Spanish conquistadors in the land of Mexico. Wherever the Spanish went always the same thing happened, from my point of view. Innocent people were killed for no good reason, cities were massacred, civilizations were destroyed or forced to

Similar Essays

Broken Spears. Speaks Of The Conquest Of The Aztec Empire

1388 words - 6 pages The conquest of the Aztec empire can be seen as a collision between two diverse societies whose cultural differences are just as distant as the dividing seas between the two worlds. Spaniards had the intention of territorial expansion and wealth accumulation while the Aztecs had intentions of maintaining their livelihood. Three of the most substantial factors that reflect the cultural differences are their perceptions of gold, warfare, and

The Broken Spears The Aztec Account Of The Conquest Of Mexico

537 words - 3 pages , magicians, signs, etc. were a major part of the Aztec religion and one can see that maybe there are signs all around us that can predict the future. The fourth omen "Fire streamed through the sky while the sun was still shining." brought forth to my mind the images of the Spaniards swinging their swords while the morning sun shined on their steel blades. The fifth omen "The wind lashed the water until it boiled..." is the boatmen paddling with all

Hispanic Culture Aztec And Modernism Of Barcelona 413 413

1715 words - 7 pages . · There are many reasons the city was important. First, it was the capital of the strong empire, Aztecs. It was built on a lake and contained hundreds and thousands of people. They had their own form of social organization, trade, and political organization. Second, the city is a great representation of Aztec architecture. Third, Cortes wrote about it in his Second Letter to King Charles of Spain describing his first encounter with the people of

The Conquest Of Peru Essay

1048 words - 4 pages The conquest of Peru by an obscure adventurer is one of the most dramatic episodes in the history of the New World. Until he was nearly 50 years old, Francisco Pizzaro, serving as a minor Spanish official on the Isthmus of Panama, had nothing to show for his years of toil and peril but a small holding of land. Little more than a decade later, he had conquered the fabulously wealthy empire of the Incas and had bestowed on Spain the richest of its