This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Historians' Viewpoints On American Freedom Essay

1249 words - 5 pages

In Stories of American Freedom, Eric Foner reveals that freedom has no “real” meaning behind it, just ideals that the different people and groups in the United States’ history that gives life to the word. Foner thus uses historical characters’ ideals of freedom to tell America’s history. Foner speaks of the hypocrisy in many groups versions of freedom, for instance when speaking of slavery and slaveholding in the United States shortly after the Revolutionary War era. He includes many people’s accounts on the combination of slavery and freedom, with some people even saying that they would not be free if not allowed to own those who could not be free. This account shapes the historical value ...view middle of the document...

The authors say that freedom in America is the central theme in all African Americans’ histories throughout time because they are constantly fighting for freedom, yet winning it less than often. They also believe that the inclusion of African American freedom and unfreedom in the United States “complicates” American history rather than staying within its own sphere. Amid the pages of Freedom on My Mind, is the shaping of a kind of hope that African Americans will persevere in American history and receive their much deserved freedom, both recognized among their communities and the United States government. The authors frame United States history from their concept of freedom—something that African Americans fought for and deserved—as a sort of tithe that African Americans gave to eventually gain the freedom that was due and the gaining of new cultures and ideals that would make the group stronger and what it would eventually become and is, today.
The most obvious similarity between Freedom on My Mind and The Story of American Freedom, is that they both primarily focus on the concept of Freedom in the United States. Both sources consistently provide reasons for or against freedom, but it is still the same basic idea no matter what or whom they draw the concept from in the characterization of this notion. Both also apply “freedom” to the historical accounts of American history. Their narratives shed a revealing light on how people thought of freedom in the past and compare it indirectly to how it is felt in the present time.
The difference between these two historical narratives is that one, Freedom on My Mind, focuses on how freedom affected African Americans while the other, The Story of American Freedom is broader and goes over how every group that was affected by this American “freedom”. Freedom on My Mind also says that freedom is a central part of all African Americans’ histories. The Story of American Freedom asserts that freedom is a part of all American’s histories through everyone’s different viewpoints on the concept.

The Story of American Freedom engages in history-making by just have been made. Foner preserves the past by using quotes from various sources and adding them as well as their context, so that the reader understands what the quote is in response to or where the person had said it. Foner interprets that past by adding his thoughts on each subject that is being mentioned on quoted. This happens, in parts, when Foner speaks of the term ”liberty” in context of slavery. A quotation from Nathan Appleton about Englishmen and slavery, Foner interprets this as the man saying that slavery is a detestable institution—and...

Find Another Essay On Historians' Viewpoints on American Freedom

Analysis of Oral History

684 words - 3 pages with their work. This could also become a conflict in sharing inaccurate information when making discoveries. When unchecked, historians can become blind to their bias. They tend to focus on the subject of oral history being new information rather than expanding and validating their knowledge on the subject. As readers continue further into the article, Grele begins to contradict himself with his different viewpoints. Grele begins to complicate

History Essay

934 words - 4 pages should not be viewed though rose colored glasses. The viewpoint expressed in this article is backed up by numerical data and is presented in a realistic approach. The article gives the truth about how the colonists treated their slaves and why the colonists received essential work labor from the African society. The difference in opinion is very important to the way in which history is perceived from the past. These differing viewpoints will give people different sides of a story and a better grasp on past history.


892 words - 4 pages glasses.The viewpoint expressed in this article is backed up by numerical data and is presented in a realistic approach. The article gives the truth about how the colonists treated their slaves and why the colonists received essential work labor from the African society. The difference in opinion is very important to the way in which history is perceived from the past. These differing viewpoints will give people different sides of a story and a better grasp on past history.

The Flaws and Shortcomings of African Historiography

5019 words - 20 pages Phokeng, Marjorie Mbilinyi’s article entitled “I’d Have Been a Man,” and several articles in White, Cohen and Miescher’s, African Words, African Voices, to put forth the claim that the information historians collect from “life histories” cannot be generalized in any way to correctly represent a society or group of people. Each author claims to recognize his/her biases and shortcomings, then goes on to say, despite these, I have something with

The Founding Fathers and Slavery

797 words - 3 pages William W. Freehling presents his view of the Founding Fathers and slavery in the article 'The Founding Fathers and Slavery.' He contends that America's Founding Fathers were antislavery but gives viewpoints of other historians to the contrary. The first sentence of the article states, 'Only a few years ago... no man needed to defend the Founding Fathers on slavery.' This implies that there was a change in the interpretation of the Founding

An Analysis of Slavery and Freedom

952 words - 4 pages superior to blacks.The central principle of American foreign policy was based on the statement, “Free ships make free goods.” This phrase was attempting to enforce a state of free seas, mostly of shipping goods. This was another technique of preaching the idealism of freedom and equality, but once again this was also contradictory seeing as how the goods that they were supporting freedom for, were produced mostly through the measures of

Civil Liberties

1564 words - 6 pages of their civil liberties, harming those around them. On the contrary, many other people feel that civil liberties are necessary tools to fight for their Constitutional rights. Critics believe that American citizens take advantage of civil liberties supporting limits on freedom of speech. They believe that degradation of humanity is inherent in unregulated speech. For example, according to Delgado and Stefancic, a larger or more

How Animal Farm Can Be Applied to Today's Viewpoints

930 words - 4 pages Religious freedom worldwide is being threatened as a whole, but not by you. If not by you, then by who? Your government is the answer. We all have different points of views on how well we believe our government runs our country, but are they over stepping their power? In a similar way that Napoleon destroyed the philosophy of animalism in Animal Farm, Governments in other countries are doing the same to their own people’s beliefs today. One

A Conquistador Arrives in Mexico, 1519-1520

919 words - 4 pages the ideas listed above, but in actuality was quite the sight to see. Historians can use these documents to infer that the Aztecs, an early American society, were mistakenly categorized and falsely accused of being uncivilized. It is important that historians use Díaz’s account because it was his own eye witnessed manuscript on the Spanish conquest after reading slanted, inaccurate, and fabricated stories. Díaz wrote this document for Spain and

"Is America Exceptional?"

887 words - 4 pages Martin Lipset reaffirms the nation of American exceptionalism byinsisting that the United States is the only nation that defines itself on thebasis of an ideology... Ian Tyrell argues that American exceptionalism is anartificial construct that is largely anachronistic in the modern world orinternationalism and global connections.After reading the two viewpoints, I came to the conclusion that even though Lispet doesaffirm American exceptionalism, so

The Idea of Mapping Out American Historiography

925 words - 4 pages The general topic that is being covered this week is the idea of mapping out American Historiography. Historiography is the study of the general trends historians focus on, about a topic during a given time period. As we had been discussing in the past couple of weeks, historians and people in general have a bias or preference for a topic or a causality of an event. This is true for the book American History Now by Eric Foner and Lisa McGirr

Similar Essays

The Patriot Act Infringes On American Freedom

758 words - 3 pages The Patriot Act Infringes on American Freedom September 11, 2001 started off as a beautiful, sunny day, like many other countless days in America; however, it will now be a day that will live on in infamy. As the news played the shot of the planes driving into the sides of the twin towers, fear was driven into the hearts of all Americans.  People became panicked and demanded that there be a better way for the United States government to

This Is An Essay Regarding The Theme Of Freedom In Contemporary American Literature, In This Case Elmore Leonard's Get Shorty. The Title Is: A Twist On Freedom. Includes Bibliography

1299 words - 5 pages A Twist on Freedom When Gandhi spoke of freedom, he derived it as independence from the British. He fought his whole life for freedom, culminating in his ultimate goal: a free India. While Elmore Leonard's goals were not as lofty in Get Shorty, he expresses the same idea of freedom. The novel's humorous take on Mafia life is the story of Chili Palmer, a loan shark down on his luck. Delving into Chili's hounding of a convict who has taken

Point Of View Of David Brion Davis, C.L.R. James, And Orlando Patterson Regarding The Abolishment Of Slavery

1298 words - 6 pages -interest we rose up to go against the current norm to end what we found wrong. His personal philosophy of the abolition of slavery has sparked plenty of debate, but this has quite an effect on other historians and their future scholarly work. As Davis looked back on the journey of slavery whether it is through the American civil war or the Haitian uprising the aspects he points out are vital to why history played out in the way it did. His

How Have The Various Generations Of Professional Historians Depicted The Seventeenth And Early Eighteenth Centuries' New England Puritans?

882 words - 4 pages culture. Historians are divided over this statement. Because of this one statement, some historians call him the greatest American historian of the twentieth century, while others, to say the least, believe that his idea of Puritanism is flawed.Although determining whether the Puritans made a positive or negative contribution to society is all but a concrete process, understanding all three views of them can help to gather information of the true history ofAmerica. The understanding of these different viewpoints gives Americans the chance to research and gain knowledge and insight into how the founders of America both lived and thought.