This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

History Essay

1623 words - 7 pages

Today, historians believe that, “the Treaty was the best that could be hoped for in the circumstances”. How far do you agree with the statement? Justify your response.

The treaty of Versailles was the first treaty after world war one that dealt with Germany. The treaty was first discussed by the allied powers of France, England and USA as well as Japan and Italy. Germany was not invited to discuss the terms of the treaty and the terms, once decided, were to be signed by Germany. Certain terms, while beneficial to the allied powers, dangerous and provoking towards Germany while other terms were consider not harsh enough by some nations. It was difficult to come up with a treaty that both dealt with Germany (hereby making the people happy) but at the same time wasn't too harsh (to stop from provoking of a relapse of world war 1). I feel the treaty was too harsh and the points below help establish why.
The circumstances were such that the allied powers had to keep the community happy and punish Germany while at the same time they had to make sure Germany wouldn't retaliate. Harold Nicholson feared the worst and stated "The historian, with every justification, will come to the conclusion that we were very stupid men... We arrived determined that a Peace of justice and wisdom should be negotiated; we left the conference conscious that the treaties imposed upon our enemies were neither just nor wise." Other criticism includes "The Peace of Versailles was an unsatisfactory compromise with little chance of ensuring an enduring peace. Each of the 'Big Three' had different aims which had to be modified in order to reach an overall agreement and the Germans were not even allowed to take part in the negotiations. Germany was humiliated, the French didn't feel completely secure, the British had wanted the re-establishment of trade more than anything else and the Americans had had to give up on their ideals of self determination where Germany was concerned. All this was a recipe for disaster in my opinion." which was cleverly said by Carole Faithorn who was the Head of History at an 11-18 Catholic Boys school in Avon, England.
Since Germany wasn't the only country who took part and lost in the war it would only be fair that the other countries paid their share of the punishment. This was not the case. Though the other countries did face punishment Germany received the worst part of it. Germans also felt that they also faced losses and that they shouldn't be forced to pay £6.6 billion (roughly equivalent to US $442 billion or UK £284 billion in 2013 about 28 lakh crore rupees). Germany also faced losses of millions of citizens so they also thought that they should receive reparations. The reparations were also unfair they had to sign without knowing what they were signing for the final bill was only presented in 1921. The amount was unrealistic and would economically cripple a country like Germany which was in shambles.
The terms saw several flaws...

Find Another Essay On History

history Essay

2295 words - 9 pages Singapore's history positively because it acts like a "shelter" for the immigrants. (Yen Ching Hwang). There was an influx of immigrants to Singapore in quest for economic advancement and to take advantage of the entre pot established. Without the establishment of clans like Gan Clan, immigrants will feel helpless and lost in a foreign land and commit themselves to social evils such as opium smoking and drinking, which can be detrimental to society. (Yen

History Essay

1091 words - 5 pages President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, was instrumental in his efforts to reshape and rebuild the United States from a struggling state making his endeavors a personal attachment in American history. First of all, Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s background consisted of, growing up in the country of New York. He attended private school, following Harvard and Colombia law school paving the way for his future civic duty, according to, Faragher, 2009. In

History

740 words - 3 pages hanging of twelve 'Edelweiss Pirates' in Cologne, 1944', B.Walsh, GCSE Modern World History, 2001, p.169Source B: A report by a mining instructor, 1941Source C: A leaflet by the 'White Rose Group'Source D: Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a church leader in GermanySource E: A letter from a member of the Swing YouthsSource F: A Hitler Youth report on a swing festival in 1940Source I: A report from the Nazi Leadership, 1942Source J: A photograph of shipyard workers

history

1213 words - 5 pages important concession to organized labor in the history of American”, the NLRA, or Wagner Act of 1935, established employee rights such as the ability to unionize as well as bargain for better working situations. Congress believed that workers, when deprived of having a voice to stand up to their employers, were more prone to economic instability. The rights to bargain about topics such as wage rates or hours worked forced laborers to create not only

history

1295 words - 6 pages History is the study man past chronological recorded events. Since the beginning of the world a lot have happened politically, socially, historically and economically. In this paper we shall examine the western world historically. Specifically we will examine the period between 500 B.C and 1500 A.D. Examine the most significant person, event, movement or occurrence. This period was the medieval period that was an era experienced in Europe during

history

1845 words - 8 pages great civilization but it was destined to end the moment Hernan Cortes and his conquistadors landed on the shores of what is now Mexico. Through the help of native allies, battle tactics, and widespread disease, Tenochtitlan fell to the crown in a manner that was unforeseen and to this day pretty unbelievable. Bibliography Primary Sources Castillo, Bernal, and Maurice Keatinge. The True History of the Conquest Mexico, written in the

history

872 words - 4 pages Imperialism in South Africa Throughout the course of Africa’s history, imperialism is one of the biggest transformations that could have happened. More specifically, South Africa. Though it happened almost one hundred and eighty years ago, we are still capable of seeing the different impacts it had on modern South Africa. You should care about the effects of imperialism because you can still see the different effects imperialism has had on

History

751 words - 4 pages soldiers then retaliated by shooting the Bostonians, killing five, and injuring seven. The trial afterwards came up with the verdict of acquitting all of the British except two. The punishment that the guilty received was a branding on their thumbs which, in no degree, compensated for the murders they have committed. Standing up for what you believe in becomes a big factor in why the Massacre is important to history. The Bostonians felt that

History - 847 words

847 words - 3 pages U.S History Test 2 Study GuideFrench and Indian War EffectsColonists were confident in their military strengthsBrits began to have conflict against the colonial troops due to them being so snobbySome colonies refused to assist the British during the war until William Pitt offered to reimburse them for all the money they spent on the war.American RevolutionProclamation of 1763- The law prohibited the colonists to move west of the Appalachian

history

2303 words - 10 pages The just exercise of political power is conceived of as resting upon constitutional principles. Constitutional principles are a position from which we operate justly. However, what constitutes as just? Throughout history political power derived from many historical foundations that were deemed just based on the society that upheld those principles. This notion is evident throughout the development of constitutional doctrines in Greek democracy

History

1444 words - 6 pages . During his time in jail Hitler wrote his book Mein Kampf or My Struggle. This summed up Hitler's and the Nazi party's ideas. The thoughts and ideas of the Nazis' leader were written down in one book and was to become the bible of the Nazi movement. Also during his time in prison, Hitler made possibly the most important decision in the history of the Nazi Party. He moved the focus of the Nazi Party from taking control by force to working to achieve

Similar Essays

History Essay 627 Words

627 words - 3 pages Reading, writing and arithmetic, these three subjects are the basic outline for American schools. In those subjects, where does history fit in? Some believe that teachers avoid history because of how corrupt America's has been. James W. Loewen, author of Lies My Teacher Told Me, says, "Parents may feel undermined when children get tools of information not available to adults and use them in ways that seem to threaten adult-held values." (Loewen

History Essay 432 Words

432 words - 2 pages At one time or as. People from all over the world can be biased, and may believe that their culture, religion, and beliefs are authentic. People who think like this are know to be ethnocentric, not giving any acknowledgments to other beliefs (of how the earth and inhabitants were created). Ethnocentrism hathe history and myths of other parts of the world. Perhaps, he didn't think other people were civilized enough to take their beliefs into

History Essay

821 words - 4 pages the last module we learned about the Reconstruction Era, which explained how ex-slaves had to fight for equality, this module connects the fight that the ex-slaves had to go through to all minorities and the poor. I also learned how the country was literally built by the sweat of the brow. My personal goal has been to learn History, to round out my education. I am meeting and surpassing my goals. I never thought that ex-slaves had more rights

History Essay 934 Words

934 words - 4 pages unrealistic and positive approach to this time period. These historians cast a positive view of this time period because of their desire not to diminish the importance of the great accomplishments of this time. It was always the desire of historians to write about events in an uplifting fashion and not blemish a particular time period. In today's society we are more receptive to a realistic and analytical approach to the views of history. History