This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

History And Effectiveness Of The Insanity Plea

1089 words - 4 pages

In 1843, testifying that one is insane became a useful defense. When Daniel McNaughtan attempted to assassinate British Prime Minister Robert Peel, he failed. Instead, McNaughtan killed Peel's secretary but was found not guilty by reason of insanity at the trial. The United States criminal justice system quickly adopted this new law of not guilty by reason of insanity, established by the McNaughton Decision. Although he was found not guilty, McNaughtan spent twenty years in a mental asylum until his death. Although helpful to truly insane criminals, the insanity plea has many flaws when it comes to the victims. Pleading insanity should be outlawed because it is unfair to the victims’ families, dangerous to society, and ambiguous in its interpretation.
One flaw of the insanity plea is how the victims and their families are affected. For example on March 21, 2010, Kathy Powell, the mother of 21 year old Taylor Powell, who was brutally murdered by Jarrod Wyatt outside Klamath, Oregon, said the suspect's recent insanity plea was a complete lie. Mrs. Powell said she knows little about what happened that night, but voiced frustration about the defense's efforts to suggest her son somehow instigated the fight that led to his death. Wyatt, age 26, was being charged with murder, aggravated mayhem, and torture. He pleaded a dual plea of not guilty and not guilty by reason of insanity.
Along with the family’s devastation, they are also particularly worried about Taylor's brother, Andrew, who learned of the killing while on duty with the U.S. Army's 101st Airborne in Afghanistan. Kathy Powell said that until the day of the killing the family had always been more concerned for Andrew's safety in a war zone, and said that it was shocking that such a crime would occur to Taylor right at home. Intending to stay involved in the case, Kathy voiced her frustration over the slow pace of the justice system. Both the prosecution and the defense were seeking doctors to testify regarding Wyatt's sanity. Wondering if Wyatt had previously sought help for his mental condition, Mrs. Powell was questioning the insanity plea and the United States Judicial System. When considering Mrs. Powell’s position, there was a great need for emotional closure for her and her family. Providing this closure is what the insanity plea lacks in terms of justice. Our judicial system is supposed to protect the rights of individuals in society. This plea currently in practice and is justifying the crimes of people with mental illnesses with arbitrary standards, and endangering society.
Secondly, the Insanity Plea is dangerous to society in that it causes jeopardy to our national security. McNaughton’s Rule states that for a defendant to establish a defense of insanity, he/she must prove:
“at the time of committing the act, the party accused was laboring under such a defect of reason, from disease of the mind, as to not know the nature and quality of the act he was doing, or if he did know...

Find Another Essay On History and Effectiveness of the Insanity Plea

The Insanity Defense Part I When is the insanity plea a reasonable and

866 words - 3 pages The Insanity Defense Part IOutlineWhen is the insanity plea a reasonable and ethical tool?Thesis: Although some criminals abuse the insanity plea by invoking it to escape being punished for their crimes, the insanity plea should nevertheless still be allowed for those with a documented record of mental illness.I. Background information on the insanity plea [the M'Naughten case]II. Abusing the insanity pleaIII. Importance of the insanity plea in

Summarizes "Insanity Plea" by William J.Winslade and Judith Wilson Ross. Speaks also about different ways people have used and abused the Criminal Justice System using The Insanity Plea

991 words - 4 pages wasthenbrought to court on the charges of 1st degree murder where he wasfound not guilty due to the plea of Insanity. On Thanksgiving Day,1976, Torsney had to work and was unhappy about it. At thirty-fourhe had been on the force for about 8 years and he was sick andtired ofthe conditions he had to work through. He would rather be athomewith his wife and kids at Thanksgiving, just like the average personinAmerica was doing. He made a note of the

Plea-Bargains: Currency of the Courts An Examination of the Effectiveness of Plea-Bargain Within our Court Systems

1514 words - 6 pages “Rahim Jaffer case heads for plea-bargain”; former Alberta MP Rahim Jaffer was being charged on cocaine possession and drunk-driving charges; his case was likely to be resolved with a plea-bargain agreement (Makin, 2010). This is but one case of many that are settled though a plea-bargain agreement. Plea-bargaining can take the form of a sentence reduction, a withdrawal or stay of other charges, or, a promise not proceed on other charges, in

A History of the Treatment of Insanity

880 words - 4 pages A History of the Treatment of Insanity Over the course of history, insanity has been subjected to a wide variety of treatments. Attempts to cure the mentally ill or simply relieve "normal" society of the problems caused by insanity have ranged from outright cruelty to higher degrees of humanity in today's society. This paper gives a brief overview of insanity--its believed causes and subsequent treatments--from primitive times up to the

This essay argues against the insanity plea. It gives about 5 points/arguments that prove the defense faulty, and tell that it should be abolished from court rooms

1081 words - 4 pages , especially a murder should go uncharged which is why the insanity plea should be abolished. It allows for the "mentally insane" people to go virtually unpunished for their crime. For hundreds of years civilized courts have recognized that, when a person who is mentally unstable is accused of a crime, it is a special circumstance and they must be deal with in a different manner than a sane person would.Granted the opponent must have some valid points

The Insanity of Hamlet

1592 words - 7 pages In the play Hamlet written by William Shakespeare the reader gets to see how Hamlet's life pertains to his insanity. “In life of Hamlet as represented by Shakespeare we have a full history of a case of insanity, of a peculiar kind” (Kellogg). “It is sometimes an appropriate response to reality to go insane” notes Philip K. Dick. Even though Hamlet is aware in the play there is a side to Hamlet that takes control of him. Though Hamlet often

The consequence of Insanity

861 words - 4 pages Humans all experience insanity in some way, some humans know how to hide these feelings, however everyone has to break out one day. We can also be driven insane by the pet peeves we carry. The photograph Freaked out by Marc relates to the story “The Tell Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe, by conveying the feeling of insanity. The insanity of the man in the photograph is relevant to the insanity of the narrator in the story. The photograph and the

History and Effectiveness of Victim Rights Legislation and Programs

1546 words - 6 pages oldest national group providing assistance to victims of crime and crisis. The Law enforcement community needs to ensure the safety of the victim before, during, and after a conviction. Many times the victims of crimes are forgotten or left out of the notification process when the criminal has been apprehended, prosecutes, sentenced, or released from the system. By examining the history and effectiveness of victim rights legislation and programs, the

Pros and Cons of Plea Bargaining

2624 words - 10 pages bargaining is being used as an easy way out; instead of having the person who committed the crime pay for what they did by serving the whole time. By managing a plea bargain the terms can sometimes be used to include pondering on how it works and who it can help. For a judge a primary encouragement for even accepting a plea bargain is so that the trials can be moved along a lot quicker. Plea bargains are much quicker by the requirement of the less work

Sample of the Format of a Plea

770 words - 3 pages plea. These will be explained later in the letter for your consideration. Firstly, I draw your attention to the nature of the charges against you.Evidence Relating to the Charge of StalkingYou have been charged with stalking ... between the dates of ... and ... .Under section 21A of the Crimes Act 1958 Vic, a person is guilty of stalking if they engaged in a course of conduct that caused either apprehension or fear in a person for their safety

Plea Bargains: Currency of The Courts

1514 words - 6 pages “Rahim Jaffer case heads for plea-bargain”; former Alberta MP Rahim Jaffer was being charged on cocaine possession and drunk-driving charges; his case was likely to be resolved with a plea-bargain agreement (Makin, 2010). This is but one case of many that are settled though a plea-bargain agreement. Plea-bargaining can take the form of a sentence reduction, a withdrawal or stay of other charges, or, a promise not proceed on other charges, in

Similar Essays

The Insanity Plea And Mental Illness

1165 words - 5 pages Minister, and unfortunately shot and killed his press secretary in the confusion. Established psychologists in England testified to the mental instability of M’Naghten. The jury eventually reached a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity and was held in a mental institution for the remainder of his life. This ruling was then brought to The House of Lords, and 15 judges met to determine the judicial standard of the insanity plea. They

The Insanity Plea Essay

2371 words - 9 pages punishment that they do not deserve. Some people really do commit crimes without knowing that what they are doing is wrong, in the article ‘Judge accepts Insanity Plea in Colorado Shooting Case’ by Dan Elliot, he tells us about James Holmes who in July went to a midnight showing at a movie theater and killed 12 people and left 70 injured, he had a history of being mentally ill and he was able to plead not guilty by reason of insanity. (Elliot 2013

The Insanity Plea Essay

1101 words - 5 pages was made by her defendents, she was found not guilty. But why? Why are these obvious killers not going to prison for their crimes? The answer to this question would be that both the Sickles and the Yates case are two of the most famous cases involving the insanity plea defense. The insanity plea is when the person accused of the crime admits to committing the crime, but denies responsibility on the basis that they were not mentally competent at

The Insanity Plea Essay

1072 words - 5 pages Literature Review   The literature on the subject of the insanity defense spans ever since the controversy first became a topic to be discussed. The defense has been inscribed in the legal system for centuries; ever since the Greeks and the teachings of Plato. The current literature covers the spectrum from perception of both the offenders and the defense, to arguments both for and against abolition from our Twenty-First Century laws, as well