History And Tragedy In Shakespeare's Richard Ii

2246 words - 9 pages

History and Tragedy in Richard II

      An attempt to sort Shakespeare's plays into neat categories may appear to have its benefits when striving to understand his work, but even a superficial reading of Richard II indicates that this approach is largely futile and sometimes misleading. While it cannot be doubted that the play is of a historical nature, based on events recorded in Holinshed's Chronicles of 1577 and named after an actual king, a sense of true Shakespearean tragedy is also present throughout. Instead of trying to analyse or appreciate the differences between these two forms, it is more interesting to understand how they complement each other. Shakespeare vividly brings the past to life in Richard II, and it is surely the careful mingling of historical fact and tragic elements that is responsible for the great dramatic value of the play.


Knowledge of the period of history from which the play is drawn means that the audience is prepared for Richard's fate, for example, and this only serves to illuminate the tragic inevitability of his downfall. The audience is aware that Richard II is only the first in a series of history plays, and will be followed by Henry IV (parts one and two) and Henry V. In this sense Richard could be viewed in a potentially unemotional light, as a component of English history whose reign simply linked the reigns of two others. The fact that he was usurped from the throne and murdered is not overwhelmingly tragic when seen in the context of world history, especially if his reign is being viewed with cold hindsight. However, Shakespeare's colourful portrayal of Richard and his fate means that the audience can in many ways appreciate the king in terms of a tragic hero; Coleridge asserting that 'the play throughout is an history of the human mind' (p.128).


The fact that the majority of the play's characters can predict Richard's downfall almost as accurately as the omniscient audience creates a sense of inevitability, which is central to the notion of tragedy. His friends and enemies are united in their experiences of negative presentiment, from which only Richard seems to be immune. The Queen relates that,


Some unborn sorrow, ripe in fortune's womb,

Is coming towards me; and my inward soul

At nothing trembles. (II.ii.10-13)


Despite the ambiguity of these lines regarding the nature of the 'unborn sorrow', there is an overwhelming sense of unavoidability. The passiveness of the Queen is notable (the sorrow is 'coming towards' her), and the emphatic positioning of 'Is' at the beginning of the second line suggests that there is no escape from this looming disaster. The dramatic irony of the audience knowing that her intuition is correct can only lead to increased pity for her situation. Meanwhile the tragic inevitability of Richard's plight is touched on with the image of 'fortune' giving birth from her 'womb': the King and...

Find Another Essay On History and Tragedy in Shakespeare's Richard II

The Scrivener and History in Richard III

2602 words - 10 pages construction of history that the scrivener represents is speaking with the audience is one of the people’s history. He, like Margaret and Richard, can communicate with the audience to bring them in as accomplices to his opinion. The scrivener, like the citizens in Act II, acts as a powerless witness to the events transpiring at Richard’s hands. His address, which breaks the fourth wall, connects this witnessing to the audience, putting aside the typical

Love, Lust, and Tragedy in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

2783 words - 12 pages common in life for the things we want in life, but more so in the history of love and romance. Panagopoulos thinks that romantic tragedy is like a dagger, it represents protection, death, stealth, and unity (Panagopoulos). Dibdin Thinks the idea of Romeo and Juliet being momentarily reunited but ironically they die at the end, is the view insisted by his friends (Dibdin). Coleridge thinks Romeo and Juliet is the first representation of a “Family Feud

Revenge and Vengeance in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Pure Revenge Tragedy?

2013 words - 8 pages !” Hamlet is kidnapped by pirates from the ship. Laertes and Claudius plan their own revenge on the protagonist. Richard A. Lanham in “Superposed Plays” comments on the lesser revenge tragedy within the greater revenge tragedy of Hamlet:   Now there is no doubt about how to read the Laertes play: straight revenge tragedy, to be taken – as I’ve tried to imply in my summary – without solemnity. We are to enjoy the rants as rants. When we get

The Portrayal of Socially Destructive and Over-Ambitious Richard, in Shakespeare's Richard III

2887 words - 12 pages latter saw Clarence save his brother’s life as lamented by King Edward on learning about Clarence’s death, “who told me, in the field at Tewkesbury, when the Oxford had me down, he rescued me, and said ‘Dear brother, live, and be a King?”… (King Edward, II.1, 113-119) In the manner of Satan, Richard orders the murder of his brother Clarence and accuses King Edward of his assassin. He intently adds psychological torture to the physically ailing

Elements of Aristotelian Tragedy Depicted in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

1811 words - 7 pages An Aristotelian tragedy includes many different characteristics. It is a cause-and-effect chain and it contains the elements of catharsis, which is pity and fear, and hamartia, which is the tragic flaw embedded in the main characters. The famous play Romeo and Juliet, written by William Shakespeare, is about two lovers of two different families who hate each other and the misdemeanors they have to surpass. Many debate on whether it is an

Shakespeare's Treatment of Women in Comedy and Tragedy

1367 words - 5 pages Linda Bamber differentiates between Shakespeare’s treatment of women in comedy and tragedy. In tragedy his women are strong because they are coherent – ‘certainly none of the women in the tragedies worries or changes her mind about who she is’ – and the attacks which are made on them are the product of male resentment at this strength – ‘misogyny and sex nausea are born of failure and self doubt’ . The comic feminine on the other hand, is

Romance and Tragedy in Shakespeare's The Winter's Tale

1644 words - 7 pages Romance and Tragedy in The Winter's Tale      In The Winter's Tale, the line between romance and tragedy runs thin and almost blends together. The romantic ending would not be possible without the tragic beginning. For example, how could the romance between Leontes and Hermione take place in the end without the almost tragic mistake that Leontes makes in the first three acts of the play? Specific characters are responsible for the way the

Manipulators in Shakespeare's "The Tragedy of Julius Caesar" and "The Tragedy of Othello"

531 words - 2 pages William Shakespeare made two great plays: The tragedy of Julius Caesar and The tragedy of Othello (The Moor of Venice). In those plays there were methods of manipulation used by one of the characters in each play. Before I go far, allow me to provide you some feedback on both. Julius Caesar is an exceedingly determined political leader in Rome and his endeavor is to become an autocrat. A soothsayer presaged him that he should “beware the

Essay on Honor in Richard II

1818 words - 7 pages The Importance of Honor in Richard II         The tension-charged exchange between Bolingbroke and Mowbray in the first scenes of Richard II provides exciting action for the audience, and gives a glimpse into trial by combat and the importance of honor in Shakespeare's plays. Trial by combat, or a judicial duel was a traditional way to settle disputes in England and Europe for many generations. People dueled to defend their own honor, and

The Role of Women in Richard II

2562 words - 11 pages fact that in Shakespeare's history play, Richard II, he did not use women in order to implement the facts regarding the historical events. Instead, he focused the use of women roles by making it clear that female characters significantly enriched the literary and theatrical facets of his work. Furthermore in Shakespeare’s history play, King Richard II, many critics have debated the role that women play, especially the queen. One of the arguments is

Failure and Success in William Shakespeare´s The Merchant of Venice and Richard II

976 words - 4 pages Shakespeare’s play The Merchant of Venice and Richard II, we can draw examples of unrest that results in both failure and success. Due to the presence of these ideas in Shakespeare’s play we can come to question what his attitude toward rebellions and authority and can conclude that he obviously saw the benefit in questioning authority, but realized that many uprisings resulted in failure. Whether this failure occurred immediately, it would always

Similar Essays

Biblical Figures And Ideals In Shakespeare's Richard Ii

4164 words - 17 pages Biblical Figures and Ideals in William Shakespeare's Richard II William Shakespeare's Richard II tells the story of one monarch's fall from the throne and the ascension of another, Henry Bullingbrook, later to become Henry IV. There is no battle fought between the factions, nor does the process take long. The play is not action-packed, nor does it keep readers in any form of suspense, but rather is comprised of a series of quietly dignified

A Comparison Of Corrupt Kings In Shakespeare's Henry Iv And Richard Ii

1119 words - 4 pages A successful monarchy relies upon a stable leader who is concerned with the satisfaction of those he rules over. Henry Bolingbroke the IV in Shakespeare's Henry the IV Part I follows a trend set by his predecessor in Richard II of self-indulgence and neglect of his kingdom. These leaders worry about the possibility of losing their kingdom or their soldiers to other nobles who were also concerned more with obtaining a higher position rather than

Balance And Tragedy In Shakespeare's Othello

2080 words - 8 pages , contributed to the presence of tragedy in the play. The character of Emilia is introduced in the play as one who seems to fit in well with the stereotypes and expectations for females in the seventeenth century. From the beginning, Emilia can be seen as one who is entirely loyal and faithful to her husband, Iago. Under the Cult of Domesticity it would be downright unacceptable for a woman to defy her husband. Women were considered to be

Tragedy In Shakespeare's Macbeth Essay

740 words - 3 pages “We are only puppets, our strings are being pulled by unknown forces.”~ Georg Buchner A tragedy is a drama or literary work in which the main character is brought to ruin or suffers extreme sorrow, especially as a consequence of a tragic flaw, moral weakness, or inability to cope with unfavorable circumstances. The play Macbeth is a tragedy because Macbeth allowed himself to be driven by his ambitions and