History As Natural History & The Destruction Of The World

1503 words - 7 pages

W.G. Sebald’s novel The Rings of Saturn explores the relationship between toleration and persecution through a first person narrative. The novel is preoccupied with loss and the ways we have tried to come to terms with mortality. It is a meditation on the destructive nature of history, the human lives affected, and the restorative power of art. However, his work is not simply a record of these human-induced catastrophes, but also attempts to fashion new representational tools for the purpose of acknowledging and coming to terms with the realities of modern human history. Sebald’s critcism tends to focus on the biographical and psychological backgrounds of the writers he mentions. He draws ...view middle of the document...

Sebald’s The Rings of Saturn presents a counter-figure drained of enlightenment’s and modernity’s emancipatory promise. His fascination for Sir Thomas Browne whose view is mystical and quasi-astrological, and who saw the world as a unified whole that was subject to a cyclical trajectory through time creates a sense of the failure of post- Englightenment Western thought. The novel similar to The Dialectic of Enlightenment undermines not only dominant enlightenment narratives of history and identity, but also the faint hopes for redemption and emancipation. The absence of the hope of the hopeless and a utopian vision for a liberating potential of modernity results in the text’s melancholic vision of loss and displacement. The novel’s evocation of modernity and the depletion of its emancipatory potential achieve a repudiation of the promises of progress and enlightenment. The novel ends not with an outlook on the possibilities of Jewish life today and in the future, but with a look back into an abyss “into which no ray of light could penetrate” (Sebald 297).
Whilst there is much to suggest that civilization has progressed, the narrator in The Rings of Saturn is confronted time and time again on his journey, with examples to the contrary; which is to say, in his desire to assert his superiority, man has inflicted terrible damage on the natural world and, most catastrophically, the human race. The narrator expresses this most emphatically, where he states that all processes of human production depend on combustion: in a physical, chemical sense, making something will involve the destruction of something else (Sebald 170). This “paralyzing horror” was felt when “confronted with the traces of destruction, reaching far back into the past” (Sebald 7). The Dialectic of Enlightenment tries to elaborate on the new Critical Theory’s ambivalence concerning the ultimate source or foundation of social domination. According to Horkheimer and Adorno, the source of today's disaster is a pattern of blind domination, domination in a triple sense: the domination of nature by human beings, the domination of nature within human beings, and, in both of these forms of domination, the domination of some human beings by others. What motivates such triple domination is an irrational fear of the unknown: “Humans believe themselves free of fear when there is no longer anything unknown. This has determined the path of demythologization…. Enlightenment is mythical fear radicalized” (DE 11). For Horkheimer and Adorno, there is a continuity of the age of myth within Enlightenment and modernity in general. They argue that the Enlightenment has taken us down a barbaric path. “Enlightenment, understood in the widest sense as the advance of thought, has always aimed at liberating human beings from fear and installing them as masters. Yet the wholly enlightened earth radiates under the sign of disaster triumphant” (DE 1). However, Horkheimer and Adorno do not reject the eighteenth...

Find Another Essay On History as Natural History & The Destruction of the World

The American Museum Of Natural History: Anthropology

1720 words - 7 pages      The American Museum of Natural History has many exhibits that demonstrate many aspects of anthropology. The Museum is located on Central Park West between W81st and W77nd streets. The museum is an excellent place to open oneself to many new ideas and cultures. When looking through the museum the exhibits that are anthropological could enhance ones understanding of a culture. The museum is very big and a lot of time is needed to get the

The Natural History of Whale Sharks

1115 words - 4 pages What is the largest fish in the world? The answer would be the Rhincodon typus, or commonly known as, the whale shark. The whale shark is vey unique because unlike normal sharks, the whale shark is a filter feeder and so, does not have use of its teeth. The whale shark is also about the size of a bus. However, like many animals in the world today, they are considered vulnerable according to the IUCN. They are seen often in the tropical

A history of the world

768 words - 4 pages series of events that ultimately shaped Egypt into the modern republic it is now. In this episode of ‘A History of the World in 101 Objects,’ we will delve into the history behind this legendary Stele, explore the ancient and current significance of such a production, and attempt to lift the veil on topics such as consolidating Menes with Narmer. Looking at this Palette, it isn’t hard to see how the old Egyptian subjects were so entranced by their

The Natural History of the Galapagos Written by Ian Thornton

1511 words - 6 pages The theory of evolution is a very interesting, but also a bit of a controversial topic. The Merriam Webster dictionary defines evolution as “a theory that the differences between modern plants and animals are because of changes that happened by a natural process over a very long time.” Even though many people would and have disagreed with this following statement, the theory of evolution as of now is the best the best way of explaining why

Writing the History of the World

1099 words - 4 pages Writing the History of the World To write a history of the world, one must begin at a point when the world is shifting from the remnants of old empires into the modern or at least the pre modern world as we know it. During the 15th century, we begin to see a change; Europe climbs out of the Middle Ages, tosses off its religious shackles and starts evolving. The Europeans set sail and we start to see well-documented

My Visit to the American Museum of Natural History

3200 words - 13 pages The three Halls that I visited at the American Museum of Natural History were: Halls of the Pacific Peoples, Northwest Coast Indians and Asian peoples. All of these Halls were distinctly different from each other, although I enjoyed viewing all three, my favorite Hall was that of Asian Peoples. Of special interest was the Hall of Northwest Coast Indians, since I was able to witness and play in my head, a reel of the transformations it has gone

The History of Archery Around the World

1253 words - 6 pages The bow and arrow dates back to thousands of years ago, it is estimated that they were found anywhere from 18,000BC to 25,000BC. They were used all over the world but the first arrowhead was discovered in Africa. There are many kinds of bows, the most common are the longbow and the recurve, there were many different styles created by several cultures during different times in history. In the Stone Ages, drawings discovered in caves illustrated

The Historical Significance of Salt as Presented in the Book, Salt: A World History

641 words - 3 pages Since the early history of man, salt has always been nearby. Salt: A World History, written by Mark Kurlansky, is describing the importance and the effects on history that salt has had over the thousands of years of human history. Salt: A World History begins with a simple introduction, which explains what content will be included in the book. Topics range from salt in the past,—Greece, Rome, Egypt, France, Germany, Poland, and Israel—to

Criticisms on the studies of world history

2250 words - 9 pages to understand the world in a broader perspective compared to a Western perspective made the study of world history popular in the United States. Historians approached the study of world history with a thematic approach to understand the integration and difference between people and major events of the world. The subject of world history is broad and as a result is open to many interpretations. In addition, world historians faced difficulties in

The History of World War II

1187 words - 5 pages World War II was the bloodiest global war ever exposed to simple society. It is generally considered to have lasted from 1939 to 1945, although several conflicts in Asia that are commonly linked as contributing factors towards the war had begun earlier than 1939. It concerned the vast majority of the world’s nations, including all of the great powers, finally forming two opposing military alliances: the Allied Powers and the Axis Powers. It

Brave New World: The Destruction of Family

1552 words - 6 pages Is the push for a perfect utopia enough to siphon motherhood, family, and love? As in Brave New World, Aldous Huxley illustrates the destruction of the idea of family in this ’perfect world‘. People in the world today have the ability to express love and obtain a family. Huxley explores the futuristic outlook on a world (in many ways similar to ours) that would not allow such humanistic traits. Science is so called the ’father of progress’ and

Similar Essays

Destruction Of One Of The World’s Most Breathtaking Natural Treasures

923 words - 4 pages Destruction of One of the World’s Most Breathtaking Natural Treasures Located on the Yangtze River near the city of Yichang, rise mountain peaks that form three beautiful gorges that form at the foot of these graceful mountains. At the heart of China, the Three Gorges is viewed by many people as a place of natural beauty and legendary history. It is a place that inspires authors, artists, and poets. However, all of

The Role Of Natural History Essay

720 words - 3 pages In Cuvier’s introduction he discusses the essence of natural sciences as to “render sensible in all its parts the mutual influence of every being” (Cuvier, 4). Cuvier is able to show that natural history is an indispensible part of natural philosophy and can successfully unveil the laws of nature. In making this assertion Cuvier argues that natural history plays an equal and scientific role in uncovering the system of natural sciences when

The Natural History Museum Of Los Angeles

869 words - 3 pages Untitled Bernard Pyun Anthropology 100 MW 8:00~9:30am Field trip report extra credit Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County Today I visited the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County located in downtown Los Angeles. I've been to the coliseum several times but I never knew the existence of the museum. I was quite surprised to discover such a great collection of museums nearby. I only been to the

Visit To The Natural Museum Of History

588 words - 2 pages I enjoyed my visit to the American Natural Museum of History, I had been there once before but, I didn't explore the south American cultures on the second floor as I did on my visit this past Saturday, it was amazing to see the displays of all the different cultures, specially because they are so vivid, I learned a lot on this trip about the different cultures, one of the displays that caught my eye was the Sipan Tomb excavation.I was always