This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

History Of Modern Palestine Essay

1003 words - 5 pages

In his book, A History of Modern Palestine, Ilan Pappe attempts to add to the discussion of the struggle between Jews and their counterparts over the idea of Israeli state. Using documents that have been released by the Israeli secret service that one of his graduate students had found, Pappe attempts to paint a “new history of the conflict” in the Middle East. His books adds a new element to the argument. The documents, released in the late 1980s, but the US, UN, and Israeli government show that the state of Israel was not completely innocent in the 1940s conflict. While history usually is written by the victors, Pappe, known for being critical of Israel and it policies, writes an ...view middle of the document...

However, at the beginning, as Pappe writes in his foreword, he does not want to regulate himself to the usual historical narrative that occurs by discussing or using the notes from those who were involved in the decisions or actions. Instead of focusing on those who influenced and the decisions, like most modern of his peers and other professionals in his field, he focuses, rather, on “the others” as he put in it in the above quote. He view on them, is the idea that their story while important, is equally to those who are more informed. Pappe views the heroes as the invaded, such as "women, children, peasants, workers, ordinary city dwellers, peaceniks, human rights activists.” The bad people in history are looked as “the arrogant generals leading the troops, the greedy politicians” stealing from the poor, the “cynical statesmen” and the “misogynist men” who cared nothing of the well-being of the women (Pappe, xix).
As one reads along, the problem with the way that is written becomes more apparent. The one that are eventually identified in the negative are mostly Jewish. When writing a historical narrative, especially on such a divisive issue, like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. This has some very negative consequences. It may come off as looking anti-Semitic. Especially in some more extreme extents of Islam, this is highly ironic. In some forms of Islam, women are ruled and regulated into third class citizens. While in class, Dr. Omid has mentioned this by pointing out that many religions have their faults, Pappe seems to skim over this and point out Israel’s faults without looking at some of the Palestinians own behaviors towards women.
There are some positives to Pappe’s book, however. In his book, he does use the second-hand account of those who are being oppressed. He takes into account the alternate history and uses it to form a unique narrative to a story that has not been told before. This is important, because these first...

Find Another Essay On History of Modern Palestine

The story of what happened to shape the area in Palestine - History - Essay

821 words - 4 pages , Syria, Lebanon, and Iraq invaded. In 1949, U.N.-brokered cease-fires left the State of Israel in permanent control of this conquered territory. The departure of hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs from Israel during the war left the country with a substantial Jewish majority. The way history interprets this situation doesn’t effectively show the Arab side and what the Palestine people view of what happened and how did this happen to them

Dueling in Early Modern England History of Early Modern England

3570 words - 14 pages as they emerged from a feudal system into a more modern capitalistic society. It was these changes that would contribute to the growing practice of honor and dueling. Before we discuss the changes and how they allowed the concepts of honor and dueling to enter into English society, let us first discuss the history and major concepts of the duel.The justification for the duel most likely dates back to the biblical story of David and Goliath. As

The History of the Modern Piano

1509 words - 7 pages The History of the Modern Piano Pianos have been around for about three millenniums, and have been redesigned hundreds- if not thousands of times! What has kept this instrument, this form of expressing deep feeling, so entwined with its owner and all those who hear it? The piano has been around for such a lengthy period of time that it is described to have an epoch, or an age, which represents its climb into fame and ends just before the

The History and Development of Modern Hebrew

742 words - 3 pages Hebrew is the basis of one of the most persecuted groups in the history of the world. Its development and its triumphs show the strength of the Jewish population worldwide. After the fall of Jerusalem, Hebrew died for nearly 2,000 years. One man made it his life purpose to revive it and his homeland. Not only is this extremely powerful on a political level, but also on an emotional and spiritual level, as well. From its revival on, Hebrew has

History of Modern Psychology: Anna Freud

1514 words - 6 pages Coles, Robert (1992). Anna Freud: The dream of psychoanalysis. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Goodwin, C. J. (2005). A history of modern psychology (2nd Ed.). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Young-Bruehl, E. (1988). Anna Freud: A biography. New York: Summit Books

History of Modern Science and Technology

2508 words - 10 pages History of Modern Science and Technology The Impact of the Microscope The world we live in today has many complexities that have perplexed mankind for ages. Various great men and women of science have gotten together to try and uncover the mysteries of the world. On their journey there have been instruments and tools invented that would help them further their studies beyond compare. One of the most significant inventions that have

The History of Modern Latin America

2022 words - 8 pages The history of modern Latin America begins after the Second World War when the economic changes wrought by the war, namely the shift towards manufacturing and urbanization, produced political and diplomatic changes across the Americas. The end of the war led to increased imports from the West, reducing the competitiveness of Latin American industry. Additionally, falling crop prices led to increasing urbanization. The result of these economic

Interpreting Modern History: Revival of the Appreciation of Art

998 words - 4 pages Modern history was the abandonment of European confinement. I understand modern history as being the revival of the appreciation of art, ideas, and moral values known as the Renaissance. During and before this time period, the majority of the European population was deeply embedded and blinded by the church. It is my understanding that Modern history is comprised of a sequence of events. It was not limited to specific dates, it was a continuous

Modern translation of declaration of Independence - AP US History - Assignment

2519 words - 11 pages The Declaration of Independence-(Original to Modern Translation) When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which

A Brief History of the Early Modern Era

2031 words - 8 pages In history, the Modern Era is a time that is identify because profound changes marked the development of many cities. In the early modern era, cities grew through general economic grow throughout all Europe. The agriculture production increased as well as the production of rural commodities, which were used for trading. A new phenomenon called global trading was starting to emerge. The different European manufactures were exported to different

The History of Modern Women and Body Art

1430 words - 6 pages The History of Modern Women and Body Art I chose to do this field report on body art because I, personally, find the topic very complex and interesting. It is for this reason that I decided to narrow the scope of my field research. I am focusing this report on the trends and evolution in body art as relating to modern women. When I say modern women I am referring to the women from about the 18th century to the current day. I chose to focus

Similar Essays

History And Geography Of Palestine Essay

913 words - 4 pages the size of Vermont, yet it has a larger variety of geographical regions then a country three times its size ("Palestine" World 85).Palestine is unique in its geographical regions, as well as in its history. People lived in Palestine at least 200,000 years ago, during the Old Stone Age. Archeologists have dug up relics from that time period. They have also found rich relics from the New Stone Age which dates to 12,000 years ago. In fact, it is

History Of Modern Computing Essay

892 words - 4 pages . Today I will be writing about the modern history of computing since it is really important to know the history of computer. HISTORY OF COMPUTING According to history, human clerks where well known as computers which helped in calculating effectively. The calculation done by the human computers which nowadays are carried by the electronic computers, human clerks worked in commerce department, research faculties and the government as well. The

The Modern History Of Computing Essay

1782 words - 8 pages their computers. Today I will be writing about the modern history of computing since it is really important to know the history of computer. HISTORY OF COMPUTING According to history, human clerks where well known as computers which helped in calculating effectively. The calculation done by the human computers which nowadays are carried by the electronic computers, human clerks worked in commerce department, research faculties and the government

The History Of Modern Wars Essay

733 words - 3 pages War is an obliterate machine employed by every nation from Third World countries to Global Empires throughout world’s history. This essay will attempt to review Modern American History from the World War II to present day. Key areas will be exam are 1) patriotism and propaganda used by the government during wartime, 2) the role of Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) enforcing domestic laws during the Cold War era of American history, 3) the