Hitler Vs. Stalin Essay

1158 words - 5 pages

Historians, analysts, and educationalists of all different measures have attempted to label one of these two leaders has "the most monstrous dictator our time has ever studied" When one first asks the question : Who was more tyrannous out of the most tyrannous ? The most obvious answer would be Adolf Hitler because through his extensive use of propaganda, he made what would seem to be an obsolete goal of genocide, a scare great enough to cause the US to take affirmative action. On the contrary, Stalin executed millions upon millions of his own countrymen in his attempt to diminish the audacity of the Russian people leaving them with little thought of any chance for resistance. Alan Bullock, author of Hitler and Stalin ,states "Adolf Hitler's actions can not even be compared to the monstrous actions of Joseph Stalin" (1). However, one man's opinion isn't enough but through interpretation and analysis of both their reigns of terror, one can only hope in identifying the dividing factor in these two leader's ideas and actions.The names Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin are synonymous with the word propaganda. Hitler and Stalin each used propaganda as their tool to further their ideas in an attempt to gain the support of their fellow countrymen.There are many different forms of propaganda that can be used effectively but Hitler's speech was his most successful means of expression. This is an excerpt from Hitler's final speech before his trial for treason and in this speech he made the people aware of his opinions and views on the events preceding the trial : "...I aimed from the first to...become the destroyer of Marxism....The army that we are building grows more from day to day, from hour to hour....You might just as well find us guilty a thousand times, but the goddess of the eternal court of history will smile and tear up the emotions of the states attorney and judgement of the court : for she finds us not guilty." (2) This speech was one of many that helped Hitler gain the control of the Nazi party and further proves that he used vocal propaganda effectively.Hitler was fully aware of the effectiveness of propaganda so he appointed his very own minister of propaganda when he had total control over Germany.Stalin was a very un-stable man and his actions were due to nervous breakdowns and his poor decision making skills but he too used propaganda profusely. His supporters spoke out with great love and belief that he would be Russia's "savior" in speeches similar to this : "Comrades !, It is time to tell the people the truth. Everyone in the party keeps talking about Lenin and Leninism. We've got to be honest with ourselves.Lenin died in 1924. How many years did he work in the party ? What was accomplished under him ? Compare it to what has been accomplished by Stalin ! The time has come to replace the slogan "˜long live Leninism' with the slogan "˜long live Stalinism' "(3) Stalin, too, was able to sway the thoughts of the people with...

Find Another Essay On Hitler Vs. Stalin

The Two Most Infamous Leaders: Hitler and Stalin

1375 words - 6 pages Although sworn enemies, Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin share an immense amount of common ground in the ways they came to power and ruled their countries. The similarities between the two dictators are undeniable; working with illegal parties, political purges, and labor camps just scratches the surface of all the qualities that they share. These tyrannical leaders, due to their similarities, are the face of hatred in the world. By choosing to

Comparing Dictators Adolf Hitler versus Benito Mussolini versus Joseph Stalin

1651 words - 7 pages This essay will compare the three leaders who are famous for their dictatorship and totalitarianism during the 30's decade-Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini and Joseph Stalin. Totalitarianism is when a government gains absolute and total control over the country, including the freedom of thought and will as well as the citizen?s lifestyle, no other political parties are allowed and has the concept where the country is most important. The difference

A Comparison of Stalin and Hitler as Dictators

1504 words - 6 pages A Comparison of Stalin and Hitler as Dictators Adolf Hitler This assignment will introduce you to two men, Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin. Two men that were responsible for genocide and mass destruction, similar in many ways though on two opposing sides with completely different fundamental ideas. Adolf Hitler was born as Adolf Schicklgruber in 1889 in Braunau am Inn, in Upper Austria and committed suicide in a

Hitler and Stalin: A Comparison of Traits Contributing to the Rise to Power

2370 words - 9 pages sense of belonging and structure to a weak society. This is what led to the rise of two of the most domineering totalitarian governments in history: Stalin’s Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) and Hitler’s Nazi Germany, or the Third Reich. The establishment and success of both the USSR and Nazi Germany are largely due to one common factor. The attributes of Stalin and Hitler enabled them to successfully gain and maintain complete

Queens: Catherine and Elizabeth, Theodore Roosevelt and Winston Churchill, Hitler and Stalin

1839 words - 7 pages increasing production and creation of new weapons and arterial.7. Stalin and Hitler were both totalitarian dictators who used terror and violence as tools to obtain and express authority. They were both megalomaniacs obsessed with having control of everything.

Non-violent resistance could never work against a ruthless despot like Stalin or Hitler

1959 words - 8 pages identifies, Mahatma Gandhi's largely nonviolent satyagraha struggle against British imperialism succeeded because of the moral constraints faced by the occupying British (Beazley, cited in Summy 1994: 5), as well as the risk of political damage back in Britain. This then begs the question of how effective nonviolent resistance would be against ruthless despots like Stalin, Hitler and their totalitarian states. Through an analysis of the nature of

Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and a Turkish Dictator reflecting the fascist and communist worldviews on key political issues

3358 words - 13 pages This paper will present a platonic dialogue between Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and a Turkish Dictator reflecting the fascist and communist worldviews on key political issues. To be more consistent, I wrote an imaginary story in order to create a context that these three people would come and talk to each other. According to the story the new Turkish Dictator did not have a certain political stand. He was about to take control of the country

Totalitarian Dictators in Twentieth-Century Europe: Mussolini, Stalin, Hitler - A comparison of the three main totalitarian dictators of the middle of the 20th Century

3029 words - 12 pages Hitler. Stalin. Mussolini. These three names define World War II. World policy revolved around them for at least a decade or in Stalin's case for almost fifty years. Much is generally known about each man's role in the war, but only as it pertains to the outcome. Not many people possess extensive knowledge of these dictators as individuals or as leaders of a particular party. This paper will attempt to shed light on the differences as well as

Totalitarianism in Animal Farm

1800 words - 7 pages Russian Revolution.” “Okhrana Mugshot.” 1900. http://en,wikipedia.org/wiki/Trotsky Kreis, Steven. "The Age of Totalitarianism: Stalin and Hitler." File last modified on 4 Aug. 2009. The History Guide. Web. 1 Dec. 2011. . Rollyson, Carl, ed. Notable British Novelists. Pasadena : Salem Press, INC., 2001. Print. Jennifer. "JOSEPH STALIN VS. NAPOLEON." 2001. Milford High

World War II

2850 words - 11 pages Britain, France, Japan and the United States. One of Stalin's ability to integrate secret police and foreign espionage came in 1940, when he gave approval to the secret police to have Leon Trotsky assassinated in Mexico (Joseph Stalin, 1999).Stalin became concerned that the Soviet Union invaded by Germany. Stalin believed the best way to deal with Adolf Hitler was to form an anti-fascist alliance with the countries in the west. Stalin realized that

ww1 ww2

2866 words - 11 pages Hitler och Josef Stalin var båda av dess tid historiska diktatorer som dödade miljontals människor i ett försök att starta egna sina nationer och båda hade sina utsedda spioner. De ville också ta över världen och styra ett globalt herradöme och skylla andra grupper av människor för allt det andra bygga ett bättre försvar och återställa strömmen så att de

Similar Essays

Stalin Vs. Hitler Essay

2643 words - 11 pages Run to the Top Josef Stalin, a politician from the earliest beginnings of his life, strove to achieve a national sense of power during his reign over the citizens of Russia. Adolf Hitler, however, a born high school dropout somewhat longed for a place in life. He rather fell into his role as a politician, after his brief shortcomings in arts and sciences. These two individuals developed varying ideas to put their controlling minds to work to

Adolf Hitler And Joseph Stalin Essay

1828 words - 7 pages Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin Hitler and Stalin will probably go down in history as two of the greatest known evil leaders of the 20th Century. What could bring two men to become the menaces they were? What kind of upbringing would cause someone to turnout the way they did? This report will compare the two through their adolescence till the end of their teenage years.      December 21, 1879 at Gori in Georgia, Joseph Stalin is born

Individual & Society: Stalin ~ Hitler ~ Mussolini

1695 words - 7 pages Individual & Society: Stalin ~ Hitler ~ Mussolini The relationship between the individual and society in Europe in the early 20th century, as it pertained to Fascism, Nazism, and Totalitarianism, was based primarily on the fact that there was no individual in the eyes of the state. Individual liberties and expressions were eliminated in order to improve the welfare of the country. Leaders taught conventional ideals and murdered enemies, so

A Comparison Of Hitler And Stalin

2153 words - 9 pages During the period leading up to World War II, there were two menwho were on opposing sides, the men were Adolph Hitler and JosephStalin. These men were each triumphant in their rise to power in theircountries and they were very comparable in the ways that theysucceeded. Their success was mostly attributed to their new ideas andtheir politics.Although Hitler and Stalin hated each other, the two leaderswere similar in many ways. Hitler and Stalin