This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Home Made Justice Essay

2053 words - 9 pages

It was about a year ago I found myself backed up against a building staring down the barrel of a forty-five. The barrel glistened in the moonlight and I found myself wondering what I was doing in the ghettos of the Buenos Aires at this late of an hour. The two thugs rummaged through my pockets and stripped me of all my money, electronics, and even made me hand over my jacket. After the robbery I called the police and was told that nothing could be done. In my frustration I talked to a few of the locals and recounted the story to them.
The next day we were passing by a park when group of hazardous looking youth approached us. After the events of the previous day, I started sweating up a ...view middle of the document...

Before my experience in Argentina I had only seen things like that in the movies. My experience with vigilantes was limited to Batman, Spiderman, and The Transformers. In the movies vigilantes are always heroes. They do good, help the helpless, and correct the problems that conventional law enforcement fails to solve; but these super heroes of the cinema aren’t exactly real life. This brings us to the question. Is vigilante action ever justifiable?
What is a vigilante? According to the Merriam Webster dictionary a vigilante is, “a member of a volunteer committee organized to suppress and punish crime summarily (as when the processes of law are viewed as inadequate); [or] broadly: a self-appointed doer of justice.” In other words a vigilante is usually a person that decides to take the law into their own hands. This definition really is not adequate to describe all vigilantes. It leaves many questions unanswered. For example, whose laws are vigilantes enforcing? What type of justice do they seek? How do they enforce said laws? What separates vigilantes from other organizations such as the Klu-Klux-Klan and Al-Qaida? It becomes a very messy situation when you start to consider how broad of a topic vigilantism really is.
To narrow the topic we can clear up some of these questions. In order to be a true vigilante, vigilantes need to be enforcing the laws of the land, and the only way to enforce these laws is by violence. William E. Burrows a professor at New York University and expert on national security had this to say about vigilantism.
Violence was and continues to be the ultimate recourse that has given vigilantes their social bite and made them a force to be reckoned with. Without violence in some form, actual or potential, vigilante action would mean next to nothing, because it would be incapable of intimidation and, therefore, of “regulation.” Those who have been threatened by vigilance, who have wandered under its shadow, have always taken it seriously, because they have understood, sometimes through the firsthand example that it amounted to certain deadly punishment. (Burrows 8)
I think it is very clear. The only way vigilantes can be effective is through violence or at least the threat of violence.
Many people would like to claim that this is not justifiable. Laws and governments are created to protect us from the unwanted violence of others. Social contract theorists argue that because we are part of a society we must follow its rules. We must look to the established system to provide retribution and punishment. Society itself must right individual wrongs and protect its citizens. Any time a person supersedes their respective role and fulfills a function that is not their own they violate this contract. More bluntly if Bill steals my car, I cannot go beat Bill and take my car back, I must go to the police and follow the legal course of action. Vigilantes skip going to the police and decide to enforce the law by...

Find Another Essay On Home Made Justice

Bowers V Hardwick Supreme Court Case

1028 words - 4 pages make his opinion more valid. The key issue that was focused on by Justice White was whether or not the Federal Constitution grants a fundamental right upon homosexuals to engage in sodomy. There were still laws in many states that made sodomy illegal, and have been in place for a very long time. When making his way to presenting his opinion of the Supreme Court, Justice White went through prior cases such as Loving v. Virginia, Roe v. Wade

A Myth Called Justice Essay

785 words - 3 pages A Myth Called "Justice"         I once had a friend with whom I shared many hours of joyful playtime. We played together just about every day. One particular occasion we got into an argument and my friend made me furious. With my anger I took a brick and heaved it at my friend. It landed on his back with a crack. I sent him home crying. I was six years old at the time, and this occasion has been burned in my memory for over 10

Justice is Served in Antigone by Sophocles

1001 words - 5 pages ). Antigone knows what she did was not wrong, but in the eyes of the ruler, she will not get away with the choice she made. Antigone was a tough girl for sticking up for herself, but unfortunately it was not enough to stop Creon in his evil and unjust ways. Justice is something extremely sacred to the human race and has always been a huge factor in people’s lives throughout history. Not to mention how important it was in Antigone’s life. If

Moral Crisis and Corruption as Obstructions to Perfect Justice

1631 words - 7 pages would hang. I think that police’s behavior that interrupts with proceeding with the trial disturbs determining justice. In addition, India also has dishonesty of the authority related to justice. In Behind the Beautiful Forevers, when Kalu died, police officer made up his cause of death. The police officers’ behavior is obviously immoral to justice because the false cause of death hid the truth (Boo, 168). It could not be happened whatsoever

Arguments Over the Most Desirable Form of Justice

2384 words - 10 pages norms they should not be punished in order to promote good actions in the future, but simply be punished because they made grievance infractions against the establishment. The proceeding statement is the philosophical bedrock of retributive justice. If using a more critical lenses and purely ethical barometer the idea of retributive could be more descriptive as the law of retaliation. In modern comedic commentary, professional comedian Ron

Justice System in Ancient Greece as Portrayed in Homer's Odyssey

940 words - 4 pages die without avenging their death. On the hand we see Odysseus as a prey of justice as he suffers Poseidon’s retribution for blinding his son, Cyclops. Cyclops prays to his father “Hear me –Poseidon, god of the sea-blue man who rocks the earth!”(9.585-586). He asked his father to punish Odysseus not to reach his home, or if he is to reach his home it should take a while. Poseidon’s listens to the prayer and develops anger towards Odysseus. He

How Does Restorative Justice Work Within Nacro?

3978 words - 16 pages Restorative Justice has been the boundary between negotiator practices and the workings of the Criminal Justice System. There are concerns that the due-process safeguards for rights, equality, and proportionality could be lost. (Marshall, 1999)Restorative Justice, at least in principle, seeks ways for victims and offenders to cooperate in preventing future crime and repairing past harm, this seems to override the remark made before about fear, which can

The Criminal Justice System

2417 words - 10 pages control agencies such as signing the sex offenders register or a prison sentence, restorative justice aims to improve and enhance social solidarity (McLaughlin, Muncie and Hughes, 2003). Furthermore conventional justice systems see crime as a violation of the state and decisions regarding the consequences of this are often made by professionals working for the state, who obviously have the best interests for the state. In contrast to this

Balancing Justice and Rehabilitation

664 words - 3 pages juvenile justice system in order to provide equitable judging. In between law enforcement and court, informal agreements can be made such as mandatory counseling or curfew (Juvenile Justice System Structure & Process 2).This aids adolescents by demonstrating that even minor offenses have consequences, but that their past do not need to stop their future. Probation also allows minors to understand that as they get older, punishment worsens, teaching

Justified tradgedy

1328 words - 6 pages ” punishment from her father who erroneously believes that Cordelia’s refusal to do what he asks demonstrates her lack of love for him. Cast away, Cordelia goes with her fiancé France as an exile from her own home. As events progress through the play, King Lear realizes that his two other daughters who professed great love for him do not really love him and he begins to see the justice he inflicted on Cordelia as irrational and unjust for he punished

Questions and Answer About Bullying, Types of Justice and Motivation

1927 words - 8 pages bullying demonstrates a lack of which one of the three types of organizational justice? According to Jerald Greenberg, organizational justice is refers to an employee’s perception of their organization behaviors, decisions and actions and how these influence the employees own attitudes and behaviors at work. This term is closely connected to the concept of fairness. Employees who are sensitive to decisions made on by their employers will judge

Similar Essays

Restorative Justice Essay

1722 words - 7 pages . However, there have also been criticisms made against the restorative approach which could, in effect, lead to no transformations regarding public debate being made. Some of the criticisms include the fact that restorative justice could potentially cause more harm than good, and that in some cases, it is completely ineffective. The idea of restorative justice appears to be a beneficial thing which could greatly impact society and how we view crime

Hidden Justice Essay

1337 words - 6 pages once again and Reach his well-built house and his own native country, let him come home Late and come a broken man- all shipmates lost, alone in a strangers ship and let him fin a world of pain at home!”(9: 523-590). Here we have a perfect example of it being more revenge then justice. Is it really fair that Odysseus has to loss all of his remaining me to this Cyclops? Even when Polyphemus had already has killed a good handful of Odysseus’s

Justice ≠ Fairness Essay

821 words - 4 pages , then they might not have made such bad choices later in life. To teach good justice, you have to start at a young age. “When my son adam was six years old, we lived in a typical suburban home… I pulled into my driveway to find Adam sitting with a bunch of caps and banging them with a rock to make them explode… He finally confessed that he had ridden his bike to the corner store and stolen the caps… I quickly put Adam in the car and drove

Justice Portrayed In Agamemnon Essay

1689 words - 7 pages ?And I, the waver of Justice, plotted out the kill, Atreus drove us into exile, my struggling father and I, a babe-in-arms, his last son, but I became a man and Justice brought me home.? (Ag, 1639-1643). He is very proud of the fact that he has brought forth Agamemnon?s death because he mentions it again by saying ?link by link I clamped the fatal scheme together. Now I could die gladly, even I now I see this monster in the nets of Justice.? (Ag