Homicide Case Study R V. Gittany Griffith University, Criminology And Criminal Justice Case Study

1790 words - 8 pages

Homicide Case Review
R v. Gittany
Question 1. Type of homicide
The type of homicide featured in the case of R v Gittany (2014) is intimate partner homicide, or more specifically intimate partner femicide as the victim was female. Intimate partner homicide is a sub-category of domestic homicide and is defined by the Australian Institute of Criminology (2015) as homicide occurring between intimate partners, where the perpetrator and victim share a current or previous relationship such as marriage, defacto, or dating partnership. An intimate relationship was evident in the case as at the time of the homicide incident, the victim and perpetrator were in a defacto cohabiting relationship and were engaged to become married (R v Gittany, 2013).
Question 2. Offender characteristics
The offender is named as Simon Gittany, a 40-year-old male at the time of the trial (38yrs old at the at the time of the homicide). The offender was born and raised in Australia and is of Lebanese descent. The offender is one of six children and was reported to have had a stable and caring upbringing, with his family being described as “close knit” (R v Gittany, 2014). Mr Gittany’s parents had allowed him to live with them for extended periods of time without paying rent and it was reported that his mother did everything for him, with Mr Gittany stating that it was "like living in a hotel" (R v Gittany, 2014).
After completing his Higher School Certificate, Mr Gittany was employed as a tiler whilst studying a TAFE course which he did not complete. His employment history was described as sporadic, as he rarely remained at any job for longer than six months (R v. Gittany, 2013). Mr Gittany undertook courses in religious studies and dramatic arts but did not complete them. He reported working for three years at the Sydney Morning Herald as an advertising account manager and claimed to be employed at Job Search at the time of his arrest, however there was no record of this (R v Gittany, 2013).
Mr Gittany had several previous criminal convictions, at the age of 18 years he was convicted of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. At the age of 21 he was convicted of two counts of receiving stolen property, assaulting a police officer in the execution of duty and malicious wounding of a police officer, he received a sentence of two and a half years periodic detention. In 2001, Mr Gittany was convicted of supplying prohibited drugs and being in the possession of property believed to be stolen (R v Gittany, 2014).
After the homicide incident, Mr Gittany underwent a personality test that showed “highly elevated and statistically significant scores” for a “schizoid”, “depressive” and “dependent” personality, individuals with these personality types often adopt a "peripheral role in social, work and family settings and may lack self-awareness or insight into the implications of interpersonal behaviour". It was also stated that “There was no doubt that the accused was controlling,...

Find Another Essay On Homicide Case Study R v. Gittany - Griffith University, Criminology and Criminal Justice - Case study

Case Study: Data Collection of the Criminal Justice System

905 words - 4 pages The Criminal Justice System has a wide range of data collection. A database gives the crime and public safety information used by the similar areas of the criminal justice systems. Technology provides every division of the criminal justice system results to a flawless use of information significant to its role. Information sharing and crime mapping based on trends increase the criminal justice capabilities of federal and local organizations

ILAC case study - legal issues for managers - Griffith Business School

1132 words - 5 pages Howard and Sheldon are likely to receive, if she is to receive any at all? Law – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s. 9: An officer of a company s. 180 - 184: Duties and liabilities of directors s. 191: Disclosure of interest by directors s. 1042: Prohibition of inside trading Common Law: ASIC v Vizard (2005) – Breached duty to act honestly Daniels v Anderson (1995) – CEO contributory negligent - breached the duty of care and

Most Significant Crime Today - Thomas Edison State University - Intro to Criminal Justice

829 words - 4 pages Thomas Edison State University General AOJ-102 In this paper, we will be going over what I think is the most important crime that has a great effect on the criminal justice system of the United States of America. First, I will be mentioning why marijuana drug criminalities are the biggest plague in the criminal justice system. Next, we will talk about the positive and negative impact on the criminal justice system if marijuana were

In R. v. Malmo-Levine; R. v. Caine, the court held that the harm principle is not a principle of fundamental justice for the purposes of Section 7 of the Charter

2454 words - 10 pages In R. v. Malmo-Levine; R. v. Caine, the court held that the harm principle is not a principle of fundamental justice for the purposes of Section 7 of the Charter. Explain the harm principle and the court's reasons for rejecting it. Did the court reach the right decision in holding that the authority of the Canadian state is not limited by the harm principle? Why or why not?In his essay "On Liberty", John Stuart Mill explains the importance of

Starbucks - Rutgers University - Case Study

544 words - 3 pages Case Study 6: Starbucks Starbucks served its first coffee back in 1985 in Seattle Washington. Starbucks is known to offer a nice relaxing coffee bar environment to society. They eventually partnered with Green Mountain Coffee Roasters to introduce new products in brewing machines for customers to brew at home. So from the store locations and the services offered out on the town you can now enjoy a number of Starbucks coffee blends right

Planned Changed Intervention (Program/Project) Analysis Paper - Monmouth University Criminal Justice - Incarcerated Mothers

1850 words - 8 pages Keith Kirkwood 3/14/2016 PC Intervention (Program/Project) Analysis Paper CJ2696 Spring 2016/Tripp Incarcerated Mothers There are programs and policies that are put in place that addresses specific problems in our Criminal Justice System, especially when it comes to Incarcerated Mothers. A program that has attempted to address this problem is Parenting Inside Out, an intervention that provides parenting skill training programs for parents

Analysis: R v. Harrison Case

2231 words - 9 pages ). In summary, although the accused may be involved in nefarious conduct (R. v. Harrison, 2009), the police must still follow legislated procedure in order to ensure that justice will be served as defined by Canadian court policy (R. v. Harrison, 2009). Precedent Cases: In relation to the fundamental breaches of the Charter presented by the facts of R. v. Harrison, the use of precedent cases exemplifies case law and the judicial reasoning for

Assignment #2: Sauve v Provost - Case Study

869 words - 4 pages SOC115 Law and Ethics 1. Which court heard the case? What was the name of the judge who heard the case? On what date was the case reported? The court who heard this case was the High Court of Justice in Ontario. The name of the judge was Granger J.. February 26, 1990 was the date the case was heard. 2. Briefly summarize the facts of the case. Who is the plaintiff that is suing for compensation? Who are the defendants that are

Policing Styles: Which do you think this is most effective? - Thomas Edison State University - Intro to Criminal Justice

571 words - 3 pages officers. Journal of criminal justice, 14(4), 329-348. Glauser, M. J., & Tullar, W. L. (1985). Communicator style of police officers and public satisfaction with officer/citizen telephone conversations. Journal of Police Science & Administration. Klinger, D. A. (1997). Negotiating peace in patrol work: An ecological theory of police response to deviance. Criminology, 35(2), 277-306. Marx, G. T. (1974). Thoughts on a neglected category of social movement participant: The agent provocateur and the informant. American Journal of Sociology, 80(2), 402-442.

Case Study Based on Q R Holdings Ltd

1379 words - 6 pages funds for expansion. Q R National should focus on increasing productivity as it influences demand and makes stakeholders’ value to increase. Queensland Bulks Handling is another stakeholder, which normally deals in handling of coal at export terminals (Queensland Bulks Handling 2003). The main interest of this stakeholder is that Q R National increases its export capacity so that it can benefit the Coal Corporation. In case Q R National

NCAA Athletics - West chester university - Case Study

2313 words - 10 pages Analysis of Case Study on NCAA Athletics: Are Its Amateurism and Financial Assistance Policies Ethical? By A.J. Strickland and Garrett Moody from The University of Alabama This case analyzes the proposition if the policies surrounding college athletes having amateur status and remaining unpaid is ethical and fair. The case, written by A.J. Strickland and Garrett Moody of the University of Alabama give facts on the funds generated in college

Similar Essays

Criminal Justice Information System Case Study

6310 words - 25 pages Metro/Davidson County, TennesseeCriminal Justice Information System Case StudyA CJIS Project ReviewAbishake ChandrasekaranDate: 05/02/2009Executive SummaryThis is a project review based on a case study of Metro/Davidson County's Criminal Justice Information System. This CJIS had been very successfully implemented, and set an example for other CJIS project in the future. The purpose of this document is to summary the valuable experience of CJIS

Diversity And Discrimination In The Criminal Justice System Kingston University Annotated Bibliography

1534 words - 7 pages lead to various social movements and the social exclusion of individuals (McGuire, J. 2002, p, 10) For the purpose of this study, the term ‘treatment’ is medical care given to a patient for an illness and the term ‘punishment’ is in the context of retribution of an offense. In this case, a custodial sentence in a prison. As in many countries, civil and criminal courts are increasingly demanding the opinions of psychiatrists, psychologists and

Criminal Law Case Study

1892 words - 8 pages ; Firstly diminished responsibility as outlined in s. 52 of The Coroners And Justice Act 2009 (s. 2 of the Homicide Act 1957 as amended), secondly loss of self-control (this used to be provocation but is now governed by the CJA 2009) and thirdly a suicide pact (Oxford University Press), which is irrelevant in this case. Firstly we shall look at the defence of diminished responsibility. This defence recognises that it is less culpable to kill someone

Racial Profiling In The Criminal Justice System Stevenson University Essay

2018 words - 9 pages Profiling Against African Americans The official definition of racial profiling is the law enforcement practice of using race, national origin, or ethnicity as a basis for suspicion of criminal activities. "Creating a profile about the kinds of people who commit certain types of crimes may lead officers to generalize about a particular group and act according to the generalization rather than specific behavior" (National Institute of Justice