Homosexuals, A Suspect Class? Essay

2611 words - 10 pages

The struggle for minority protection by lesbians and gay men has moved to the center of American life at the outset of the 1990's. It is almost certain that lesbian and gay issues will be a more eminent aspect of the public consciousness and American political scene in the coming decade than in any other time in American history. Policy changes early in Bill Clinton's administration created a heated debate over the military presence of gays and lesbians, several states have passed amendments prohibiting laws that protect homosexuals from discrimination, and nearly every religious organization in the nation is facing tough questions ranging from the ordination of homosexuals to homosexual marriages. Furthermore, the homosexual community is more prominent than ever: Lesbians and gay men are fighting for civil rights in the courtroom and in Congress, there are gay characters on prime-time television shows, well-known public figures openly discussing their homosexuality, and there is virtually no one who can claim that they have never had contact with a homosexual. In the middle of all this publicity, there lingers a pending Supreme Court case in which the fate of the homosexual lies: Romer v. Evans, a case that dominated Colorado that has come to 'symbolize the controversy over gay legal rights' throughout the nation. This paper will trace the elements behind that case, and attempt to focus on the steps the Supreme Court will follow to determine whether homosexuality must be legally considered a 'suspect class' for the purposes of 'quota preferences, protected status or claim of discrimination' as outlined by Colorado's now-famous Amendment 2.Amendment 2 does away with any attempt to protect homosexuals as a group that needs special rights because of discrimination. It was enacted after a statewide referendum, in which 53% voted for the measure. Richard Evans sued the state and Governor Romer (who, ironically, opposed the amendment) under the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause, saying that Amendment 2 infringes upon the homosexual's 'fundamental right to participate in the democratic process.' Romer v. Evans has had amicus curiae or 'friend of the court' briefs filed for both sides--briefs that have pitted state against state and church against church. Colorado officials are quick to say that their state is not acting out of hate, but merely deciding in a democratic fashion whether homosexuals need to be singled out for protection against discrimination. The Colorado Supreme Court, however, struck down the amendment, saying:[Amendment 2] bars gay men, lesbians and bisexuals from having an effective voice in governmental affairs, insofar as those persons deem it beneficial to seek legislation that would protect them from discrimination based on their sexual orientation. The United States Supreme Court must now determine whether or not to uphold the Colorado Supreme Court's decision, despite the results of the referendum that was basically...

Find Another Essay On Homosexuals, A Suspect Class?

Russia and the underlying causes of homophobia

662 words - 3 pages homosexuality. Under the Tsars, homosexuality was a crime punishable by imprisonment or death, after Lenin came to power after the October Revolution, homosexuality was decriminalized and homosexuals were allowed to hold office in the newly formed Soviet Union. However, as anti-gay laws were enacted by Stalin, homosexuals were seen as a “danger to the state” and sent to prisons and forgot about. After the glasnost, Yeltsin under pressure from the Council

Homosexuality Essay

1335 words - 6 pages , people look down upon them and class them as unnatural and not quite the same. This therefore leads them into becoming alarmed and fearful of revealing their true identities and resort to covering in order to prevent further degradation. Homosexuals consequently find it necessary to down play their outsider identities in order to blend. This then leads to a wide range of effects on both the individual covering and to the society the person is

Gays in the Military a matter of national insecurity

2021 words - 8 pages has developed into a case of whether our country should discriminate against a group merely because of involuntary sexual orientation. Two persistent principles are evident within this topic: that homosexuals are ever present throughout all branches of the military and a persistent hostility against this group is in American society and the military. In order to effectively examine this topic the following concepts will be discussed: an analysis of

Gays in the Military

1998 words - 8 pages has developed into a case of whether our country should discriminate against a group merely because of involuntary sexual orientation. Two persistent principles are evident within this topic: homosexuals are ever present throughout all branches of the military and a persistent hostility against this group is in American society and the military. In order to effectively examine this topic the following concepts will be discussed: an analysis of the

Construction of difference within the homosexual population

1156 words - 5 pages assumptions on why a subordinate group exists. History has shown the progression of other subordinate groups such as African-American's and women. Hopefully in the future homosexuals will erase the stigma that has been attached to them for years.BibliographyBerggren, Niclas Dr. "Is Social Constructionism an Appealing Construction?" http://hem.passagen.se/nicb/construct.htmKlages, Mary Dr. "Queer Theory" http://www.colorado.edu/English/ENGL2012Klages/queertheory.htmlOre, Tracy, 2003. The Construction of Difference and Inequality: Race, Class, Gender, and Sexuality.

Does homosexuality harm the institution of marriage?

1046 words - 5 pages married. It denigrates and distinguish against religious beliefs that marriage is between on man and one woman before God. God is good enough reason. Gay are imposing their beliefs on others. They are not a suspect class and have not been marginalized, so they do not deserve special treatment under law. The fact that they have enough money to influence legislation and affect court decisions to promote and impose their beliefs on others proves that

Rights toward Equality: Fair for Homosexuals or Not?

1894 words - 8 pages regards to where it is at this moment in America. “The lesbian, gay man, or transgendered person will be considered deviant and will be subject to social, economic, and political discrimination” (Eskridge 2411). The motive regarding why this is is attributable to homosexuals being reflected as a minority, where Eskridge on page 2411, states “In 2000, the norm will be white, middle-class, male and heterosexual”. Why numerous individuals

Homosexuality and the Prevention of Homophobia

2273 words - 10 pages Homophobia in schools has taken on a different shade in recent years. There is evident bullying of homosexuals in the school system; however, there is also a lack of acknowledgement of the triumphs within the homosexual population, failing to accurately portray historical events. Thus, a lack of appropriate care in schools creates an unnecessary stigma around homosexuality that perpetuates homosexual members of society failing to amount to

Homosexuality and Human Rights

1430 words - 6 pages want, but also any other rights that they are entitled to. In 2004, the US general accounting office found that exactly 1, 138 federal benefits are granted to married couples including filing joint tax returns and inheriting each other’s Social Security and pension benefits when one spouse dies (Kafka 25). These rights are crucial when it comes to an emergency. However, as a result of being only partners, not spouses, homosexuals never have the

Comparison of The Crucible And Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell

1503 words - 6 pages ]. Homosexuals are comparative to women in that they disrupt their manly image and order of society. Pre-DADT, everything was blamed on them, from ship explosions to natural disasters [Frank 31] thereby adding to the belief that gay men were hindrances to the military and inferior beings. Similarly, in Salem, the people first being accused of witchcraft were lower class, unchristian-like women such as Tituba, the slave, and Goody Osbourn, a midwife

Acceptance of Homosexuality

1269 words - 5 pages Childhood Remafedi, French, Story, Resnick, and Blum (1998) conducted a study that consisted of 29 white, middle class gay men. They found that 31% became aware of their attractions to males around age 6. The mean age of first awareness was 11 years old. Another study showed that homosexuals go through four stages; sensitization, identity confusion, identity assumption, and commitment (Beaty, 1999). The stage in this study that affects middle

Similar Essays

Homosexuals: A Suspect Class? Essay

2616 words - 10 pages ' throughout the nation. This paper will trace the elements behind that case, and attempt to focus on the steps the Supreme Court will follow to determine whether homosexuality must be legally considered a 'suspect class' for the purposes of 'quota preferences, protected status or claim of discrimination' as outlined by Colorado's now-famous Amendment 2.Amendment 2 does away with any attempt to protect homosexuals as a group that needs special

Romer V. Evans Essay

1701 words - 7 pages unconstitutional on the basis that it violates the equal protection clause because it denies homosexuals special rights that any other minority has access to, and it singles out one class that it affects instead of creating a general law that affects everyone. Thus, Kennedy’s argument should prevail because it relies on the constitution as its main evidence to show that the amendment is invalid and should not be permitted, and Kennedy believes that the amendment violates the rights of homosexuals, which is clearly does by singling them out as a specific class.

Interviewing A Homosexual Essay

3443 words - 14 pages really define them as homosexual or heterosexual. We shouldn't judge a person on their appearance because in the end it's what they have inside that matter. This assignment has reinforced what I had already learned in this class; that every individual, no matter their race, culture or sexuality should be treated equally. The fact that homosexuals are attracted to individuals of the same sex doesn't take their rights away. Homosexuals are individuals

Don't Ask Don't Tell Essay

2372 words - 9 pages Justin Cook is a student at Stanton College Preparatory who is currently in the eleventh grade. Cook is enrolled in an AP Psychology and takes a great interest in connecting the work he does in the class to the work in his other current classes. In this essay, Cook presents his argument on why homosexuals should be permitted to serve in the American Armed Forces primarily from a psychological standpoint. Cook is an active advocate for human