Honor Versus Friendship In Becket Essay

906 words - 4 pages

Honor versus Friendship in Becket

 
   Anouilh's Becket offers the story of the relationship between Thomas Becket and Henry II, King of England.  The relationship begins with the two being fun-loving and teasing friends, develops into a rough-and-tumble relationship, and then ends in cold hatred.  Because he will not give in to his demands Henry has Becket executed in Canterbury Cathedral.  Becket had been Henry's friend and loyal supporter until he became Archbishop of Canterbury.  At that point, he was determined his first loyalty was due God and not Henry even though he had supported Henry against the church previously.  Becket fled to France in exile before returning to Canterbury where Henry had four barons murder him.  It was a decision which Henry would regret and pay penance for the rest of his life.  As Anouilh (8) notes in his introduction, this drama remains above all a tale of two friends "...for this drama of friendship between two men, between king and his friend, his companion in pleasure and work (and this is what had gripped me about the story), this friend whom he could not cease to love though he became his worst enemy the night he was named archbishop...."

 

The play is tragic in the sense that the inability of Becket to serve both God and King equally results in his murder at the hand of his friend.  Becket is well aware that he cannot be loyal to both Henry and God on the same level, and if there comes to be an issue where the choice must be made he will choose God.  This is why he literally begs Henry not to make him Archbishop, but Henry's purposes, he thinks, will be best served by such a move and he does so anyway:

 

King:  Becket, this is an order!

Becket:  If I become Archbishop, I can no longer be your friend.

Officer:  The church is now empty, my Lord.  The Bishop and his clergy await your Highness' good pleasure.

King:  Did you hear that, Becket?  Pull yourself together.  You have an odd way of taking good news.  Wake up!  They say we can go in now.

Becket:  This is madness, my Lord.  Don't do it.  I could not serve both God and you.

(Anouilh  71)

 

 

The problem with remaining friends once Becket is made Archbishop is that he takes his job too seriously.  He knows that politics and the church are corrupt, and he even admits that he used to laugh at the foibles of both.  However, once he becomes Archbishop he intends to pay homage to a higher force than either the earthly king or the earthly church.  While...

Find Another Essay On Honor versus Friendship in Becket

An analysis of two themes found the film "Becket," and how those themes can be relevant today. Done as a contemporary to Murder in the Cathedrial and Canterbury Tales

852 words - 3 pages There are a number of themes that can be extracted from the play based film, "Becket." They range everywhere from loyalty, honor, and friendship to politics and religious views of the time and concepts of secular and spiritual seperations. Many of these concepts presented in the film hold much contemporary relavance.What seems to be the most prevalent theme in "Becket" is honor. When looking into the film, we aremade to ask the question "what is

"So Similar, Yet so Different" - An essay on the relationship between THOMAS BECKET and KING HENRY II

1083 words - 4 pages and domestics of Thomas, [and] banished them..."(Walsh 433). It was only because of their past friendship that they were resolved again in July 1170, and they did not talk about their problems with each other. Becket was then allowed to return to England as archbishop. Yet things soon grew complicated again when Becket excommunicated the priests who had sided with the king in the acrimonious clerks issue. This was the final straw for King Henry

Compare And Contrast Thomas Be

1956 words - 8 pages church has the right to try its, and holds God’s will above the king’s. Murder in the Cathedral begins with Becket, the current Archbishop of Canterbury, returning to England. Becket has been hiding from King Henry II since his dispute with Henry caused his fleeing from England seven years ago. Becket is pressured to make a fate-determining decision. After contemplating several tempters’ propositions, Becket realizes

During the middle ages, there was a struggle for power between the church and the state. I backed this up with the tale of Thomas Becket and Henry II

2274 words - 9 pages Kenny NamThomas Becket vs Henry IIThe High Middle Ages was a time of power struggles between the Church and the State. Increases in royal power and expeditions like the Crusades symbolized the teeter-totter of the balance of power between the two foundations, and a prime example of the fight for power is the conflict of Henry II, King of England, and Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury.Henry II gained his throne thanks to the efforts of his

Ghostly Residents: The Tower of London

1380 words - 6 pages 1592, the queen discovered that he had secret marriage to Elizabeth Throckmorton. Elizabeth was a maid of honor of Queen Elizabeth. The discovery then threw “Elizabeth into a jealous rage” that caused the couple to be imprisoned in the Tower (BBC). Elizabeth's successor, “James I of England and VI of Scotland, disliked Raleigh”(BBC). In 1603 James I accused Walter Raleigh of “plotting against the king and [was] sentenced to death”(BBC). Walter

Analysis of Murder in the Cathedral

2056 words - 8 pages deliberation Becket faces in Part I about his upcoming inevitable martyrdom. The Catholic Church commissioned Eliot in 1935 to write a play for Kent’s annual Canterbury festival. Without many restrictions on his writing, he decided to honor the most famous Canterbury saint, Thomas Becket. It would be directed and produced by E. Martin Browne, who directed Eliot’s last play, The Rock (1934). It debuted in the Chapter House of the Canterbury Cathedral

The Value of Honor

722 words - 3 pages there is for any other elected official in the United States.       The honor that develops over time in a friendship is one that should never be toyed around with. A good example of this would be two friends losing their friendship because of a woman. A friend is someone that you can trust, someone who’s word means something, and a friend is someone that you should not have to question about anything when it comes to their actions. If you

Reading in New Contexts

1522 words - 6 pages have happened to Aggy if she had delivered her speech directly to the master” (Scott 525). Her trust in Mary’s friendship and sympathy allowed her to say something in confidence and had no possibility of leaking to the master. This hidden transcript between Aggy and Mary is apart from the public transcript between her and her master. In Honor and Shame, she describes the reaction of Kamla, and the reaction of herself, when Kamla states

Aristotle's Perspective of Friendship in Homer's Iliad

2551 words - 10 pages them. In trying to preserve his own honor, Achilleus behaves most ignobly. It seems that this is a case where true friendship obliges Patroklos to aid Achilleus, not by supporting his misguided deeds, but by actively exhorting him to return to the battle where he is most needed, and thereby do justice to his countrymen. Recalling the basis of true friendship, the mutual appreciation of the intrinsic good in each other, it would also seem

Honor in No One Writes to the Colonel and Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Garcia-Marquez

1674 words - 7 pages Doctor in the town claims that "[Xius] [dies] because [of a] broken heart"(211) In these novellas the author shows that pursuing honor can cause a wide range of issues including the loss of friendship and connection to another. The pursuit of honor can put people into a state of paralysis or give them liveliness and vigor to their life. Putting them into a state of paralysis refers to a person living a slow dull life with out happiness and

On Aristotle's Notion of Friendship

1605 words - 6 pages , there exists little to no friendship among their perversions, being tyranny, oligarchy, and democracy (mob rule). This is on account that there is no mutual exchange of honor or respect between the ruler(s) and those which they govern. Friendship can exist to an extent within a democracy, but it is primarily an issue of concord. Of justice, there is a common ground with respect to friendship as it implies a 'shared' notion; in this case, being of

Similar Essays

Becket Essay

1163 words - 5 pages should be honor in me there is only a void." He knows that he is only human, but tries to do the best he can. He takes his duties very seriously, especially when he is make Chancellor of England by Henry. Becket takes his moral obligations seriously and refuses to give in to Henry's whims to change things to suit himself. Becket could not find anything that was fulfilling to him in life, even in women. His lady friend loved him very much, but

"Becket" By Jean Anouilth Essay

761 words - 3 pages no longer be your friend", meaning that, in the choice between the position of Chancellor and the Archbishopric, the choice he chose was the honorable one--that of the archbishop.Yet, even later in the play there came a time when Becket had to choose between his relationship with his friend, The King, and his relationship with God. But Becket's honor is again challenged as to which one is right: his long friendship with The King or his true

Thomas A. Becket/ King Henry Ii

295 words - 2 pages needed it. Henry was a typical King who spent his money and just had fun. Becket was seeing the way of the church and felt he was doing what was right in god's eyes. Henry's allegiance was to the state. These changes forced the two apart from friendship, and later Henry's men killed becket. Becket and Henry were great friends even when they first met. They shared many common perspectives and had a great friendship. But as time passed they both began to see their differences. These differences began to separate them, and turned out to a hurtful ending for both.

"Dying For A Cause" In Becket

884 words - 4 pages responsibility of the honor of God to explore the major theme in the play, "Dying for a Cause."At the beginning of the play, Thomas Becket serves King Henry II as "the office of Chancellor of England, keeper of the Triple Lion Seal" (Anouilh 7). He shows reverence to his king by continuing to stay loyal and respectful to the king. Becket becomes the king's friend: "And Becket was my friend, red-blooded, generous and full of strength!" He enjoys the