How Capote's "In Cold Blood" And Lewis's "Main Street" Discredit The Typical Western Stereotype

1950 words - 8 pages

In much of literature the Midwest is portrayed as an abode to a wholesome family life, where young girls bake apple pies with their neighbors and married couples live in quaint happiness for the rest of their lives. In reality, as with all stereotypes, that is just a view of the surface, where underneath it all we find the darkest and most rebellious lifestyle. Truman Capote's narrative In Cold Blood and Sinclair Lewis' novel Main Street both give their own distinct interpretations of the people and lifestyle of the Midwest. Main Street portrays the drastic change that a sophisticated city girl, Carol, experiences when moving into Gopher Prairie with her husband, Will Kennicott, shortly after getting married. Lewis uses Will Kennicott's role in Main Street to act as the embodiment of Midwestern society and allow the reader to view the flaws that Lewis believes many of these characters have in contrast to Carol's personality. Capote's "In Cold Blood" displays midwestern life in a darker story, using the crime and trial of Perry Smith and Richard Hickock as a backdrop. Unlike Lewis who provides commentary of his views of the Midwest, Capote simply gives the details of the crime and trial as well as the reaction in Holcomb and leaves interpretation up to the reader. Perry Smith in particular is an interesting character to analyze because in contrast to Will Kennicott, he is not viewed as a moral person in his environment, but yet his character just as effectively demonstrates the thoughts of those in the Midwest. Both Main Street and In Cold Blood might have the same setting, but the tales are very different and delivered in distinct styles, each giving a different analysis of the Midwest.The greatest theme from both Capote and Lewis in their works is the Midwest's reaction to change, where in both novels many opportunities are unwelcome and dismissed because it causes a disturbance to their natural order of life. Most of Main Street focuses on the resistance of change in Gopher Prairie, especially by Will Kennicott. Kennicott, unlike his wife, is not very enthusiastic when Carol attempts to devise a plan to rennovate their town, Gopher Prarie, into a more sophisticated neighborhood. Kennicott is complacent with his home, whereas Carol is bored by its simplicity and tries to incorporate a more modern feel to the town. "And she saw that Gopher Prarie was merely an enlargement of all the hamlets which they had been passing. Only to the eyes of Kennicott was it exceptional." (Pg 32) Kennicott feels that his town is the most important one around, where change is unnecessary and overzealous, and this characteristic is emphasized when we are first introduced to Kennicott. In his first conversation with Carol he states his pride and loyalty to his hometown, showing her various snapshots of the town while giving descriptions. This pride is also seen the other residents of Gopher Prairie, especially when they constantly boast about their town legend Percy...

Find Another Essay On How Capote's "In Cold Blood" and Lewis's "Main Street" discredit the typical western stereotype

Vengeance in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

2063 words - 8 pages In this day and age the term “murder” is coined as a word used in everyday language, albeit fifty years ago in the [rural] heartland of America, that word evoked emotion out of the entire town’s population. Prior to writing In Cold Blood, Truman Capote had written several pieces that lead him to writing a piece of literature that would infuse fiction and nonfiction, thus In Cold Blood was created, albeit after six years of research (“Truman” 84

Truman Capote's In Cold Blood: Comparison of Book and Movie

623 words - 2 pages      "In Cold Blood" is a tragic story of two men, Eugene Hickock and Perry Edward, who murder an entire family in search of money and then find themselves running from the law. While writing the book, Truman Capote used only facts to create a novel out of an actual event. He had thousands of notes on the subject, but his problem was making his book read like a novel. He accomplished this by adding dialogue and describing characters

A Chilling Perspective in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

1259 words - 5 pages ). Truman Capote is definitely convinced that these two men were products of the anger, rage, and isolation they felt from a very early age. This was one of the main contributors to their low emphasis on human life, including their own, and therefore what enabled them to take the lives of four innocent people. Capote's emphasis on the lives of the criminals and how their lives related to their actions is what makes the novel, "In Cold Blood" disturbing to the reader. Works Cited: Capote, Truman. In Cold Blood. New York: Random House, 1965.  

Mental Illness in Truman Capote's novel "In Cold Blood"

676 words - 3 pages Madness, madness, madness. It is but a word, yet those who possess it are capable of doing the most amazing or terrible of things. According to the Merriam-Webster's online dictionary, madness is defined as “a state of severe mental illness.” Perry Edward Smith is the best individual that depicts this characteristic. Throughout Truman Capote's novel “In Cold Blood” the main character, Perry Smith, as Dr. Jones says “... shows definite signs of

Use of Characterization in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

971 words - 4 pages In Cold Blood:  Effective Use of Characterization    Capote's extensive characterization is a key element of In Cold Blood. The characters can be divided into three groups: the Clutter family, the two murderers, and the characters who were emotionally attached to the murder. Each killer's psyche is researched by Capote, and each is individualized by his specific psyche. Capote goes to great lengths to show that the

Narrative Style of Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

673 words - 3 pages In Cold Blood - Narrative Style Capote's structure in In Cold Blood is a subject that deserves discussion. The book is told from two alternating perspectives, that of the Clutter family who are the victims, and that of the two murderers, Dick Hickock and Perry Smith. The different perspectives allow the reader to relive both sides of the story; Capote presents them without bias. Capote masterfully utilizes the third person omniscient point

Mix of Journalism and Fiction in Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

790 words - 3 pages John Hollowell's, critical analysis of Truman Capote's novel In Cold Blood focuses on the way Capote used journalism and fiction to try and create a new form of writing (82-84). First, Capote involves his reader. "This immediacy, this spellbinding 'you-are-there' effect, comes less from the sensational facts (which are underplayed) than from the 'fictive' techniques Capote employs" (Hollowell 82). Capote takes historical facts and brings in

Truman Capote's In Cold Blood: Novel vs Movie

1710 words - 7 pages today’s lawyers a great reason for appeal or new trial. By not reading the book you miss a lot of these details. As the movie unfolds you feel how useless and stupid these murders are. This is a true, also in the book, while reading In Cold Blood the details of the murder are so gruesome and with no reasoning it makes it hard to read, or watch. While Dr. Jones testified about his study of Perry Smith, he was not allowed to speak of his personal

Truman Capote's Questionable Murder Involvement and His Novel, In Cold Blood

1007 words - 4 pages debate. Some peoples' imagination escaped into believing that Capote fell in love with Perry Smith and became devasted after his execution because of the possibility that Perry Smith could've been the lost love of Truman Capote's life. There's a possibility that maybe Truman Capote's obsession for Perry Smith is what affected him or created this life changing experience. What created more tension is that is how he put a maxium set of details

Title: Truman Capote and In Cold Blood: Pioneer or Playing Writer? This essay details the literary style of Truman Capote's "non-fiction novel" and it's effects on and from society

2243 words - 9 pages complete honesty in his writing of the book difficult to believe. Other discrepancies have been found in Capote's adaptation. To what extent is Capote allowed these discrepancies, and still call the book nonfiction?The modern day readers of Truman Capote's In Cold Blood are often too quick to accept his word as the truth. While most of the story was truthfully documented, there are crucial points tries to prove in his novel, to make the reader feel a

Ethics of Punishment Essay on Truman Capote's "In Cold Blood". This essay states what punishment Dick and Perry should get. It includes the counter arguement and specific detail in the book

1484 words - 6 pages Not in Cold BloodIn the book, "In Cold Blood", by Truman Capote, Dick Hickock and Perry Smith commit a heinous crime by slaughtering the Clutter family. Should Dick and Perry die for their crimes by receiving the death penalty? Throughout the book there is clear evidence that supports both sides. Would this case adhere to the M'Naghten rule or were both defendants aware of what crime they were committing? After close analysis of both defendants

Similar Essays

Truman Capote's In Cold Blood Essay

2078 words - 8 pages In Cold Blood is a novel written by Truman Capote in 1966. In Cold Blood is a true account of a multiple murder case that took place in Kansas in the 1950's. The book outlines a brutal murder case, but it shows the story from many perspectives, not just that of the law. Capote introduces you to the Clutter family, a well known, very hard working and loyal family to the community. The town of Holcomb is a small farming town. There is not much

Truman Capote's In Cold Blood Essay

1331 words - 5 pages recording everyday details throughout the characters life; all of which Capote’s In Cold Blood does flawlessly. In the first chapter of, In Cold Blood, is bluntly titled “The Last to See Them Alive”, in this Capote uses detailed descriptions of Holcomb, the sleepy town where a majority of the novel’s action occurs; every sentence reads as if the reader is standing in the middle of Kansas prairie: “The land is flat, and the views are awesomely

Truman Capote's In Cold Blood Essay

2055 words - 9 pages Literature attempts to shape or reflect society, and oftentimes literature reveals truths and provides insight into the condition of that society. The American Dream is a dominant theme in American literature, and in Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood, the idealistic dream is critically evaluated. In this paper, I will explain the context of the work, and then I will compare and contrast Dick any Perry (the murderers) with the Clutter family (the

Truman Capote's In Cold Blood Essay

590 words - 2 pages In Cold Blood is a true account of a multiple murder case that took place in Holcomb, Kansas in 1959, written by Truman Capote. Capote’s attention to detail causes the reader to gain an extreme interest in the Clutter family even though they were an ordinary family. The suspense that is a result of minimal facts and descriptive settings was an elaborate stylistic technique that gave effective results throughout the book. His ability to make this