This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Do The Sources You Studied Help To Create A Better Understand Of Women In Industry In The Two World Wars

1779 words - 8 pages

Wasim Aamir Noordin
Candidate number: 3105
Question 1 (15 marks)
Select five sources. Explain how useful these sources have been in informing you in your enquiry into the involvement of women in industry in the two world wars. (15 marks.)
My first source, a quote taken from Mona Marshall, a nursemaid who had become a steelworker during the war, describes the significance of women when working in industry during the First World War. The source was created in 1986; 40 years after the Second World War which makes it particularity useful as the person being interviewed can offer a retrospective view on the war, which gives the interviewed person time to reflect, enabling them to think before they speak, rather than expressing untamed raw emotions which have not had time to ‘mature’. We can infer that Mona Marshall is pro-war as the source only selected the positives of war. Mona says that the war was the “best thing” and “the war made me stand on my own two feet”. This lessens the usefulness through limiting what can be extracted from the source as what is extracted is subjective and created for the creator’s desired purpose. What is immediately evident from this quote is the massive positive change that the war had on a woman’s life, as in giving a woman her own independent living saying that saying that the war made women “stand on (their) own two feet”. Nonetheless, the usefulness is greatly limited as the detail given is too vague, being demonstrated by the use of “steelworker” which ultimately gives no actual detail. Mona Marshall says “The war changed all that”, indicating that this war was a massive factor which resulted in her independence. This is supported by the background information recounting her entire transformation from a Nursemaid to a Steelworker. However, she says that the war made her independent, not all women automatically: “made me stand on my own two feet” displays that not all women may have benefited from the war and Mona’s ignorance and idle mind is demonstrated by her saying that she was “as green as grass”, which is a saying that relates to naivety. Therefore, this lessens the reliability of the source, which in turn lessens the usefulness of this source, in that Mona’s account of the war may lose accuracy due to her naivety, indolence and to an extent immaturity, mentally. Nonetheless, it could be argued that Mona’s view is more broadened and she has gained experience as she is expressing this statement 40 years into the future, in 1986, which relays a sense of ‘learning from mistakes’ and is made veteran-like. Source one infers the war is a positive event through the use of “best thing” by Mona Marshall. However, we are unaware who Mona is speaking to and henceforth, this person who Mona is speaking to may be selecting only the pro-war statement which lessens the usefulness of the source, limiting the source. The purpose of the source is to demonstrate that the war was beneficial for people, specifically women, as...

Find Another Essay On How do the sources you studied help to create a better understand of women in industry in the two world wars

How the Music Industry Utilized Film to Help Create the Image of Rock Star Icons

1279 words - 6 pages . (Camus; 1967) Through analysing, in a sociological context, the way the music industry utilized film to help create or reinvent star image of Rock icons The Beatles and The Rolling Stones, we can see how the signifier of the Rock Rebel has evolved with the developing Rock culture. (Dyer; 1979:1) Even before first staring in the 1964 film A Hard Day’s Night (HDN), The Beatles had already become acclaimed on a global scale and it was this initial

Women and Industry: The Role of Women During World War Two in Ontario, Canada, 1939-45

1629 words - 7 pages women they saw the war as a framework on how to make sense of all the changes that were going on around them. For women that had not entered the work force before it was a big change and it took a while to adjust to the changing going on around them. World War Two led to the large majority of women helping out and getting involved to make up from the loss of men in the workforce. Beulah Musslewhite went to work for Victory Aircraft in Malton

Compare the theme of a young person growing up in two or more literary works you have studied

795 words - 3 pages Growing up is a current issue nowadays with children and youngsters seeming to enter the adult world earlier and earlier and having to take on the responsibilities of adults. When does a child become an adult? For many the right answer is that it has nothing to do with age; it is determined by the behaviour. In this essay I will not go into the issue of when a child turns into an adult but rather think about how the issue is treated in "A

How did the texts you studied help shape your definition of change

516 words - 3 pages Change is such a simple word, yet so hard to define, because everybody sees it as something different. But one thing that is common in every definition of change is that no one can prevent it, live without it, or go a day without experiencing it. I studied two sources (a book and a movie) relating to change. The novel I chose is 'Looking for Alibrandi' by Melina Marchetta. And the movie is "Remember the Titans" starring Denzel Washington

In the texts you have studied this year have you found that criminals have received a fair punishment? Refer to at least two texts in your answer

3115 words - 12 pages has trouble recognizing her husband in him. In my opinion, Roger has no right to take revenge. He left his wife alone in a completely new country for two whole years without sending any news. His wife thought he was dead. He was an elderly scholar and she a young, beautiful woman who made it clear from the start that she didn’t love him. Roger himself remarked this on page 62: “so a learned man as you speak of should have learned this too

Describe what are the main sources of stress at work are in general? Do any of these apply to you as a student? If so, what could you do to alleviate it?

1816 words - 7 pages BH1107 731676 With reference to relevant theories, describe what the main sources of stress at work are in general? Do any of these apply to you as a student? If so, what could you do to alleviate it?Stress has become a big concern of the employers and investors as it is single largest reason of work absenteeism resulting in lose of millions of working days every year. (Money Marketing, 2004) This has resulted in loses to businesses reaching in

With reference to two volcanic events that you have studied from contrasting areas of the world, compare the nature of the volcanic hazard and its

859 words - 4 pages andesitic lava which has high silica content and an acidic chemical composition; gases do not escape easily – thus it is viscous – so they build up to produce explosive eruptions with lower temperatures (max. 1000 degrees Celsius). Rhyolitic lava is similar, although it has lower temperatures at around 750 degrees. An example of an andesitic lava eruption is Soufriere Hills in Montserrat which has been actively erupting since 1997. The eruption

What do you find confronting in the poetry studied this year?

879 words - 4 pages , Pieta and November. The cycle of life is shown through Pietà and November in two different ways. The child’s life is unfortunately cut short as it, ‘only [lives] one day.’ Whilst in November, the subject of the poem is about a Grandmother who is at the end of the cycle of life. This is unlike the baby in Pietà who is not able to live, or have a chance of living a long life. This may cause the audience to ponder about the purpose of life. Armitage

Compare and contrast the role that women played in both world war one and world war two. To what extent did women expand their role in society between the wars?

1299 words - 5 pages events" of World War I, British society "sought above all to reestablish a sense of peace and security" and this precluded the egalitarian feminism of the prewar years, mandating instead a feminism of separate spheres to avoid "provoking the men to anger."Several major differences distinguish the two World Wars' effects on women. The first war had more concentrated action, on the Western front and in static trench warfare, leaving civilians

Texts across time have portrayed women in terms of a dichotomy between "good" and "bad", but to what extent are the composers of the texts you have studied ambivalent towards their female characters?

2007 words - 8 pages the way in which Armande behaves makes us doubt the charge of murder, saying, "you need to know where to stop", and using a metaphor - "my last course" - planning her birthday to be the last day of her life. Readers are called to debate the rightness of euthanasia, and to cast doubt on the label of "weed" and "parasite" placed upon Vianne.The "goodness" of virtuous women in the books is also called into question by composers, and whether it truly

How does the writer show one or two characters making difficult decisions or choices in the text(s) you have studied?

847 words - 3 pages GCSE English Sophie Simpson 880498How does the writer show one or two characters making difficult decisions or choices in the text(s) you have studied?Of Mice and Men by John SteinbeckThe novel 'Of Mice and Men' is written by John Steinbeck and tells the story of two displaced migrant ranch workers, who move from place to place in search of new job opportunities during the Great Depression in California. Throughout the story we are introduced to

Similar Essays

How Do The Sources You Studied Help To Create A Better Understand Of Women In Industry In The Two World Wars

1831 words - 8 pages are unable to see how the women dealt with their work, accurately, like source 5 which is too propaganda. This is not as useful as source 2, which gives the view of a woman who had worked in a factory as a munitions worker. Source 2 is more valuable to us as it provides a view of factories which actually comes from a woman and not from a cartoonist or an official war artist, like sources 5 and 6 do. Source 6 is limited as it only gives a depiction

How Do You Understand Sun Tzu's Concept Of "Know The Enemy And Know Yourself" And What Is The Significance Of This Concept In Modern Wars?

1110 words - 4 pages ? What are his strengths and weaknesses? Can he be exploited? The commander must understand what the enemy plans to do in order to evaluate friendly courses of action. In Sun Tzu's words, "Determine the enemy's plans and you will know which strategy will be successful and which will not." War can not be conducted successfully in a vacuum by only one side - so you must know the enemy.Third, what is the battle space? Sun Tzu's first two admonitions

How Far Do You Think Observing A Visible Religious Activity, Such As A Festival, Can Help You Understand The Part A Religion Plays In The Life Of An Individual Or A Community?

1282 words - 6 pages To fully understand the part a religion plays in the life of an individual or a community, I would suggest that we need to examine it from several different points of view, only some of which can be addressed by observing a visible religious activity.Using Ninian Smart's 'dimensional model' as a starting point, we can examine the different dimensions of a religion and discover how much insight into each of them the observation of a visible

Many Poems Explore The Idea Of Hopelessness. To What Extent Do The Poems You Have Studied Create A Sense Of Hopelessness?

1618 words - 6 pages Justin Cheng 11G1 Section 2Many poems explore the idea of hopelessness. To what extent do the poems you have studied create a sense of hopelessness?The poem 'Once Upon a Time' can be read with a range of meanings very similar to 'Prayer before Birth'. The meanings of this poem also further emphasize the idea of hopelessness the present is however in contrast the past. One way to interpret the meaning of this poem: it is about the artificiality