How Effective Is The Westminster Parliament In Holding The Executive To Account?

1081 words - 5 pages

The effectiveness of Westminster Parliament in holding the executive to account relies on a number of variables, arguably, the most important being the degree of the government’s majority. Other variables include the unity of the party, the presence of a foreign war or the presence of a hostile media. This being said, there are also a number of mechanisms by which Parliament is able to hold the executive accountable.

Westminster Parliament has the ability to hold the executive to account through a variety of methods, such as through the House of Lords. Though it is unelected, the Lords fulfill a fundamental democratic requirement; as the upper chamber within a bicameral legislature, it acts as a constitutional check and balance on executive power. This being said, Tony Blair forced the Hunting Bill of 2004 through the Lords as a Parliament Act; the very rarely used route by which Bills can become law without the assent of the House of Lords. In this way Westminster Parliament failed to ensure executive accountability.

In terms of scrutinizing the executive and actions of government, the House of Commons has a number of opportunities at its disposal, mainly in the form of debates and questions. The Commons is notorious for its constant debate; the Commons can express its views on foreign policy and international crisis, for example the 1956 debates of the Suez crisis and the emergency debate on the Falklands following the Argentinean invasion in 1982. Question time is also a very important example of an opportunity for the executive’s actions and plans to be publicly questioned as the meeting is now frequently featured on TV news and politics analysis programmes. This allows Her Majesty’s Royal Opposition to challenge the executive on a number of issues; a very important democratic feature of holding the executive to account. The prime minister may be directly asked difficult and searching questions to which he/she must answer, though it must be said that many of the Prime Minister’s answers will have been carefully constructed not by the PM but by the Civil Service. However, debates and questions must always be answered and if a reasonable and justified response is not available then the public may a) lose faith in the current executive and b) question whether the PM is suitable for a position of such authority. The PM relies on the votes of the people and must aim to retain this popularity or else their party may turn against them for a more agreeable and popular representative i.e a vote of no confidence e.g Callaghan in 1979 voted out by the House of Commons.

Tony Blair is an example of a prime minister who Westminster Parliament hugely struggled to hold to account, another example being Margaret Thatcher. Both prime ministers had huge majorities; Blair +179 in 1997 and 167 in 2001 whilst Thatcher had majorities of 100+ in both general elections of 1983 and 1987 the largest being +144. It is evident from these numbers that Blair and...

Find Another Essay On How effective is the Westminster Parliament in holding the executive to account?

How effective is the portrayal of the independent self in "Citizen Kane"

990 words - 4 pages surrounded by darkness. These are fitting as depth and darkness embody Kane's life, a life of no light but all darkness.The symbolism contained within many scenes is also highly effective. The scene in Xanadu for example, where Kane, lonely and desolate, walks in front of a series of mirrors, presents us with a seemingly endless vision of the emptiness of his life and the independence which he has indeed achieved - his solitude seeming to stretch to

Discuss Shakespeare's presentation of the witches in Macbeth. How dramatically effective is the presentation?

1173 words - 5 pages the first place? Is it the witches for invigorating him to open himself up and let evil surround and take control of him? Some other characters feel the witches are too mystical and are afraid to listen to them, yet they end up being under the witch's control. This is how the witches influence the reaction of the other characters in 'Macbeth'. Not only do the witches bring out the worst in people, make them think they are indestructible and make

How effective is Edurant in improving the quality of life in patients with HIV-1 infection?

2545 words - 11 pages answers the question “How effective is Rilpivirine in improving the quality of life in patients with HIV-1 infection?” – the answer is it is very effective. The results were reliable as they were objective – The level of HIV-RNA in the blood was tested for. From the results table (figure: 7&8) it can be established that HIV RNA levels decreased to less than 50 copies in 76% of the patients. Also the mean CD4+ count raised by an average of 228

Is the reader expected to view the signalman's account of events as reliable in Charles Dickens' story "The Signalman"?

762 words - 3 pages is intimidated by the signalman's appearance and doubts his sanity. Later on he learns of the signalman's background and starts to believe him. Towards the end of the tale he again doubts of the signalman's sanity as he suspect that the signalman is subject to paranoia, and he tries to find logical explanations.The audience's perception of the story depends on how the signalman's account is read. The genre of the story also depends on your

The Scottish Parliament

3843 words - 15 pages Scottish public for the Parliament, and that there is consensus that the devolved issues are the ones that appear to matter most to the majority of the general public, this does not account for the low turnout on election day. While the 59% was higher than that of the local and European elections, it was significantly lower than the turnout that Westminster elections have previously upheld (see Figure 3).TURNOUT IN PREVIOUS ELECTIONS85 7170 58.5

Holding Onto The Past

1133 words - 5 pages Holding onto the Past The novel The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger shows how people try and look into the past to move forward. They look into past happy memories for comfort and relief in order to feel better. This however makes it harder to accept the changes in life. If your mind is in the past your reality is in the past while your physical self is in the present, which prevents you from accepting changes around you in the present. J.D

How Effective is Trademark Law in the Context of Online Disputes?

2409 words - 10 pages described as an “international attempt to attract, for commercial gain, internet users to respondent’s website by creating a likelihood of confusion with complainant’s mark as to the source, sponsorship, affiliation, or endorsement of respondent’s website” . Cybersquatting is also deemed as evidence of registering in bad faith. Cybersquatting encompasses the passive holding of domain names with intent to prevent trademark owner usage or with

How Effective is the Opening Chapter in Charles Dickens' Great Expectations?

1536 words - 6 pages parents and siblings from their tombstones is immature. The reasons for this may be because Pip had no-one around his age to grow up with and so has been kept as a child by the over-powering presence of his sister and the playful antics of his brother-in-law. Soon sympathy for Pip develops as he seems helpless. He has gone to visit his parents, maybe in the hope to feel close to them, yet he is left alone and feels isolated. Pips isolation and

Movement Is Effective in the Classroom

965 words - 4 pages students around the room. Some students will refuse to participate in different physical activities causing frustration when trying to plan full class activities and this takes away from academic instruction. It is often that educators exclude these physical activities from the classroom due to stress that is put on the schools to perform higher academically. There are so many ways to incorporate movement into the lessons that increase the

The Scottish Parliament

1290 words - 5 pages union, the idea of Scottish independence has again come up for fierce debate. How, I ask myself, did Alex Salmond and his nationalist cronies manage to concoct such a specious solution to Scotland's problems? A question easily answered: on the basis of false, misinterpreted and corrupt data. In 2007, the SNP scraped a narrow election victory in the Scottish Parliament of 1 seat, holding 47 to Labour's 46 out of 129. This forced the SNP to

Holding Back A Child Is Not The Answer

1003 words - 5 pages Holding Back A Child Is Not The Answer How could holding back a student in a grade longer than average help them? Would not it just make them feel as if they were slower than others? Which could make them develop into something they're not.Academic Achievement of kids who are retained for advancing to the next grades poorer that, that of peers who are promoted. ( http://www.greatschools.org/special-education/health/659-repeating-a

Similar Essays

Which Legislature Has The Most Power In Holding The Executive To Account, The Uk Or The Us?

1286 words - 5 pages most power in holding the executive to account, regardless of the change in role it has undergone.With specific regard to the US legislature, its role has altered from the constitutional powers of law making, to the seemingly less powerful role of law scrutiniser. Although this may appear as if Congress has lost a significant amount of it's powers, this is not the case as Congress is still a very influential body with regard to legislation

How Effective Is The Singer Solution To World Poverty?

1197 words - 5 pages children of varying countries, but my question concerns the impoverished children of America. The poverty level in America is significantly rising as well as those of other countries. If America’s social safety net programs are barely assisting Americans, how can they allow organizations to donate money to other countries? Yes, it’s true that the foreign countries may not have availability to certain resources, but America must solidify its foundation

Compare And Contrast With Detailed Reference Used To The Language Used How Blake And Wordsworth Have Described The City In London And Westminster Bridge

733 words - 3 pages Compare and Contrast with Detailed Reference Used to the Language Used How Blake and Wordsworth have described the City in London and Westminster BridgeThe poets Blake and Wordsworth have wrote two opposing poems, which express different opinions of industrial places. I will be comparing the language and attitude expressed by both poets. Blake seems to express extreme dislike towards London, whilst Wordsworth expresses like, and peace in his

To What Extent Was The Film Elizabeth An Accurate And Faithful Account Of The Main Events Of Elizabeth's Reign? How Useful Is The Medium Of Film In Helping People To Understand Events Of The Past?

1350 words - 5 pages Northumberland, intending to oust Mary and Elizabeth for of Lady Jane Gray. The first evidence of their involvement was in a dispatch from deFeria to King Phillip dated April 1559:"During the last few days...Lord Robert has come into favour so much hedoes what he likes with his affairs. Her Majesty visits his chamber day andnight...People say [Elizabeth] is waiting for [Amy] to die so they can wed"This contradicts her self-imposed image as the 'Virgin Queen