How Does Class Influence Identity? Essay

1282 words - 5 pages

Influence of class on an individual's identity is greater than many would like to perceive. The main reason for this misconception is the fact that everyone wants to hear what they can accomplish and not what factors (i.e. socio-economic standing) stand in their way. Identity is composed of many separate factors and therefore is affected is by many factors as well. The idea of what factors affect identity has been touched upon by many writers. Three such works consist of Horatio Alger's "Ragged Dick", "The Lesson" by Toni Cade Bambara and Gregory Mantsios' "Class in America: Myths and Realities". Each of these writer's at one point or another had to make the decision of "How does class influence identity" and each of them confronted this topic in different ways.Horatio Alger's "Ragged Dick" is a book based upon the fact that success is based upon an individual's merit. Alger tackles the concept of class and its affect on one's identity very slowly. He is hesitant because it would go against the morale he is portraying. This rags to riches story is too naive, it only depicts the fact that the main character (Richard Dick) moves up in life due to his actions and nothing more.Dick's boss in the story, Mr. Rockwell offers dick the job based solely on merit and does not look at Dick's socioeconomic standing. Dick is the one in the story who makes the slightest change on identity based upon his new position. When Mr. Rockwell asked, "How would you like to enter my counting-room as clerk, Richard?" Dick was about to reply, "Bully," when he recollected himself, and responded, "Very much." This change depicts that Dick is aware that he now is in higher position and therefore his regular slang "Bully" would not be acceptable.Alger maintains that class has no major influence on society. As is seen when Dick returns the favor and hands over his old job to Johnny Nolan. This story however does not hold a strong of an argument because Alger's view of what affects identity is too narrow. It fails to mention the affect of Race, Education, Qualifications and Connections. These factors are purposely left out by Alger because they contradict his idea that merit is the underlying factor. However, in the actual these factors would be what decide class mobility. These factors most often decide if you get the position. The failure to mention these factors made this story unbelievable."The Lesson" by Toni Cade Bambara goes further than Alger. Bambara analyzes the differences in classes. It is based upon the fact that class does indeed affect an individual's identity. Bambara does this by depicting different classes and expanding on the slight differences. The story is more believable from the start by being in the first person narrative. Whereas "Ragged Dick" was fiction, "The Lesson" is from experience.This story is written through the eyes of Sylvia, a young low class girl. Sylvia and her "cousins" reside in a poor apartment complex. They are first exposed to the...

Find Another Essay On How does Class Influence Identity?

How does sociology help us to understand 'class' as an important social phenomenon?

675 words - 3 pages How does sociology help us to understand 'class' as an important social phenomenon?Sociology emerged in the nineteenth century as an attempt to understand the transition from traditional to modern society. Many argue that class is no longer important as a social phenomenon as an individual's identity are based more on status and cultural factors such as lifestyle, values, intelligence, education. Others argue that class is still a central

How Does 'The Truman Show' Demonstrate The Influence of The Media?

1755 words - 7 pages How does the Truman show demonstrate the influence of the media? There is a strong influence from the media which can and will change the way we live our lives forever. Peter Wier uses this same theory to show us how far the media will go to keep us watching. ‘The Truman Show’ was a film produced to show how this was done and to predict how the public will react and be motivated by what they see on the show. The plot shows the

How does an organisations culture develop and what can managers do to influence it?

3497 words - 14 pages now argue with this point. I have discussed how culture develops in an organisation and the different levels and types of culture that emerge. Referring back to the second part of the original question, we have seen how managers can influence and attempt to change an organisations culture and the various problems that are encountered in this process. Although there are debates as to whether an organisations culture can or cannot be changed it

Identity Fraud. What is it? How does it impact over 33 Million Victims since 1990? How does a person protect themselves from it?

2584 words - 10 pages What is Identity Fraud?In the year 2002 alone there has been a total of 161,819 reported cases of Identity Theft according to the Federal Trade Commission. According to Consumer Reports, "Identity theft [is] the fraudulent use of your name and identifying data by someone else to obtain credit, merchandise, or services". Identity Fraud does not discriminate; it affects all races, ages and classes. The actual number of Identity Theft victims

How Does Television and the Media Influence Children? The Influence of Media on Obesity Media Influences on Behavior Other Sources of Media Violence

1060 words - 4 pages How Does Television and the Media Influence Children?The Influence of Media on ObesityMedia Influences on BehaviorOther Sources of Media ViolenceMedia plays very a important role and has influence in virtually every aspect of our lives. It is considered as the best source to know about the happenings of world. Newspaper, magazine, radio, television and internet are the different types of media. It greatly affects our lives because media has the

How does life in exile influence kinship practices? Discuss with reference to at least two ethnographic case studies.

2417 words - 10 pages This essay will attempt to examine how living in exile can influence various kinship practices of different cultures and societies. Many cultures choose a life in exile due to vast economic, social or political issues in their origin country. They may be forced to leave due to their own safety or for the safety of their family. War, conflict and political turmoil is usually one of the most common reasons for groups to relocate elsewhere and

"The Truman Show": How does the film "The Truman Show" tell the audience about the influence of the media?

1628 words - 7 pages The influence that the media has on the growing race of mankind is often not acknowledged when the average person turns on their television in the evening, or reads the paper on the way to work. Not until the consequences that would occur if the media really took over someone's life, and manipulated their every action are realized. Not until The Truman Show. This film directed by Peter Weir, is a simulation of a reality show that is a live

Ben Franklin: How did the Enlightenment and Great Awakening influence him? How was Franklin exemplar of colonail life - does he fit rags to riches rule?

933 words - 4 pages proved the rule. The rule was people tended to stay within whatever class they were born into. For instance, if you were born wealthy you would probably die wealthy and if you were born a slave you would probably die a slave. Ben Franklin going from the class he was born into and becoming a wealthy prominent person in American society made him an exception that proved that wasn't how things usually went for people at this time (the rule)..During the

How does a climate change influence water resources?

3000 words - 12 pages rise by up to another 88 centimetres by 2100. In this essay I will discuss how climate change influences water resources and how the impact of climate change on hydrology can be minimised.Water is essential to human life and many of life's activities, from direct issues such as drinking water and agriculture, to other essential modern activates such as industry and power generation. Consequently, there have been a number of studies into the

How does technology influence the ways we spend leisure time?

515 words - 2 pages Name: Milana Alsabekova Grade: 8D Date: 15.04.14How does technology influence the way we spend our leisure time?As you know, 21st century is century of high-tech. Look around. This boy is sitting with computer and playing online games. That girl is standing near the window and chatting with her friends. Way of spending our leisure time changed completely almost. Interests of people change every day. Technologies develop day by day. We cannot say

How does the setting influence the devellopment of the storyline in Shakespeares 'Romeo and Juliet'?

987 words - 4 pages In Romeo and Juliet, by William Shakespeare, we see the progression of the storyline through a number of different components of the setting. The events that took place, the place the text is set and how quickly time moves contribute to a great extent to the development of the plot and inform the audience and determine the direction in which the story will be headed, the problems that may occur and the possible outcomes of these problems. Also

Similar Essays

How Does Class Influence Identity In Contemporary Society?

812 words - 3 pages belonged to and there was an inequality in the distribution of incomes. Social class can provide us with a sense of belonging; it can tell us who 'we' are and who 'they' are, and how to relate to the world around us. (Woodward,2004, p.96)It has been said by sociologists that class does not play an important role in shaping identity. Some sociologists have gone as far as to say that 'class is dead' (Pakulski and Waters, 1996) Manufacturing and

How Does Class Influence Identity In Contemporary Society?

766 words - 3 pages factors that shape our identity, as is how we spend the money we make. However there is no simple link between what we do and who we are (Opcit, p16) :The strength in which you identify yourself as a member of a social class will be shaped by your personal history, including your background, occupation and personal experiences (Opcit, p96).The emphasis in the mass media on diverse consumption-based lifestyles has reinforced awareness that

Schindler's List By Thomas Keneally: Character Identity Conflict/How Does This Book Provide Inspiration For Hope In Modern Times? (Also Recieved An A In An 11th Grade Ap Lit. And Comp. Class.)

564 words - 2 pages In the book, 'Schindler's List,' identity conflict is central to the story of the main character, Oscar Schindler.Oscar Schindler is a member of the Nazi Party, a war profiteer. At the beginning of the book, Schindler seems cool and slick; he is a womanizer, he drinks, but seems to never get drunk, and has a plethera of friends in high places.Because of the war, Schindler has moved to the city to try his hand at business once again. He decides

How Does Moniza Alvi Explore The Concept Of Identity In An Unknown Girl?

2185 words - 9 pages happiness to sadness and longing. The speaker describes how the henna “will fade in a week.” The henna continues to be symbolic of India, and the Indian cultural identity, which the speaker does not want to lose. The use of the end-stopped line accentuates her sadness that she will eventually lose this new aspect of her own identity, as when something fades, it is a sadder event than when something is gone altogether, as it lasts longer and lengthens