How Has Lord Of The Flies And Forbidden Planet Conveyed Similar Meanings Through Differing Techniques? Comment On Use Of Characters, Context And Other Relevant Ideas.

2028 words - 8 pages

Untitled

Human nature is something that has been much discussed throughout history. A testament to this is the sheer number of works that have been published regarding this very topic. However, two particular works that present fundamentally similar ideas in completely different ways are the 1954 novel The Lord of the Flies by William Golding and the 1956 film Forbidden Planet directed by Fred Wilcox. The creators of both these texts have used their ideas of context and characters to convey, in the way that they find most convincing, their views on the nature of humanity.

The context of any text is always a major tool in unlocking the composer's intent. The Lord of the Flies is no exception. William Golding uses a context in his text that had already been used by many forerunners of the `deserted island' genre for example, Daniel Defoe and RM Ballantyne. However, the unique thing about The Lord of the Flies is that is the only book of its kind to use children and show their contrast and turn into monsters. Furthermore, its post-war setting reinforced the contents of the novel and caused it to impact greatly with its target audience. Golding has set The Lord of the Flies on a deserted, lush tropical island. Initially this island is portrayed as an idyllic paradise, one which is thought to be lovely and wonderful. In the opening chapter of the novel, Golding says `It was clear to the bottom and bright with the efflorescence of tropical weed and coral'. This highlights how initially this island paradise is just that, an island paradise. However, Golding contrasts this with the end of the book when the island is in flames and `the roar of the forest rose to a thunder and a tall bush directly in his (Ralph's) path burst directly into flame.' This contrast and metamorphosis form tranquil paradise into hot, fiery hell, is symbolic of how the characters in the novel lose their innocence and transcend into savagery. Through the use of this symbolism, Golding shows that he believes human nature to be fundamentally evil and isolation and struggles for survival will bring that out of humans, much like the inherent nature of the island as a wild place with its own horrors is brought out by the end of the book. Furthermore, Golding uses children instead of adults in his novel. The reason for his use of children in his novel, is that children are young, innocent and raw, they have not had the time to build up their shroud of civility. It is because of this that their transition into murderous, mindless savages is all the more shocking. Golding has used children to show his view that human nature is fundamentally destructive and savage and this is shown to be all the more so when using children. Golding's use of context in The Lord of the Flies is a major way in which he shows his views on human nature as brutal and savage, behind the shroud of civility. However, Golding was not alone in his thoughts.

Similar ideas can be...

Find Another Essay On How has Lord of the Flies and Forbidden Planet conveyed similar meanings through differing techniques? Comment on use of characters, context and other relevant ideas.

The three best characters in lord of the flies, pride and predjudice and all quiet on the western front

773 words - 3 pages Three Favorite CharactersOver the course of this summer, I have been assigned three books to read. All Quiet on the Western Front, Lord of the Flies, and Pride and Prejudice. Of these three novels, I have chosen one of my favorite characters from each to compare to one another and to myself. The first character I have chosen is Kat from All Quiet on the Western Front. The next character was from Lord of the Flies and this characters name was

Analysis Of "Mississippi Burning" In The Context Of Setting, Events, Characters And Their Role, Techniques And The Historical Period

1443 words - 6 pages Peace Prize that year.Much progress had been made since the 1960s in regards to racism, that many people saw this movie has a way to bring about awareness. Some organisation had praised it as it gave an insight into how "blacks" were treated, but still held their heads high. People also saw the film as a way to see the true extent of what life was like for a coloured during the 1960s and to understand their pain through startling images of the

Lord of the Flies- Fruedian Psychology and the Comparison to the Characters

882 words - 4 pages Man is inherently evil. More accurately, a piece of man is inherently evil. Golding helps reinforce Freud's theories through his novel, Lord of the Flies. The boys take on sections of the unconscious mind and give the little island a larger importance. By Golding narrowing down the aspects of the mind and the world itself onto a small island with opposing personalities it allows the author to tackle very universal problems and topics. Golding

Friendship in "Lord of the Flies". It describes the characters and the friendships that evolved

683 words - 3 pages Friendship in Lord of the FliesIn the novel, Lord of the Flies, the children had many disagreements. There wereseveral arguments, and the boys even had a war against the original leader, Ralph.Seemingly, Jack and Ralph are friends in the beginning, but end up being enemies in theend. Piggy and Ralph were not friends in the beginning, but a friendship eventuallydeveloped later in the novel. Roger and Jack were also friends because they were

The Lord of the Flies: How The Conch Is Used To Highlight Ideas In the Book

1693 words - 7 pages conch is used to control those who are willing to follow the civil codes, whereas the pig head appears to be the ‘lord of the flies,’ with the flies being the boys who have been tempted by evil, because they give in to the sow’s edible flesh. By portraying this contrast, Golding implies that there are two forces at work on the island, one is civilized and ‘good,’ while the other is ‘evil’ and destructive. Although the conch is discovered

Path To Ultimate Power: The Forbidden Route. Comparison Essay of Animal Farm ( Film) and Lord Of Flies ( Novel) and an Article

1460 words - 6 pages attain ultimate power and control over their citizens.In conclusion, in all the sources, the leaders use unethical tactics to maintain control and gain ultimate power over their citizens. William Golding's novel, The Lord of the Flies, Stephenson's film, Animal Farm, and Chogugudza's article, "Failure of Democracy in Zimbabwe, a Tragedy for SADC and Beyond", all portray the journeys of different leaders who take the similar forbidden route to

How, through dialogue and other dramatic effects, Miller has constructed a credible representation of human conflict

1506 words - 6 pages ; and because Miller manages to create a sympathy for Eddie, Catherine, B., Rudolpho and Marco, the audience is more inclined to believe their actions and their unhappiness. Miller presents the audience with a family caught in a fierce human conflict made believable by the use of sympathetic characterisation, dialogue and an intrusive chorus.Arthur Miller presents strongly moral characters that exemplify 'real decency'; and because they are decent

Disturbed Characters in Shakespeare’s ‘Macbeth’ and Golding’s ‘Lord of the Flies

1092 words - 5 pages different opinions toward the definition of disturbed and this is reflected through their characters. Atmosphere and settings are used by both Golding and Shakespeare to foreshadow future events. In the Lord of the Flies, the island stands as an allegorical object representing the general modernist view of civilisation: that the world is improving and that progress is inevitable. With its “dazzling beach” and “open sea”, the island almost creates

Lord of the Flies Brings to light Ideas about Humanity

1087 words - 4 pages Ben KairaitisSATLord of the flies practise essay-Lord of the flies is considered a classic novel because it brings to light important issues about the human condition. To what extent do you agree with this statement?William Golding's novel, Lord of the Flies is an extremely well written story that has lead to it earning the title of a classic novel. Whilst the entertaining plot and storyline are important features, it's the many ideas about

"lord of the flies" context importance on events that took place - essay

675 words - 3 pages democratic leadership yet one who is ultimately disregarded. The second world war's influence on Golding and his involvement in it is reflected through the elements of war and conflicting ideologies that are present through the novel and its characters.   Throughout the novel, Golding uses the repeating theme of power to portray an androcentric world which relates back to the context of 'Lord of the Flies'. The text shows characters, Jack and

Abuses of Power: Lord of the Flies, and I Only Came To Use the Phone

1207 words - 5 pages story “I Only Came to Use the Phone”. Displayed through characters and actions, abusive power has dominated what should be morally correct in literature. Characters have played a large role in setting the theme of abusive power; they gain power over a group of individuals and misguide them. One obvious example from Lord Of the Flies was Jack. Towards the beginning of the novel, when the “elections” for the leader of the group took place Jack

Similar Essays

Differing Views On Humans As Portrayed By William Golding In Lord Of The Flies And Jean Jacques Rousseau

716 words - 3 pages In the book “Lord of the Flies” written by William Golding, Golding has a certain type of philosophy that he applies throughout the book. The main idea of Golding’s philosophy is that people were naturally cruel and that if there were no rules people would fight, rob, and kill. A little later on there was another philosopher named Jean Jacques Rousseau. Rousseau’s philosophy opposed Golding’s philosophy by believing that humans in their normal

Comparing Ralph And Jack To Show How The Characters Change In Lord Of The Flies

978 words - 4 pages Comparing Ralph and Jack to Show How the Characters Change in Lord of the Flies Golding uses many techniques to change his characters as they progress throughout the novel. The main character Ralph is a prime example of this developing character. Both of the boys arrive on the island with a certain manner. They are sensible and being from well brought up families and homes, soon start to work together in harmony on the island. The

Critique On Society: Lord Of The Flies, And I Only Came To Use The Phone

1269 words - 5 pages on characters, they also demonstrated its faults through characters who abused their power. In Lord of the Flies, these characters would be Jack and his group. At one point, Jack’s friend Roger “ceased to work at his tooth and sat still, assimilating the possibilities of irresponsible authority” (160). The quote shows how he thinks about what he could do if he had the power, and it shows how power can easily be abused. If he had the power, Roger

Lord Of The Flies Important Characters

780 words - 3 pages In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, Jack, Piggy and Ralph play a key role in Golding's literary experiment concerning the nature of man. These three characters demonstrate Golding's theme that a structured society is needed to sustain order and prevent chaos.Jack's role in the novel shows the extreme extent of the theme and how a society will not work without rules. As Jack continues to slowly take control, Golding uses pathetic