How Has The Human Rights Act Affected Parliamentary Supremacy?

1548 words - 6 pages

Parliamentary supremacy has changed over vast number of years, especially since the Human Rights Act 1998 was introduced. The role of the courts has also changed as they have been given more responsibility since the introduction of the act. This had meant the role of the courts has been heightened. The rule of law has stated that the law is supreme and that everyone is subject to it and the separation of powers makes sure that power is controlled and exercised properly. The cases representing my views will indicate that before the act was introduced, parliament had more power and were very influential. However, the cases after the act was introduced, there was an increase in the number of cases indicating the new powers of the court.The article written by Mills had proved that the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) plays an important role in making sure that the judicial process evolve as opposed to erode away. Therefore, it can be thought that the ECHR allows the courts extra power. This can be illustrated in the case of Stafford v United Kingdom (2002) ,regarding the decision made by the Home Secretary to keep murderers in prison after the Parole Board had decided they could be released. The Court of Human Rights had ruled that the Home Secretary had no power to decide whether the murderers should stay in prison. Mills had stated in his article that "the judges have denied the supremacy of Parliament in order to better achieve a particular moral objective" . This can be interpreted as the judges gaining more power so that they are able to lower the supremacy of Parliament when making decisions.The article written by Barber, had mentioned that "the exercise of this power can be shown to be effective; the judges are obeyed" showing that as the judges are given more power, they gain more respect which makes the power given to them, more valuable. Barber continues to state that "the courts and Parliament must recognise that judges have a dual authority. They have legal authority to apply, develop, and change statute within the legal sphere." This provides emphasis on judges who have been given more authority since the introduction of the Human Rights Act 1998. The article written by McAlister, states that the court s are beginning to become supreme. This is because "a form of judicial review of legislation is already expanding the constitutional work of the judiciary in our top level courts. If a statute is at odds with European Union law, the courts can point out the inconsistency and make a declaration of incompatibility. They would give their reasons and it is then for the executive and legislature to put it right if they so choose." This shows that the role of the courts is powerful in relation to the executive and the legislature.The view that parliament is supreme, can be supported by Dicey's theory that parliament has the ultimate power to make the law and it can change any law that has been enacted. Dicey also states that no person...

Find Another Essay On How has the Human Rights Act affected Parliamentary Supremacy?

The Affect Human Rights Has On History

962 words - 4 pages punishment, they all demonstrate the mistreatment of adolescents as a response to a lack of consideration to natural rights. Furthermore, another sequence of rejecting human rights is the inequality of races which conveys the misconduct of people. The issue of racism and segregation has been a constant battle throughout history that has affected the world in many negative ways. According to Eleanor Roosevelt, “Segregation goes against human rights

Describe the geological & morphological development of the Malham area. How has this affected human utilisation of this landscape over the last 10,000 years?

3888 words - 16 pages ''Describe the geological & morphological development of the Malham area. How has this affected human utilisation of this landscape over the last 10,000 years?''Malham is a small village at the southern base of the Yorkshire Dales. The area around Malhamhas many examples of limestone landforms and the cliffs of Malham are made of strong, white, carboniferous limestone (Waltham 2007).It is also shaped by glacial erosion which dates to 10,000

The Canadian Human Rights Act: Controversial or Not?

1747 words - 7 pages , as reported by the CHRC (2011), because of the threats of singling out individuals not only as targets of hate, but also as targets for terrorist acts. Having to deal with such serious risks, the body that judges the cases pertaining to the Canadian Human Rights Act, the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, has been forced to apply stringent measures in identifying potential perpetrators and convicting them accordingly. For instance, the University

Is There Such Thing as a European Human Rights Regime? How the European Convention on Human Rights has Transformed into the most Effective Human Rights Regime in the World Today

5222 words - 21 pages has been the provision of a human rights committee to examine individual petitions, even on an optional basis. As long as an institution lacks the enforcement mechanisms for supplying the optimal result of protecting human rights, it will only continue to act as a regime, more as an embryonic journey and less as an effective regime.BibliographyBeitz, Charles R. "Human Rights as a Common Concern". American Political ScienceReview. Vol.95, No.2 (June

Evaluate how well Australia has adopted its obligations under its ratifications of international human rights principles

711 words - 3 pages (1979) However, in Dietrich v the Queen 1992 the High Court accepted that there was a common law right to a fair trial, this shows how Australia has undergone legal metamorphosis overtime to conform to its international liabilities.However, it can't be denied that within this 'GOOD' ratification record, there ARE certain violations of human rights in Australia that are AS harmful in their effect and as REGRETTABLE in their occurrence as you will

Significance of Section 3 and 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998

1738 words - 7 pages incentive to act once a DOI has been issued. Section 3 Case Law In R v A, section 41 of the Youth Justice & Criminal Evidence Act 1999 was found to violate Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) because it denied the Defendant’s right to a fair trial. Section 41 prohibited cross-examination of the complainant’s sexual history with Defendant, which was an important factor in the Defendant’s case. The court decided, in

The United Nations and Human Rights: Has the United Nations failed in its determination to support and advocate for human rights?

3896 words - 16 pages I. Introduction The supporting and advocating on behalf of human rights has been one of the primary principles of the United Nations. Since its founding in 1945, the United Nations has worked to preserve the basic human rights and fundamental freedoms it believes to be deserved of by every man, woman, and child on the planet. Throughout the near seventy years of the United Nations’ existence, it has been challenged with an array of questions

The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution

3695 words - 15 pages The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution The Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA), an Act introduced to give effect to rights from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in domestic legislation. Its introduction has affected many legal areas; especially the conceptions of the rule of law and their place in the UK constitution. To understand the effect of the HRA

"The Human Rights act for ever changes the nature of British society, marking a major turning point in British Constitutional history." Discuss

2358 words - 9 pages concept of Parliamentary sovereignty, as expounded by Dicey, is that no Parliament may be bound by its predecessor or bind its successor. All Acts of Parliament therefore, must be regarded as equal and cannot be considered 'entrenched'. Potentially, any Act could be repealed at any time - leading us to conclude that the Human Rights Act 1998 'has no greater legal importance than, say, a statute to regulate the practice of dentistry.' Many other

How has globalisation affected the world economy?

2802 words - 11 pages How has globalisation affected the world economy? Discuss.Globalisation what is it? How has it affected the world's economics? How will it continue to affect the global village? Is anyone being adversely affected?Globalisation - is the movement of goods, services and money capital or investment across international boundaries and in this way becomes a predominately economic phenomenon sweeping the world. Throughout which, what were formerly

How the Mongol Empire has Affected the World

2717 words - 11 pages present or the future is also very legitimate. Some of the effects from the empire are still present and living. The Beginnings of a Great Empire Before one can see how the Mongol Empire has affected the world, an in depth look at the empires origin must be studied. The empire needed a strong leader that could guide his people into conquest and victory. This leader of the Mongol Empire was Genghis Khan. Genghis Khan did not originate as a

Similar Essays

Have The Courts Struck A Balance Between The Protection Of Individual Rights Under The Human Rights Act And Parliamentary Sovereignty?

2052 words - 8 pages incompatible statute. Even where the courts have used their power to change the meaning of a provision within an Act, or to read in words, it is debatable whether this power has been used wisely. The case of R v A indicates that a court can easily cross the line between interpretation and legislating. By exceeding their powers, the courts will undermine the concept of Parliamentary sovereignty and create an imbalance between the need to protect individual rights, and respect for Parliamentary sovereignty. Therefore, the judges can be trusted to uphold and protect human rights to quite a large degree, but not to a total degree.

How Technology Has Affected Human Relationships

784 words - 4 pages Several experts claim that technology has taken over our lives and its deteriorating human relationships. I do agree that our society has an obsession with technology, but it’s not deteriorating human relationships. The educational systems are using technology to teach classes. Online dating is the new way to meet other people; and social media is making us more aware of what is going on around the world. There are pros and cons of technology

The Human Rights Act 1998 Essay

2485 words - 10 pages The Human Rights Act 1998, under which rights are to be 'brought home' (1), incorporates the rights guaranteed by the European Convention of Human Rights 1950 into domestic law. It appears to raise issues in the UK concerning the separation of power, as it seems to provide the courts news powers that dispute Parliament sovereignty and the executive on a certain level. This essay is going to discuss the scope of the judiciary power through the

Human Rights Act 1998 Essay

816 words - 4 pages against public authorities. However, because the Act has affected the way that judges are interpreting and developing existing laws it can also affect both individuals and private organisations. Clearly though, there will be situations that will arise where the rights contained within the Act will be in conflict between individuals and authorities or organisations. For example, Article 11: Freedom of association and assembly. This Article protects