How Life Is Affected Through Disparate Impact And Treatment

1843 words - 8 pages

Disparate impact and treatment on employees and employers
The Civil Rights act of 1964 along with Title VII gives employees the option to sue business owners based on color, race, sexual orientation, and religion. This act, rules on the fact, that individuals can take action if a discrimination or harassment issues happens at the employer’s workplace. It expands Civil Rights statues to provide more protection against people who are victimized due to discrimination. It sets the guidelines for job related issues due to disparate impact or treatment issues. However, this act does not assure that everyone who faces discrimination will be employed because frankly he is a minority. If it is felt that there is a possibility of discrimination in the workplace then a lawsuit might be possible. In order for an employee to present a disparate impact case, that individual must show proof that the company has violated the rules or practices regarding a particular group of people. Then the employee or employees would proclaim that the company treated them different than the other co-workers given the same situation. Situations such as physical fitness test, weight lifting, or running might be subject to a disparate impact allegation. Other factors may include written tests, academic tests, or different types of interviews. All these types of tests are up for debate.
1989 was a year that a lawsuit was filed by the Wards Cove Packing Company vs. Atonio, 490 U.S. 642, 109 S.Ct. 2115, 104 L.Ed.2d 733 (1989). It was believed that the skilled jobs were filled by whites who had little or no experience working in a cannery. The unskilled jobs went to the non-white workers. These skilled workers were natives of Alaska (Asian decent). The court ruled in the natives favor. According to the Supreme Court (1989), “The workers appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which reversed the District Court decision, stating the workers had made a prima facie case of disparate impact” (William Rehnquist 1). The court based some of their rulings on the percentage of the number of workers in the skilled jobs and the unskilled jobs. Along with this ruling, the Supreme Court appealed this case. It was believed that the plaintiffs in the case needed more proof. The court wanted the plaintiff to show more reasoning why that individual was denied a job based on race, creed, color, or other factors. The Supreme Court also wanted the employer to show the reasoning behind the testing or the requirements of the job. As a result, the case moved closer to disparate treatment. However, in these types of emotional cases proving the case can be tedious.
According to the Legal Dictionary (2014), “The Wards Cove decision was severely criticized by Civil Rights leaders, who believed the Supreme Court had made disparate impact cases almost impossible to win” (p.1). The Civil Rights Act of 1991 was in effect. This act proposed that employees...

Find Another Essay On How life is affected through disparate impact and treatment

Disparate Impact Disparate Treatment Case study

981 words - 4 pages sales positions, preferring white salespeople to serve predominantly white customers, would be guilty of this kind of discrimination. Disparate treatment violates the plain meaning of Title VII.On the other hand, disparate impact is the discrimination caused by policies that apply to everyone and seem neutral but have the effect of disadvantaging a protected group. Such policies are illegal unless strongly job-related and indispensable to conduct of

Disparate Impact / Disparate Treatment Case Study - MGT434

1097 words - 4 pages Disparate Impact/Disparate Treatment Case StudyThe U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) enforces laws enacted to prevent job discrimination. They are also involved in oversight and policy making as it is related to job discriminations. Any individual who feels their employer has discriminated against them for any of the reasons overseen by the EEOC has the right to file a complaint.One of the largest pieces of legislation overseen

Explain How the Social and Economic Changes Affected Gaucho Life

910 words - 4 pages Explain How the Social and Economic Changes Affected Gaucho Life Due to the huge migration to Latin America, foreigners introduced the gauchos to many changes that would have a lasting effect. Two of the main changes felt by the gauchos included social and economic restructuring. One must understand that history about the gauchos can potentially be biased. This is due to the fact that only news that is interesting is reported and only bad

Edgar Allan Poe's Life and How It Affected His Writing.

922 words - 4 pages writing started after the death of a loved one, and was strongest when he was going through a hardship. So his writing was mostly dark, detective stories about unheard of crimes, poems about loosing something you loved. I think that the events in Poe's life had everything to do with the way he wrote. He lived a hard life with many losses, so that is what he wrote about. He did not know anything else, to him that was reality and that was what happened

Discuss the "Cinderella" fairytale through its appropriation, how it is affected by its culture, a different version and Bettelheim's psychoanalytical reading.

646 words - 3 pages approaches of different storytellers.The result of this is a variety of appropriations of the text, to suit the cultural and social norms of the time. One example of this is Andy Tennant's film "Ever After". In this film version, Cinderella is Danielle who has a wicked stepmother and stepsisters, but in no way is she in need of rescuing; saving herself from her horrible family and the prince from gypsies. She overcomes hardship, marries prince

What is Feminism and how it has affected out society

909 words - 4 pages man to take over a woman's duty at home. Another way women have changed the definition of men is politically.Many years ago women were not allowed to vote. But women changed that in the early 1900's. With the woman suffrage movement, it was courageous and persistent political campaigns, which lasted over 72 years, yet because of these women are allowed to vote today. This might have affected men greater than anything else, giving women power to

Child Abuse: who is affected , why they are affected and how to stop child abuse

1974 words - 8 pages Child AbuseChild Abuse is a rising phenomenon in our society. There are numerous factors that are thought to be involved in the cause of child abuse. The first being a parent's history. Others include emotional status, and psychological state. A parents background of abuse often contributes to the abuse that takes place and is often overlooked by the parent because they too went through the same thing.By Definition, child abuse Includes physical

Money in Dickens. This is a chronological analysis of Dickens' treatment of filthy lucre, and how his perception changed and matured through time.

2905 words - 12 pages represented as a crude panacea for all ills, as Snagsby views the half-crown in Jo's case in Bleak House. Oliver Twist is a fable of money and how (and how not) to get it. Oliver's life follows an archetypal rags-to-riches arc as simplistic as it is traditional, with his eventual wealth un-earned but well deserved. It is the goal which all characters in the novel pursue, and the fulcrum on which the plot rests. The money itself is represented as a

How Mental Illness Has Affected My Life

899 words - 4 pages internal deciders; they dictated what I did, said and how I executed those actions respectively. They kept me from making friends and making the school bus in the morning. I would sit up the whole night before and dread the thought of being surrounded; suffocated by people. People who did not like me, people who want to embarrass me, hurt me, and destroy me. This mentality followed me all the years through to High School. I attended four different

Robert Frost's life and how it affected the writing of his poem "design"

730 words - 3 pages Robert Frost - PAGE 3 - "He has bequeathed his nation a body of imperishable verse from which Americans will forever gain joy and understanding." This is how President John F. Kennedy described Robert Frost. Robert Frost's amazing poetry has been capturing the hearts and minds of readers around the world. The life Frost lived, and the poetry he wrote are a testament to his love for nature and his awe of the world.Robert Frost, who died in 1963

How is the Government Affected by Autism?

2008 words - 9 pages that so many organizations and programs are provided to families that have autistic children or family members. There are positive and negative ways that autism affects the government. A positive way is that more research is being done on the causes of autism and how to prevent it before it fully takes over the child’s life. A negative way to counter the positive way, is that the government is spending too much money. In California alone, almost

Similar Essays

Disparate Impact/Disparate Treatment Essay

1543 words - 6 pages "Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act provides two primary theories of recovery for individuals; these are disparate treatment and disparate impact" (Bennett-Alexander & Hartman, 2007). Disparate treatment exists if an employer gives less favorable treatment to employees because of their race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. On the other hand, "disparate impact is the discrimination caused by policies that apply to everyone and

Disparate Impact And Disparate Treatment Case Study

736 words - 3 pages Most people have to work in order to survive and stay out of poverty. Not all people are born into wealth or win the lottery. Although most people have to work to make a living, it does not mean that discrimination and unfair treatment are bestowed upon them. There are many laws that avoid a discriminating work place. However, there are cases where disparate impact and disparate treatment occur.The work place for most people is where they spend

Disparate Impact/Disparate Treatment Case Study

803 words - 3 pages trial could cost the employer more than just money.These decisions not only provide a law that is required to be followed but it also reflects to the public what is morally right and wrong. The public looks to these cases and decisions to see what is acceptable in how they treat each other and where the boundaries are. The decisions from disparate impact and disparate treatment cases give employees and employers alike the “green light”

Disparate Impact/Disparate Treatment Case Study

1178 words - 5 pages follow the guidelines that are spelled out for them through these acts. Proving a disparate impact or a disparate treatment case can be very difficult because malicious intent is not usually something that is documented by an organization. Organizations may sometimes be put in a position of being accused of malicious intent even when none existed.In order for organizations to avoid violations and allegations of discrimination lawsuits, organizations