What would be the benefits and drawbacks for Bronwyn, whose story was featured in Unit 2, of being assessed as having a psychiatric disorder?
To be assessed as having a psychiatric disorder requires medical diagnosis, either from a doctor or a mental health practitioner. A treatment plan will be offered if a diagnosis is made that may include medication and a care plan. Bronwyn is an example of someone who is not classified with a psychiatric disorder, yet is questioning her mental health as life has become unmanageable and overwhelming (The Open University, 2008). The K225 Course Model examines the external influences of the service user and determines whether they have contributed to the mental distress being experienced (The Open University, 2008b, pp.26-27). This essay will use the K225 Model to discuss Bronwyn’s situation, working like a map to reveal the route that has led to her mental distress, explore both the benefits and the drawbacks of being diagnosed with a named psychiatric disorder and how the decision that she makes could impact her life. “To be placed in a category of ‘mental illness’ can have a significant impact on someone’s life” (The Open University, 2008d, p.105).
The K225 model places Bronwyn at the centre and surrounds her with the social, environmental, economic and political dimensions of her life. Many of Bronwyn’s issues can be seen in more than one dimension and therefore can affect or be affected by other areas. The model shows that relating Bronwyn’s experience of mental distress to these external areas of her life will reveal a wider holistic view of her world (The Open University, 2008a, p.20). These dimensions are held together by Bronwyn’s ethics and values, which will also influence how she responds to and copes with these issues (The Open University, 2008b, p.26).
Examining the social dimension of Bronwyn’s life reveals that she is feeling isolated; Bronwyn believes her family do not appreciate or support her. Over a short period of time Bronwyn’s mother has died, her friends have moved away and local shops have closed. Bronwyn misses the contact she had with these people and places and hasn’t replaced them with other significant people or experiences. Bronwyn describes that she feels as though she is “being tucked away … inside, under a blanket” (The Open University, 2008b p.31). Social connection is important and any difficulty in the area of social interaction can impact mental health (Loat, 2011).
The environmental dimension has impacted Bronwyn’s life at home and in her wider world, her home has become disorganised and untidy causing her to misplace and forget items. She feels negative about the area she lives in and intimidated when out alone at night. This is due to the lack of services and opportunities within her community and to Bronwyn’s perception of teenagers hanging around being a nuisance and littering the locality (The Open University, 2008). Further evidence for the idea that...