This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Much Power And Liberty Did The Constitution Give To ?The People??

2175 words - 9 pages

     How much power and liberty did the constitution give to “the people?”

     The constitution is the document that has framed and shaped the United States from inception. It is the document that is defended by all new presidents and also the document which affords the citizens of the United States freedoms and rights that cannot be removed. In its drafting it shaped the formation of a new country and a new style of governance. It is a ‘bottom up’ as opposed to established ways of government which are ‘top down’. However for all its virtues the Constitution is somewhat ambiguous and there is some debate of the intent of the drafters, did they intend to give as much power or did they intend to give less power to the people?

     The Constitution sets out the system, rules and regulations of how the new American government was to work. The constitution was drafted by a small select group of people from the 13 states; they were the people’s representatives for the constitution. However these people were very much part of an emerging elite, the masses weren’t literate nor would they have had a vast understanding of theories of government, all they knew was the old system and monarchical government. Therefore the drafting of the constitution fell to what one could call idealistic gentry, who were very wealthy and well educated perhaps an upper class group of individuals. They may have been acting on behalf of the people but there are numerous examples of blatant self-interest. When assigning powers to congress taxation was obviously a big area, the representatives from the Southern states managed to get exemptions for export duties. Many of the representatives from these southern states were heavily involved in the Tobacco trade and made a lot of their personal wealth from this trade so it was is in their own direct interest to get exemptions for these things. This is a clear demonstration on how some representatives weren’t wholly representative.

     To assess how much power and liberty the constitution gives to the people one obviously must look at the language and the content of the document itself. In article one, section four, it states “The congress shall assemble at least once in every year, and such meeting shall be on the first Monday in December, unless they shall appoint a different day”. The language of this section implies that congress was only intended to meet rarely, any elected chamber that is intended to meet rarely cannot have much legitimacy. It cannot be thought of, as a great democratic institution representing the peoples will.

     At the time of drafting the constitution, the rules on the senate were to be two senators for each state, which were appointed by the state legislatures, rather than directly elected by the people. “The Senate of the United States shall...

Find Another Essay On How Much Power And Liberty Did The Constitution Give To ?the People??

How far did Napoleon Bonaparte maintain the revolutionary ideals of liberty and equality in France?

2528 words - 10 pages rose to power in 1799, to impose these reforms which would reflect the revolutionary ideals of liberty and equality. Some of these reforms were beneficial to the French population and kept with the revolutionary ideals, however, most reforms contradicted them. For this reason, he did not do a satisfactory job in maintaining them. According to Andrew Matthews, with regard to liberty, Napoleon disobeyed the revolutionary principles. He also states

Why did the people stormed the Bastille and how important was the storming to the start of the revolution?

3389 words - 14 pages The revolutionary storming Why did the people stormed the Bastille and how important was the storming to the start of the revolution?The French Revolution in 1789 changed France and "equalized" the rights of the people. One of the major events that started it was the storming of the Bastille on July 14th, 1789. This day represented the French revolution because it showed us the public's sprit of rebellion. Rumors were everywhere during that

How did Alexander the Great manage to conquer so much territory in so quickly?

4043 words - 16 pages the credit for himself; I investigated these claims as well. I discovered that Alexander's father, King Philip II, did in fact work very hard to hone his people into a fighting machine. This was one of the biggest considerations that caused some historians to jump to the conclusion that his father did all the heavy lifting, and Alexander was handed his victory on a silver platter. However, I also found that Alexander was an excellent tactician

How did Hitler replace the Weimar government and what was the nature of support that helped him come to power?

853 words - 3 pages reasons why Hitler and the Nazi Party managed to establish power in Germany.The rise of Hitler can be explained in two ways: the weaknesses of the Weimar Republic and the strengths of the Nazis. First of all, there was no popular support for Weimar. By signing the Armistice in November1919, the Weimar politicians became known as the November Criminals. The people of Germany didn't want a democracy, they wanted a strong government and support for

How Does the Constitution Protect the People from Tyranny?

854 words - 4 pages “Give me liberty, or give me death.” We must diminish tyranny among our government. How did the United States accomplish this? After the Revolutionary War, the Founding Fathers decided to construct a government that was of the people, by the people, and for the people. By doing so, they needed to prevent the more than likely possibility of overbearing power falling into the hands of one or a few people, in other words a prevention of tyranny was

"How was Hitler able to successfully capture the hearts and minds of the German people and achieve such great power?"

1046 words - 4 pages Hitler's rise to power was one of circumstance and propaganda. He knew how to use certain situations to gain authority and seize the senses and emotions of the German people. Hitler made use of the Treaty of Versailles to stir the emotions of the Germans and broadcast his shared resentment towards the treaty. This successfully persuaded the Germans to support Hitler and his party. Hitler deeply benefited from the Great Depression as the Germans

This is on the period of jacksonian democracy and how they saw themselves as the guardians of the United States Constitution, political democracy, and individual liberty

710 words - 3 pages Jacksonian DemocracyThe Jacksonian democrats saw themselves as the guardians of the United States Constitution, political democracy, individual liberty, and equality of economic opportunity. However, were they really all they claimed to be? They did attempt to increase the power of lower classes while decreasing the influence of the rich and powerful. Economically, they benefited from governing during a time of huge advances in transportation

The Power of Congress to Regulate and Enfore the Interstate Trade Clause in the Constitution

1638 words - 7 pages The "Declaration of Independence" revealed the birth of a new nation. Its foundation rested on no particular grievance, but many against King George III and the British people. Thomas Jefferson lists "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" as the rights of all man. In the late 1700s with the formation of the American these rights were understood, however, there were no documents to officially uphold these rights aside from the "Declaration

How did the pigs’ rise to power affect the other characters in the story?

750 words - 3 pages How did the pigs’ rise to power affect the other characters in the story? In George Orwell's sattire Animal Farm, one can see how the pigs’ rise to power affect the other characters in the story in that it affected their health, economic system, and rights. The first way that the pigs’ rise to power affect the other characters in the story in that it affected their health. The farm animals lived to work, and the work seemed worse now than

Our Living Constitution: An modern interpretation of the flexibility of the constitution and how much foresight our fore fathers had in the wording of it, not much history, mostly interpretation

1088 words - 4 pages , federalism, separation of powers, and the statement of individual liberties simply give the underlying ideals of government. This leaves plenty of room for interpretation by the courts as well as by individuals.During the time that has passed since the Constitution was ratified over two hundred years ago, there have been many interpretations that have led to even more social and political changes. However, the essential framework of the Constitution

How much did the outcomes of the treaties reflect the leadership personalities of France, Germany and Great Britain?

814 words - 3 pages Wilson of America had been genuinely stunned by the savagery of the Great War. He could not understand how an advanced civilisation could have reduced itself so that it had created so much devastation.In failing health, Wilson wanted America to concentrate on itself and, despite developing the idea of a League of Nations, he wanted an American input into Europe to be kept to a minimum. He believed that Germany should be punished but in a way

Similar Essays

"To A Great Extent The Constitution Is A Document With As Many Checks Upon The Power Of The People And Majority Rule As Upon The Power Of The Government." Assess The Validity Of This Statement

745 words - 3 pages roam freely, doing whatever they wish. American people are not even allowed to vote directly for president. The Electoral College, an establishment created by the founding fathers of the constitution checks the people's right to vote. Although Americans' direct vote is directly related to the election of the president, it is not the final say in who will win the election.For both the people and the government, power is checked and balanced. As Lord

The Power And Protection Of Religious Liberty

1131 words - 5 pages .” According to this ideology, PRC has its own constitution which includes specific provisions of religious liberty clearly.The Article 36 of China’s constitution said,“the citizen of PRC has the religious belief liberty. Any nations’ department, social organization and individuals should not force people believe religion or disbelieve it. Nation protect the normal religious activity, any one should not use religion belief to do harm to the social

How Much Homework To Give Kids?

1507 words - 6 pages How Much Homework to Give Kids? To many kids in elementary schools, homework is a menace. It takes away quality time from a student’s daily life and activities. In Romesh Ratnesar’s article “The Homework Ate my Family”, Ratnesar mentions about a student named Molly and her daily routine. Her daily routine consists of “spending two hours doing homework, practicing the piano, doing more than 100 math problems, labeling the countries

Miimum Wage And Power To The People

2172 words - 9 pages Alternative Three – Power to the people The third and final alternative minimum wage is to allow the local people in the community vote on a living wage. This alternative would put all the power in the hands of the people; allowing them to decide what is best for their neighborhoods. If the people are allowed to vote in such matters, they will be permitted to use their voice and at the very least express their concerns with the gaps in minimum