This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Planned Was The Soviet Economy

1967 words - 8 pages

How Planned was the Soviet Economy

As Marxists claim that capitalism is 'anarchic, planless, inefficient
and wastes human and natural resources', what with the modern advances
made by Russia in such a short space of time, one would assume that
the Soviet economy between 1924 and 1939 was meticulously planned and
controlled. However, many facts would beg to differ and instead
suggest the contrary.

It is true that institutes of planning existed in Russia in the period
concerned. As of July 1922, VSNKh operated its control over industry
by "methods of a production-planning character". The institution was
responsible for the drafting of production and disposal plans amongst
other things. Another institution in existence was Gosplan which was
known as the state general-planning commission. Set up in February
1921, Gosplan was to "work out a single general state economic plan
and means of implementing it." However, although such institutions
were in place, there was no evidence of a thoroughly worked out
production and allocation programme; there was no "command economy."
Gosplan did not produce plans in the sense of orders from which one
could act upon, but produced "control figures" which were in part a
prediction and in part a guide for strategic investment decisions. So,
according to Alec Nove, neither Gosplan nor VSNKh could provide, even
if they attempted to, output plans for all trusts and enterprises,
excluding a small number in key sectors, with most trusts making their
arrangements with minimal supervision from above.

Another point one must not forget is that the state's ability to plan
was inhibited by the fact that the people in the Left who had had a
strong belief in planning in the first place had been ousted out of
the government by the ruling forces. One must not overlook the timing
of the First Plan and brand it an accident. The Left Opposition had
originally proposed rapid industrialization to be the part's primary
priority. Now that they had been defeated the government was able to
adopt their industrialization policies without putting them in power.
Industrialization also came hand in hand with collectivisation as
machinery such as tractors had to be produced.

1921 to 1927 were the years of the NEP.VSNKh can be said to have just
regulated the economy during the NEP as opposed to doing anything
else. However in all fairness, it is difficult to even talk about a
planned economy between the years of 1924 and 1928, whatever the role
of the state planning institutions, as the state did not run the most
effective parts of the economy. The state's ability to plan was
greatly hindered by the fact that it ran heavy industry and not
agriculture. Between 1921 and 1927 the state industrial sector
stagnated while agriculture flourished in the private sector.


Find Another Essay On How Planned was the Soviet Economy

How did the Soviet Union develop their Atomic Bomb?

781 words - 3 pages The Soviet Union did not keep a record of the Soviet atomic project, even of the major events, so there is very little information known about this topic. As it was a regime with strict secrecy, only a few of the top leaders knew of the events on the atomic bomb project. Most of the people who worked on this project have died, so it is really difficult to find out about the project. Much of what we know about the project is through

How far do you agree that as late as 1940, Hitler remained undecided on the "Jewish question". It was the invasion of the Soviet Union, which transformed the situation?

884 words - 4 pages place after the invasion on the Soviet Union on 22nd June 1941. Hitler ordered the Einsatzgruppen to advance into Russia - they are to execute the Jews, however, in the first period women and children are excluded from executions. The exact plan of Holocaust was designed on Wannsee Conference in January 1942 and in July the first mass executions begin in Treblinka.The above presented chronology is the argument in favour of functionalists because it

To what extent was Stalin's rule a disaster for the Soviet Union and its people?

915 words - 4 pages was left unhurt from the effects of collectivisation. Civil war soon developed - the peasantry against the authorities. As a result, millions of people died from either bloody warfare or starvation. Livestock had drastically reduced as the people ate them as a last resort. In this way, Stalin's ideas were disastrous. The economy also suffered extensively from poor grain production. Politically, however, Stalin was successful as the Soviet Union

Why Stalin Was Able to Hold on to Power in the Soviet Union

1017 words - 4 pages Why Stalin Was Able to Hold on to Power in the Soviet Union Stalin was ruthless in order to stay in power, there are many reasons that helped him hold on to his position. Through the Purges Stalin was able to eliminate or clear out all opposition within the party. Anyone who threatened his position, or disagreed with some of his policies, was purged. They were purged in great Show Trails, in order for

How the President Can Strengthen the Economy

2146 words - 9 pages It is obvious that the economy is currently facing the problem of recession. There are reasons why the country’s economy is currently facing these problems. One reason why is that the U.S. is in an abundance of debt. This includes the federal economic system, countries and individual citizens in general. The second problem is the issue with health care. Many American citizens are without a sufficient amount of health care. The sad matter is

How successful was Japan in establishing a new style of economy, government and armed forces in the period of the Meiji Emperor (1868-1912)?

2749 words - 11 pages emperor's personal desire for Japan to revolve. He also initialized the First Industrial Fair in 1877 in Ueno. The Japanese government had been involved in such fairs in Philadelphia and Vienna and wanted one for its own. This was yet another first, a success and opened by the hands of the noble emperor himself. Six such expositions were planned. He was also seen later, clad in western style clothing. He hoped that the Japanese after seeing him

How the U.K. was formed

1413 words - 6 pages established. While the surrender of independence was utterly unpopular in Scotland, their economy improved vastly over many years with access to the now British trade routes and Scotland played a formative role in what would soon become the largest empire in entire human history, despite that the actual Scottish ‘kingdom’ never really benefitted from the union of the two kingdoms. That being said, still more than three-hundred years later, Scotland has

How the West Was Won

1128 words - 5 pages How the West Was Won Table of contents???pg.1 (History) How the West was ?won?????pg.2 (History) Harmony Lost???pg.3 The Long Walk???pgs.4-7 Bibliography???pg.8 How the West was ?won?? For hundreds of years the early stories of the United States have been summed up by the expression, ?How the West was won.? The classic cowboy and Indian films have always portrayed the white settlers moving across America?s

How the church was formed

1579 words - 6 pages the church that took place by the end of the 2nd century (just when, and how, is uncertain). At some point, Christians with Gentile backgrounds began to outnumber Jewish Christians. Clearly, the work of the apostle Paul was influential. Born a Jew, he was deeply involved in the destiny of Judaism, but as a result of his conversion, he believed that he was the "chosen instrument" to bring the message of Christ to the Gentiles. He was the one who

How Does Technology Affect the Economy

771 words - 4 pages . There are many pros and cons to technology in the economic world, but the truth is that technology is growing and it is important and needed in the working world. With all the productivity, technology is taking over and the economy will grow because of it. Works Cited Lacoma, Tyler. “The Positive & Negative Effects of Technology in Business.” Web. 27 April 2014. Pethokoukis, James. “How the rise of smart machines will affect the US economy and jobs: A Q&A with Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee.” Web. 27 April 2014. Thompson, Lindsey. “How Does Technology Affect Our Economy?” Technology Affects the Economy. Web. 26 April 2014.

How has globalisation affected the world economy?

2802 words - 11 pages How has globalisation affected the world economy? Discuss.Globalisation what is it? How has it affected the world's economics? How will it continue to affect the global village? Is anyone being adversely affected?Globalisation - is the movement of goods, services and money capital or investment across international boundaries and in this way becomes a predominately economic phenomenon sweeping the world. Throughout which, what were formerly

Similar Essays

So Why Was The Soviet Union Attacked In 1941?

3086 words - 12 pages requirements for living space.” Hitler saw how vast the Soviet Union territory was and he wanted the German people to have the rich lands that it possessed for the surplus German population. If Hitler succeeded in taking the lands east of Germany, he would have enough room for Germany’s surplus population. The Soviet Union had many acres of unsettled land. The Soviet Union stretched all the way from Europe to the end of Asia. Hitler and Stalin were

Why Was The Soviet Union Attacked By Germany In 1941?

3034 words - 12 pages territorial requirements for living space.” Hitler saw how vast the Soviet Union territory was and he wanted the German people to have the rich lands that it possessed for the surplus German population. If Hitler succeeded in taking the lands east of Germany, he would have enough room for Germany’s surplus population. The Soviet Union had many acres of unsettled land. The Soviet Union stretched all the way from Europe to the end of Asia. Hitler and

What Are The Four Functions Of An Economic System? Contrast The Way In Which The Market Economy And Planned Economy Attempt To Solve The Economic Problem

981 words - 4 pages The four functions of an economic system are what to produce, how much to produce, how to produce and whom to distribute to.The market economy is one that is controlled by the people and there is little government intervention. It is also known as a free enterprise economy.The planned economy is one that is controlled by the government and there is a lot of government intervention into the way in which the economy runs.They both try and solve

Leveraging The Soviet Union's Economy For Cold War Success: Reagan's Impact, 1981 1989

3184 words - 13 pages regarding how to deal with the situation. At the end of a number of meetings of Communist leaders, it was concluded that it was important to improve the material conditions of living for the people in the GDR so that they did not feel compelled to leave their country. Freedom of travel was not enough - a market economy had to be introduced. This freedom was yet another indication that the Soviet regime was ultimately going to fail. On June 12, 1990