How Satisfactory Are Explanations Of The Welfare State Reforms Of The Liberal Party In The U.K In 1906 14, Which Rest Upon A 'rediscovery' Of Poverty Coupled With Middle And Upper Class Altruism.

1848 words - 7 pages

How satisfactory are explanations of the welfare state reforms of 1906-14 which rest upon a 'rediscovery' of poverty coupled with middle- and upper class altruism.The years of liberal administration between 1906-14 can now be clearly seen as a period of extensive social reform, during which time many items of government legislation were passed and various organisations and institutions concerned with welfare reform were set-up. However, the extent to which these measures have been successful and the reasons behind the implementation of these initiatives have long since been the subject of debate amongst social and economic historians. This argument usually involves questions of both altruism and efficiency on behalf of both the liberal government and the individuals concerned with the legislation. The model of the reforms being a result of a 'rediscovery of poverty' and the altruism of the middle and upper classes is too simplistic and negates many other important factors which had an effect on the implementation and nature of the legislation. Another important point to make when assessing the liberal welfare reforms is that each of the separate reforms has it's own history and background. Therefore it is important to take note of the point emphasised by the historian Hay, that the reforms should be viewed as "individual solutions to particular social problems, not as part of a wider movement. " It is from this angle that I will examine the liberal reforms, taking each measure in it's own context.From assessing many of the Liberal measures it seems that national efficiency and political considerations were just as much a factor of the reforms as middle class altruism was. This can be seen particularly in the Liberal government's treatment of children and the young. Many of the measures which on the surface appeared to be born of a desire to help improve the situation of many of the country's underfed and badly clothed children were actually aimed at improving the efficiency of the country and gaining popular support. This can be seen in the Education (administrative provisions) Act of 1907, concerned with medical inspection of school children. Like many of the reforms, the act was passed due to backbench political pressure, in this case by the Secretary of the Board of Education, Robert Morant. Morant's primary concern was with using medical inspection as a means of revealing the mass of preventable disease, which would result in greater acceptance of medical treatment. The same can also be said of the Children act of 1908, which sought to keep children out of prison and imposed fines on parents guilty of neglect, and the choice of employment act of 1910. These are examples of legislation brought about because of the changing way in which children were viewed at the turn of the century. As birth rates fell, particularly amongst the middle classes, concerns grew over the future of a population being born more and more into the working classes....

"The history of the poor in Australia reveals that state interventions to ameliorate poverty are misguided."

1551 words - 6 pages only assisted for short period of time as if you received assistance for too long you were a danger and lazy.Often charities kept records of the poor women and the cause of their poverty, which was undoubtedly, prejudiced by middle class values . Each person asking for assistance was investigated as to find out the validity of their need for financial help. Therefore despite state interventions that were implemented in an environment espoused of

What are the principal philosophies of the Liberal Party? Why had the Liberal Party been so electorally successful over the years? Why did it lose the last election?

3452 words - 14 pages national level for just over two-thirds of the sixty four years since 1944 and, when not in government, has always been the main opposition party. A similar picture, though with obviously varying lengths of time in government, can be found at the state level. In short, Robert Menzies brain child has been extremely successful. This essay analyses and explores the principal philosophies of the Liberal Party to assess why it has been so electorally

Poverty in America: Government Welfare Programs are the Solution

1370 words - 5 pages , employment opportunities and incomes of the adversely affected groups are reduced. The 2001 census bureau report 22.2 percent of people without a high school diploma lived in poverty as opposed to 9.6 who had a diploma. 14.2 percent of high school dropouts were lived in long term poverty, while 3.8 percent of people with high school diplomas lived in long term poverty. In less affluent neighborhoods, there is usually no funding available to

Discussion of the representation of masculinity in the Arthur Miller's 'A View From the Bridge', considering the extent to which the male characters are more acted upon than acting

1740 words - 7 pages freewill. The best example Eddie being acted upon is when he calls Immigration about Marco and Rodolpho. At this point in the play, Eddie thinks that he has no other options. He is struggling to control his feelings for Catherine, which on its own is an example of being acted upon. Although Eddie knows that these incestuous feelings are not acceptable, he cannot help but feel this way. Catherine's developing relationship with Rodolpho is clearly testing

Analyse the transpostion of one literary text to film, discussing which features of the literary text are cut in the process and which features are focus upon/expanded. I have chosen to analyse...

1600 words - 6 pages with image and with dissolves" (Minghella)An example of how he used sound to soften the transitions was displayed in what I have called The Hopscotch Scene (situated in section 8 of chapter One and occurs at 24 minutes into the movie). Right after Hana plays hopscotch by herself, when the patient is lying in bed listening to the thuds, in the literary text, the paragraph which follows is a flashback. However, in the film text, the scene shows a

Social Reformist and Market Liberal approaches may have been suitable for the social condition of the 20th Century, but 3rd Way welfare policies are more relevant to the 21st Century

2925 words - 12 pages This essay will look at the social conditions that existed for each of the political parties and the welfare policy approaches that each party adopted in relation to the NHS. Initially I will look at Social Reformist policies followed by Market Liberals. But as a consequence of the research the essay will demonstrate that New Labour has used a collaboration of existing ideologies to create a set of welfare policies, which they claim are relevant

A comparison essay discussing the different beliefs and concepts of Alan Strang's parents' from the play Equus by Peter Shaffer. The essay discusses the different beliefs on the main issues of the...

672 words - 3 pages Untitled "Equus" Distinct differentiation on certain concepts under one household can cause a child to be confused and torn between two worlds. Equus depicts the state of mind of Alan Strang and how the conflicting beliefs of his parent's set his development as a teenager and a troubled boy. "Class". Few have it, many desire it, and then there are those who like to believe they obtain it. Dora Strang

Bram Stokers Dracula: A Struggle to Maintain Victorian Upper and Middle Class

1831 words - 7 pages The Victorian men and women conveyed in Bram Stoker's Dracula are pure and virtuous members of the upper and middle class. However, hiding behind this composed and civilized conception of England lies a dark and turbulent underbelly. This underbelly is the lumpenproletariat, whom Karl Marx defined as "the lowest and most degraded section of the proletariat; the ‘down and outs’ who make no contribution to the workers cause". Victorian

Everyone in Australia Thinks That They Are Middle Class

1434 words - 6 pages , contrary to what many may think.It was Karl Marx who first asked the question, 'how are classes formed'? He also wrote about middle and working class people being exploited by a capitalist regime. His argument was based around workers generating large sums of money for an employer using their 'labour power', but only getting a diminutive portion of the profit, which is very unfair to the worker who has done all the hard manual labour. The

The Liberal Adoption of a Policy of Social Reform in the Period 1906-1914

1537 words - 6 pages The Liberal Adoption of a Policy of Social Reform in the Period 1906-1914 There are many issues to examine when answering the question of what prompted the Social reforms of 1906-1914 such as the changing ideas of the British public and national efficiency which was decreasing. In the period of 1906-1914, the social reform acts were passed in parliament by the Liberal government under Herbert Asquith PM, Lloyd-George

The Problem of Poverty: Welfare in America

2100 words - 8 pages The Problem of Poverty: Welfare in America For centuries, nations, cities, and individual families have dealt with the problem of poverty; how to remedy current situations and how to prevent future ones. For most of history, there have been no government controlled poverty assistance programs. The poor simply relied on the goodness of their families or, if they did not have a family, on the generosity of the public at large. In the United

The Liberal Election Of 1906 And The Dissatisfaction With The Conservative Party

1323 words - 5 pages The Liberal Election of 1906 and the Dissatisfaction with the Conservative Party The 1906 election was a landslide victory for the Liberal Party. It was a dramatic turn-around for the main contender to British Government that had been out of power for twenty years. The Liberals won 377 seats outright, and including the 27 Lib-Lab seats and around 80 Irish Home Rule seats they had made a dramatic defeat. The

Homes And Decor Of The Victorian Upper Middle Class

797 words - 3 pages Homes and Décor of the Victorian Upper-Middle Class “For, in the Veneering establishment, from the hall-chairs with the new coat of arms, to the grand pianoforte with the new action, and upstairs again to the new fire-escape, all things were in a state of high varnish and polish” (Dickens 17). The homes of upper-middle class Victorians were as extravagant as their money would afford, inside and out. In a home where one hoped to host

What Are The Key Features And Limitations Of A Liberal Democratic State?

1620 words - 6 pages the state? Perhaps there are certain aspects or vague points in the concept of liberal democracy that can be discussed and even criticised. Does the whole idea in general, minimal regulation on the free market, maximising basic civil rights, create a state in which the government is in touch with the population, or is it simply the case of a representative highlighting arguments that his electorate do not really feel are relevant to them? It is

Discuss Some Of The Factors Which Led To The Emergence Of The Modern Welfare State In The 1940s:

2026 words - 9 pages Histories of the welfare state usually are much discussed. In order to begin the story, it dates back hundred years in the record of histories as it challenged sort of reform extended three and a half century. But The first attempt at providing formal social protection in the Britain which began with Lloyd George’s 1909 budget called “people’s budget” and finished with Mr Attlee, Labour's 1945 Prime Minister! Who securely routed the guide