How Should States Who Are All Facing The Same Security Dilemma Interact With One Another?

2943 words - 12 pages

Within a society, the populace are compelled to follow rules due to being prompted by a higher authority. When these laws fail, rectifying this deficiency becomes a priority of the state; murderers are arrested, riots are suppressed, new regulations and safe checks are imposed to deter future renegades from harassing the system. These actions by the state’s sovereign power ensure that the community remains harmonious and balanced. Within the international community an individual state is unable to defer to a higher authority to demand that justice be enforced, since there is no authority higher than the state itself. The consequence of this is that independent nations are forced to rely on themselves for security within international society. These facts lead to a question that has been at the core of just war theory debates; how should states who are all facing the same security dilemma interact with one another? The various theoretical answers to this question form to two fundamentally opposed conclusions; nations will either seek to expand their individual power to facilitate their own security, or will construct an international union to ensure mutual defense. While the latter promotes an international community based upon cooperation, the former predicts perpetual conflict. In order to perform an analysis of these conflicting predictions we will turn to Thucydides, who provides a historical example of this debate within his recount of the Melian Dialogue. Within this dialogue, the powerful Athenians assert that strength alone justifies their demand for the submission of the weaker island of Melos. The Melians counter with their own plea to justice, claiming that the advancement of Athenian power and Melian autonomy are not mutually exclusive pursuits. By identifying the arguments advanced by each of these nations and comparing them with the teachings of several just war philosophers, we will be able to weigh the merits of each respective school of thought. We will arrive at the conclusion that state interaction is not an isolated event, but rather a reiterated relationship. From this, states more thorough cooperation than conflict and thus the arguments advanced by the Athenians within the dialogue should be rejected.
The negotiations within the Melian Dialogue began with the Athenians making a preemptive counter to the argument of why it would be unjust to subject Melos to servitude. They stated, “…we both know that decisions about justice are made in human discussions only when both sides are under equal compulsion; but when one side is stronger, it gets as much as it can, and the weak must accept that,” (Thucydides, page 103). Since the Athenians were the stronger nation within the negotiation they advanced the concept that justice is dependent upon interests, not morality, and that the interest of the powerful is simply to retain power. The Melians countered that being powerful does not give a nation the right to do as...

Find Another Essay On How should states who are all facing the same security dilemma interact with one another?

Cite one or two major problems facing this country today and what you think the government should be doing to deal with them.

549 words - 2 pages "It took seven economists 11 months to decide what should seem obvious given all the foreclosures, bank failures and layoffs - the United States is officially mired in a recession." ,(San Francisco Chronicle - Dec 2, 2008). It has been months everybody is talking about the economic and financial situation before the U.S government can actually do something to lift it up. From 1960s up to now there has been 6 recessions sweeping through the

Smoking should be banned all over the United States

1667 words - 7 pages that annual public and private expenditures on smoking have cost $96 billion (Tobacco Free Kids,16), evidently shows why smoking needs to be banned because it will save the United States billions of dollars. “Annual health care expenditures solely from secondhand smoke exposure is $4.98 billion”, showing us how those who socialize with smokers also suffer the same consequences as them ,and therefore smoking needs to be banned to prevent the

This essay is on two best friends who grew up with one another going through what life throws on a high school student and how they got through it..imagery is very strong.

813 words - 3 pages became closer and closer to one another. They knew they could always count on one another; no matter what happened they would be there for each other. Through this relationship, Rickie finally learned the meaning of true friendship; a friend that goes through thick and thin and are there for you no matter what.In the beginning, Rickie could never say she had any true friends. She had many friends, some of whom were best friends, but because she

Dying with Dignity is about the whole process of PAS - Ph. Assisted Suicide. It gives good arguments on why PAS should be permitted in all states.

994 words - 4 pages suicide is a criminal act. One exception is the state of Oregon, which allows people who are terminally ill, and in intractable pain to get a lethal prescription from their physician. This is called "Physician Assisted Suicide," (PAS) or Euthanasia.The word Euthanasia originated from the Greek language: eu means "good" and thanatos means "death". One meaning given to the word is "the intentional termination of life by another, at the explicit request

Should a nation require all its students to study the same national curriculum until they enter college?

585 words - 2 pages different students' talents and knowledge foundation. Because different courses are generally of the different values in determining the students' ability, the evaluation must synthesize all the nation's on teaching courses and make decision to put how much weight on each one in the evaluation. And if some tremendous changes occur in one district, the nation has to change the original system to adapt to it. While, it is not the case in another

Gay Marriage Should Be Legal in All States

1127 words - 5 pages States is a case that helped gain more federal rights for married same-sex couples. In this case, the Supreme Court struck down a key part of Defense of Marriage Act that denies certain protection and responsibilities of marriages. When the Supreme Court stated that the part of Defense of Marriage Act was unconstitutional, it showed that those who are married should have the same rights under the law no matter what their sexual orientation is

Gay Marriage Should Be Legal in All States

1980 words - 8 pages One of the most controversial topics that has been debated throughout the United States for decades has been Gay Marriage. Whether same-sex couples should be given the right to marry or even if same-sex couples should be given rights at all, this has been a contentious discussion which creates division and disunity throughout the country. The Supreme Court of the United States ruled that the Constitution guarantees a right to same-sex marriage

Gay Marriage Should Be Legal in All States

1215 words - 5 pages ? Many gays and lesbians are in serious relationships or are seeking a significant other to build a life with, just as their heterosexual counterparts. But some may never get that chance, as same-sex marriage is not universally legal. Everyone be permitted to marry whom they love. The Supreme Court of the United States recently ruled that the Constitution guarantees a right to same-sex marriage. Gay and lesbian couples deserve for their commitment

Medicinal Marijuana: Should It Be Legal in All States?

1481 words - 6 pages relievers that leave you incapacitated.”( Lewis is only one example of how marijuana has been used, and how marijuana has helped some one with chronic pain or other conditions. According to, 577,712 people are using marijuana for medical purposes in the United States. ( There are currently sixteen states that have legalized marijuana for medicinal purposes, including: Alaska, California, Colorado

Should Marriage for Same Sex Couples be Legal in United States?

1201 words - 5 pages want to be in caring, stable relationships, and they want to start a family with someone. I think their argument can be considered to be a flaw for the simple reason that they are not able to come up with convincing reasons as how same-sex marriage will not just be for their benefit, but it impact on children and marriage in the society as a whole. If legal rights to same-sex marriage is granted to gays and lesbians it would weaken the

Take a Penny, Leave all the Pennies? Essay taking the position that the penny should be taken out of circulation in the United States

1808 words - 7 pages services are also retained by other raw material providers as well as vending and coin operated machine operators (Choma). Now the question is, who is in favor of keeping the penny that doesn't have a vested financial interest?If the penny were just another consumer good there is no doubt it would have already been done away with. Unfortunately it's not. To many people it is still a symbol, something familiar that has always been a part of our

Similar Essays

We Are All One People. This Is An Essay About How It Doesn't Matter Who You Are Or What You Think You Are, That When Tragedy Happens We Are All The Same.

601 words - 2 pages and in New York.Needless to say the conference was canceled, due to the closeness of the airport with the governors and Vice President being so close to us.We were all walking out of the building though I left with one thought in my mind, as well as in my heart? No matter who we are or what we do that in times such as these "we are all but one people". There wasn't anyone in the room that was of any higher stature than anyone else, professionally or naturally we were all on equal ground for that moment of time.

Should Same Sex Marriage Be Legalized In All States?

1881 words - 8 pages each other should be allowed to marry. Thirdly, many people talk of the sanctity of marriage and this is one of their reasons against the legalization of same sex marriages in the United States. Is marriage really sacred in the United States? Many couples get into marriage and divorce in less that a week, in addition, there are many couples who get married to many spouses and these are the people who are destroying the sanctity of marriages

United States Of The 21st Century Faced With The Same Dilemma And Problems That The Roman Republic Faced As It Transformed Due Its Strength, Into An Empire.

1352 words - 5 pages would not take control over our government. Also, in order to avenge his brother's death, you would not find Jeb Bush raising an army and attacking the enemy.The reason for this is simple; the United States of the 21st Century is not nearly as archaic and barbaric as the Roman Republic was. Although some of our situations may be compared to those Roman Republic faces during its change to an empire, overall our problems are different in nature. The United States will remain a strong democracy and will not follow the same path as Rome...One that led to disaster and downfall.

'his Bundle Of Names Links All Our Little Band Of Men Together': How One Man Relates To Another In The Novel Of "Dracula"

1900 words - 8 pages some new scheme of villainy...' (D 43). The count tells Harker where he can withdraw and where he is not supposed to go under any circumstances. The reading out of the rules was a common procedure when one was incarcerated: 'Let me advise you, my dear friend - nay, let me warn you with all seriousness, that should you leave these rooms you will not by any chance go to sleep in any other part of the castle. It is old, and has many memories, and