How Successful Was J.S. Mill In Overcoming The Problems Associated With Bentham's Utilitarianism?

1120 words - 4 pages

How successful was J.S. Mill in overcoming the problems associated with Bentham's Utilitarianism?"The greatest good for the greatest number" is a simple way to sum up a fairly simple idea. But despite its simplicity it still has lots of problems; in this essay I will be looking at how John Stuart Mill tries to overcome these problems.In 1789 utilitarianism was born, the brainchild of Jeremy Bentham. Bentham was a hedonist or someone who is constantly in pursuit of pleasure or happiness. It is around this idea of hedonism that Bentham founded a way of making moral and ethical decisions, he called it utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is a teleological theory that worked on that basis that you should do the "greatest good for the greatest number", in simpler terms means that if ever confronted with a moral dilemma you should always do what will cause the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people as a consequence of your choice. So you think through the consequences of your action, and work out how much pleasure it will cause then subtract the amount of pain it would cause. So for Bentham a good person would be one that maximised happiness and minimised pain caused.To help establish how good one action was in comparison to another, he created a tool called a hedonic calculus. The Hedonic Calculus was based around seven principles of pleasure:1.Intensity - The strength of the happiness created2.Duration - How long the happiness lasts3.Certainty or Uncertainty - How sure/unsure you are that the happiness will occur4.Propinquity or Remoteness - How close/far away the happiness is in time, with closer being better5.Fecundity - How likely the act is to cause more feelings of the same kind (pleasure/pain)6.Purity - The chances of the act being followed by feelings of the opposite kind.7.Extent - The amount of people that will be affectedI will now put the hedonic calculus into practise using the example of euthanasia:FactorHelp them dieDon't help them dieIntensity¡Ô The happiness created by ending the patients suffering will be far greater than their pain, if they continue to suffer when living.X Their pain of seeing a loved one unable to do anything is greater than the pain of letting them die, knowing they are no longer suffering.Duration¡Ô The pleasure of the patient who will no longer be suffering will be infinite.X The patients pain will last as long as their life does.Certainty¡Ô It is 100% certain that if the patient stopped living, their pain would end.X It's fairly certain that keeping them alive would keep the family happy to an extent.Propinquity¡Ô The pain of the patient would end instantly.X The happiness of pain ending with a natural death would take longer than euthanasia.FecundityX After any death people get sad, even if they are happy their pain and suffering has ended.¡Ô By keeping them alive, the family will be happy simply because they are alive.Purity¡Ô As...

Find Another Essay On How successful was J.S. Mill in overcoming the problems associated with Bentham's Utilitarianism?

How successful were Solon's measures in dealing with the problems facing Athens in 594 BC?

2388 words - 10 pages In 594BC, Solon was appointed as archon (leader with supreme civil authority and power to act as a judge to cases involving Athenian citizens) to Athens, in an attempt to reform the state, which was facing a number of social and economic problems caused by political systems that they had in place at the time. His appointment was also intended to alleviate the problems that were threatening Athens with civil war, caused by other practices in

The Differences in John Stuart Mills and Jeremy Bentham's Versions of Utilitarianism

2653 words - 11 pages is a method of making the interests of the individual coincide with that of the community; that is its justification"#. In short, Bentham's belief was that all individuals should pursue their personal happiness as long as it does not compromise the happiness of the community. J. S. Mill shared many of Bentham's beliefs, but altered some to create a more sensitive version of utilitarianism. Mill argued that "Pleasure is the only thing desired

Utilitarianism is usually connected with the specific doctrines of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill.

1665 words - 7 pages Utilitarianism is usually connected with the specific doctrines of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, who both took the goodness of consequences to be measured by their effect on the happiness of human beings. Bentham was both the founder of utilitarianism and a contemporary of Mill's father, who ensured that his son received a strict utilitarian education based upon Bentham's theories . It is not surprising, then, that aspects of Mill's views

Problems Associated with Drought in Africa, and Proposed Solutions

2036 words - 8 pages Africa is a continent that suffers from many problems in many areas. The name of the continent has become synonymous with poverty, hunger and disease. These problems are connected with each other significantly. Many observers believe that the successive African crises are because of some reasons such as violence in most African countries, corruption that is rooted in the majority of African governments and stagflation which puts the continent in

How Successful Were Hitler And Mussolini Dealing With The Problems Of Their Countries Before 1939?

2866 words - 11 pages made it too expensive to support without creating problems in the economy, but Hitler still insisted in increase the size of it even more. I agree with historians Mason and Bracher who state that rearmament was the Nazis' first aim, because their political aims shape their economic policies.It can be argued that Germany did not suffer the consequences of this wrong decisions until the Second World War started, thanks to the credit notes and other

How could magnetically levitated trains relieve the problems of efficiency, safety, and ecology associated with the conventional trains and airplanes?

2588 words - 11 pages : Garcia, 2010, 41. Air transport is constructed to be faster and more convenient than trains, however there are also several burdens that are associated with airplanes. The most important aircraft problem is vast fuel utilization - European Commission 2009 indicates that airplanes have huge CO2 emission - 51.5 gram per passenger-kilometer. In addition, serious risks of safety usually worry people, for instance, there is a recent loss of Boeing-777

How successful was the Détente Period

2148 words - 9 pages , the Cold war started to flourish again. Furthermore, both President Ford and President Carter found it difficult to maintain détente against criticism of the Soviet Union’s continued interventions in the Third World.1 We could say that this brief and partially successful coexistence started with the Cuban missile crisis. Both superpowers had reasons for seek relaxation. On the USSR’s side, Leonid Brezhnev felt that the nuclear arms race was

How Successful was the Nazi youth policy?

905 words - 4 pages The Nazi Youth policy was very successful in some areas however in other areas it failed. Firstly though, it is important to see its aims before it can be deemed successful or not. The Nazis aimed to make Children obedient and disciplined, they also wanted them to idolise the Fuhrer and make him seem like God to them. They also aimed to make the growing nation a lot fitter and aimed to implant the idea that it was great to sacrifice yourself if

Problems Associated With Fossil Fuel Powered Transportation

1377 words - 6 pages was responsible for 28% of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and 2% of sulphur oxides (SOx) discharged to the atmosphere. If these levels were allowed to continue, the effects of global warming could become an unpleasant reality very soon.SOx and NOx emissions also contribute to acidification of the water vapour in the atmosphere resulting in what is known as "˜acid rain'. The oxide gasses react with the evaporated water present in the atmosphere with

How successful was propaganda in indoctrinating Nazi ideals?

986 words - 4 pages The Nazi propaganda after the consolidation of power featured many of the common characteristics associated with totalitarian propaganda; Twisted truths, stereotypical and distorted pictures of populace groups, simple messages repeated frequently and the use of a common enemy as a scapegoat. Also the Nazi propaganda featured many new methods of indoctrination, such as the mass rally meetings and the extensive radio propaganda. But how successful

The Success of Louis in Overcoming the Problems He Inherited in the Period 1816-1820

1078 words - 4 pages The Success of Louis in Overcoming the Problems He Inherited in the Period 1816-1820 Louis XVIII faced many difficulties during the period 1816-1820 due to the previous French rule under Napoleon. This is because of the Napoleonic wars of 1792 to 1815 and his reappearance in 1815 which had a dramatic effect on the nation in almost every respect. As a result, Louis XVIII had to contend with political, social, economic and

Similar Essays

How Successful Was Hitler Between 1933 45 In Solving The Problems Which Brought Him To Power ?

1665 words - 7 pages . Price controls meant to curb inflation worsened shortages instead. Germany was far worse in 1945 then before Hitler had come to power. However, if we consider the changes made by Hitler between 1933 and January 1945, we can affirm that he was successful in solving the problems that brought him to power because he was popular amongst the German people, had instaured one government with one party and a strong leader which executed decisions whether good or bad; unemployment was inexistent for real Germans and national status was reinstated.

How Successful Was Mussolini In Solving The Social And Economic Problems He Inherited?

1360 words - 5 pages government spending and privatized numerous big industries in order to stimulate the economy. Mussolini's choice of de Stefani was very successful as it secured his popularity as the Duce and really led the Italian economy into a period of boom with record export numbers especially in the cars and textile industry. However, after 1925, Mussolini gradually steered the economy towards his fascist ideals. With the dismissal of de Stefani and the launch

How Successful Was The League Of Nations In The 1920's? This Essay Analyses The Problems And Difficulties Of The First Attempt Of A World Security Organization

743 words - 3 pages How successful was the league in the 1920's?The League of Nations main aim was in: "stopping wars, improving people's lives and jobs, in encouraging disarmament and in enforcing the decisions made in the peace Treaty of Versailles."If we consider the above statement to judge the successes of the league, we may say that when the League was called to settle a quarrel in the 1920s, it has always been quite successful.The most important successes

Overcoming Problems In The Alchemist Essay

614 words - 2 pages Have you ever encountered problems while trying to fulfill a goal in your life? In the book The Alchemist, written by Paulo Coelho, a shepherd boy named Santiago overcomes obstacles to reach his personal legend. Throughout the book Santiago encounters many friends to help him fulfill his destiny. Santiago encounters many problems throughout the story. He overcomes them with the help of his friends and his wife-to-be. These problems shape