How Successful Were English Pm Sir 'robert Peel's Policies Towards Ireland Between 1841 46?

852 words - 3 pages

Cameron SeymourHISTORY."How successful were Peel's policies towards Ireland between 1841-6?"Success, I this context, can be considered as:- Making the other members of the Tory party content,- Making the Public of Ireland content,In more still more detail, success can be defined by judging:- If the Irish Protestants were content,- If the Irish Catholics were content,- If the policy contradicted past opinions/ views.If Peel's policy can satisfy all of the above criteria then that would be a success ratio of 6:6, if the English and Irish Catholics weren't happy, the success ratio would be just 3:5.Act of Union - 4:5 successful:Daniel O'Connell set up the 'Repeal Association' in 1841. It's main objective between 1841-6 was to repeal the Act of Union, but Peel - being a Tory (and thus against change) - threats to use 'governmental force' to uphold the act. This makes the Tory party happy, as well as the English and Irish Public, but O'Connell's Repeal Association is not happy. O'Connell plans to hold a big meeting to highlight the importance of the act's repeal. This would make the Irish public feel great vengeance, so Peel bans the meeting by passing a 'Coercion act', then arresting O'Connell on grounds of conspiracy. After this the Repeal Association breaks down and this is success in Peel's eyes. But in mine, Peel only satisfies the criteria for success by abusing his power.Other areas of failure as a leader lie with the Irish Nationalists. This is because once O'Connell's peaceful measures were shown as unsuccessful, the Irish Nationalists became much more violent as this was seen as the only way to bring about political change.The Devon Commission (1843) was set up by Peel, looking into the conditions for Irish people; obviously was trying to please the Irish Protestants/Catholics. Devon was asked to investigate land tenure in Ireland. This all seems fine, but there were 3 problems:1) Leases on land were short and not expected to exceed 3 lives. Therefore people that are landowners were unlikely to invest in their land as there's no long-term reward.2) Since 1815 there was a continuous depression in prices.3) An increase in population meant there was more pressure on the amount of land available.In 1845 the Devon Commission reported back to Peel that a limited compensation for those tenants who had carried out improvement on the land, and longer-term leases would be beneficial to the Irish people.But by now it was too late as this was the beginning of the...

Find Another Essay On How Successful were English PM Sir 'Robert Peel's policies towards Ireland between 1841-46?

Sir Robert Peel's Twelve Principles or Standards of Policing

935 words - 4 pages pain that comes about for a soldier when remembering the horror of war. He creates the poem's persona by using flashbacks to the war, thereby informing the reader as to why the speaker is behaving and feeling the way he is. The thirty-one lines that make up "Facing It" journey back and forth between present and past to tell the story of one man's life.Three people, whose names we do not know, briefly appear on the wall. How might we describe their

As chancellor between 1871 and 1890, Bismarck had set out for many innovative aims in terms of Germany’s domestic and foreign policies, and most of which were successful.

623 words - 2 pages Untitled PRACTICE MINI ESSAY ASSESS THE AIMS AND ACHIEVEMENTS OF BISMARCK'S FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC POLICIES BETWEEN 1871 AND 1890 As chancellor between 1871 and 1890, Bismarck had set out for many innovative aims in terms of Germany's domestic and foreign policies, and most of which were successful. Regarding his domestic policy, it is clear that his Kulturkampf had been a failure. After Bismarck placed the clergy

What were the economic effects of Nazi policies towards Jews and towards women?

717 words - 3 pages There were many Nazi policies that effected Jews and women. In this essay I will look closely at the economical effects it had on them.Women were encouraged to have a lot more children. There were even medals if you had a certain amount of children. Four was bronze, six silver and eight gold. Holders of the award were given an honoured place at Nazi meetings. The Nazis believed that women and men had different roles in life. A man was either a

How important were economic factors in shaping US foreign policies between 1890 and 1917?

867 words - 3 pages possible if the US economy had not been as strong, and of course if other countries had not been in such economic turmoil.Economic factors such as these were key in shaping US foreign policies between 1890 and 1917.One of the key factors that influenced American foreign policy were the personal agendas of the presidents of the period. Other politicians in powerful positions also affected foreign policy, for example during the Boxer Rising in China

How far were Mussolini's policies really fascist?

739 words - 3 pages very important in his point of view so he tried to create a strong state, through his propaganda Italy looked strong not only in sport they were successful but also it seemed that economical they were doing well, and all off Italy was doing well. But there are two lies. The first one is that there was a huge difference between the south and the north of Italy, the north was much wealthier and people lived better. The second lie was the economic

How Far Were Lenin's Policies Implemented After WW

1997 words - 8 pages practice his political ideologies after World War 1 was limited by both internal and external influences. It was necessary for Lenin to rule with pragmatism to secure the revolution. He set a slow course towards socialism waiting until domestic and foreign conflicts were resolved before initiating most of the revolutionary economic policies. Lenin believed that keeping power was more important than instant adherence to pure communism, and his

Account for Changes in British Policy Towards Ireland Between 1914 and 1922. Why Did These Changes Fail to Satisfy the People of Ireland?

2218 words - 9 pages Britain's policies towards Ireland between 1914 and 1922 have gone through much change and continuity. Most of the Policies and attitudes the British Government either had or did not have at the time caused much conflict within Ireland and its citizens and against England.The Primary cause of this conflict was the Home Rule situation, both the Catholics and the Protestants generally agreed that Ulster should be separated from a self governing

What were Peter the Great's westernization policies and how did they help modernize Russia?

1174 words - 5 pages reforms.During Peter's rule, the taxes rose three times causing the peasantry and commoners to become even more oppressed, while the nobles were exempt from paying taxes. It was through these various taxes that the Tsar was able to fund his military spending, and domestic reforms. Peter introduced a soul tax on all males, excluding the clergy and nobility, which allowed Peter to pay for the various conflicts that would arise with Sweden and the

How successful were Solon's measures in dealing with the problems facing Athens in 594 BC?

2388 words - 10 pages Athens, which were extremely well established. He is best known as a political reformer, as through his measures and his attempts to democratise justice, he managed to, if not revolutionise, then reform much of the political practice of Athens. This paved the way for future leaders to build upon his work, as well as aiding the economic and social growth of Athens. Although many of his measures were not immediately particularly effective or successful

How Successful Were Hitler And Mussolini Dealing With The Problems Of Their Countries Before 1939?

2866 words - 11 pages . Besides, jobs required living in bad conditions in camps that followed the progress of the roads constructed and were very badly paid. In any job wages ever reached their pre-depression levels and, though national income increased dramatically, as well as the amount of goods produced by the industry, but these were not consumer goods. Hitler directed everything towards war: the highways were constructed to enable the quick transportation of the

To what extent were soviet policies responsible for the outbreak and development of the cold war between 1945, 1949?

620 words - 2 pages an 'iron curtain'. Stalin believed this was necessary to maintain the safety of the USSR. The tension worsened all the time. For example, March 1947 Truman Doctrine, The US implemented a policy of 'containment' towards the USSR, and this is the evidence of the increased tension between the two superpowers.By the end of 1949, East Europe was in the hands of USSR. The Communist states installed by Stalin were controlled by two organizations. One of

Similar Essays

How Successful Were Sergei Witte’s Economic Policies?

698 words - 3 pages How successful were Witte’s economic policies? Sergei Witte was the Minister of Finance from 1892 to 1903, his aim was to modernise Russia’s economy to a level on par with other advanced western nations (such as England and France). To do such a great task Witte needed a plan of action, so he took the ideas of Western states and formed several economic policies. These policies are seen to be very successful in Russia’s economic reform, but to

Early Roots Of Policing: Sir Robert Peel's Twelve Principals Of Policing

1385 words - 6 pages Early Roots of Policing: Sir Robert Peel's Twelve Principals of Policing For over a century police departments in the United States and across the world have been following Sir Robert Peel's twelve principals of policing. Almost nothing or very little has changed since these principals were first implemented in England's "Scotland Yard". Many of these principals are behind today's investigating and policing practices. THE POLICE MUST BE

Nazi Policies Towards Jews Were Brutal But Erratic

1858 words - 7 pages Nazi Policies Towards Jews Were Brutal but Erratic In the years after the Machtergreifung in 1933, German Jews were subject to fluctuation levels of violence and intimidation at the hands of the Nazi Party and its supporters. The variations in intensity were the result of a number of factors including the occasion of the Berlin Olympics, and internal rivalries in the Nazi party about the best way to proceed with Anti

What Were Sir Robert Peel's 12 Principles Of Reform And How Do Each Of Them Stand Up Today? Support Your Answer.

1289 words - 5 pages Peel's Principals, established with the Metropolitan Police Act of 1829, (Johnson, H. & Wolfe, N., 2003, pg 211)1.) The police must be stable, efficient, and organized along military lines.Officers are trained in seeing the areas that the patrol as they are. Since officers no longer walk the 'beat', they have to rely on community involvement and outside tips. Police brutality is something that is taught to control while being trained. The