This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How The Ohio Vouchers Program Violates The Establishment Clause

1226 words - 5 pages

The Ohio Vouchers Program is a school voucher program in which students are selected through a lottery process from the Cleveland City School District. The program selects students based on financial need. These vouchers or tuition grants allow parents the “choice” to use them in private secular or religious schools within the Cleveland district and any districts that have registered with the Ohio Vouchers Program. Depending on the income level of each student, a student can receive vouchers that cover 90% of a school’s tuition. But the overall limit that a student may receive is $2,500. Ohio Revised Code states the guidelines of the program in statute § 3313.974 to 3313.979.
The Ohio Vouchers program was created to respond to the failing of Cleveland’s public school system. With this program however, the vouchers are not supporting students to attend public school in the Cleveland school district. The surrounding school districts can accept the vouchers but have not done so since the program has started. This program is hurting the Cleveland public school system by diverting money that should be going to improve public schools but instead being put in private schools which are largely religious schools. The program continues to hurt not only the public school district but also the parents of the students who try to take advantage of the program. Parents are left with no alternative than to choose a nonpublic school and even then a religiously private school.
Of the non-public schools that participate in the Ohio vouchers program, 82% are religious schools. Almost 88% to 96% of the student who participated in the program have enrolled or is attending a religious school. So the government funds that are being distributed through this program are going directly to these religious schools. The State of Ohio sends the money by check to the schools, in which the parents must come in person to endorse the check to the school. The checks come and go directly to the schools, and parents do not receive a say in how it should be used. The religious schools of course will use these funds to buy supplies such as bibles, religious icons, and anything that furthers the religious ideology of that school.
Students within these religious schools do receive religious instruction even though the student may be of a different faith. Students do learn about religious beliefs and do observe worship. They participate in a wide array of religious activities and this is funded by the direct and unrestricted payments made to the school by the State of Ohio. With the incentives of the program benefiting mostly religious schools than secular, the program is very much slanted to push religious education. This places parents with a difficult choice in which they do not have much choice in where they can send their child.

Summary of Argument
The Ohio Voucher Program violates the Establishment Clause by allowing direct, unrestricted funds to be...

Find Another Essay On How the Ohio Vouchers Program Violates the Establishment Clause

The Establishment of Freedom Essay

1199 words - 5 pages decisions, and we are only slaves when the causes of our actions are placed upon us by external forces. In this examination Spinoza’s Theological-Political Treatise, I will first briefly explain Spinoza’s theory of the law of nature and then explain how it pertains to freedom. I will then discuss the natures of the subject and the slave and show how reason establishes freedom. It is each person’s natural right to do everything in their power to obtain

The Ohio Senate Race Essay

1742 words - 7 pages NRA and all Mike DeWine voted yes on background checks, but no on more penalties for gun and drug violation. Ted Celeste being the democrat he is believes strongly in gun restrictions and is in no way pro-NRA. This is how it is for just about every other issue. One of the candidates is for and the other against. As you can see the two are not very alike and it will be up to the voters to decide who should be the next senator of Ohio, but

School Vouchers are the Solution

1673 words - 7 pages market-oriented education developments like vouchers will end social inequalities and offer a quality education to all students regardless of anything but merit. What supports my last statement is the fact that lately, state-run schools have proven extremely problematic. Instead of the lessening of the “opportunity gap” between the affluent and the poor, the situation has worsened. “Despite a 14 fold increase in inflation adjusted spending

Effects of the Commerce Clause

617 words - 3 pages Without the Commerce Clause, trade between states would be greatly impeded. The Commerce Clause allows for the elimination of interstate trade barriers and thwarts in-state biases, which in turn encourages free trade between states. States still have limited power to regulate intrastate commerce provided the regulations meet a “balancing test,” but the federal Commerce Clause takes precedence over state regulations. Christians are expected to

The Interstate Commerce Clause: How the Supreme Court Interpreted It Over

2446 words - 10 pages writing out certain powers of the government such as coining money and offering patents for inventions. To see how the Clause has been misconstrued by the Supreme Court over the years to its present interpretation, and how the Congress has strayed so far from the original intent of the "Framers", we have to look at the history of the Interstate Commerce Clause.In 1787, the states were independent and sovereign nations, free to maintain separate

Gasp! Musician Challenges the Establishment

990 words - 4 pages language. The enemies are the “queens and the Africans and the reds and the Jews.” The listener is disturbed, but aware of where they stand. The next, however, the song becomes a sultry siren. It’s the voice of reason. A relationship of warmth and friendship is established. All one has to do, of course, is “follow the worms” to the safety of ignorance, hate and intolerance.To examine the song in detail is to understand how

School Vouchers are NOT the Solution

1178 words - 5 pages that the Establishment Clause requires that “no tax in any amount large or small… be levied to support any religious activities or institutions.” (School Vouchers: The Wrong Choice, 2001). However, in a recent ruling, the Supreme Court found that the school voucher program in Cleveland does not infringe upon the constitutional separation of church and state. This ruling is detrimental to opponents of voucher programs. Vouchers use taxpayer money

The Effectiveness of Private School Vouchers

1358 words - 5 pages parents feel that their education goals are not being met through the public school system. But how beneficial are these vouchers to everyone, including taxpayers? It seems that more research needs to be done to see what the real cost is, if it truly allows children from low income families to attend without a financial burden, and to see if the students transferring from public schools to private schools are becoming more successful in achieving

Anti-rape Legislation and the Commerce Clause

1262 words - 5 pages The issue at stake is whether the rape of a female student by two male athletes (who have confessed to committing the crime) at the Virginia Polytechnical Institute in the year 2000 was a violation of a law passed via the Commerce Clause. A Federal law had been passed (43 U.S.C. 13981) which allowed victims of “gender motivated violence” (such as this student) to seek damages in a civil action through Federal court. The victim has since filed

The Establishment of the Electoral College

1084 words - 4 pages by each state legislature and the other as the electors to be chosen by direct vote. It passed under a compromise that granted the individual states the power to decide how to choose their electors(Peirce 44).      Initially, different states adopted different methods for choosing their electors. Some states decided to have the state legislatures select the electors. Other states chose the district system, where the

The Program

2089 words - 9 pages ] which states “The institution may not provide an automobile for use by the prospect” as he was brought to the university by the college bus and was the only occupant on the bus. Second Institutions cannot use student females as hostess for recruits to entice them into committing to their program including the usage of cheerleaders and band. Violates [] which states “The student host must be either a current student athlete or designated

Similar Essays

Freedom Of Religion: The Establishment Clause Of The Constitution

1924 words - 8 pages exercise of religion.I agree with Sullivan's initial assertion that the unstated corollary of the Establishment Clause is a creation of a secular civil order. Although Sullivan's article is and in depth assessment of the Establishment Cause and what it should mean and how it should be applied I feel that she takes for granted and assumes that the Establishment Clause creates a secular civil order. She seems to just assume as fact that the intention of

Stretching The Commerce Clause Essay

868 words - 3 pages Spending Clause or any other provision in the Constitution; the Act also violates Article IV, section 4 of the Constitution, depriving States of their sovereignty and their right to a republican form of government; as well as the Ninth and Tenth Amendments; the constitutional principles of federalism and dual sovereignty on which this nation was founded. COUNT FIVE COERCION AND COMMANDEERING AS TO HEALTHCARE INSURANCE (Const. art. I & amends. IX

The Establishment Of Globalization Essay

1352 words - 5 pages Traditional international trade involves a complex system of trade barriers to ensure the protection of domestic industry and its workers interests. The trade impediments and subsidies include protective tariffs, import quotas, non-tariff barriers such as licensing, and export subsidies. Originally, a country’s economy acted independently of other nations. The growing trend since the establishment of GATT in 1947 is globalization

The Establishment Of Apartheid Essay

1027 words - 5 pages bring the Afrikaner ethnic group to a higher power in South Africa, and accomplished just that. The Afrikaner group was made up of descendants from Dutch colonists who settled in South Africa in order to make a refreshment station, a sort of rest stop, for the Dutch East India Company. The longer people stayed in Africa, the more they started to associate with it as their home. With the enslavement of many Africans, it is easy to see how these