Hrd And Hrm Are They The Same? A Qualitative Exploration

1930 words - 8 pages

Running head: HRD AND HRM ARE THEY THE SAME? QUALITATIVE EXPLORATIONHRD and HRM are They the Same? A Qualitative Exploration"Aggies do not lie cheat or steal, nor do they tolerate those who do."BackgroundUpon graduating with a Master of Science (M.S.) degree in Educational Human Resource Development, I began the journey of locating a job. Much to my astonishment the only prospective positions offered were for what I alleged to be HRM positions; i.e. Recruiter, Human Resource Generalist, Human Resource Analyst, and Human Resource Coordinator. This led me to question my educational background and beliefs that HRD and HRM were two different entities. I entertained an interview as a Human Resource (HR) Generalist. During this interview I ask the interviewers if the job incorporated any aspects of HRD. The interviewers were dumbfounded at first and did not comprehend what HRD entailed. I explained what I believed to be HRD foundational concepts and beliefs and the interviewers soon assured me that their Human Resources Department incorporated many if not all aspects of HRD. I accepted the position of HR Generalist. Much to my dismay I was involved in recruiting, on-boarding, job termination process, benefits, and performance appraisals. For four months the aforesaid were my job duties and all facets of HRD were perceived to be absent. One could argue that the aforementioned encompass Career Development and indirectly Organizational Development. I left the position and started to question if Corporations, practitioners, and/or scholars are failing to see the differences and similarities of HRD and HRM? Did organizations, practitioners, and scholars fail to acknowledge both disciplines due to a lack of fully understanding them? Or is it so that HRD and HRM are so highly related that organizations mesh the two disciplines and use facets of both in their respective Human Resources Department? Should there be separateness between the two, or should scholars and practitioners begin constructing a coherent discipline? Are HRD and HRM the same, different, or highly related?The aforementioned led me to explore this topic. It was my assumption that academia and practice were not in accord on this topic. It interests me that those outside of HRD do not have an understanding of what HRD truly embodies and assume HRD is Human Resources. Furthermore, this topic has me questioning my own beliefs and perceptions about HRD and HRM.IntroductionIssues, confusion, and debate have been emerging between HRD and HRM in respect to their correlation, if at all. The issue in which this article is included is imperative for human resource development and human resource management professionals and scholars concerned with aiding people, groups, and organizations. The standards by which organizations can operate efficiently and effectively demands for the total understanding of both HRD and HRM. Scholars and practitioners ostensibly have divided the two disciplines, yet each...

Find Another Essay On HRD and HRM are They the Same? A Qualitative Exploration

The work, roles and skills of a manager are the same throughout the world.

1811 words - 7 pages Assignment Title: "The work, roles and skills of a manager are the same throughout the world."Abstract:The essay aims to evaluate that the work, roles and skills of a manager have differentiation throughout the world. Definition and classification of managerial roles and skills authorised from management theory are given. Academic journals has been analysed to give instances in order to support the thesis. To sum up, the managerial work, roles

They Can't be the Same Essay

1648 words - 7 pages female), are consistent throughout most cultures. There are cases where the men communicate indirectly and the women directly but not where both the genders communicate in the same way. (Lakoff 627) If the two genders do communicate in the same way, there is bound to be serious conflict that usually involves violence.The movie Thelma and Louise tells the story of two women who have run away from their traditional roles as women. They have been put

The times they are a changin

545 words - 2 pages Bob Dylan's, "The Times They Are A-Changin" is an anthem for the oppressed, down-trodden young people, while warning that oppressors and abusers will be victims of their own actions. In the beginning of the poem, Dylan speaks to everyone and talks of the change coming from young people who feel that laws from the government and mom and dad's rules are smothering. He emphasizes "everyone" by using water to help the reader visualize how complete

The Pilgrim's Progress: Are Dreaming and Sleeping the Same?

817 words - 4 pages Is Dreaming and Sleeping the Same? "As I walked through the wilderness of this world, I came to a place where there was a den. There I lay down to sleep: and as I slept, I dreamed a dream." This great and simple opening of The Pilgrim’s Progress may tell us that in the late 1600s Bunyan is trying to talk about his dream to the public to get his message through to the people. Before I get into this essay I need to clear out the true

What are "Spirituality, Religion, and the Supernatural"? How are they the same? Different? Can one exist without the others? Why or why not? How have these concepts affected you (or not) in the...

1320 words - 5 pages questions, such as who are they, what is their purpose, and why do they exist. Although religion usually is a big factor in the life of a spiritual person, a person can achieve spirituality without subscribing to any religious faith. All religions a set of laws defining how followers of the religion should conduct themselves and live their lives. A religious spiritual person will see these laws as a way to become closer to finding god. A spiritual person

Two of the Same: The short stories "A&P" and "Where are you going, Where have you been?"

1125 words - 5 pages will probably never forget.Connie and Sammy is the same person, essentially - a woman with different problems wishes to be something that they are not, and wiser and smoother conmen see this, and take advantage of them. In the end, they are proven to be the phonies that they really are, and are left moreVulnerable and more open, than they were before they tried to infiltrate the world in which they didn't belong. If there were a shared moral to

Are all cities the same?

824 words - 3 pages different sizes will be seen as having coarse grain and uneven texture; this is shown in Lower Manhattan.Lower Manhatten's%20Yankee%20Weekend%20-%202002-06-01/Fred's%20camera/lower%20manhattan%20map.jpgIf the buildings are the same in size then they will be seen as coarse grain but a uniform texture, such as that of Yonkers, New York.There are different types of spaces in different cities. When looking at the

Case Study - Dales Pickles and Preserves: A structural and cultural change, focusing on HRD solutions

3326 words - 13 pages on the HRD implications of a transformation in production organisation.This has ultimately led to shifting from bureaucratic structures that are best suited to coping with stable, unchanging environments, towards organisational forms that effectively accommodate rapid environmental change (Kanter et al, 1992).The change is focusing on structure and culture and as the scale of the change is significant the type of change process involved is

Science and Technology: Are they really a success?

762 words - 3 pages Science and technology are what shape society today and humans take great pride in the success they have had in technological and scientific developments.Many look upon science and technology as the secret of the worlds success. But is todays exceedingly advanced technology really a step towards success?? Or just a step towards the dehumanization of mankind.A success is defined as something that turns out satisfactorily.Lets take a look at some

About aboriginal and migrant how they keep 2 culture at the same time in white society

566 words - 2 pages Aboriginal people and migrants always have to face a lot of problems if they want to stay at white society successfully. In the white society, aboriginal people and migrants are very hard to be accepted by white people therefore they must be very strong and strength enough to pass the problems to stay alive.For Aboriginal people, white people took away their land, their identity and even their culture which those things are means everything to

EXERCISE AND AGING: A Qualitative Correlation

2923 words - 12 pages EXERCISE AND AGING: A Qualitative CorrelationIn 1523 the Spanish explorer and conquistador Ponce de Leon went searching for the legendary Fountain of Youth. What he discovered was Florida; not quite the quick-fix of a magical substance flowing from a fountain but a nice place for frozen northeastern residents to go for recreation in the winter. The idea of mythical youth is still very much alive in our culture and most noticeable in the

Similar Essays

A Qualitative Exploration Of The Spatial Needs Of Homeless Drug Users Living In Hostels And Night Shelters

2141 words - 9 pages With homelessness levels rapidly increasing in the UK (Fitzpatrick et al., 2012), the necessity for a study analysing the spatial needs of homeless individuals who suffer from drug abuse and are housed in hostels/night shelters was paramount. The task of the critical appraisal is to firstly, summarise the research article A Qualitative Exploration of the Spatial Needs of Homeless Drug Users Living in Hostels and Night Shelters (2013), discuss

Examine The Contention That Hrd, Culture And The Management Of Groups Are Critical Determinates Of Organisational Performance.

1955 words - 8 pages be defined with respect to a task, function, status within the managerial hierarchy ( such as members of the bored of directors), or length of service with the firm (long serving employees might receive privileges not available to others and hence constitute an identifiable group). Formal group are characterised by a high degree of managerial involvement in co-ordinating, controlling and defining the nature of the activities they undertake. Group

Are Botellon And Rave Partyes The Same?

550 words - 2 pages Before answering this question, i will clarify why I have chosen this subject.I thought it would be interesting to learn more about the rave parties and find out if it the same custom we have in pain but with another name, also because now days they are becoming a big problem for societies, and police its trying to find a solution for. I think the main problem for this is that there is lots of young people involved in it which it makes it more

The Virtues, What Are They And Where Are They Found?

1326 words - 5 pages I. The VirtuesIn Robin Waterfield's translation of The Republic,Socrates attempts to give a definition of justice. At the end of Book II he began a detailed description of the construction of a good city. The good city is a relation to the human soul, and its four virtues. In the following paper I will discuss the virtues, what they are and where they are found. Also discussed will be the foundation, arrangement, and the interconnectedness with