Hsün Tzu And Jean Paul Sartre Comparison Of Two Philosophers

1963 words - 8 pages

Fraud, murder, courage, and strong will are all words that can be linked to humanity. These words will often raise questions like, who did it, how they did it, or why. Can it be that the true answer to these questions lies in getting a better understanding of our human nature? Does man act according to his divine plan, or is he taught how to act? In analyzing the works of Hsün Tzu and Jean-Paul Sartre, I will determine which of these two philosophers offers the strongest foundation for living an ethical life in the modern era.

HSÜN TZU
Hsün Tzu is one of the main founders of eastern philosophy and is considered one of the three great sages in China along with Mencius and Confucious. Tzu’s style of writing is poetic and easy to understand. In his writings, he repeats his main ideas constantly as if he were preaching. This is a style that we can identify as being used also by some of our politicians, teachers, and clergymen to name a few.
Tzu also states that, “ (man’s) goodness is the result of his activity” (198). This means that a man’s actions are what determine the goodness of such a man’s nature. However, Tzu explains that in reality man acts apparently good but only because his actions of goodness are born from selfish reasons. According to Tzu, because man’s nature is evil and his focus is on personal gain, man seeks the gain that comes from doing good. This idea continues to be argued today. One can find people in either side of this debate almost anywhere and anyplace. It is interesting to learn how his views on this matter originated from so long ago.

Tzu explains that in order for men to reach goodness they must be taught the “Way” by the sages. The Way teaches men the path to righteousness and propriety, he says, “the nature of man is evil. It must depend on teachers and laws to become correct and achieve propriety and righteousness and then it becomes disciplined” (199). Learning the Way is how man can unlearn his evil nature. Similarly, in the world today this philosophy proves to be valuable since we still depend on the elders, on our community, our teachers, and pastors to teach us and younger generations the way to act in harmony with fellow man.

JEAN-PAUL SARTRE

Jean Paul Sartre was a Western French philosopher and wrote some of his major works during World War II. His multiple styles of writing were in the forms of academic essays to novels and many others. He self-described as an atheistic existentialist who believes, “existence precedes essence, or that subjectivity must be the starting point” (143) that is, that man must make subjective choices in his life that are acceptable not only to himself but to others and not find any other excuses for himself.
Sartre explains that, “the existentialist does not think that man is going to help himself by finding in the world some omen by which to orient himself” (147) therefore, according to Sartre, man without God can no-longer use him as an excuse...

Find Another Essay On Hsün Tzu and Jean-Paul Sartre Comparison of two Philosophers

No Exit: Jean-Paul Sartre Essay

585 words - 2 pages In the play, No Exit, written by Jean-Paul Sartre, three souls are united in the same room in hell. Garcin, Inez, and Estelle are placed into this unexpected situation with each other. They are faced with memories of their sins and the hell that is created is that they have each other to remind if their sins that they committed. In other words, their hell is one another. In this play, which takes place in a plain room furnished in Second Empire

Jean-Paul Sartre: On the Other Side of Despair

3067 words - 12 pages consciousness. Sartre very clearly distinguishes between these two entities of being and explains that human existence is characterized by nothingness, the capacity to negate and rebel ("Jean-Paul Sartre"). "Being-for-itself", then, is dependent upon "being-in-itself" for its origin; "being-for-itself" is derived when one undergoes "an act of nihilation, for ‘being-for-itself’ is a nothingness in the heart of being" ("Being and Nothingness" 2270

Jean-Paul Sartre - Problems with the Notion of Bad Faith

4486 words - 18 pages Jean-Paul Sartre - Problems with the Notion of Bad Faith In Being and Nothingness, Jean-Paul Sartre presents the notion of "bad faith." Sartre is a source of some controversy, when considering this concept the following questions arise. "Of what philosophical value is this notion? Why should I attend to what one commentator rightly labels Sartre's 'Teutonically metaphysical prose

Jean-Paul Sartre the Existentialist, Sigmund Freud the Determinist, and Victor Frankenstein

2692 words - 11 pages Human nature has been determined by many as many different things. Some believe that humans have a preexisting "essence" that account for their actions. However, an existentialist or a determinist would disagree on such a philosophy. Jean-Paul Sartre is a famous French existentialist. Not only was he an existentialist, but an atheist as well. He asserted that God does not exist, and that the only human condition is that of free choice. Sigmund

Comparison of Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau

1269 words - 5 pages being raised to become acceptable members of society. The nature of man is a coherent argument that’s not limited to the two separate distinctions of Hobbes and Rousseau. Centuries of philosophers have attempted to apply reason to why mankind has certain tendencies. Hobbes when discussing human nature often uses beast-like tendencies as a comparison. “The imagination that is raysed in man (or any other creature indued with the faculty of imagining

Sartre and the Rationalization of Human Sexuality

2644 words - 11 pages objects. Sartre calls this "bad faith." He begins by attempting to take human sexuality seriously as a fundamental category, but ends by abandoning the effort in favor of other substitutes. Akin to Plato in his rationalization of sexuality is Jean-Paul Sartre. Sartre is probably the end of existentialist philosophy in two senses: in the first place in the sense of extending existentialist premises as far as they can be taken, and in the second

Personification and Metaphor in two of Paul Dunbar´s Poems

1230 words - 5 pages put effort into a friendship with someone who cannot handle the bad moments. The overall implication in “ After the Quarrel” is that some relationships are toxic and that it is more beneficial to make room for more positive relationships in our life. Works Cited Dunbar, Laurence Paul. “ A Confidence”. The Complete Poems of Paul Laurence Dunbar. New York: Dodd, Mead, and Company. 1922 Print. Dunbar, Laurence Paul. “ After the Quarrel

Sartre and the Meaning of Human Existence

844 words - 3 pages Where the Meaning of Human Existence is Located According to Sartre The word philosophy comes from Greek and literally means "love of wisdom." The Merriam-Webster online dictionary defines philosophy as "a critical study of fundamental beliefs and the grounds for them." Both explanations of philosophy are correct and concrete. The meaning of human existence has no such concrete answer, but in this paper we will examine where Sartre believes

Sartre, Camus, and the Death of Innocence

1000 words - 4 pages and Camus went back to the basic questions of existence in order to build up a philosophy that would be more realistic for the age after the Age of Innocence. Sartre's ideas followed the general feeling of pessimism that was apparent during the 20th century. Unlike previous philosophers, who had celebrated freedom, Sartre felt that human beings were condemned to be free. And this led Sartre to a very pessimistic view of human nature

Do The Ends Justify The Means? A Comparison Of The Writings Of Niccolo Machiavelli And Lao Tzu

1252 words - 5 pages "Uneasy lies the head that wears a crown." An apt quote from William Shakespeare's King Henry IV, Part II, on the trials and tribulations of those in power. Numerous writers have had their say on the subject, more often than not with vastly different ideas on how leaders should act. In this paper I compare and contrast the opinions of two different philosophers, Lao-Tzu and Niccolo Machiavelli, as to the principles by which a leader should

History of the History of Jean Paul Marat

2913 words - 12 pages at the works of the contemporary Marat scholar, Clifford D. Conner. Unlike his predecessor, Gottschalk, Conner‘s two books on Marat focus on separate portions of Marat’s life. In his earlier book, Jean Paul Marat: scientist and revolutionary, Conner claims that there is an undeniable imbalance in the works of previous Marat Biographers with two heavy an emphasis on the last four years of Marat’s life.13 This statement is supported by the works

Similar Essays

Jean Paul Sartre. Essay

855 words - 3 pages Jean Paul Sartre was someone who had a massive influence on people, yet he did not seem to have the credentials to support it. It seems that he was in the right place at the right time, and this gave him the momentum, which he needed to keep his place in society with massive influence. Sartre's most successful part of life was his middle ages, and even then, he wrote quantity without quality, making large sums of money from it somehow, and not

Jean Paul Sartre Essay

4921 words - 20 pages regretted not having the privilege of meeting his father, Sartre admitted that the death of his father was nevertheless beneficial for two reasons; the first is that the death of his father "sent my mother back to her chains and gave me freedom." The second reason is that he just wouldn't have been the Sartre that he became had events not transpired the way that they did.As a result of the death of his father, Jean-Paul and his mother went to go live

Biographie Jean Paul Sartre Essay

1358 words - 5 pages La notion de liberté a évolué à travers le temps et a été étudiée par différents philosophes. Elle est de façon incontestable une valeur universelle, mais n'est toutefois pas un concept univoque. Dans ce texte, la liberté selon Sartre sera étudiée. La biographie de Jean-Paul Sartre sera d'abord abordée suivie d'une présentation de la libert

The Life Of Jean Paul Sartre Essay

1065 words - 4 pages , Sartre received much of his early education from tutors. In 1924, Jean-Paul Sartre started studying at the École Normale Supérieure in Paris. (Media) He graduated in 1929 with a doctorate in Philosophy. (Channel) With the help of a stipend from the Institut Francais, Jean-Paul Sartre was able to study the philosophies of Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger in Berlin, Germany. Husserl and Heidegger were both philosophers whose beliefs were centered