Huck Finn Is Not A Racist Novel

964 words - 4 pages

There is a major argument among literary critics whether Mark Twain’s Huckleberry Finn is or is not a racist novel. The question boils down to the depiction of Jim, the black slave, and to the way he is treated by Huck and others. In the 1950s the effort to banish The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn from required classroom reading lists came publicly to the floor again, not chiefly on the grounds that its depiction of black characters and the use of the word “nigger” were demeaning to African-American students. Many feel that Twain uses the word too loosely. However, many believe that Huck Finn should be taught in schools on the grounds that the novel’s racist theme accurately depicted what life was like for a slave in pre- Civil War times.

Opponents of Huck Finn contend that literary censorship is acceptable. But is not censorship a violation of the first amendment? In places such as Philadelphia and New York City, they have adapted a new version which not only tones down the violence and dialects, but cuts all passages demeaning to African Americans. In today’s hypersensitive society, wouldn’t that be the entire book? It would be impossible to write a novel that did not offend at least one demographic. Being politically correct at the expense of a broadened mindset is simply not worth the sacrifice.

There are mixed feelings regarding Huck Finn being taught in elementary schools. On one hand, its themes might be a little too mature for a child’s delicate psyche, confusing them on what is right or wrong. At the same time, one could argue that teaching it early in development allows adolescents to see the evils of slavery, so any potential prejudice can be abolished at a young age, thus reducing the number of hate crimes in America’s already-too violent society.

It is necessary to analyze the way white characters treat Jim throughout the book. Note that what the author felt is not the way most characters act around Jim, and his feelings are probably only shown through Huck. In the South during that period, black people were treated as less than humans, and Twain needed to portray this. The examples of the way Jim is denigrated: by being locked up, having to hide his face in the daytime and how he is generally derided, all examples which are necessary for historical accuracy. So, Mark Twain had to display Jim’s treatment in this manner, even if it was not the way he felt.

Huck, however, does not treat Jim as most whites do. Huck looks at Jim as a friend, and by the end of their journey, disagrees with society's notion that blacks are inferior. There are two main examples of this in the story. The first one is where Huck is disgusted by Jim's plans to steal his own children, who are "someone else's property." While Huck is still...

Find Another Essay On Huck Finn is NOT a Racist Novel

A discussion of Mark Twain's anti-racist stance in Huck Finn and the novel's theme of freedom for all.

1530 words - 6 pages African descent are "nigger[s] and wouldn't understand" (120-121). Another critic simply sums up her ideas by saying, "Irony, history and racism all painfully intertwine in our past and present, and they all come together in Huck Finn [through the ideas and dialect used in the novel]" (Fishkin 4). What these critics fail to realize is that Mark Twain is only writing in a realism sense of his day. He is not trying to hurt or disgrace African-Americans

Literary Analysis Paper for the Adventures of Huckleberry Finn: What is the effect of having Huck, a naïve boy, and not an omniscient narrator, tell the story?

2018 words - 8 pages people in a fair and unbiased manner. We, as readers, come to understand the feelings of Huck, and sympathize with him due to his young age. Through the many people and incidents Huck encounters and witnesses, Twain is able to criticize society indirectly, while not making it too obvious by using an omniscient narrator, or by writing the novel in third person.Huck lives in a society where blacks are considered inferior to whites. In the Southern

The Controversy of Huck Finn: Reasons as to why Huck Finn should and should not be taught in schools

1276 words - 5 pages want to ban the book simply have not read it or don’t understand the message behind it. One of the arguments against the book is the almost excessive use of the racial slur, nigger, which is written 212 times. Many readers, particularly African-Americans, take offense to this and label Huck Finn a racist book. However, we must remember that this book takes place in the south twenty years before the Civil War; it would be unrealistic if the

Huck Finn, describes the importance of land and water throughout the novel. Discusses the idea of freedom versus slavery and how the settings affect the characters.

1523 words - 6 pages when he is willing to stand watch all night so Huck can get some extra rest. His true nature is revealed as a result of the rivers' freedom, something that society lacked to provide him with.It is clear that the river and shore are greatly responsible for the outcome of the novel. Mark Twain uses the plot developments alongside with the characters' lives to mold two worlds that not only serve as settings, but also symbolize the enslavement Huck and Jim are trying to get away from, and the freedom they succeed in obtaining.

Is Huck Finn Too Mature?

919 words - 4 pages is well beyond his years. Twain wrote this book with never having accomplished his childhood dreams and wishes. It is likely that Twain realized how advanced Huck was turning out to be, and therefore had him make a few acts which were performed without the use of common sense. Huckleberry Finn is the image of an adventurous boy with nothing to hold him back from doing what he wants. He is what Samuel Clemens hoped to be as a child, and regretted not having had these experiences to carry through adulthood.

Conrad's Heart of Darkness is Not a Racist Work

1183 words - 5 pages species of superior hyena" (Singh 273). The natives are dehumanized like this throughout the novel, with the construction not granting them speech – but merely grunts, and them being given animal-like forms. This, therefore signals perhaps a racist construction, however this is done in a way which reflects the context of it’s times and the ignorance of the European society of the native Africans. This ignorance is expressed throughout the

Mark Twain a Racist? Absolutely not!

1604 words - 6 pages , page 175). In this quote, Huck appears to be racist and insensitive, however, he is just acting the way he has been taught his whole life. Huck’s racism is not the product of an immoral soul, just an immoral society that raised him. However, Twain’s choice of a young and apparently racist boy in the novel can be accounted for by his own childhood experiences. Twain is quoted as saying “In my schoolboy days I had no aversion to slavery. I was not

Huck Finn: A Mind of Conflict

1086 words - 5 pages The mind of Huckleberry Finn is in a constant battle with none other than itself, one side always choosing to debate against the other. Huckleberry Finn is a young boy that embarks on a perilous journey to save his friend Jim from enslavement in the fiction novel The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. Throughout the story Huck encounters people that change the way he thinks, has a couple of major internal conflicts while floating down

Is othello a racist play?

884 words - 4 pages towardshim. Iago is the most racist character in the book as he has it in forOthello right from the start. What sparks off Iago's hate towards himis the fact that when Othello chose his lieutenant , it was Cassio whowas chosen instead of Iago. What made Iago angry was the fact thatCassio had no experience in war when he did and Cassio was choseninstead of him. Iago does not say anything racist to Othello's facebut he has a lot to say against him

Huck Finn, A Warning Against Romantic Philosophy

761 words - 3 pages analysis of the hardships that plague everyday life, while Tom Sawyer represents the romantic who sees life on a superficial level, seeking the love of adventure and self gratification. Throughout the progression of the novel, the emergence of Huck Finn's realist reasoning displays Twain's transition from romantic thinking to a world of brutal struggles and oppressive themes. Huck Finn demonstrates his realistic thinking "where the current

Who is your Daddy? An essay on That Jim is a true father of Huck (from Clemens's "Huckleberry Finn")

914 words - 4 pages . Theirpaths cross and they attain respect and love for each other.The father figure in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is not what it seems to be.The first appearance of a father figure is Pap, but over the course of the book, we that hedoes not deserve to be called a father, even though he is the biological parent. The secondappearance of a father is a poor slave, Jim. At first, he does not seem to have the abilitiesof being a father, but over the course of the novel, he shoots down these inaccuracies.Between these two men, as stated by Lionel Trilling, 'In Jim he [Huck] finds his truefather' (321).

Similar Essays

Should Huck Finn Be Taught In The Classroom? Twain Was Not A Racist; He Was Simply Exposing Racism In His Novel, The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn.

726 words - 3 pages . As the first ?truly American novel,? it established a foundation for future works that still holds strong today.Many black readers of Huck Finn are greatly offended by the common use of the word ?nigger.? However, Mark Twain was simply trying to ?show the discrepancy between the dehumanizing effect of the word and the real humanity of Jim.? He chose to use that particular word to show the backwardness of people of that time. They do not see

The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn Is Not A Racist Book

663 words - 3 pages Is the Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn Racist or Not? The book Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is not a racist book. The main arguments against it are the characters’ personalities and the dialect they used. This book is criticized by Twain critics and on the top ten ban list for school reading material. If people just concentrated on the main plot of the story, instead of the fine details that makes the novel realistic, they would agree

Huck Finn: To Be Or Not To Be? Is The Book Racist And Should It Be Thought In Schools?

872 words - 3 pages South, and it is most certainly not a racist book.The word "nigger" is used so often in the book , that it doesn't just appear in every chapter but also on almost every page. Does that mean that this book is racist? Without reading the rest of the text, the answer would be yes, but at the end of the book the doctor makes a speech about Jim in front of an enraged mob who caught him and after complimenting him ends the speech with "He ain't no bad

Huck Finn: "Recommended" Not "Required", Controversey Of Huck Finn.

1704 words - 7 pages absurd that Wallace base his arguments against Huck Finn on the usage of the word "nigger" alone. My personal read of the book is that Twain uses Huck's experiences to challenge his audience to come to grips with the ugly reality of slaveholding as he presents it, not to promote it in an offense manner.Many criticizes have been made about "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" being a "racist" novel because of Mark Twains portrayal of Jim as a slave