This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Human Cloning And Congress Essay

852 words - 3 pages

Human Cloning and Congress

    Recent months have seen news of biotech advances all along the front: cloned cats, artificial wombs, nascent human-animal hybrids, genetic selection of embryos for implantation, fetal-tissue manipulation--and on, and on, nearly every day bringing some news item about the technology that is redefining what it means to be human. The question is, do we want this redefinition? And this essay attempts to answer this pressing question.


Like a giant jigsaw puzzle as each piece is put in place, the picture of the brave new world of eugenic biotechnology is coming clear, and it is an ugly and frightening picture of designed descendants, commodified body parts, manipulated babies, and life itself twisted to little more than the attempt to prove that it is possible to twist life.


The time to stop this is now, and the place to stop it is human cloning. We must send a message that some things we will not do, even though we can. We must draw a line and say that we do not simply acquiesce in the biotechnologists' willful and unthinking desire to fool with the basic stuff of life.


In the next two months, the Senate will debate the question of cloning, with three proposals now in play: the Brownback-Landrieu bill to ban all cloning (echoing the bill already passed by the House of Representatives), and the Feinstein-Kennedy and Harkin-Specter bills, both of which allow scientists to perform so-called "therapeutic" cloning, while prohibiting the bringing of those clones to birth in "reproductive" cloning.


There is moral fecklessness in human cloning. The attempt to allow cloned embryos and then to ban the birth at which they naturally aim is a bizarre and unworkable compromise. How exactly could we enforce it without the courts ordering women to have abortions? How could we prosecute violators without an unattainable knowledge of a scientist's intention in creating a clone? And how could we call the compromise ethical when it would establish in law a class of embryos that it is a crime not to destroy, not to treat as disposable tissue? The attempt to ban only reproductive cloning will prove simply an invitation for scientists to get their techniques right until the pressure to bring one of those clones to birth becomes overwhelming. In truth, the only way to ban reproductive human cloning is by banning all human cloning, and the only bill now before the Senate that will do that is the Brownback-Landrieu bill.


Indeed, for Senators Feinstein and Kennedy to label their...

Find Another Essay On Human Cloning and Congress

The Benefits and Ethics of Human Cloning

1522 words - 6 pages The Benefits and Ethics of Human Cloning Introduction On February 24, 1997, the whole world was shocked by the news that Scottish scientists had successfully cloned a sheep. Dolly an artificially cloned mammal was born a star. After the shock, that cloning was not only a possibility but a reality, wore off the out cry against human cloning began. Physicians, scientists, politicians and church leaders and many more have been trying to ban

The Pros and Cons of Human Cloning

835 words - 3 pages "To clone or not to clone?" that is the question troubling the mind's of many Americans and citizens all over the world. Imagine how life would become when millions of people start looking alike, acting alike, and thinking alike. There would be no diversity what so ever in today's society. Ban human cloning!, Jean Bethke Elshtain author of "To Clone or Not to Clone", displays a strong argument as to why human cloning should be banned

Animal and Human Cloning: Moral, Ethical, and Regulatory Issues

2478 words - 10 pages Animal and Human Cloning: Moral, Ethical, and Regulatory Issues Dolly, woolly, innocent, and sweet, strongly contrasts with the severity of the issues that she has raised. Ever since the news surfaced that Dr. Ian Wilmut had succeeded in cloning a sheep, people around the world have been participating in a frenzied debate over the morality of cloning animals, and more importantly human beings. The cloning of animals and humans could help

The Science and the Laws Impacting Human Cloning

6561 words - 26 pages outrageous that it could not be done in this country for any reason. Based on NBAC report, Clinton sent the “Cloning Prohibition Act of 1997” to Congress, which specifically prohibited cloning of humans, but was carefully worded not to interfere with other cloning research. Clinton’s bill was never introduced on the floor of Congress, and is still without support, though several other bills have been introduced dealing specifically with human

The Effects Human Cloning Has on Society and People's Reactions

1163 words - 5 pages The Effects Human Cloning Has on Society and People's Reactions *Missing Works Cited* The purpose of this year's study is to determine what effects does human cloning have on society and how people react to human cloning. The most commonly cited ethical and moral arguments against human cloning seem to originate from religious perspectives. These religious arguments can even be made by politicians and scientists

Genetics, Genetic Research and Cloning The Human Genome Project

1996 words - 8 pages Eight page paper outlining the Human Genome Project, a research study and project involving cloning of DNA for medical and research use. Written as an ethical issues paper from a nurse's standpoint. It includes the history of the project and uses today and in the future. Also includes potential ethical issues regarding cloning. Complete with references in APA format.Running head: GENETICS, GENETIC RESEARCH AND CLONINGGenetics, Genetic Research

Human Cloning Examines the issue human cloning. Debates the pros and cons and the ethical issues surrounding the procedure. Describes political efforts to outlaw the process

1198 words - 5 pages A couple that has been trying for years to conceive a child has finally succeeded. But when the baby is born nine months later, it is stillborn. The couple is absolutely heartbroken by their loss, and by the thoughts of the child that could have been. They know that they may not be able to conceive another child. So, the daring thought of using human cloning comes to mind. They could get the exact same child they had before using its DNA. Such

The idea of human cloning has brought a lot of controversy and ethical questions. - English - Essay

1347 words - 6 pages Teran Fernando Ms. Josephson English Transactional 40s March 17th, 2016 Word Count: Cloning Will Bring Chaos to the Future Society Cloning has been a controversial issue ever since scientists cloned the first mammal, a sheep named Dolly, in 1996. Cloning technology has since been progressing rapidly, and methods used to clone Dolly the sheep has made it possible to clone humans as well. This idea of human cloning has brought a lot of controversy

The Cost of Human Cloning: A Threat to Individuality and Diversity

725 words - 3 pages The Cost of Human Cloning: A Threat to Individuality and Diversity Have we as a society come too far too fast? This is a very applicable question recently asked by senator Roger Bennett, from Michigan, before the Senate on the topic of human cloning. It is speculated that we as a human race have the technology to make a clone of any given human (Jackson 2). If this is done, at what cost is it done? If cloning is allowed it will come at

National Academy of Sciences: Human Cloning

954 words - 4 pages The National Academy of Sciences (NAS) made headlines when it issued a broadside that would, if followed by Congress, grant an open-ended license for biotech researchers to clone human life. True, the NAS recommended that Congress ban "reproductive" cloning, that is, the use of a cloned embryo to produce a born baby. But it also urged that human cloning for purposes of experimentation--often called "therapeutic" or "research" cloning--remain


910 words - 4 pages same features; not a single difference between them besides the fact that one of them was actually born from a mother and father, while the other was born from a test tube. So is cloning ethical or is it "playing God" as some would say it?Many people have different views of cloning such as "a crime against humanity" (Trounson) and "the prospect of human reproductive cloning has been widely condemned by clerics and ethicists, politicians, pundits and

Similar Essays

Cloning And Human Cloning Essay

2128 words - 9 pages this definition of the “What are the Risks of Cloning,” the one who have the exact same copy as the other is considered a clone. According to the “National Human Genome Research Institution,” there are three methods of creating clones: gene cloning, reproductive cloning and therapeutic cloning. Gene cloning produces the exact copy of the DNA while reproductive cloning produces copies of whole organisms. And therapeutic cloning will produce

Science Today And Human Cloning Essay

843 words - 3 pages Science Today and Human Cloning Nowadays, we are being constantly fed with the prophecy that molecular biology is the next revolutionary "wave" replacing information technology which has changed the way we live in the past 50 years. The past decade has seen scientists making significant breakthroughs in this field to start the current biotechnology hype. One defining achievement was the cloning of a sheep named Dolly by Dr. Ian Wilmut of

Human Cloning And Immanuel Kant Essay

1135 words - 5 pages Ruben GuizarPhilosophyOver the last decade, the advent of cloning andadvancements in human genetic research have presentedsociety with a complicated moral quandary. Debate rages asto what constitutes legitimate paths of inquiry and whereto draw the line as to research that strikes many people asmorally wrong. The basic question is: "how does societydetermine what's right?" While, of course, questionsregarding human genetic research are new, this

The Present And Future From Human Cloning

1567 words - 6 pages Is the cost of a life worth that of a loved one? Human cloning is a topic that has existed since the 1970’s when Dr. John Gurdon cloned a frog. From cloning a frog in 1970 to cloning a sheep in 1997, the technological advances in cloning have exponentially increased. The concept of human cloning is to retrieve the DNA of a human and place it into the embryo of a woman and the child born 9 months later would be a replica of the original person