This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Human Cloning Should Not Be Permitted

4387 words - 18 pages

 
   According to Richard Seed, "cloning is inevitable.  If I don't do it, someone else will.  There's no way you can stop science" (qtd. in Kadrey 2001). Depending on one's personal opinion about cloning, human cloning in particular, a quote such as that will most likely either anger a reader or excite them.  Human cloning is one of the hottest topics for debate in society today-the lines are very strictly drawn between those in favor of continuing cloning research and those who are staunchly opposed to it.  Meanwhile, despite public opinion, science trudges on behind closed doors working to clone the first human. This paper will first provide a thorough, but brief, introduction into the topic of cloning itself, including its history and its mechanisms; then, through a series of carefully thought out points, it will illustrate why human cloning should not be allowed to continue at this point in time.

Part A.

        The "origins" of cloning are vague and variant from source to source.  It has been suggested that cloning began in 1952 when a team of geneticists removed a nucleus from an embryonic frog cell and placed it into an egg cell from which the nucleus had been removed.  To the amazement of the scientists, a frog was hatched from the egg cell with the embryonic nucleus.  The research was furthered in 1975 when embryologist John Gurdon of Britain attempted to do the same thing with an adult cell.  While his research was not fruitful, it started the ball rolling for later cloning attempts. Research with embryonic cells continued into the 1980s and led to the creation of cloned cows and sheep (Reilly 2000).  Finally, in 1997, scientists were able to take an older cell, that of an adult sheep, and successfully created a cloned sheep from that older cell.  The sheep was affectionately made known to the world in February of that year as Dolly.  However, her creation sparked many efforts to end cloning research for fear of future possibilities involving human cloning.  Later that same year, cows were cloned in the same manner, and if scientists had not already been considering investigating the cloning of humans, they were then (Humber and Almeder 1998). "Animal research has become routine.  Mice, sheep, cows, goats, pigs, even a rare Asian gaur-a massive wild ox-have been cloned.  Dogs and cats are expected to appear soon.  Primate researcher [Don] Wolf expects to successfully impregnate monkeys with clones sometime this spring.  You can now order up you own cloned cow on the Net" (Alexander 2001).

        Recently, the lid on the topic of human cloning has come off in abrupt fashion.  Scientists around the world claim that they now have the technology and participants to clone humans.  Of notable interest is an Italian group headed by Severino Antinori and Panos Zavos who have created quite a stir by saying that they are "...ready to start work on the first human clone within weeks" (Italy doctor 2001).  Antinori, an Italian...

Find Another Essay On Human Cloning Should Not be Permitted

Human Cloning Should Not Be Regulated

1084 words - 4 pages these breakthroughs in their sights, would be forced to take their experiments underground to avoid political repercussions.           The opposition insists on the regulation of cloning and is suggesting a permanent ban, arguing that cloning in any way is unethical.  Some take the position that scientists can not be trusted, ethically, to know when the experiments should stop, therefore, the scientific community would be unable to effectively

Should Human Cloning Be Pursued? Essay

1209 words - 5 pages procedures and forced to live his/her life completely for the purpose of another. “Allowing cloning would be taking a significant step toward a society in which human beings are grown for spare body parts, and children are engineered to custom specifications; and that’s not acceptable” (Bush). Reproductive cloning could also be abused by people who want to create genetically superior children. Using reproductive cloning you could clone the world’s

Should Human Cloning Be Banned?

783 words - 4 pages . Although some scientists and ethicists agree with human cloning, there are more evidence that human cloning yields negative results. Opponents of banned human cloning claim that human have the right to clone themselves. They insist that human cloning is problem of individual choice and individual choice should be guaranteed if individual choice do not damage to other people. (Kerry, 2006) Also, they claim that human have right to choose the

Human Cloning Should be Condemned

614 words - 2 pages should be condemned because it reduces human beings to mere products of a manufacturing technique. When cloning is done to attempt a live birth, the child is produced and wanted not for his or her own sake, but because he or she will carry traits that someone else values and wants to replicate. When cloning is done to pursue medical research, the reduction of human life to a mere instrument is even more complete, for a new human being is created

Should Human Cloning Be Banned?

937 words - 4 pages Physicians and scientists joined the chorus of “Thou Shalt Not Clone Humans!”(Pence 1). Since the creation of Dolly, there has been a long debate about the correct practice of biotechnology and inspiring the expectable imaginations of the public (MacKinnon 3). In the end, we always come back to one specific debate. Should human cloning be banned? Cloning is immoral and we would see clones as products for our use or as “test tube babies”. The

Human Reproductive Cloning Should be Banned

1053 words - 4 pages Human Reproductive Cloning Should be Banned The issues concerning human reproductive cloning are shrouded in controversy, perhaps overshadowing the true advantages of cloning technology. Therapeutic cloning, which is often misunderstood as reproductive cloning, is less controversial than the latter as it does not involve the creating of an individual being. Instead, vital stem cells are extracted from human embryos, in order to generate

Should Human Reproductive Cloning Be Legal

1004 words - 5 pages , she should not be part of the child’s life. This sort of repeal of parenthood for the surrogate mother would be devastating. We would create a great amount of turmoil for this woman and we completely disregard that she has rights as well as a human being. I decided upon using Kant’s ethical theory, also known as Kantianism to discuss the topic of human reproductive cloning. This theory is applicable to the topic because it is based on doing

Embryonic Stem Cells Should NOT Be Used for Cloning

1511 words - 6 pages the cloning of mice and other cloned animals. In fact, it has been hard to get good data on the life span of clones because most of them die at such an early age. The same side effects would be prevalent in human clones. For this reason, many do not and should not condone human cloning. Also, the mental effects on the clone themselves would be significant. The mere way in which the clone is brought into existence would have effects on how he

Human Cloning Should Be Banned (Negative)- Argumentative Speach

1763 words - 7 pages that I can see here is that clones are human, they are not some robot, or piece of machinery, unless you take out the 'human' factor.So you're wondering about the physiological effect on them. Well considering we haven't actually had the opportunity to talk to one I think this might be difficult to answer. Even still, once you're a clone that does not mean you're no longer human. Clones are just humans, which instead were created in a cold hard

Human Torture Should Not Be Allowed

1555 words - 6 pages The world should not sit down and ignore the blatant violation of basic human rights. Without human rights the world would be in total chaos. Yet torture, the most maleficent violation of human rights, continues to be used as a means of interrogation. Even here, in the United States of America, officials look to torture to get the information they need out of foreign prisoners of war. Torture, even under the direst conditions, should never be

Human Reproduction Should Not be Controlled

1577 words - 6 pages Human Reproduction Should Not be Controlled There are many ways that human reproduction can be controlled either for better or for worse. One of the ways of controlling human reproduction is with in vitro fertilisation (IVF), this is widely used across the country for various reasons, for example IVF can be used to help infertile couples, single women, gay couples and many others to have children. IVF is quite a

Similar Essays

Should Human Cloning Be Permitted? Essay

2064 words - 9 pages people oppose the practice of human cloning owing to different scientific, religious and ethical perspectives. People in favor of human cloning claim that it will not only facilitate biologists in medical field but it will also allow infertile couples to have children and let other people to bring back their loved ones. However, it should not be legalized because it is considered immoral and unethical in many religions; it diminishes the genetic

Human Cloning Should Be Permitted Essay

1435 words - 6 pages Human Cloning Should be Permitted What would you say if I told you that scientists had just developed a new procedure that could lead not only to the cure for cancer, but would provide an unlimited source of organ donors and could lead to the first effective treatment of nerve damage? Now adding on to this scenario lets say that our government was taking action to ban this new procedure because of a few myths and some loud mouthed

Abortion Should Not Be Permitted Essay

1201 words - 5 pages up in the future. Before we continue, let me define some vital terms (proceed to view powerpoint or note-board; define “Viability” “Roe v. Wade” “D&X”). Since so many babies are being killed needlessly, I strongly believe that the court ruling in Roe v. Wade should be limited and enforced with fines, so that it only protects necessary abortions for women in danger. Every year, almost 150,000 women in the US alone have abortions past the first

Human Cloning Should Not Be Banned

2939 words - 12 pages Proposition: Human Cloning Should Not Be Banned.The news of the successful cloning of an adult sheep, in which the sheeps DNA was inserted into an unfertilized sheep egg to produce a lamb with identical DNA, has generated an outpour of ethical concerns. These concerns are not about Dolly, the now famous sheep, nor even about the considerable impact cloning may have on the animal breeding industry, but rather about the possibility of cloning