This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Human Interaction With Nature In The Works Of Aldo Leopold And Elizabeth Bishop

1583 words - 6 pages

Human Interaction with Nature in the Works of Aldo Leopold and Elizabeth Bishop

The poet Elizabeth Bishop and the naturalist Aldo Leopold share a keen power of
observation, a beautifully detailed manner of writing, a love for the beauty of nature, and an interest in how people interact with the natural world. Like Leopold, Bishop examines human interactions with nature on both the personal and the ecological level. On the individual level, a hunter’s contact with the animal he or she is hunting changes his or her attitude toward nature in both Bishop’s poem “The Fish” and Leopold’s essay “Thinking Like a Mountain.” On the larger level, both Bishop in her poem “The Mountain” and Leopold throughout the Sand County Almanac envision the role of human beings in relation to the rest of the natural world as one of exploration and interpretation through science and art.

In both Bishop’s “The Fish” and Leopold’s “Thinking Like a Mountain,” the
person’s contact with a wild animal comes about through hunting. In theory, hunting is a
sport, “a challenge of fang against bullet” (Leopold 129), in which the animal has a fair
chance of escaping. In reality, however, there is no real challenge for the hunter in either
case. Leopold and his companions, “pumping lead into the pack” (130), kill the wolf not
by skill but by the sheer number of bullets, while Bishop’s speaker testifies, “He didn’t
fight. / He hadn’t fought at all” (5-6). Thus, both call into question whether their hunting
is actually a sport.

Both Leopold and Bishop’s speaker are initially unaware of the true value of the
creatures they hunt. Leopold writes, “I thought that because fewer wolves meant more
deer, that no wolves would mean hunter’s paradise” (130). Bishop’s speaker, with her
detailed and evocative visual descriptions of the fish, seems more sensitive to its
significance, but when she looks into the fish’s eyes and it does not look back at her, it is
clear that she has not yet made a connection with the fish. For both narrators, this lack of
emotional connection changes when they notice some striking detail about the wolf or
fish which awakens them to the symbolic value of the animal and transforms their way of
relating to nature. Leopold sees “a fierce green fire dying” (130) in the eyes of the wolf
and senses that his neat equation of fewer wolves equals more deer is inadequate, and that
wolves have an importance unknown to him. He goes on to develop a new conservation
ethic, one that values wolves as well as deer and protects wild animals for their own sake
and that of the ecosystem, not just for the pleasure of hunters. Bishop’s speaker notices
five fishhooks dangling from the fish’s mouth and realizes how many times the fish has
battled for its life and won. Its fighting spirit earns her respect and causes her to release
the fish.

The particular symbolic value that each writer finds in the wild animal is evident
in his or her beautifully poetic...

Find Another Essay On Human Interaction with Nature in the Works of Aldo Leopold and Elizabeth Bishop

Analysis of The Fish by Elizabeth Bishop

1123 words - 4 pages elements weave themselves together to create a work of art that goes beyond its simple subject. The first element to analyze when looking at “The Fish” is figurative language. The reader is drawn to this element because of its heavy emphasis throughout the poem. Elizabeth Bishop profusely uses similes with the intention of heightening the sensation of fishing. She writes: [...] Here and there his brown skin hung in strips like ancient

Analyzing "One Art" by Elizabeth Bishop is an Analytical Essay of One Art by Elizabeth Bishop. It looks at the authors meaning of "losing" in this polygamous poem

1764 words - 7 pages "faster". The quality of the list increases from her "mother's watch" to "three loved houses", "two cities", "two rivers" and a continent". The hyperbole's Bishop uses show how she progresses and acquires the skills to master the art of losing.The things she mentioned that are small in quality, in stanza four end with the phrase, "the art of losing isn't hard to master". The hyperbolic examples of things she lost in stanza five ends with the

"Filling Station" by Elizabeth Bishop and "The Jailer" by Sylvia Plath - analysis and comparison of styles

2060 words - 8 pages 1.Elizabeth Bishop - "Filling Station"The poem consists of seven stanzas. Most of them have six or seven verses, except the very last one, which contains only two.The first stanza, with a strong exclamation in the beginning verse, introduces the setting - a small, dirty gas station. There is a clearly visible intention of creating some kind of repulsion through the description, as everything is "dirty" and "oil-soaked" - a good example of

Commentary on The Sand County Almanac by Aldo Leopold

1264 words - 6 pages not match up with nature as well as it should, and that humans are slowly making their way to an anti-nature lifestyle. Aldo Leopold pushes us to see nature as “The community in which we belong”. We need to be able to see nature as something other than simply property. Leopold’s Sand County Almanac and Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring were counted as one of the most environmental books in the 1900’s. The book is considered to be the main reason for

Isolation and Nature in the Works of Robert Frost

3441 words - 14 pages Isolation and Nature in the Works of Robert Frost During the height of Robert Frost’s popularity, he was a well-loved poet who’s natural- and simple-seeming verse drew people - academics, artists, ordinary people both male and female - together into lecture halls and at poetry readings across the country.1 An eloquent, witty, and, above all else, honest public speaker, Frost’s readings imbued his poetry with a charismatic resonance

Power and Uncertainty in Elizabeth Bishop´s Poems

834 words - 4 pages mother moved on to another man. In the fall of 1930, Bishop then attended Vassar College in Poughkeepsie, New York after completing her basic education. Bishop published her work very sparingly for a major American poet. In 1946, twelve years after graduating with her bachelor’s degree in English literature, Bishop decided to pursue her literary career releasing her first publication, North and South that won the Houghton Mifflin Prize for poetry

The Fish By: Elizabeth Bishop

1100 words - 4 pages that reflects Elizabeth Bishop's ability as a poet. She observes the beauty in nature through the simple act of catching a fish. Bishop employs several literary techniques such as metaphor, symbolism, personification, and imagery to convey her experience. Her great attention to detail allows us to understand the fish as she does and, as a result, understand why she sets the fish free.Work CitedBishop, Elizabeth. "The Fish." Contemporary American Poetry. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. 1980."Elizabeth Bishop Overview." Gale Resource Database. Site Accessed May 6, 2004. <>

The Fish by Elizabeth Bishop

886 words - 4 pages The Fish by Elizabeth Bishop      With fewer than fifty published poems Elizabeth Bishop is not one of the most prominent poets of our time. She is however well known for her use of imagery and her ability to convey the narrator?s emotions to the reader. In her vividly visual poem 'The Fish', the reader is exposed to a story wherein the use of language not only draws the reader into the story but causes the images to transcend the written

An essay on "The Land Ethic" by Aldo Leopold

850 words - 3 pages people all clean their cars out while driving home it can add massively to the devastating havoc being wreaked on mother nature in today's world. If people would realize the invaluable resource that has been provided to them they may realize that their actions are becoming a big problem and growing worse with every passing day.The only other way to make a system like this one work is to make it mandatory by law for everyone to do only actions that of

An Anyalsis of the poem 'The Fish' by Elizabeth Bishop

681 words - 3 pages The poem 'The Fish' by Elizabeth Bishop is a narrative poem told in first person about the capture of a fish by an amateur fisher and the progression of the understanding for the beauty of nature.As the poem progresses the speaker moves from a sympathetic pitiful view to a respected and admiring view of the fish. The internal confrontation of the speaker is aided with vivid imagery and similes. The speaker convinces the reader alternatively of

The Theme of Nature in Literary Works

1112 words - 4 pages The Theme of Nature in Literary Works In his Poetics, Plato contemplates the nature of aesthetics and existence. He postulates that for every existing object and idea there is an absolute "ideal" which transcends human experience. He further concludes that art, including literature, is an aesthetic representation of real objects and ideas that is used to better understand their "ideals." In theory, as an object becomes closer

Similar Essays

Nature In The Poems: The Fish By Elizabeth Bishop And The Meadow Mouse By Theodore Roethke

658 words - 3 pages Two poems, “The Fish” by Elizabeth Bishop and “The Meadow Mouse” by Theodore Roethke, include characters who experience, learn, and emote with nature. In Elizabeth Bishop’s poem “The Fish,” a fisherman catches a fish, likely with the intention to kill it, but frees it when he sees the world through the eyes of the fish. In Theodore Roethke’s poem “The Meadow Mouse,” a man finds a meadow mouse with the intention of keeping it and shielding it

The Power Of Human Nature In The Works Of Christopher Marlowe

2226 words - 9 pages trying to accomplish. His plays have many levels of meaning, often at odds with one another. What can be drawn out however, is a consistent assertion of the importance of embracing human nature. Marlowe wants his audience to come to terms with what is actually important in the world. Most people know how the world really works, that power, intelligence, and ambition are what dominate society. However, very few people actually act on these natural

"Human Nature" Marcia – This Is Excellent, Just Excellent. A Clear Thesis, Good Analysis – I Am Very Impressed, And You Should Be Pleased With Your Work.Your Works Cited Page Is Perfectly Formatted. ...

726 words - 3 pages cruelty". This is especially true when Hyde all of a sudden loses control and savagely murders Sir Carew, "And then all of a sudden he broke out in a great flame of anger, stamping with his foot, brandishing the cane, and carrying on…and clubbed him to the earth."(15) Mr. Hyde's rash and abrupt actions of impulsiveness and cruelty are simply due to his human nature; something that he cannot control. Human nature does not discriminate. Evil

Imagery And Diction In The Fish By Elizabeth Bishop

1304 words - 5 pages Imagery and Diction in The Fish by Elizabeth Bishop Elizabeth Bishop's use of imagery and diction in "The Fish" is meant to support the themes of observation and the deceptive nature of surface appearance. Throughout the course of the poem these themes lead the narrator to the important realization that aging (as represented by the fish) is not a negative process, and allows for a reverie for all life. Imagery and diction are the