This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Human Nature At Its Worst Essay

2803 words - 11 pages

When Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” was first published in The New Yorker in 1948, it struck a nerve with readers. “The story was incendiary; readers acted as if a bomb had blown up in their faces . . . Shirley struck a nerve in mid-twentieth-century America . . . She had told people a painful truth about themselves” (Oppenheimer 129). Interestingly, the story strikes that same nerve with readers today. When my English class recently viewed the video, those students who had not previously read the story reacted quite strongly to the ending. I recall this same reaction when I was in high school. Our English teacher chose to show the video before any student had read the story. Almost every student in the class reacted with horror at the ending. Why do people react so strongly when they read the story or see the video? What is it about “The Lottery” that is so disturbing? To understand, one must examine the very nature of humankind.
Man’s propensity for violence has been around since Cain killed Abel. In the Old Testament, the Bible speaks frequently of wars and killing. “And it came to pass . . . that all Israel returned unto Ai, and smote it with the edge of the sword. And all that fell that day, both of men and women, were twelve thousand” (Josh. 8.24-25). The ancient Romans were known for their bloodlust. “The ancient Romans loved gladiators. They loved the men, the weapons, the fighting and the bloodshed. They also loved the death” (Baker 2). While most people today would be horrified by “what the historian Michael Grant has called ‘the nastiest blood-sport ever invented’ [it] was much loved in ancient Rome” (Baker 3). It is also well known that over the years, various cultures have practiced human sacrifice. “The Aztecs probably offered up more sacrificial victims than any other people in recorded history. In this, they were enacting a Mesoamerican tradition that originated far back in the region’s past” (Allan 19). Throughout more modern history, wars have been fought resulting in the deaths of millions. Murders and other violent crime are inescapable. Throughout the entire history of mankind, it can be shown that man’s capacity for evil has no limits. But is this what troubles readers of Jackson’s story?
“We cannot, in all honesty, make any serious claim that our own culture really abhors violence. . . . Modern society still feels the need to watch violent events, whether it be at a boxing match or spattered across the cinema screen” (Baker 5). Society today is bombarded with violence. There is graphic, and often gratuitous, violence in movies and video games. Most people do not give this type of violence a second thought. This may be because they know that the violence in the movies or games is not real, but “The Lottery” was just a story; it, too, was not real. So what is it about Jackson’s story that hits readers so deeply? What makes “The Lottery” so disturbing?
For years, critics have been trying to answer these questions. Some...

Find Another Essay On Human Nature at its Worst

The title of the paper is Human Nature: Comparing Christianity to Islam. The question was aimed at comparing the work of a prevalent figure from each religion in regard to understanding the varying...

1750 words - 7 pages at some points, but in general his approach is centered on the human nature's ability to question itself. It is on this subject that some overlap with Paul occurs, which is human nature's ability to ponder the infinite. As Mutahhari states, "…man sends his thought racing after things limitless and eternal and gains a knowledge of some of them" (Stevenson 71). Even though man cannot fully grasp the limitless and eternal because

Demonstrate an understanding of human rights legislation and reflect on its implication for people with a learning disability. this reflection looks at personal relationships

1765 words - 7 pages UK Citizens now have certain basic human rights which government and public authorities are legally obliged to respect. These became law as part of the Human Rights Act 1998. This Act 1998 gives legal effect in the UK to 16 of the fundamental rights and freedoms contained in the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). These rights not only affect matters of life and death like freedom from torture and killing but also affect your rights in

Human Nature Is EVIL

773 words - 4 pages think it’s okay to kill in war when it’s not at all. It’s an evil thing to kill. Killing is something the human nature has discovered and for human nature to learn there must be evil in all of us. To sum everything up, human nature does have its goods, but there has always been a far more evil side to it. The government over powers people, bullying is somewhat acceptable when it shouldn’t be, killing will never be fine no matter what it’s for

Comparison of Leviathan, by Thomas Hobbes, and the Discourse on the Origin and Foundations of Inequality Among Mankind, by Jean-Jacques Rousseau

1289 words - 5 pages like"(qtd. in Cruz). Hobbes states that this state of human condition "...is worst of all, continual fear and danger of violent death, and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short"(Hobbes, 377). Through his state of nature, Hobbes wants to show what men are characteristically like- what our human nature is like without conventional government to protect us. He is attempting to show us that we need a strong central power. However

Wicked Blessing

660 words - 3 pages The existence of mankind is a wicked blessing with the full capability to uphold good intentions, but human nature drives us to do otherwise, going beyond moral constraints into the depths of corrupt curiosity. The idea can be more crisply summarized in the words of Bill Bryson “It’s an unnerving thought that we may be the living universe’s supreme achievement and its worst nightmare simultaneously.” Bryson obviously sees the aptitude of the

The Grey

1307 words - 5 pages incident. The remaining men were then stuck in a white, snowstorm that created conflict for their survival. The filmmaker's central purpose here was to introduce them in an unbearable setting, that way he could later reveal their true attitudes toward nature at its worst. One man out of the group, steps up to be a leader and guide them through all that they come in contact with. The men feel as though they are not obligated to listen to the leading man

When is it ever morally permissible to kill and eat animals?

1196 words - 5 pages Is it ever morally permissible for human beings to kill and eat animals? When is it ever morally permissible for human beings to kill and eat animals? This is a question in which its answers have been argued since the early period of stoic philosophy up to now with the “rights view.” Known philosophers, Tom Regan and Epictetus use two different moral theories to defend what is morally permissible. Tom Regan uses the “rights view” moral theory

modern day slavery

876 words - 4 pages same principles. Where as slavery is an economic system in which the trade of human beings creates profit of their owner and eventually their new owner. Modern slavery is truly capitalism at its worst because it demonstrates the true nature of how slavery can be financially successful in the modern day, how money rather than fair treatment is idolized, and the lack of obstacles that perpetuates the life of slavery. The private owners of slaves in

Aspects of Human Nature in "Heart of Darkness" by Joseph Conrad

1078 words - 4 pages ... no earthly reason for any kind of scruple. Restraint! ... the fact facing me - the dazzling fact." (Conrad, 1990, p.38).Through the novel "Heart of Darkness" Conrad portrays and exposes human nature at its best and at its worst. Conrad embeds irony throughout the entire novel to show that not everything is as it seems and that when involving humans there are contradictions. The main point that Conrad is conveying to his reader is that

Defining Tragedy through Pessimism

885 words - 4 pages . Cassio, pleasant and full of good intentions, was perceived by Othello as a traitor. Othello himself, a respected warrior, to whom even Iago who hates him attributes “a constant, loving, noble nature” (Othello 2.1.283), was exposed to the audience in his worst states: losing his temper and striking Desdemona, and losing his grasp of reality altogether in a fit of madness. Secondly, similarly to the assumption of the aforementioned

fuck the jews

1767 words - 8 pages steadfast all the time. After reading this the true message of the sonnet is revealed, that even after hitting its limitations and the worst may happen, when love continues you know it is at it's strongest. Thus, nature may be imperfect, constantly changing, and harsh, however the spirit, beauty and love among humanity will prevail identically. “That Time of Year Thou Mayst in me Behold” and “Shall I Compare Thee to a Summer’s Day” by William

Similar Essays

Heroes Reflect The Best And Worst In Human Nature

1048 words - 5 pages /war puts humans and the buggers at risk of the worst of humanity; such as pain, torture, massacre, and hate for one another; in which, eventually happens when the buggers are destroyed. Card portrays at the start of the novel that “the power to cause pain is the only power that matters”, the human will to destroy and “cause pain” reflects the worst of human nature. Ender shows that heroes’ sacrifice for survival portrays the best of human nature

Human Nature And Its Views On Religion

478 words - 2 pages It is human nature to question all that pertains to life and our surroundings. We speculate and attempt to answer anything that extends beyond our grasp. This is most common in ancient Greek times where the belief of gods and goddess ruled the minds of all. In today's modern era, religion is looked upon more as guidance rather than a way of life. In the first paragraph, the type of religious faith that is present is one where faith is present

Totalitarianism At The Expense Of Human Nature

2084 words - 8 pages novel has an affair with Julia which is one of the reason to his torture in Room 101, or the place in which there is no darkness, which at first is perceived as a great place where there may be a chance of freedom until we realize it is really just a place for torture and the destruction of human nature. “His affair with Julia and their time above Mr. Charrington’s shop gave him control over his present, with which he finally achieves control over

Alcoholism At Its Best And Worst

1019 words - 5 pages Coupeau had been able to turn his life around, perhaps things would have turned out differently for their family. The drinking began as a reasonably positive thing for the family. Coupeau and Gervaise became friends with many people, including the Goujets, the Bjiards, and the Boches over friendly dinners at Gervaise’s store. The alcohol even brought Lantier and Coupeau together, a relationship that would have never been expected to work out