Human Rights And John Rawls The Law Of Peoples

3834 words - 15 pages

Human Rights and John Rawls The Law of Peoples

Abstract: Which political and juridical foundation can justify the transit from the Western, particular, to the universal? John Rawls tries to answer this question in his article, "The Law of Peoples," proposing a kind of contract or agreement. A first agreement should be attained among liberal-democratic societies on a few political and social issues such as human rights. Then this agreement can be widened to non-liberal/democratic but well organized hierarchical societies or those that satisfy the requisites of being peaceful, of having a reasonably well organized legal system, of admitting a measure of freedom-political and religious-and of admitting the right of emigration. These two groups of nations would belong to a Society of Nations with the juridical and political duty of fulfilling the few political issues that have been previously accepted. But Rawls' proposal overcomes neither eurocentrism nor western-centrism. It seems that the first circle of liberal democratic nations would decide which peoples satisfy the requirements of the 'well organized hierarchical societies.' This second circle of nations are only invited peoples; they are not supposed to contribute new proposals, but only to accept the proposals of the liberal-democratic nations. I present a new effort to attain human rights through a true universal dialogue in which the representatives of all cultures and peoples can equally speak, make proposals, and listen or accept the proposals of others.


Human rights, specially those belonging to the first generation, as they are expressed in "The Universal Declaration of Human Rights" of December, 10th, 1948, are the end product of a long historical process inside Western Culture and whose previous stages are the English Revolution of 1648, the Declaration of American Independence of 1776, and the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen of August, 1789. These documents, at the same time, take back the sociopolitical thought that had been developped in a long tradition, and whose most striking stages are: the supreme value of reason as basis for any sociopolitical relation such as we discover at the Greek Polis and such as it is presented by the great thinkers Plato and Aristotle; the intrinsic value of human person, son of the same Christian God, and capable, because of his freedom, either of salvation or of condemnation, as it was understood by the main thinkers in the Middle Ages; the human Individual, considered as a juridical subject, capable of making contracts and assuming rights and duties and, therefore, as the last foundation of any sociopolitical organization, as he was thought by the liberal tradition embodied by Hobbes, Locke and the Encyclopedists. The concrete praxis of these theoretical principles in democratic societies and nations where the Individuals are the cause and the end of this sociopolitical order such as we find in Great...

Find Another Essay On Human Rights and John Rawls The Law of Peoples

Investigate the increasing importance of human rights after World War II in both international and Australian law.

1153 words - 5 pages Atrocities of 2nd War led to greater emphasis on role of international law in achieving peace and established United Nations, an international organisation for maintenance of security and promotion of human rights. In 1948, Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) was proclaimed asserting rights to life, liberty and security of all. This led to a foundation for the fundamentality of human rights worldwide as states ratified and were liable

Kenya: International Human Rights Law Essay

1362 words - 6 pages . Major violence erupted between the Orange Democratic Movement and the Party for National Unity (Odinga, 2013). This violence results in a sickening number of human rights abuses. These atrocities included over one thousand deaths, thousands of displaced people, countless cases of rape, and immense physical and emotional injury. In addition to these human rights violations, physical property and infrastructure was demolished, and the economy was

The Impact of the European Convention on Human Rights on UK Law

1987 words - 8 pages The Impact of the European Convention on Human Rights on UK Law In democratic societies, it is usually felt that there are certain basic rights which should be available to everyone. These rights tend to vary in different legal systems but they generally include such freedoms as the right to say, think and believe what you like (freedom of expression, thought and conscience), and to form groups with others (freedom of

Relevance of Public International Law in Human Rights

1317 words - 5 pages Human rights seem to be one of the most current issues worldwide. Uncountable efforts have being made to assure the avoidance of violations and abuse of them during human history. However, it is not just until the end of World War II that joined efforts by most of the countries in the world were visible, being public international law one of the ways to . It could be said that public international law is one of those important efforts that

How Does English Law Give Effect to the Right to Marry and Found a Family as Guaranteed by Article 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights?

1816 words - 7 pages How Does English Law Give Effect to the Right to Marry and Found a Family as Guaranteed by Article 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights?Article 12 states 'Men and women of marriageable age have the right to marry and found a family, according to the national laws governing the existence of this right'. The European Court held that there is no one European-wide view of what marriage is and so each country is given a margin of

The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution

3695 words - 15 pages The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution The Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA), an Act introduced to give effect to rights from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in domestic legislation. Its introduction has affected many legal areas; especially the conceptions of the rule of law and their place in the UK constitution. To understand the effect of the HRA

Do human rights treaties call for special treatment under the law relating to reservations laid down in the Vienna Convention of the Law of Treaties 1969?

2909 words - 12 pages to a treaty, so if these reservations are deemed impermissible, "the only course open is to declare that this consent is not valid and decide that these states cannot be considered parties to the instrument in question".In the Human Rights Law Journal, the US government also stated that reservations which are contained in instruments of ratification are integral parts of a state's consent to be bound by the treaty in question, and so are not

"In Our View, Therefore, Medical Law is a Subset of Human Rights Law" (Kennedy, I & A. Grubb. Medical Law 3rd edition (2000))

2223 words - 9 pages handicapped. The issue of the human rights of these individuals would be paramount in modern health care law. This has also been recognised by Rawls and Dworkin, who also believe these individuals should be respected and should be given human rights. In one of the leading cases on this topic, the House of Lords in Airedale NHS Trust v Bland carefully analysed the possible rights of a patient in a persistent vegetative state. The House of Lords

Compare and contrast Nozick and Rawls approaches to the issue of Indigenous Australians land rights

4314 words - 17 pages question of legitimate territorial expansion. There were three recognized means whereby a state could come to acquire sovereignty over new lands at international law in the eighteenth century. The three were conquest, cession, and occupation of territory which was terra nullius. Indigenous peoples' rights have different status, origin and force depending on the means of obtaining sovereignty employed by the colonizing state. 6The criteria for

Analysing John Rawls' Theory of Justice and its principles, and the conflicts which may arise from its implementation.

1651 words - 7 pages Justice as FairnessThe late John Rawls, in 'Justice as Fairness', acknowledges that society exists for the "mutual benefit of all its members" (Nuttall 2002:223). They should be better off living in a society than not. However, he also indicates that there is a conflict of interest between members within the society, as each tries to accumulate a larger share of wealth and goods available.Rawls' theory of justice is seen as the solution to the

Reflection and Objection on John Rawls

549 words - 2 pages injustices. There would be mutual respect amongst all of them, and they would all do their fair share to better the society.Everything that Rawls says sounds pretty good on paper. It is a hypothetical, idealistic view of life and human nature. However, his ideas cannot be taken into practice, which makes his whole philosophy sort of useless. Everything he bases the idea of a perfect society on is based on two impossible ideas: the veil of

Similar Essays

The Relationship Between Human Rights And Common Law

2505 words - 10 pages common law and the making of administrative decisions .There has been an ever-increasing gap, between the reality of what the state should be doing in compliance with its obligations, and the actions it has actually taken. "Despite a commitment to internationalism in Australia's human rights diplomacy, international statements of human rights have been enacted as part of domestic law in only a very small number of cases" , given this lack of active

Human Rights And The Savings Law Clauses Of The Jamaican Constitution

905 words - 4 pages unconstitutional any period thereafter. Thus precludes any possible constitutional challenge to the lawfulness of the death penalty per se. Nevertheless, under human rights law, rules giving substance to particular principles are not always immutable, and with the passage of time, one would think it reasonable that forms of punishment once regarded as culturally acceptable may become objectionable both domestically and internationally. The

Islamic Law And Universal Human Rights

3191 words - 13 pages been at the forefront of much of today’s diplomatic work, and specific citizens and regions of our world have drawn special attention when relating to this matter. One group that is of particular interest is the body of citizens practicing Islamic law. Numerous books, articles, and journals have recently been written on the topic of Islamic law and its relationship to universal human rights. These published works have also contributed to the

Law And Society: Human Rights Violation

1263 words - 5 pages UN report, “Gross human rights violations remain a serious threat to continuing efforts to transform Afghan society,” The number of human right violations has increased from the past according to the UN report and immediate steps have to be taken place so that the people of afghan can enjoy their freedom and to the country’s long-term prospects for peace, stability, democracy, development and the rule of law. “Coupled with a weak, corrupt and